Dataset Viewer
index
int64 | prompt_original
string | prompt_distorted
string | selected_dims
string | llm_judge
dict | hpsv2_reward
dict | llm_selected
int64 | blip_selected
int64 | model
string | blip_score
list | image_reward
dict | hpsv3_reward
dict | rater
dict | blip_score_original
list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0
|
A standing toilet in a bathroom stall next to a trash can.
|
A standing toilet in a bathroom stall beside a trash can, rendered with no light or shadow, appearing random and unfinished, lacking clear intent or design, with flat, indistinct surfaces and no depth or texture.
|
["richness", "lighting distinction"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- no light or shadow: Visible. The image uses flat colors with no discernible light source or shadows.\n- appearing random and unfinished: Partially visible. The overall style is simplistic and somewhat unfinished, but not entirely random.\n- lacking clear intent or design: Not visible. The composition is clear and intentional.\n- with flat, indistinct surfaces: Visible. The surfaces are rendered with flat colors and minimal detail, making them indistinct.\n- no depth or texture: Visible. The image lacks realistic depth and texture, appearing very flat.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- 'no light or shadow': The image clearly has light and shadows, indicating this effect is not present.\n- 'appearing random and unfinished': The image appears well-defined and finished, not random or unfinished.\n- 'lacking clear intent or design': The image shows a clear and intentional bathroom stall design.\n- 'with flat, indistinct surfaces': Surfaces have clear definition and some texture, not flat and indistinct.\n- 'no depth or texture': The image clearly exhibits depth and texture, especially on the floor tiles and the trash can.\n\nNone of the specified special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2291259765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.22900390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2919921875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.274658203125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.2286376953125,
0.221923828125
],
[
-1.1396484375,
1.134765625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.70947265625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.4326171875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.8427734375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.75830078125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.689342498779297,
-4.920155048370361
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.6279497146606445,
-4.130467891693115
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.20141315460205,
-5.0528950691223145
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.158187866210938,
-5.01566219329834
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.6875,
0.828125,
0.92578125,
0.0498046875,
0.53125,
0.59765625,
0.56640625,
0.00701904296875,
1.515625,
0.77734375,
0.54296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.9765625,
1.875,
0.96875,
0.0128173828125,
0.87109375,
1.421875,
0.6875,
0.353515625,
2,
0.81640625,
1.03125
]
}
}
|
[
0.7392578125,
0.93505859375
] |
1
|
A woman talking on a phone with a smile on her face.
|
A woman smiling while talking on a phone, surrounded by clashing, overexposed, and muddy colors; the image feels dark, random, and unfinished, with no clear design, emphasizing unpleasant, disharmonious tones.
|
["color aesthetic", "richness", "color brightness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Clashing colors: Visible, the background has a mix of colors that don't harmonize.\n2. Overexposed colors: Partially visible, some areas in the background appear brighter and somewhat overexposed.\n3. Muddy colors: Visible, the overall color palette has a somewhat desaturated and dirty feel.\n4. Dark: Visible, the image has significant dark areas, especially around the edges.\n5. Random: Visible, the background brushstrokes and color placement appear random.\n6. Unfinished: Visible, the background looks like an unfinished painting.\n7. No clear design: Visible, the background lacks a coherent design.\n8. Unpleasant, disharmonious tones: Visible, the color choices and their application create an unpleasant and disharmonious feel.\n\nAll 8 effects are visible to some extent, leading to a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- clashing colors: Not visible. The colors are harmonious and natural.\n- overexposed colors: Not visible. The exposure is well-balanced.\n- muddy colors: Not visible. Colors are clear and vibrant.\n- dark: Not visible. The image is bright and well-lit.\n- random: Not visible. The composition is clear and focused.\n- unfinished: Not visible. The image appears complete and polished.\n- no clear design: Not visible. The design is clear with a central subject.\n- unpleasant tones: Not visible. The tones are pleasant and warm.\n- disharmonious tones: Not visible. The tones are harmonious.\n\nAll listed effects are absent from the image, resulting in a special effects score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.336669921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.288330078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.292724609375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.308349609375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.23046875,
-1.251953125
],
[
-3.490234375,
3.498046875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.708984375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.51953125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.28564453125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6162109375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
14.50979995727539,
-4.957979679107666
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.828288078308105,
-4.895738124847412
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
15.466788291931152,
-4.815302848815918
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.205389022827148,
-5.033448696136475
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.765625,
0.890625,
0.59765625,
0.59375,
0.4765625,
0.6328125,
0.68359375,
1.34375,
1.9921875,
0.376953125,
1.0859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.265625,
1.8984375,
0.96875,
0.0849609375,
0.2041015625,
1.3046875,
1.84375,
0.1279296875,
2,
0.255859375,
1.34375
]
}
}
|
[
0.90283203125,
0.9326171875
] |
2
|
A person riding a bike across a brick road.
|
A barely visible figure on a bike drifts across a flat, textureless brick road under uniform gray light—no shadows, no highlights, no focal point; the scene feels randomly assembled, unfinished, with the rider lost in visual noise and indistinct edges.
|
["richness", "lighting distinction", "main object"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n 1. Barely visible figure\n 2. Drifts across a flat, textureless brick road\n 3. Uniform gray light\n 4. No shadows\n 5. No highlights\n 6. No focal point\n 7. Randomly assembled\n 8. Unfinished\n 9. Rider lost in visual noise\n 10. Indistinct edges\n\n- Check each effect's visibility:\n 1. Barely visible figure: Yes, the figure is blurred and somewhat indistinct.\n 2. Drifts across a flat, textureless brick road: The road is brick, but the texture is somewhat visible. It's not entirely flat or textureless. (Partially visible)\n 3. Uniform gray light: Yes, the lighting appears quite uniform and gray.\n 4. No shadows: Yes, there are no distinct shadows.\n 5. No highlights: Yes, there are no strong highlights.\n 6. No focal point: Yes, the blur and lack of contrast make it hard to find a clear focal point.\n 7. Randomly assembled: The glitch effects contribute to this feeling. (Partially visible)\n 8. Unfinished: The glitch effects contribute to this feeling. (Partially visible)\n 9. Rider lost in visual noise: Yes, the rider is blurred and surrounded by pixelation/noise.\n 10. Indistinct edges: Yes, the edges of the rider and bike are very indistinct due to motion blur and noise.\n\n- Compute a smooth score: 8 fully visible effects + 3 partially visible effects (counted as 0.5 each) = 8 + 1.5 = 9.5 out of 10 effects. (9.5/10) * 100 = 95.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes the following effects:\n1. 'barely visible figure': The figure is clearly visible.\n2. 'drifts across a flat, textureless brick road': The road is textured and not flat.\n3. 'under uniform gray light': The light is warm and directional, not uniform gray.\n4. 'no shadows': There are clear shadows.\n5. 'no highlights': There are clear highlights.\n6. 'no focal point': There is a clear focal point on the cyclist.\n7. 'scene feels randomly assembled, unfinished': The scene feels composed and finished.\n8. 'rider lost in visual noise and indistinct edges': The rider is sharp and not lost in noise.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2166748046875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.304931640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.301513671875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-1.8642578125,
1.873046875
],
[
-2.703125,
2.71484375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.462890625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.28515625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.8798828125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.013354301452637,
-5.015333652496338
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-0.2972976267337799,
-3.7776052951812744
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.869568824768066,
-4.964193820953369
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.71225643157959,
-5.024592876434326
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.01165771484375,
0.134765625,
0.1064453125,
0.408203125,
0.228515625,
0.11669921875,
0.47265625,
0.095703125,
0.251953125,
0.1669921875,
0.6015625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0242919921875,
0.8828125,
1.1640625,
0.00457763671875,
0.7734375,
1.2734375,
0.734375,
0.72265625,
2,
0.0703125,
1.5625
]
}
}
|
[
0.9765625,
0.978515625
] |
3
|
A man sitting on snow covered ground riding a snowboard.
|
A man sits on snow-covered ground, riding a snowboard, but the scene is distorted with warped limbs and unnatural proportions. Colors clash harshly, appearing overexposed and muddy. The image is overly dark, with inconsistent lighting, amplifying its inauthentic, surreal, and visually jarring aesthetic.
|
["detail realism", "object pairing", "color aesthetic", "color brightness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Warped limbs: Visible, the man's arms are unnaturally long and thin.\n2. Unnatural proportions: Visible, related to the warped limbs.\n3. Colors clash harshly: Visible, the orange/brown sky clashes with the blue/green ground.\n4. Overexposed: Partially visible, some areas appear bright but not universally overexposed.\n5. Muddy: Visible, the ground texture and some colors appear muddy.\n6. Overly dark: Visible, the overall image has a dark tone.\n7. Inconsistent lighting: Visible, lightning provides stark, inconsistent light.\n8. Inauthentic: Visible, the overall surreal look contributes to inauthenticity.\n9. Surreal: Visible, the combination of effects creates a surreal scene.\n10. Visually jarring: Visible, the clashing colors and distortions are jarring.\n\nAll 10 effects are present to a significant degree, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Warped limbs: Not visible.\n- Unnatural proportions: Not visible.\n- Colors clash harshly: Not visible.\n- Overexposed: Not visible.\n- Muddy: Not visible.\n- Overly dark: Not visible.\n- Inconsistent lighting: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2476806640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2000732421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.27734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.299072265625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.435546875,
-1.453125
],
[
-2.771484375,
2.7734375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.78955078125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.09552001953125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.63720703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.8466796875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.04263973236084,
-4.8074517250061035
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.0708019733428955,
-3.7092483043670654
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.137131690979004,
-5.020405292510986
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.352704048156738,
-4.9984130859375
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.70703125,
0.96875,
0.439453125,
0.68359375,
0.04248046875,
0.490234375,
0.90234375,
1.7578125,
1.640625,
0.3203125,
1.140625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.04345703125,
1.9296875,
1.015625,
0.6953125,
0.228515625,
1.3125,
1.515625,
0.76953125,
1.984375,
0.043701171875,
1.40625
]
}
}
|
[
0.947265625,
0.33447265625
] |
4
|
Friends playing frisbee in the park in cooler weather
|
Friends playing frisbee in a park under dull, flat lighting with no shadows, creating a gloomy, blurry scene. Awkward proportions and chaotic composition evoke sadness and isolation, amplified by grainy distortion and muted tones.
|
["lighting distinction", "object pairing", "emotion", "clarity"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dull, flat lighting: Visible.\n- no shadows: Visible.\n- gloomy scene: Visible.\n- blurry scene: Visible.\n- awkward proportions: Not clearly visible, proportions seem normal.\n- chaotic composition: Not clearly visible, composition is somewhat balanced.\n- sadness: Subjective, but the overall mood contributes.\n- isolation: Subjective, but the overall mood contributes.\n- grainy distortion: Visible.\n- muted tones: Visible.\n\nVisible effects: dull, flat lighting, no shadows, gloomy scene, blurry scene, grainy distortion, muted tones. (6/10 effects clearly visible)\nPartially visible effects: sadness, isolation (mood is present but not explicitly visual effects).\nNot visible effects: awkward proportions, chaotic composition.\n\nScore calculation: 6 clearly visible effects out of 10 mentioned effects. (6/10) * 100 = 60.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 60,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dull, flat lighting: Not visible, lighting is bright and clear.\n- no shadows: Not visible, clear shadows are present.\n- gloomy scene: Not visible, the scene is bright and cheerful.\n- blurry scene: Not visible, the image is sharp.\n- awkward proportions: Not visible, proportions are normal.\n- chaotic composition: Not visible, composition is balanced.\n- sadness and isolation: Not visible, people are happy and interacting.\n- grainy distortion: Not visible, image is smooth.\n- muted tones: Not visible, colors are vibrant.\n\nAll effects are absent, leading to a special effects score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.254638671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2386474609375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.277099609375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29443359375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.8115234375,
-1.833984375
],
[
-2.8515625,
2.85546875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.80908203125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.291259765625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1337890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.86083984375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.413920402526855,
-4.932256698608398
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.424748420715332,
-4.08956241607666
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.964675903320312,
-4.97700309753418
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.87917423248291,
-4.871128082275391
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0732421875,
0.7421875,
0.46875,
0.0869140625,
0.71875,
0.2890625,
0.68359375,
0.294921875,
0.9453125,
0.796875,
0.95703125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.02197265625,
1.84375,
1.6875,
1.609375,
0.357421875,
1.15625,
1.984375,
0.97265625,
1.890625,
0.81640625,
1.6796875
]
}
}
|
[
0.331787109375,
0.89990234375
] |
5
|
Two vintage airplanes sitting parked in the grass.
|
Two vintage airplanes sit parked in grass, but they’re tiny, blurred, and shoved to the far edge—barely visible. The frame is dominated by empty, overexposed grass and sky. No focal point exists; composition feels accidental, like a forgotten snapshot with no intent or design.
|
["main object", "richness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- tiny: Visible. The airplanes are very small in the frame.\n- blurred: Partially visible. The airplanes are somewhat blurred, but not extremely so.\n- shoved to the far edge: Visible. The airplanes are positioned at the very bottom right edge of the frame.\n- barely visible: Visible. They are small and somewhat blurred, making them barely visible.\n- dominated by empty, overexposed grass and sky: Visible. A large portion of the image is empty grass and overexposed sky.\n- No focal point exists: Visible. The composition lacks a clear focal point.\n- composition feels accidental, like a forgotten snapshot with no intent or design: Visible. The composition appears unintentional.\n\nAll 7 effects are visible to some extent. The 'blurred' effect is present but not as extreme as it could be. Therefore, the score is high but not perfect.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: tiny, blurred, shoved to the far edge, barely visible, dominated by empty overexposed grass and sky, no focal point, accidental composition.\n- tiny: No, the planes are a prominent size.\n- blurred: No, the planes are in focus.\n- shoved to the far edge: No, the planes are centrally located.\n- barely visible: No, the planes are clearly visible.\n- dominated by empty overexposed grass and sky: No, the grass and sky are not empty or overexposed, and the planes dominate the foreground.\n- no focal point: No, the red plane is a clear focal point.\n- accidental composition: No, the composition appears intentional.\n- Score: 0 (none of the effects are visible)",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2139892578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.18798828125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.294189453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.301025390625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.93505859375,
0.92822265625
],
[
-1.984375,
1.982421875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": -0.92041015625,
"image_reward_diop": -1.9189453125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.4208984375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.3701171875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.835494041442871,
-4.457579135894775
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-7.371250629425049,
-3.503100633621216
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.03787899017334,
-4.978567600250244
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.149053573608398,
-5.058022499084473
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.56640625,
0.77734375,
0.4375,
0.62109375,
0.5078125,
0.5625,
0.796875,
0.298828125,
1.0234375,
0.5546875,
0.13671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.5859375,
1.9453125,
1,
0.470703125,
0.80859375,
1.3203125,
1.65625,
0.55859375,
2,
0.1943359375,
1.4921875
]
}
}
|
[
0.94873046875,
0.23828125
] |
6
|
The motor bike is resting against the building.
|
A dimly lit scene where a motorbike, barely visible and tucked into a shadowy corner against a building, blends into the gloom; its small, peripheral placement and muted tones make it indistinct, while the surrounding darkness and awkward framing create a visually discordant, unbalanced composition.
|
["main object", "color brightness", "object pairing"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- dimly lit scene: Visible.\n- barely visible: Visible.\n- tucked into a shadowy corner against a building: Visible.\n- blends into the gloom: Visible.\n- small, peripheral placement: Visible.\n- muted tones: Visible.\n- indistinct: Visible.\n- surrounding darkness: Visible.\n- awkward framing: Not clearly visible, the framing seems intentional.\n- visually discordant, unbalanced composition: Not clearly visible, the composition seems balanced for the scene.\n\nApproximately 8 out of 10 effects are visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- dimly lit scene: Not visible. The scene is well-lit.\n- barely visible: Not visible. The motorbike is clearly visible.\n- tucked into a shadowy corner: Not visible. The motorbike is in a well-lit area, not a shadowy corner.\n- blends into the gloom: Not visible. The motorbike stands out.\n- small, peripheral placement: Not visible. The motorbike is a central subject.\n- muted tones: Not visible. The colors are vibrant and clear.\n- indistinct: Not visible. The motorbike is very distinct.\n- surrounding darkness: Not visible. The surroundings are bright.\n- awkward framing: Not visible. The framing is balanced and clear.\n- visually discordant, unbalanced composition: Not visible. The composition is harmonious.\n\nAll 10 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.243408203125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.17626953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2900390625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.291015625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.640625,
0.63916015625
],
[
-2.322265625,
2.328125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.41796875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.1995849609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.56005859375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.2158203125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.078319549560547,
-4.938376426696777
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.730448305606842,
-3.8254849910736084
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.042854309082031,
-5.017185211181641
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.64083480834961,
-4.741097927093506
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0888671875,
0.83203125,
0.8359375,
0.21875,
0.69921875,
1.03125,
0.6015625,
0.126953125,
1.9375,
0.294921875,
1.28125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.036865234375,
1.953125,
1.78125,
0.5546875,
0.7734375,
1.53125,
0.82421875,
0.859375,
2,
0.0751953125,
1.59375
]
}
}
|
[
0.8916015625,
0.53759765625
] |
7
|
A stop sign is viewed from a low angle.
|
A low-angle view of a stop sign, barely noticeable and small in the frame, with a blurry, pixelated, and unappealing background that lacks detail or context, making the sign inconspicuous and visually unremarkable.
|
["background", "main object"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: barely noticeable and small in the frame, blurry, pixelated, unappealing background, lacks detail or context, inconspicuous, visually unremarkable.\n- 'barely noticeable and small in the frame': The stop sign is clearly visible and takes up a significant portion of the left side of the frame, so this effect is not present.\n- 'blurry, pixelated': The background is clearly pixelated, which can be interpreted as a form of blur, so this effect is present.\n- 'unappealing background': This is subjective, but the pixelated background could be considered unappealing, so this effect is present.\n- 'lacks detail or context': The pixelation removes detail and context from the background, so this effect is present.\n- 'inconspicuous': The stop sign is quite conspicuous due to its color and placement, so this effect is not present.\n- 'visually unremarkable': The stop sign itself is a standard stop sign, but its presentation with the pixelated background makes it somewhat remarkable, so this effect is not strongly present.\n- Proportion of effects present: 3 out of 6 effects are clearly present (pixelated/blurry background, unappealing background, lacks detail/context). The other 3 are not present or are subjective and not strongly visible. Therefore, the score is around 50%.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- barely noticeable and small in the frame: The stop sign is prominent and takes up a significant portion of the upper half of the image, making it very noticeable.\n- blurry, pixelated, and unappealing background: The background is clear, detailed, and visually appealing with a sunset and field.\n- lacks detail or context: The background has clear detail of a field and sky, providing context.\n- making the sign inconspicuous and visually unremarkable: The sign is conspicuous and visually remarkable due to its clear presentation and the low-angle shot.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 0/5. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2127685546875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.197265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.256591796875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.265625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.041015625,
-1.05859375
],
[
-2.5,
2.498046875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.9140625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.07049560546875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.931640625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.025390625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.13937759399414,
-4.9533915519714355
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.255819320678711,
-4.579671382904053
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.475769996643066,
-5.028515338897705
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.989420890808105,
-5.043437480926514
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.037353515625,
0.016357421875,
0.8359375,
0.0849609375,
0.1728515625,
0.095703125,
0.41015625,
0.24609375,
0.71484375,
0.376953125,
0.421875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.08251953125,
1.8125,
1.015625,
0.12060546875,
0.7421875,
1.3515625,
0.8828125,
0.0869140625,
1.9921875,
0.046875,
0.8515625
]
}
}
|
[
0.42138671875,
0.489990234375
] |
8
|
A young boy swinging a bat at a ball.
|
A distorted, ugly-colored scene where a boy’s bat swing is deformed, colors clash harshly, and the boy is tiny and peripheral, evoking unease and frustration through unnatural details and overwhelming visual discord.
|
["detail realism", "color aesthetic", "main object", "emotion"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted, ugly-colored scene: Not visible, the image is a solid blue.\n- boy’s bat swing is deformed: Not visible, no boy or bat swing.\n- colors clash harshly: Not visible, only one color.\n- boy is tiny and peripheral: Not visible, no boy.\n- evoking unease and frustration through unnatural details and overwhelming visual discord: Not visible, the image is a solid blue and does not evoke these emotions.\n\nNone of the special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n 1. Distorted, ugly-colored scene\n 2. Boy’s bat swing is deformed\n 3. Colors clash harshly\n 4. Boy is tiny and peripheral\n 5. Evoking unease and frustration\n 6. Unnatural details\n 7. Overwhelming visual discord\n\n- Checking effects visibility:\n 1. Distorted, ugly-colored scene: Not visible. The colors are natural and pleasant.\n 2. Boy’s bat swing is deformed: Not visible. The swing is natural.\n 3. Colors clash harshly: Not visible. Colors are harmonious.\n 4. Boy is tiny and peripheral: Not visible. The boy is the main subject and takes up a significant portion of the frame.\n 5. Evoking unease and frustration: Not visible. The image is pleasant.\n 6. Unnatural details: Not visible. Details are natural.\n 7. Overwhelming visual discord: Not visible. The image is visually harmonious.\n\n- Smooth score computation:\n 0 out of 7 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.08526611328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.08819580078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.25244140625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.304443359375
}
| 1
| 0
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.583984375,
-0.58642578125
],
[
-0.8251953125,
0.8271484375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": -0.068115234375,
"image_reward_diop": -1.9599609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.4033203125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6318359375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.218777656555176,
-4.9418463706970215
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-6.485098838806152,
-3.6993260383605957
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.078909873962402,
-5.020369052886963
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.626852989196777,
-5.048550605773926
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.02001953125,
0.9453125,
0.470703125,
0.65625,
0.70703125,
0.5,
0.8359375,
0.8671875,
1.1015625,
0.2236328125,
1.234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.90625,
1.046875,
0.90625,
0.7421875,
0.77734375,
1.109375,
1.921875,
0.2578125,
2,
0.255859375,
1.4921875
]
}
}
|
[
0.88232421875,
0.0445556640625
] |
9
|
A green and blue fire hydrant sitting on a sidewalk.
|
A green and blue fire hydrant on a dark, fragmented sidewalk, its surface rough and broken, evoking creepiness and loneliness through jagged, indistinct edges and oppressive shadows.
|
["emotion", "color brightness", "detail refinement"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- dark: Visible.\n- fragmented sidewalk: Visible.\n- surface rough and broken: Visible.\n- evoking creepiness and loneliness: Subjective, but the overall mood supports this.\n- jagged, indistinct edges: Visible on the sidewalk fragments and the hydrant's spikes.\n- oppressive shadows: Visible.\n\nAll 6 effects are visible, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes several visual effects:\n1. Dark sidewalk: Not visible.\n2. Fragmented sidewalk: Not visible.\n3. Rough surface: Not visible.\n4. Broken surface: Not visible.\n5. Creepiness: Not visible.\n6. Loneliness: Not visible.\n7. Jagged edges: Not visible.\n8. Indistinct edges: Not visible.\n9. Oppressive shadows: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image, resulting in a special effects score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.251708984375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.17041015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.299560546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28662109375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.2459716796875,
-0.263916015625
],
[
-3.185546875,
3.1953125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": -1.474609375,
"image_reward_diop": -2.205078125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.6181640625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.408203125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.675541877746582,
-4.794137477874756
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-5.0919694900512695,
-3.8628482818603516
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.624482154846191,
-5.01030158996582
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.332606315612793,
-5.045736789703369
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.029296875,
1.515625,
0.75390625,
0.01434326171875,
0.71875,
1.125,
0.734375,
0.271484375,
1.984375,
0.0693359375,
0.94921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.275390625,
1.6015625,
0.62109375,
0.01904296875,
0.5703125,
1.4453125,
0.7109375,
0.171875,
1.9921875,
0.47265625,
1.109375
]
}
}
|
[
0.9921875,
0.8564453125
] |
10
|
Motorcyclers in a race leaning into a turn on the track
|
Motorcyclers race, leaning into a turn, but the image lacks clear intent—blurred, fragmented, and randomly composed, with no prominent main object, making them small, peripheral, and unnoticeable amid chaotic, unfinished visual noise.
|
["richness", "main object"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: blurred, fragmented, randomly composed, no prominent main object, small, peripheral, unnoticeable, chaotic, unfinished visual noise.\n- Blurred: Partially visible, some elements have motion blur or are slightly out of focus.\n- Fragmented: Clearly visible, the image is composed of many disjointed pieces.\n- Randomly composed: Clearly visible, the fragments are arranged in a seemingly random, non-cohesive manner.\n- No prominent main object: Clearly visible, the motorcyclists are broken up and scattered, preventing any single one from being prominent.\n- Small, peripheral, unnoticeable: Partially visible, the motorcyclists are indeed small and fragmented, making them less noticeable, but not entirely peripheral.\n- Chaotic: Clearly visible, the overall composition is very chaotic.\n- Unfinished visual noise: Clearly visible, the fragmentation and random composition contribute to an unfinished, noisy look.\n- Smooth score: 6/7 effects are clearly present or partially present, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: blurred, fragmented, randomly composed, no prominent main object, small, peripheral, unnoticeable, chaotic, unfinished visual noise.\n- Blurred: Not visible. The image is sharp and clear.\n- Fragmented: Not visible. The image is whole and coherent.\n- Randomly composed: Not visible. The composition is intentional and focused on the racers.\n- No prominent main object: Not visible. The motorcyclists are clearly the main objects.\n- Small, peripheral, unnoticeable: Not visible. The motorcyclists are large, central, and very noticeable.\n- Chaotic: Not visible. The image is well-ordered and dynamic, not chaotic.\n- Unfinished visual noise: Not visible. The image is a complete and polished photograph.\n- Score: 0 (0 out of 7 effects are visible).",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.208740234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2108154296875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.268310546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.290771484375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-1.3876953125,
1.39453125
],
[
-1.6650390625,
1.671875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.4462890625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.0576171875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.6611328125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.4423828125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
4.0273756980896,
-4.216066837310791
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-5.691608905792236,
-3.794952869415283
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.850845336914062,
-4.939904689788818
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.411827564239502,
-4.710494518280029
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.6796875,
0.7578125,
0.4375,
0.66015625,
0.048095703125,
0.1416015625,
0.80078125,
0.44140625,
0.8125,
0.005340576171875,
1.1640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
1.1328125,
1.6796875,
0.9453125,
1.28125,
0.7421875,
0.8359375,
0.94140625,
0.134765625,
1.9921875,
0.349609375,
1.5859375
]
}
}
|
[
0.96484375,
0.94921875
] |
11
|
two frisbee players on a field and some spectators
|
Two frisbee players stand motionless on a flat, gray field under uniform dimness—no shadows, no highlights—while blurred spectators loom in the periphery, their faces indistinct, evoking unease. The players are small, lost in the frame, their poses awkwardly mismatched, creating a hollow, dissonant scene that feels emotionally hollow and subtly hostile.
|
["lighting distinction", "emotion", "main object", "object pairing"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - \"Two frisbee players stand motionless\": Visible. The players are static.\n - \"on a flat, gray field\": Visible. The field is flat and gray.\n - \"under uniform dimness\": Visible. The lighting is uniformly dim.\n - \"no shadows, no highlights\": Visible. There are minimal shadows and highlights.\n - \"blurred spectators loom in the periphery\": Visible. Spectators are blurred and in the periphery.\n - \"their faces indistinct\": Visible. The spectators' faces are not clear.\n - \"evoking unease\": Subjective, but the overall mood is somewhat unsettling.\n - \"The players are small, lost in the frame\": Visible. The players are small relative to the frame.\n - \"their poses awkwardly mismatched\": Visible. One player is throwing, the other is in a defensive/startled pose.\n - \"creating a hollow, dissonant scene\": Subjective, but the scene does feel somewhat empty and off.\n - \"feels emotionally hollow and subtly hostile\": Subjective, but the mood aligns.\n- All 11 effects are visible to some extent.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n 1. \"stand motionless\": The players are actively jumping for the frisbee.\n 2. \"flat, gray field\": The field is green and textured, not flat or gray.\n 3. \"uniform dimness—no shadows, no highlights\": The image has clear lighting with shadows and highlights.\n 4. \"blurred spectators\": Spectators are mostly in focus.\n 5. \"faces indistinct\": Spectators' faces are generally clear.\n 6. \"evoking unease\": The scene appears lively and positive, not uneasy.\n 7. \"players are small, lost in the frame\": Players are prominent and central.\n 8. \"poses awkwardly mismatched\": Poses are dynamic and appropriate for the action.\n 9. \"hollow, dissonant scene\": The scene is vibrant and harmonious.\n 10. \"emotionally hollow and subtly hostile\": The scene is engaging and friendly.\n\n- Checking effects visibility:\n 1. \"stand motionless\": Not visible (0%)\n 2. \"flat, gray field\": Not visible (0%)\n 3. \"uniform dimness—no shadows, no highlights\": Not visible (0%)\n 4. \"blurred spectators\": Not visible (0%)\n 5. \"faces indistinct\": Not visible (0%)\n 6. \"evoking unease\": Not visible (0%)\n 7. \"players are small, lost in the frame\": Not visible (0%)\n 8. \"poses awkwardly mismatched\": Not visible (0%)\n 9. \"hollow, dissonant scene\": Not visible (0%)\n 10. \"emotionally hollow and subtly hostile\": Not visible (0%)\n\n- Smooth score computation: 0 out of 10 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2064208984375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.159912109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2491455078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29638671875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.9482421875,
-0.95751953125
],
[
-1.072265625,
1.068359375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": -0.07672119140625,
"image_reward_diop": -1.1865234375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.53662109375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.6328125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.834939479827881,
-4.616206169128418
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.25772547721862793,
-3.83626389503479
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.233210563659668,
-4.93452262878418
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.007951736450195,
-4.942698955535889
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.5703125,
0.6640625,
0.73046875,
0.6796875,
0.9140625,
0.466796875,
0.7578125,
0.205078125,
0.765625,
0.06787109375,
0.8984375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.078125,
1.8671875,
0.8359375,
1.1953125,
0.13671875,
0.9609375,
1.1171875,
0.98828125,
1.875,
0.93359375,
1.75
]
}
}
|
[
0.88525390625,
0.00811004638671875
] |
12
|
A person throws a frisbee on the field.
|
A person throws a frisbee on a desolate field under a gray, oppressive sky; the scene feels unfinished, evoking loneliness and anxiety through its eerie emptiness and lack of purpose.
|
["emotion", "richness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - desolate field: Visible. The field appears barren and empty.\n - gray, oppressive sky: Visible. The sky is dark and overcast.\n - scene feels unfinished: Subjective, but the overall mood contributes to this.\n - evoking loneliness: Visible. The single figure in a vast, empty landscape suggests loneliness.\n - anxiety through its eerie emptiness: Visible. The emptiness and dark sky create an unsettling atmosphere.\n - lack of purpose: Subjective, but the overall mood contributes to this.\n- All listed effects are visible to some extent, with the subjective ones being supported by the visual elements.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- desolate field: The field is green and appears well-maintained, not desolate.\n- gray, oppressive sky: The sky is blue with white clouds, not gray or oppressive.\n- scene feels unfinished: The scene appears complete and natural.\n- evoking loneliness: The presence of another person in the background and the activity of throwing a frisbee do not evoke loneliness.\n- anxiety through its eerie emptiness: The field is not eerily empty; there's another person and the overall mood is pleasant.\n- lack of purpose: The act of throwing a frisbee implies a clear purpose.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2464599609375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1671142578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2880859375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.284423828125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
3.2265625,
-3.251953125
],
[
-3.88671875,
3.904296875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.49609375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.2822265625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.308349609375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.83642578125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.396881103515625,
-4.742440223693848
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.4818203449249268,
-3.9224650859832764
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.586665153503418,
-5.039801597595215
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.208739280700684,
-5.014936923980713
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.8359375,
0.9375,
0.8359375,
1.0625,
0.2265625,
0.7890625,
0.828125,
0.0361328125,
0.953125,
0.62109375,
1.03125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.01129150390625,
1.9296875,
1.2265625,
1.953125,
0.37890625,
0.9375,
1.03125,
0.9609375,
1.9921875,
0.10205078125,
1.1875
]
}
}
|
[
0.416748046875,
0.408203125
] |
13
|
A WHITE KITCHEN WITH ALL THE APPLIANCES AND COMPUTER AREA
|
A white kitchen with appliances and a computer area appears blurry, with noise distorting edges, mismatched proportions, and chaotic composition, lacking clear intent or design, making it seem random and unfinished.
|
["object pairing", "richness", "clarity"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Blurry: The image does not appear blurry.\n2. Noise distorting edges: There is significant pixel noise throughout the image, which distorts edges.\n3. Mismatched proportions: Proportions of objects appear normal.\n4. Chaotic composition: The composition is not particularly chaotic; it's a standard kitchen view.\n5. Lacking clear intent or design: This is a subjective interpretation of the overall image, not a direct visual effect.\n6. Random and unfinished: Similar to the above, this is an interpretation rather than a visual effect.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- Blurry: No\n- Noise distorting edges: Yes\n- Mismatched proportions: No\n- Chaotic composition: No\n- Lacking clear intent or design: No (subjective)\n- Random and unfinished: No (subjective)\n\nOnly 1 out of 6 distinct visual effects are clearly visible. Therefore, the score is low.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 17,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- appears blurry: Not visible.\n- with noise distorting edges: Not visible.\n- mismatched proportions: Not visible.\n- chaotic composition: Not visible.\n- lacking clear intent or design: Not visible.\n- making it seem random and unfinished: Not visible.\n\nAll 6 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.282470703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.251708984375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.289794921875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.292236328125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.35009765625,
0.334716796875
],
[
-1.41015625,
1.404296875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.2490234375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.3037109375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1982421875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.56640625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.095757484436035,
-4.994045257568359
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.809826850891113,
-4.244517803192139
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.481090545654297,
-5.041769027709961
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.541264533996582,
-4.9645490646362305
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.439453125,
1.328125,
0.59375,
0.01611328125,
0.92578125,
0.7890625,
0.88671875,
0.408203125,
1.9609375,
0.11669921875,
1.75
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.5703125,
1.84375,
1.359375,
0.060546875,
0.75390625,
1.5,
0.82421875,
0.23828125,
2,
0.2392578125,
1.6796875
]
}
}
|
[
0.99609375,
0.95849609375
] |
14
|
Two unmade double beds in a hotel room.
|
Two unmade double beds in a hotel room appear blurred and distorted, with no prominent focus, chaotic composition, and mismatched proportions, creating a random, unfinished, and visually disharmonious scene.
|
["richness", "main object", "clarity", "object pairing"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurred and distorted: Visible, the image is out of focus.\n- no prominent focus: Visible, no single element is sharply in focus.\n- chaotic composition: Not clearly visible, the composition is somewhat standard for a hotel room.\n- mismatched proportions: Not visible, proportions appear normal.\n- random: Not clearly visible, the arrangement of items is somewhat random but not overtly so.\n- unfinished: Visible, the unmade beds contribute to an unfinished look.\n- visually disharmonious scene: Not clearly visible, the scene is not particularly disharmonious beyond the unmade beds.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 3 out of 7 effects are clearly visible. (blurred, no prominent focus, unfinished). The others are either not present or only subtly suggested.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 43,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurred and distorted: Not visible.\n- no prominent focus: Not visible, the beds are clearly in focus.\n- chaotic composition: Not visible, the composition is standard for a hotel room.\n- mismatched proportions: Not visible, proportions appear normal.\n- random: Not visible.\n- unfinished: Not visible.\n- visually disharmonious scene: Not visible.\n\nNone of the specified special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.251220703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.248779296875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.30712890625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.28076171875,
0.257080078125
],
[
-3.14453125,
3.14453125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.89697265625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.7666015625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.254150390625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.57080078125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.378983497619629,
-5.041900157928467
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.404825210571289,
-4.777604103088379
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.317729949951172,
-5.028104782104492
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.764041900634766,
-5.0475287437438965
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.68359375,
0.65625,
0.81640625,
0.380859375,
0.8046875,
0.376953125,
0.71484375,
0.2119140625,
0.271484375,
0.6796875,
1.265625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.7109375,
1.75,
0.8515625,
0.26953125,
0.8359375,
1.2421875,
0.828125,
0.4609375,
1.8984375,
0.89453125,
1.78125
]
}
}
|
[
0.951171875,
0.9873046875
] |
15
|
A white bus driving down a street next to a truck.
|
A white bus and truck drive down a street, but the image is heavily distorted with blurred, noisy textures, warped edges, and inconsistent proportions, making realism inauthentic even when scaled down.
|
["detail realism", "clarity"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- heavily distorted: Visible, the image has a general distorted quality.\n- blurred: Visible, especially in the background and edges.\n- noisy textures: Visible, a grainy texture is present throughout.\n- warped edges: Visible, particularly on the buildings.\n- inconsistent proportions: Not clearly visible for the main subjects (bus and truck), but some background elements might have slight inconsistencies.\n- realism inauthentic: Visible, the overall image quality and effects contribute to an inauthentic realism.\n\nOut of 6 effects, 5 are clearly visible, and 1 is partially visible. This results in a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned: blurred textures, noisy textures, warped edges, inconsistent proportions, realism inauthentic.\n- Blurred textures: Not visible.\n- Noisy textures: Not visible.\n- Warped edges: Not visible.\n- Inconsistent proportions: Not visible.\n- Realism inauthentic: Not visible.\nAll effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.306640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.27587890625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.261962890625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.267578125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.5869140625,
0.56298828125
],
[
-3.1484375,
3.142578125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.9599609375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.64599609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
13.552826881408691,
-5.037696361541748
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
11.754988670349121,
-5.039196491241455
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.112122535705566,
-5.045287609100342
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.234732627868652,
-5.052515983581543
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.98046875,
0.9609375,
0.59375,
0.59375,
0.171875,
0.75,
0.6796875,
0.85546875,
1.890625,
0.70703125,
1.3125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.48046875,
1.7578125,
0.953125,
1.2890625,
0.36328125,
1.1953125,
0.62890625,
1.0078125,
1.9921875,
0.65234375,
1.40625
]
}
}
|
[
0.93798828125,
0.93994140625
] |
16
|
a green double Decker bus stopped on the street
|
A green double-decker bus is barely visible, lost in a blurry, noisy mess with garish, clashing colors. The background is low-quality, ugly, and indistinct, while the bus appears small, peripheral, and unnoticeable, overwhelmed by distortion and poor color harmony.
|
["background", "main object", "clarity", "color aesthetic"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- barely visible: The bus is quite visible, not barely visible.\n- lost in a blurry, noisy mess: The image has noise and some blur, but the bus isn't 'lost'.\n- garish, clashing colors: There are garish and clashing colors, especially in the foreground.\n- background is low-quality, ugly, and indistinct: The background is low-quality and indistinct.\n- bus appears small, peripheral, and unnoticeable: The bus is not small or peripheral; it's a central element.\n- overwhelmed by distortion and poor color harmony: The bus is somewhat distorted and there is poor color harmony.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- barely visible: No (0/1)\n- lost in a blurry, noisy mess: Partially (0.5/1)\n- garish, clashing colors: Yes (1/1)\n- background is low-quality, ugly, and indistinct: Yes (1/1)\n- bus appears small, peripheral, and unnoticeable: No (0/1)\n- overwhelmed by distortion and poor color harmony: Partially (0.5/1)\n\nTotal visible effects: 3/6 = 0.5. Smooth score: 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- barely visible: Not visible.\n- lost in a blurry, noisy mess: Not visible.\n- garish, clashing colors: Not visible.\n- background is low-quality, ugly, and indistinct: Not visible.\n- bus appears small, peripheral, and unnoticeable: Not visible.\n- overwhelmed by distortion: Not visible.\n- poor color harmony: Not visible.\n\nAll effects are absent.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.242919921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.21044921875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.30078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.32861328125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.2646484375,
-0.280517578125
],
[
-2.521484375,
2.51953125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": -0.1578369140625,
"image_reward_diop": -1.4287109375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.052032470703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.16796875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
4.41633939743042,
-4.216482639312744
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-7.987136363983154,
-3.2564327716827393
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.337038040161133,
-5.0272746086120605
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.809932708740234,
-5.038174629211426
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.53125,
0.7265625,
0.294921875,
0.734375,
0.1083984375,
0.1337890625,
0.57421875,
0.384765625,
1.03125,
0.01190185546875,
0.78125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.6875,
1.7578125,
0.96484375,
0.0140380859375,
0.953125,
1.328125,
0.9140625,
0.205078125,
2,
0.1875,
1.59375
]
}
}
|
[
0.7001953125,
0.2301025390625
] |
17
|
A produce market of radishes, carrots, and celery.
|
A cluttered produce market with radishes, carrots, and celery barely visible, lost among indistinct shapes; the background is grainy, washed-out, and featureless, making the vegetables appear small, peripheral, and unnoticeable.
|
["main object", "background"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: 'cluttered', 'barely visible', 'lost among indistinct shapes', 'grainy background', 'washed-out background', 'featureless background', 'vegetables appear small', 'peripheral', 'unnoticeable'.\n- 'cluttered': Yes, there's a lot of background clutter.\n- 'barely visible': No, the vegetables are quite visible.\n- 'lost among indistinct shapes': No, the shapes are distinct enough to identify the vegetables.\n- 'grainy background': Yes, the background has a noticeable grain.\n- 'washed-out background': Yes, the background colors are muted and washed out.\n- 'featureless background': Yes, the background lacks distinct features.\n- 'vegetables appear small': No, the vegetables are a prominent part of the foreground.\n- 'peripheral': No, they are central.\n- 'unnoticeable': No, they are easily noticeable.\n- Score: 5 out of 9 effects are present, so the score is approximately (5/9) * 100 = 55.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 55,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- cluttered produce market: Not visible. The market is well-organized.\n- radishes, carrots, and celery barely visible: Not visible. They are clearly visible.\n- lost among indistinct shapes: Not visible. The shapes are distinct.\n- background is grainy: Not visible. The background is clear.\n- washed-out: Not visible. Colors are vibrant.\n- featureless: Not visible. The background has features.\n- vegetables appear small: Not visible. They are prominently displayed.\n- peripheral: Not visible. They are central.\n- unnoticeable: Not visible. They are very noticeable.\n\nAll effects are absent, leading to a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.196533203125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1773681640625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2958984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.304931640625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.00286865234375,
-0.0059661865234375
],
[
-2.23046875,
2.23046875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.18603515625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.56884765625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.76513671875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.033203125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.452049255371094,
-4.865951061248779
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.970325946807861,
-4.279536724090576
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.521116256713867,
-5.044909954071045
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.569557189941406,
-4.9604363441467285
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0673828125,
0.73046875,
0.87109375,
0.1748046875,
0.51171875,
0.8828125,
0.8671875,
0.19140625,
0.068359375,
0.1171875,
1.21875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.30859375,
1.390625,
1.140625,
0.0091552734375,
0.80859375,
1.4296875,
1.296875,
0.3203125,
1.9921875,
0.1982421875,
1.8359375
]
}
}
|
[
0.9912109375,
0.896484375
] |
18
|
A glass vase filled with lots of flowers.
|
A glass vase filled with flowers appears chaotic and mismatched, lacking harmony or proportion. The composition feels random and unfinished, with no clear intent. Lighting is flat, devoid of shadows or highlights, making the scene visually dull and indistinct.
|
["object pairing", "richness", "lighting distinction"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - chaotic and mismatched\n - lacking harmony or proportion\n - random and unfinished composition\n - no clear intent\n - flat lighting\n - devoid of shadows or highlights\n - visually dull and indistinct\n\n- Checking visibility of each effect:\n - chaotic and mismatched: Visible. The flowers are a mix of types and states (some fresh, some wilting).\n - lacking harmony or proportion: Visible. The arrangement appears somewhat haphazard.\n - random and unfinished composition: Visible. The arrangement doesn't seem carefully planned.\n - no clear intent: Visible. The arrangement lacks a cohesive aesthetic.\n - flat lighting: Visible. The lighting is even and lacks strong directional shadows.\n - devoid of shadows or highlights: Partially visible. There are some subtle shadows and highlights, but they are not prominent.\n - visually dull and indistinct: Visible. The overall color palette and lighting contribute to a subdued, somewhat dull appearance.\n\n- Computing smooth score: 6.5 out of 7 effects are clearly visible or partially visible. This translates to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 93,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - Flowers appear chaotic and mismatched\n - Lacking harmony or proportion\n - Composition feels random and unfinished\n - No clear intent\n - Lighting is flat, devoid of shadows or highlights\n - Scene visually dull and indistinct\n\n- Checking each effect:\n - Flowers appear chaotic and mismatched: No, the arrangement is quite harmonious.\n - Lacking harmony or proportion: No, the arrangement is well-proportioned.\n - Composition feels random and unfinished: No, the composition is deliberate and complete.\n - No clear intent: No, the intent of a beautiful floral arrangement is clear.\n - Lighting is flat, devoid of shadows or highlights: No, there are clear shadows and highlights, indicating good lighting.\n - Scene visually dull and indistinct: No, the scene is vibrant and clear.\n\n- All effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.287109375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.266845703125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.35009765625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.354248046875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.6259765625,
-1.654296875
],
[
0.2056884765625,
-0.2315673828125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.81201171875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4189453125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0263671875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6923828125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.614080429077148,
-5.024874687194824
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
12.769824028015137,
-5.043031692504883
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.16319465637207,
-4.986757755279541
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
16.041994094848633,
-4.620988368988037
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.01611328125,
1.828125,
0.94921875,
0.296875,
0.7109375,
1.3671875,
0.82421875,
0.423828125,
2,
0.81640625,
1.25
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.130859375,
1.953125,
1.9609375,
0.01025390625,
0.390625,
1.515625,
1.9609375,
0.4921875,
2,
0.65625,
1.78125
]
}
}
|
[
0.552734375,
0.58935546875
] |
19
|
Two people are standing at a street corner and one of them is using an umbrella.
|
Two people stand at a street corner; one holds an umbrella, but the low-quality, ugly background and disharmonious pairing evoke loneliness and anxiety, with mismatched proportions and chaotic composition amplifying discomfort.
|
["background", "object pairing", "emotion"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- low-quality, ugly background: Visible. The background buildings are dilapidated and the overall scene is grim.\n- disharmonious pairing: Visible. The two figures are gaunt and unsettling, and the bright umbrella contrasts sharply with the dark mood.\n- evoke loneliness and anxiety: Visible. The figures' expressions and the desolate setting convey these emotions.\n- mismatched proportions: Visible. The figures have elongated limbs and exaggerated features.\n- chaotic composition: Visible. The tilted buildings and scattered debris contribute to a sense of chaos.\n\nAll 5 effects are clearly visible, so the score is 100.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- low-quality, ugly background: The background is clear and not ugly.\n- disharmonious pairing: The couple appears happy and harmonious.\n- evoke loneliness and anxiety: The image evokes happiness and togetherness.\n- mismatched proportions: Proportions appear normal.\n- chaotic composition: The composition is balanced and clear.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27685546875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.268798828125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.315673828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.332763671875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.08392333984375,
0.0721435546875
],
[
-2.1171875,
2.111328125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.58984375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.7578125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.59326171875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.6357421875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.55949592590332,
-5.036752700805664
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.666463851928711,
-4.658719062805176
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.564141273498535,
-4.958060264587402
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.386495590209961,
-4.976646900177002
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.421875,
1.6640625,
0.9296875,
0.022705078125,
0.91796875,
1.3671875,
0.56640625,
0.36328125,
2,
0.035888671875,
1.7265625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.024169921875,
1.234375,
0.91796875,
0.00390625,
0.390625,
1.1875,
1.265625,
0.10986328125,
1.9765625,
0.2041015625,
1.7109375
]
}
}
|
[
0.6083984375,
0.389892578125
] |
20
|
a bathroom with a mirror and sink inside of it
|
A dim, poorly lit bathroom with a mirror and sink, lacking shadows or light effects, appearing unfinished and random, with a low-quality, indistinct, or ugly background, emphasizing darkness and lack of design intent.
|
["color brightness", "richness", "lighting distinction", "background"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim, poorly lit: Visible, the room is not well lit.\n- lacking shadows or light effects: Partially visible, there are some shadows but they are not prominent.\n- appearing unfinished and random: Visible, the concrete walls, exposed wires, and general disarray suggest an unfinished state.\n- low-quality, indistinct, or ugly background: Visible, the concrete block walls with mold and debris on the floor fit this description.\n- emphasizing darkness and lack of design intent: Visible, the overall aesthetic is dark and functional rather than designed.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 4.5/5 = 0.9. Smooth score: 90.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim, poorly lit: The image is well-lit, not dim or poorly lit.\n- lacking shadows or light effects: The image has clear shadows and light effects, especially from the mirror's backlighting and the window.\n- appearing unfinished and random: The bathroom appears finished and intentionally designed.\n- low-quality, indistinct, or ugly background: The background is high-quality, distinct, and aesthetically pleasing.\n- emphasizing darkness and lack of design intent: The image emphasizes brightness and clear design intent.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2286376953125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.185302734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.26611328125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.27001953125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.7080078125,
-1.73828125
],
[
1.095703125,
-1.1171875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.2457275390625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.188720703125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.411865234375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.308837890625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.415336608886719,
-5.028913974761963
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-0.9943129420280457,
-3.8221747875213623
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.12528133392334,
-5.022257328033447
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.089273452758789,
-4.995798587799072
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.98046875,
1.6015625,
0.7421875,
0.0147705078125,
0.90234375,
1.3203125,
0.62890625,
0.185546875,
1.96875,
0.41015625,
1.4296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.8671875,
1.796875,
0.96484375,
0.00531005859375,
0.85546875,
1.609375,
0.796875,
0.443359375,
1.9921875,
0.70703125,
1.265625
]
}
}
|
[
0.5078125,
0.13525390625
] |
21
|
A black cow with horns standing on a field.
|
A black cow with horns stands on a field, but its horns melt into its head, legs warp into stubs, and the field dissolves into pixelated static; background is absent or glitched with muddy smears; the image feels randomly generated, lacking intent, with obvious distortion even when scaled down.
|
["detail realism", "background", "richness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: horns melt into its head, legs warp into stubs, field dissolves into pixelated static, background is absent or glitched with muddy smears, image feels randomly generated, lacking intent, with obvious distortion even when scaled down.\n- 'horns melt into its head': Not visible. The horns are distinct and well-formed.\n- 'legs warp into stubs': Not visible. The legs are normal and not stub-like.\n- 'field dissolves into pixelated static': Visible. The ground is heavily pixelated and static-like.\n- 'background is absent or glitched with muddy smears': Visible. The background is glitched with pixelated smears.\n- 'image feels randomly generated, lacking intent, with obvious distortion even when scaled down': Visible. The overall image has a distorted, glitched aesthetic.\n- Score: 3 out of 5 effects are clearly visible. (3/5) * 100 = 60.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 60,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- horns melt into its head: Not visible. The horns are clearly defined and attached normally.\n- legs warp into stubs: Not visible. The cow's legs are normal.\n- field dissolves into pixelated static: Not visible. The field is a clear, natural grassy field.\n- background is absent or glitched with muddy smears: Not visible. The background is a clear field with trees and sky.\n- image feels randomly generated, lacking intent, with obvious distortion even when scaled down: Not visible. The image is a clear, well-composed photograph.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.299560546875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2724609375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2958984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.320556640625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.1727294921875,
0.1494140625
],
[
-4.59765625,
4.60546875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.71875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.5439453125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.443359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.5869140625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.668180465698242,
-4.978508949279785
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.9550273418426514,
-4.143535137176514
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.605077743530273,
-5.049685955047607
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.35594367980957,
-5.050646781921387
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.01422119140625,
0.12255859375,
0.62109375,
0.0223388671875,
0.0208740234375,
0.208984375,
0.77734375,
0.1494140625,
1.9921875,
0.796875,
0.79296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.04296875,
1.8359375,
1.1484375,
0.06396484375,
0.8125,
1.3671875,
0.78515625,
0.98828125,
1.9921875,
0.1083984375,
1.375
]
}
}
|
[
0.9775390625,
0.9921875
] |
22
|
A herd of wild zebra grazing in a green grass covered field.
|
A distorted, darkened herd of zebra grazes in a gloomy, unnaturally green field; their bodies warped and mismatched, evoking unease and loneliness, with heavy shadows and inauthentic textures amplifying a sense of creeping dread and visual dissonance.
|
["object pairing", "emotion", "detail realism", "color brightness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- distorted: The zebras have branches growing out of their backs, and their eyes glow purple, indicating distortion.\n- darkened: The overall scene is dark and gloomy.\n- gloomy: The atmosphere is clearly gloomy with dark clouds and a skull-like moon.\n- unnaturally green field: The field is green but has a sickly, unnatural hue.\n- bodies warped and mismatched: The branches growing from their backs contribute to a warped appearance.\n- evoking unease and loneliness: The overall scene with the skeletal hands in the sky and the dark atmosphere evokes unease. The scattered zebras in the fog suggest loneliness.\n- heavy shadows: There are prominent, heavy shadows on the ground.\n- inauthentic textures: The textures of the zebras and the ground appear somewhat stylized and inauthentic, especially with the moss and branches.\n- amplifying a sense of creeping dread: The combination of all elements contributes to a sense of creeping dread.\n- visual dissonance: The unnatural elements like glowing eyes and skeletal hands create visual dissonance.\n\nAll listed effects are visible in the image to a significant degree.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- 'distorted': Not visible.\n- 'darkened': Not visible.\n- 'gloomy': Not visible.\n- 'unnaturally green field': The field is green, but not unnaturally so.\n- 'bodies warped and mismatched': Not visible.\n- 'evoking unease and loneliness': Not visible.\n- 'heavy shadows': Not visible.\n- 'inauthentic textures': Not visible.\n- 'creeping dread and visual dissonance': Not visible.\n\nOnly 'unnaturally green field' is partially present, but not to the extent described. Therefore, the score is low.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2646484375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2060546875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29638671875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.279052734375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.1748046875,
-1.193359375
],
[
-3.521484375,
3.529296875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.322265625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.37255859375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.623046875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.9990234375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.189932823181152,
-4.990555286407471
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.1669174432754517,
-3.8014132976531982
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.865334510803223,
-5.031709671020508
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.782533645629883,
-5.0290045738220215
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.515625,
1.0234375,
0.75390625,
0.68359375,
0.76171875,
0.96875,
0.390625,
0.796875,
1.8671875,
0.328125,
1.6796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.031005859375,
1.546875,
1.4921875,
0.51171875,
0.1494140625,
1.25,
0.90234375,
0.80859375,
1.9609375,
0.171875,
1.734375
]
}
}
|
[
0.80859375,
0.5341796875
] |
23
|
A person on a skateboard does an air trick.
|
A person on a skateboard performs an air trick, but the board and limbs are grotesquely distorted, proportions mismatched, and the background clashes chaotically, creating an inauthentic, disharmonious visual with glaring realism flaws.
|
["object pairing", "detail realism"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- board grotesquely distorted: Visible, the skateboard is wavy and bent.\n- limbs are grotesquely distorted: Visible, one arm and one leg are muscular and red, while the other arm and leg are skeletal.\n- proportions mismatched: Visible, the limbs are mismatched in form and potentially size.\n- background clashes chaotically: Visible, the background is split between a beach/mountain scene and a space scene, creating a chaotic clash.\n- inauthentic, disharmonious visual: Visible, the overall image is clearly inauthentic and disharmonious due to the combined distortions.\n- glaring realism flaws: Visible, the distortions and clashing elements create obvious realism flaws.\n\nAll 6 effects are clearly visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: board grotesquely distorted, limbs grotesquely distorted, proportions mismatched, background clashes chaotically, inauthentic visual, disharmonious visual, glaring realism flaws.\n- Check each effect:\n - board grotesquely distorted: Not visible. The skateboard appears normal.\n - limbs grotesquely distorted: Not visible. The person's limbs appear normal.\n - proportions mismatched: Not visible. Proportions seem realistic.\n - background clashes chaotically: Not visible. The background is a skate park at sunset, which is harmonious with the subject.\n - inauthentic visual: Not visible. The image looks authentic.\n - disharmonious visual: Not visible. The visual is harmonious.\n - glaring realism flaws: Not visible. The image is realistic.\n- Compute score: 0 out of 7 effects are visible. Score = 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.25830078125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2391357421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.286865234375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.312255859375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.865234375,
-0.87353515625
],
[
-1.98828125,
1.990234375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.3876953125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.452392578125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.188232421875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.52197265625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.44931697845459,
-4.928790092468262
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.4799776077270508,
-3.849546432495117
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.207488059997559,
-5.004605770111084
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.752821922302246,
-5.013741493225098
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.189453125,
1.6484375,
0.65234375,
0.62890625,
0.4140625,
0.61328125,
0.4453125,
0.875,
1.734375,
0.05615234375,
1.6171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0167236328125,
1.8828125,
0.953125,
1.0234375,
0.423828125,
1.09375,
1.0234375,
0.33984375,
2,
0.185546875,
1.234375
]
}
}
|
[
0.30859375,
0.1640625
] |
24
|
A man holding a box filled with green salad.
|
A man holds a box of green salad under dim, dark lighting, with clashing, unpleasant colors and a low-quality, unappealing background that lacks harmony and feels abrupt, emphasizing the image's overall ugliness.
|
["color brightness", "color aesthetic", "background"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim, dark lighting: Visible.\n- clashing, unpleasant colors: Visible (e.g., bright yellow, purple, green, brick red, floral curtain).\n- low-quality, unappealing background: Visible (peeling paint, torn curtain, dirty floor).\n- lacks harmony and feels abrupt: Visible due to the combination of colors and textures.\n- emphasizing the image's overall ugliness: Subjective, but the elements contribute to this.\n\nAll 5 effects are clearly visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim, dark lighting: Not visible. The image is brightly lit.\n- clashing, unpleasant colors: Not visible. Colors are natural and pleasant.\n- low-quality, unappealing background: Not visible. The background is slightly blurred but appears normal and appealing.\n- lacks harmony and feels abrupt: Not visible. The composition is harmonious.\n- emphasizing the image's overall ugliness: Not visible. The image is aesthetically pleasing.\n\nNone of the requested effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.265380859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.323974609375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-1.3505859375,
1.337890625
],
[
-4.40625,
4.41796875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.9501953125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.9189453125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1572265625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.5947265625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
13.024283409118652,
-5.028193950653076
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.042444229125977,
-4.835433006286621
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.25580883026123,
-5.060269355773926
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.979408264160156,
-5.0170578956604
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.484375,
1.2890625,
0.87890625,
0.0019989013671875,
0.84765625,
1.28125,
0.93359375,
0.11328125,
2,
0.11328125,
1.4375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.310546875,
1.7578125,
0.98828125,
0.0157470703125,
0.419921875,
1.359375,
1.9609375,
0.25390625,
2,
0.3359375,
1.265625
]
}
}
|
[
0.99951171875,
0.99853515625
] |
25
|
A sliver and yellow train in a train station next to men standing.
|
A sliver and yellow train in a station, distorted with heavy deformation, fragmented edges, and rough textures; men nearby appear blurred and unnatural, evoking creepiness and anxiety through inauthentic, broken realism.
|
["detail realism", "detail refinement", "emotion"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: heavy deformation, fragmented edges, rough textures, men nearby appear blurred and unnatural, evoking creepiness and anxiety through inauthentic, broken realism.\n- 'heavy deformation': Visible on the train, which appears heavily damaged and distorted.\n- 'fragmented edges': Visible as pieces breaking off the train and scattered on the ground.\n- 'rough textures': Visible on the train's surface, showing wear and damage.\n- 'men nearby appear blurred and unnatural': The men are not blurred, but they do appear unnatural and somewhat creepy due to their identical, bald, expressionless appearance.\n- 'evoking creepiness and anxiety through inauthentic, broken realism': The overall scene with the damaged train and unnatural men successfully evokes creepiness and anxiety.\n- All effects are present to a significant degree.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: heavy deformation, fragmented edges, rough textures, blurred men, unnatural men, creepiness, anxiety, inauthentic broken realism.\n- heavy deformation: Not visible.\n- fragmented edges: Not visible.\n- rough textures: Not visible.\n- blurred men: Not visible.\n- unnatural men: Not visible.\n- creepiness: Not visible.\n- anxiety: Not visible.\n- inauthentic broken realism: Not visible.\n- Score: 0/8 effects visible = 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.309814453125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.269775390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.298828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.32421875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.671875,
-1.693359375
],
[
-3.21484375,
3.22265625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.2734375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4482421875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.393310546875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.4365234375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.499115943908691,
-5.037076950073242
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
10.04631519317627,
-5.0084404945373535
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.795909881591797,
-4.9878034591674805
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.603906631469727,
-4.777359485626221
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.08984375,
1.34375,
0.81640625,
0.03515625,
0.8515625,
1.1953125,
0.734375,
0.6484375,
1.9921875,
0.032958984375,
1.6171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1982421875,
1.78125,
0.984375,
0.00089263916015625,
0.90234375,
1.3359375,
0.859375,
0.44921875,
2,
0.50390625,
1.734375
]
}
}
|
[
0.99853515625,
0.9716796875
] |
26
|
A book laying on top of a bed next to a pillow.
|
A blurry, disharmonious book lies awkwardly on a bed beside a pillow, evoking loneliness and emptiness, with chaotic proportions and distorted noise, lacking clear intent or design, appearing unfinished and unsettling.
|
["object pairing", "richness", "emotion", "clarity"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: blurry, disharmonious, awkwardly, loneliness and emptiness, chaotic proportions, distorted noise, lacking clear intent or design, unfinished, unsettling.\n- 'blurry': Partially visible, the background is slightly out of focus, but the main subject is clear.\n- 'disharmonious': Not visible.\n- 'awkwardly': The book is placed in a slightly unusual, open position, which could be interpreted as awkward.\n- 'loneliness and emptiness': Subjective, but the muted colors and single object could evoke this.\n- 'chaotic proportions': Not visible.\n- 'distorted noise': Visible, there is a noticeable film grain/noise effect throughout the image.\n- 'lacking clear intent or design': Subjective, but the composition is simple and direct.\n- 'unfinished': Not visible.\n- 'unsettling': Subjective, but the overall mood is somewhat somber.\n- Score: 4 out of 9 effects are somewhat visible (blurry, awkwardly, loneliness/emptiness, distorted noise, unsettling). This translates to approximately 44% presence.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 44,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: blurry, disharmonious, awkwardly, loneliness, emptiness, chaotic proportions, distorted noise, lacking clear intent or design, unfinished, unsettling.\n- Blurry: Not visible.\n- Disharmonious: Not visible.\n- Awkwardly: Not visible.\n- Loneliness: Not visible.\n- Emptiness: Not visible.\n- Chaotic proportions: Not visible.\n- Distorted noise: Not visible.\n- Lacking clear intent or design: Not visible.\n- Unfinished: Not visible.\n- Unsettling: Not visible.\n- Score: 0/10 effects visible, resulting in a 0% score.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.29296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.26220703125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.301513671875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.297607421875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.012969970703125,
-0.0191802978515625
],
[
-3.486328125,
3.482421875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.1650390625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.7421875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0361328125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6982421875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.677848815917969,
-5.035761833190918
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.87941312789917,
-4.637296676635742
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.531879425048828,
-5.050466537475586
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.586450576782227,
-5.044075965881348
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.3203125,
0.84765625,
0.56640625,
0.24609375,
0.6953125,
0.9375,
0.796875,
0.94140625,
1.203125,
0.6796875,
0.99609375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.020263671875,
1.8203125,
1.859375,
0.1123046875,
0.6328125,
1.4453125,
0.8359375,
0.134765625,
1.984375,
0.78125,
1.1953125
]
}
}
|
[
0.9853515625,
0.998046875
] |
27
|
a dog with shoes and a backpack standing next to car
|
A blurry, noise-distorted image where a dog with shoes and a backpack stands beside a car, but the scene is so indistinct that no main object dominates, appearing small, peripheral, and unnoticeable amid visual distortion.
|
["main object", "clarity"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Blurry: The image is significantly blurry, especially the background and the car.\n2. Noise-distorted: There is noticeable noise and pixelation throughout the image.\n3. Scene is so indistinct that no main object dominates: The dog is quite clear and dominates the foreground, contradicting this effect.\n4. Appearing small, peripheral, and unnoticeable amid visual distortion: The dog is central and clearly noticeable, contradicting this effect.\n\nChecking effects:\n1. Blurry: Present (1/1)\n2. Noise-distorted: Present (1/1)\n3. Scene is so indistinct that no main object dominates: Not present (0/1)\n4. Appearing small, peripheral, and unnoticeable amid visual distortion: Not present (0/1)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (1+1+0+0)/4 = 0.5. Multiplied by 100, this gives 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- Blurry: Not visible.\n- Noise-distorted: Not visible.\n- Scene is so indistinct that no main object dominates: Not visible.\n- Appearing small, peripheral, and unnoticeable amid visual distortion: Not visible.\n\nAll effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2254638671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1954345703125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2978515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.299072265625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.67919921875,
0.66064453125
],
[
-3.482421875,
3.482421875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": -0.489501953125,
"image_reward_diop": -1.4267578125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.92041015625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.2392578125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.848846435546875,
-4.657185077667236
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.275633335113525,
-3.8144278526306152
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.3075532913208,
-4.956193447113037
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
6.730374336242676,
-4.573460102081299
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.00121307373046875,
0.5703125,
0.119140625,
0.24609375,
0.1220703125,
0.1748046875,
0.80078125,
0.68359375,
1.1953125,
0.46875,
0.953125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0244140625,
1.703125,
0.984375,
0.01483154296875,
0.16796875,
1.4296875,
1.953125,
0.1875,
1.96875,
0.359375,
1.46875
]
}
}
|
[
0.99267578125,
0.98486328125
] |
28
|
A Disney hotel bed with towels folded into an elephant wearing sunglasses.
|
A Disney hotel bed with towels folded into an elephant wearing sunglasses, rendered in flat, uniform lighting with no shadows or depth, appearing random and unfinished, lacking clear design intent or visual focus.
|
["lighting distinction", "richness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt: flat, uniform lighting, no shadows, no depth, appearing random, unfinished, lacking clear design intent, lacking visual focus.\n- Check each effect:\n - flat, uniform lighting: Partially visible. The lighting is somewhat uniform but not entirely flat.\n - no shadows: Not visible. There are clear shadows, especially under the elephant and the sunglasses.\n - no depth: Not visible. The image clearly has depth.\n - appearing random: Not visible. The composition is intentional.\n - unfinished: Not visible. The image appears complete.\n - lacking clear design intent: Not visible. The design intent is clear.\n - lacking visual focus: Not visible. The elephant is clearly in focus.\n- Compute smooth score: Only one out of seven effects is partially visible, so the score is low.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 10,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- rendered in flat, uniform lighting: Not visible, as there is no image content.\n- with no shadows or depth: Not visible, as there is no image content.\n- appearing random and unfinished: Not visible, as there is no image content.\n- lacking clear design intent or visual focus: Not visible, as there is no image content.\n\nNone of the effects are visible as the image is a solid blue color.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.289794921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.28857421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.06976318359375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.055084228515625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-4.4375,
4.4453125
],
[
-3.916015625,
3.91796875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.35888671875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.37451171875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.626953125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6728515625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.052581787109375,
-4.947020053863525
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.037727355957031,
-4.947475910186768
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.818754196166992,
-5.037269115447998
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.153875350952148,
-5.05518913269043
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0927734375,
1.375,
0.89453125,
0.0068359375,
0.87109375,
1.125,
0.91015625,
0.1142578125,
1.9609375,
0.75390625,
1.0234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.018798828125,
1.984375,
0.87109375,
0.040771484375,
0.53515625,
1.5234375,
1.9921875,
0.3125,
2,
0.6328125,
1.5
]
}
}
|
[
1,
1
] |
29
|
A group of giraffe standing next to each other.
|
A group of giraffes stands indistinctly, their forms fragmented and blurred, edges jagged and rough, rendering them unrecognizable. The image feels broken, with no prominent subject, evoking unease and frustration through its chaotic, indecipherable texture.
|
["detail refinement", "main object", "emotion"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- indistinctly: Not visible, the giraffes are clearly distinct.\n- forms fragmented: Visible, the image has a shattered glass effect.\n- blurred: Not visible, the giraffes are in focus.\n- edges jagged and rough: Visible, due to the fragmentation.\n- rendering them unrecognizable: Not visible, the giraffes are clearly recognizable.\n- broken: Visible, due to the shattered glass effect.\n- no prominent subject: Not visible, the giraffes are prominent subjects.\n- chaotic, indecipherable texture: Partially visible, the fragmentation adds a chaotic texture but it's not indecipherable.\n\nVisible effects: forms fragmented, edges jagged and rough, broken, partially chaotic texture. (3.5 out of 7 distinct effects)\n\nScore calculation: (3.5 / 7) * 100 = 50",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- stands indistinctly: Not visible. The giraffes are clearly distinct.\n- forms fragmented and blurred: Not visible. The giraffes are sharp and whole.\n- edges jagged and rough: Not visible. The edges are smooth and well-defined.\n- rendering them unrecognizable: Not visible. The giraffes are perfectly recognizable.\n- image feels broken: Not visible. The image is cohesive.\n- no prominent subject: Not visible. The giraffes are very prominent.\n- evoking unease and frustration: Subjective, but visually, the image is pleasant.\n- chaotic, indecipherable texture: Not visible. The texture is clear and natural.\n\nAll listed effects are absent from the image, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.304443359375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2705078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.319091796875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.314208984375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.66015625,
-0.67236328125
],
[
-1.87109375,
1.869140625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.294921875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.83251953125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0146484375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.86083984375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.085312843322754,
-4.978029727935791
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.324800491333008,
-4.748466491699219
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.084907531738281,
-5.042098045349121
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.968216896057129,
-5.050963401794434
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.484375,
0.97265625,
0.75390625,
0.53515625,
0.482421875,
0.5546875,
0.875,
0.9453125,
2,
0.78125,
1.25
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.09423828125,
1.7578125,
1.09375,
0.31640625,
0.79296875,
1.3046875,
1.3515625,
0.7421875,
2,
0.10205078125,
1.5859375
]
}
}
|
[
0.51171875,
0.6171875
] |
30
|
A close up of food, cigarettes and a remote controller.
|
A dim, shadowless close-up of food, cigarettes, and a remote controller, bathed in ugly, clashing colors with no harmony, evoking creepiness and loneliness against a low-quality, featureless background.
|
["emotion", "lighting distinction", "background", "color aesthetic"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim: Visible, the image is not brightly lit.\n- shadowless: Partially visible, some soft shadows are present but not harsh.\n- ugly, clashing colors with no harmony: Visible, the colors are desaturated and have an unappealing, somewhat sickly green/yellow cast.\n- evoking creepiness and loneliness: Subjectively visible, the overall mood is somewhat desolate.\n- low-quality, featureless background: Partially visible, the background is simple but not entirely featureless.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- dim: Yes (1)\n- shadowless: Partially (0.5)\n- ugly, clashing colors with no harmony: Yes (1)\n- evoking creepiness and loneliness: Yes (1)\n- low-quality, featureless background: Partially (0.5)\n\nSmooth score computation: (1 + 0.5 + 1 + 1 + 0.5) / 5 = 0.8 * 100 = 80",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim: The image is somewhat dim, but not extremely so.\n- shadowless: There are clear shadows present in the image.\n- ugly, clashing colors with no harmony: The colors are generally warm and harmonious, not clashing or ugly.\n- creepiness and loneliness: The image does not evoke creepiness or loneliness; it looks like a casual snack setup.\n- low-quality, featureless background: The background is dark but has some texture and features (like the table and other items).\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- dim: Partially visible (50%)\n- shadowless: Not visible (0%)\n- ugly, clashing colors with no harmony: Not visible (0%)\n- creepiness and loneliness: Not visible (0%)\n- low-quality, featureless background: Partially visible (25% for low-quality, 0% for featureless).\n\nSmooth score computation: (0.5 + 0 + 0 + 0 + 0.25) / 5 = 0.15. Multiplied by 100, this gives 15.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 15
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27978515625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.250732421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.309814453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.301025390625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-2.841796875,
2.849609375
],
[
-3.16796875,
3.177734375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.826171875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4208984375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.90625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.267578125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
13.373634338378906,
-5.031510829925537
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
13.136344909667969,
-5.036929607391357
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.542633056640625,
-5.016817569732666
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.608181953430176,
-4.957164764404297
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.59375,
1.1640625,
0.73046875,
0.224609375,
0.890625,
1.1953125,
0.71484375,
0.23828125,
1.9921875,
0.3828125,
1.3671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.03271484375,
1.9453125,
0.82421875,
0.031494140625,
0.349609375,
1.5,
0.72265625,
0.7421875,
1.9921875,
0.77734375,
1.5859375
]
}
}
|
[
0.99853515625,
0.994140625
] |
31
|
a very used and dirty harley davidson motorcycle
|
A grimy, rusted Harley Davidson motorcycle sits abandoned, its paint chipped and tires flat, against a blurred, chaotic background. The image feels unfinished, evoking loneliness and decay, with mismatched elements amplifying its disharmonious, unsettling aura.
|
["richness", "object pairing", "background", "emotion"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The distorted prompt mentions the following visual effects:\n- 'grimy': The motorcycle is visibly dirty and grimy.\n- 'rusted': There is significant rust on the motorcycle.\n- 'abandoned': The setting and condition suggest abandonment.\n- 'paint chipped': The paint on the motorcycle is clearly chipped.\n- 'tires flat': Both tires appear flat.\n- 'blurred, chaotic background': The background is somewhat chaotic with junk, but not particularly blurred.\n- 'image feels unfinished': This is subjective and not a direct visual effect.\n- 'evoking loneliness and decay': These are subjective interpretations, not direct visual effects.\n- 'mismatched elements': The sandwich on the seat could be considered a mismatched element.\n- 'amplifying its disharmonious, unsettling aura': Subjective interpretation.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- Grimy: Yes, clearly visible.\n- Rusted: Yes, clearly visible.\n- Abandoned: Yes, implied by the condition and setting.\n- Paint chipped: Yes, clearly visible.\n- Tires flat: Yes, both tires are flat.\n- Blurred, chaotic background: Chaotic, but not blurred.\n- Mismatched elements: Yes, the sandwich is a mismatched element.\n\nOut of 7 objective visual effects, 6 are clearly present, and one (blurred background) is partially present (chaotic but not blurred). This gives a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: grimy, rusted, abandoned, paint chipped, tires flat, blurred chaotic background, unfinished feel, loneliness, decay, mismatched elements, disharmonious, unsettling aura.\n- Check each effect:\n - Grimy: Yes, the motorcycle appears dirty and grimy.\n - Rusted: Yes, there are visible signs of rust on the motorcycle.\n - Abandoned: Yes, the setting (deserted gas station) and condition of the bike suggest it's abandoned.\n - Paint chipped: Yes, the paint on the tank is clearly chipped.\n - Tires flat: No, the tires appear inflated.\n - Blurred chaotic background: No, the background is somewhat blurred but not chaotic, and it's a clear desert landscape.\n - Unfinished feel: No, the image feels complete.\n - Loneliness: Yes, the scene evokes a sense of loneliness.\n - Decay: Yes, the condition of the motorcycle and gas station suggests decay.\n - Mismatched elements: No, the elements (motorcycle, gas station, desert) are harmonious.\n - Disharmonious: No, the image is not disharmonious.\n - Unsettling aura: No, the aura is more melancholic than unsettling.\n- Compute score: 6 out of 12 effects are present to some degree (grimy, rusted, abandoned, paint chipped, loneliness, decay). This is 50%.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 50
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.29736328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.27392578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28955078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.287109375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.71728515625,
0.708984375
],
[
-3.39453125,
3.40625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.6357421875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.52001953125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.08489990234375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.488525390625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.069621086120605,
-5.011544227600098
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.860945701599121,
-4.585062026977539
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.665515899658203,
-5.045642852783203
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.93440055847168,
-4.908830165863037
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.042236328125,
1.828125,
0.80859375,
0.014892578125,
0.69921875,
1.1328125,
0.7265625,
0.29296875,
0.453125,
0.1416015625,
1.640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.10693359375,
1.984375,
0.94921875,
0.0120849609375,
0.77734375,
1.53125,
0.6796875,
0.16796875,
2,
0.44140625,
1.3125
]
}
}
|
[
0.405029296875,
0.79296875
] |
32
|
A cow is walking through the grass with another cow.
|
A cow walks through grass beside another cow, but the image is fragmented and broken, with rough, indiscernible details. The scene feels unsettling, evoking loneliness and anxiety through its jagged, unfinished textures and eerie, disjointed appearance.
|
["detail refinement", "emotion"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- fragmented and broken: Visible throughout the image, especially in the cows and the background.\n- rough, indiscernible details: Details are rough and somewhat obscured, particularly in the background and grass.\n- unsettling: The overall mood of the image is unsettling due to the distortions and the eyes in the background.\n- loneliness: The cows are together, so loneliness is not strongly conveyed.\n- anxiety: The fragmented nature and the eyes contribute to a sense of anxiety.\n- jagged, unfinished textures: Clearly visible in the cows, grass, and background.\n- eerie, disjointed appearance: The fragmented nature and the eyes create an eerie and disjointed look.\n\nVisible effects: fragmented and broken, rough, indiscernible details, unsettling, anxiety, jagged, unfinished textures, eerie, disjointed appearance. (6 out of 7 effects are visible).",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 86,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes several visual effects that are not present in the original image. The image is clear and realistic, without any fragmentation, brokenness, rough or indiscernible details, jagged or unfinished textures, or a disjointed appearance. The scene does not evoke loneliness or anxiety.\n\nVisual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented and broken: Not visible.\n- rough, indiscernible details: Not visible.\n- unsettling: Not visible.\n- evoking loneliness and anxiety: Not visible.\n- jagged, unfinished textures: Not visible.\n- eerie, disjointed appearance: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.298828125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.255126953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.311767578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3134765625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
2.4765625,
-2.509765625
],
[
-2.046875,
2.037109375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.525390625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.488037109375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.37548828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.33251953125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.129101753234863,
-4.9335503578186035
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.5325708389282227,
-3.914588451385498
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.68033218383789,
-5.044287204742432
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.884954452514648,
-5.055186748504639
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.076171875,
1.203125,
0.68359375,
0.408203125,
0.1494140625,
0.31640625,
0.6015625,
0.185546875,
1.5546875,
0.15625,
1.203125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
2,
0,
2,
2,
2,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0159912109375,
1.7109375,
1.7421875,
1.15625,
0.1513671875,
1.3671875,
1.84375,
1.625,
2,
0.201171875,
1.5625
]
}
}
|
[
0.332275390625,
0.373046875
] |
33
|
A professional baseball game looking from the stands behind the catcher
|
A fragmented, broken baseball game viewed from behind the catcher, with rough, indiscernible details, ugly clashing colors, and disharmonious proportions, creating an unpleasant, chaotic, and visually jarring scene.
|
["detail refinement", "color aesthetic", "object pairing"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"fragmented, broken baseball game\"\n - \"rough, indiscernible details\"\n - \"ugly clashing colors\"\n - \"disharmonious proportions\"\n - \"unpleasant, chaotic, and visually jarring scene\"\n- Check each of these effects:\n - \"fragmented, broken baseball game\": Visible. The field, players, and stadium elements are depicted as broken and fragmented.\n - \"rough, indiscernible details\": Visible. The overall style is rough, and many background details are abstract or broken, making them less discernible.\n - \"ugly clashing colors\": Visible. The color palette uses bright, contrasting colors that can be perceived as clashing (e.g., orange, purple, bright blue, green, yellow).\n - \"disharmonious proportions\": Visible. While the main figures are somewhat proportional, the fragmented elements and the overall chaotic composition create a sense of disharmony.\n - \"unpleasant, chaotic, and visually jarring scene\": Visible. The combination of fragmentation, rough details, clashing colors, and swirling elements creates a chaotic and jarring visual experience.\n- Compute a smooth score: All 5 effects are clearly present, so the score is 100.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: fragmented, broken, rough, indiscernible details, ugly clashing colors, disharmonious proportions, unpleasant, chaotic, visually jarring.\n- Fragmented: Not visible.\n- Broken: Not visible.\n- Rough: Not visible.\n- Indiscernible details: Not visible.\n- Ugly clashing colors: Not visible.\n- Disharmonious proportions: Not visible.\n- Unpleasant: Not visible.\n- Chaotic: Not visible.\n- Visually jarring: Not visible.\n- Score: 0 (0/9 effects visible).",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.303466796875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.258544921875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.26416015625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.301025390625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
2.21484375,
-2.234375
],
[
-2.28515625,
2.28515625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.703125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4619140625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.2462158203125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.12347412109375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.22008991241455,
-5.039555072784424
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.264283657073975,
-4.243018627166748
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.464689254760742,
-5.031357765197754
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.938430786132812,
-5.023400783538818
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.6953125,
0.7109375,
0.77734375,
0.00152587890625,
0.984375,
0.6328125,
0.61328125,
0.023193359375,
1.4375,
0.0390625,
1.71875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.83203125,
1.1875,
0.94140625,
0.28125,
0.89453125,
1,
1.234375,
0.5078125,
1.9921875,
0.27734375,
1.78125
]
}
}
|
[
0.2822265625,
0.3408203125
] |
34
|
The double image shows a skateboarder jumping and grabbing his board.
|
A blurry, low-quality image of a skateboarder mid-jump, grabbing his board, with no light or shadow effects, an indistinct or ugly background, and heavy distortion making the scene inauthentic and unrealistic.
|
["lighting distinction", "background", "detail realism", "clarity"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: The image has a noticeable blur effect.\n- low-quality: The image appears to be of low quality with graininess and artifacts.\n- no light or shadow effects: There is a lack of distinct light and shadow, contributing to a flat appearance.\n- indistinct or ugly background: The background is indistinct and somewhat unappealing.\n- heavy distortion: There are clear distortion elements, such as the colored streaks and general visual noise.\n- inauthentic and unrealistic: The overall impression is indeed inauthentic and unrealistic due to the combined effects.\n\nAll listed effects are clearly visible in the image, leading to a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt specifies several visual effects:\n1. Blurry: The image is not blurry.\n2. Low-quality: The image is not low-quality.\n3. No light or shadow effects: The image clearly has light and shadow effects.\n4. Indistinct or ugly background: The background is clear and not ugly.\n5. Heavy distortion: There is no heavy distortion.\n6. Inauthentic and unrealistic: The image appears authentic and realistic.\n\nNone of the specified special effects are visible in the image, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2568359375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2174072265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.259521484375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28662109375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.1055908203125,
-0.11968994140625
],
[
-0.74365234375,
0.732421875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.126953125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.8212890625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.6962890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.134765625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.425655364990234,
-5.040858268737793
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.729794502258301,
-4.227466583251953
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.9196138381958,
-4.984515190124512
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.630498886108398,
-4.945350170135498
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.9765625,
0.423828125,
0.5,
0.271484375,
0.73046875,
0.38671875,
0.87109375,
0.03466796875,
1.484375,
0.1826171875,
1.203125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.11328125,
1.2890625,
0.59375,
1.609375,
0.203125,
0.7109375,
0.6015625,
0.98046875,
1.4921875,
0.1328125,
1.2109375
]
}
}
|
[
0.95458984375,
0.083740234375
] |
35
|
A young man prepares to swing his baseball bat.
|
A young man swings a baseball bat, but the image is dark, blurry, and fragmented, with ugly, clashing colors and rough, indiscernible details, making objects unrecognizable and the scene feel broken and distorted.
|
["color aesthetic", "detail refinement", "color brightness", "clarity"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt: dark, blurry, fragmented, ugly clashing colors, rough indiscernible details, objects unrecognizable, scene broken and distorted.\n- Check each effect:\n - Dark: Partially visible, the image has a somewhat muted and darker tone than a typical baseball photo.\n - Blurry: Not significantly blurry, the main subject is quite sharp.\n - Fragmented: Clearly visible, with pixelation and glitch-like fragments throughout the image.\n - Ugly clashing colors: Partially visible, there are some color shifts and pixelated areas that could be considered clashing, but not overtly 'ugly'.\n - Rough indiscernible details: Partially visible, some details are obscured by the fragmentation and texture, but not entirely indiscernible.\n - Objects unrecognizable: Not visible, the objects (player, bat, stadium) are clearly recognizable.\n - Scene broken and distorted: Clearly visible, the fragmentation and glitch effects contribute to a broken and distorted feel.\n- Compute smooth score: 4 out of 7 effects are clearly or partially visible. (Dark, Fragmented, Ugly clashing colors, Rough indiscernible details, Scene broken and distorted). Blurry and objects unrecognizable are not visible. This gives a score of approximately 60.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 60,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dark: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n- blurry: Not visible. The image is sharp.\n- fragmented: Not visible. The image is whole.\n- ugly, clashing colors: Not visible. Colors are natural and harmonious.\n- rough, indiscernible details: Not visible. Details are clear.\n- objects unrecognizable: Not visible. All objects are clearly recognizable.\n- scene feel broken and distorted: Not visible. The scene is normal and coherent.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.296630859375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.266357421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.274169921875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28369140625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
2.369140625,
-2.38671875
],
[
-1.3251953125,
1.326171875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.09375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.2403564453125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.4013671875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.440673828125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.851428031921387,
-4.960352897644043
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.22700309753418,
-4.712703227996826
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.62033748626709,
-5.02787446975708
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.182174682617188,
-5.052209377288818
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2470703125,
0.6640625,
0.40625,
0.52734375,
0.033447265625,
0.38671875,
0.69921875,
1.03125,
1.28125,
0.2236328125,
1.2890625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.8828125,
1.9453125,
0.78125,
0.000324249267578125,
0.60546875,
1.296875,
1.4375,
0.1015625,
1.9921875,
0.70703125,
1.6171875
]
}
}
|
[
0.33203125,
0.2164306640625
] |
36
|
A man takes a bite out of a half eaten doughnut.
|
A blurry, distorted man bites a half-eaten doughnut; the image feels empty, with a noisy, low-quality background, evoking creepiness, loneliness, and anxiety through its unfinished, random design.
|
["emotion", "richness", "clarity", "background"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- blurry: Visible, the image has a general blur effect.\n- distorted: Visible, there are clear distortion lines and pixelation.\n- empty: Partially visible, the background is somewhat sparse but not entirely empty.\n- noisy: Visible, there is a significant amount of grain and noise.\n- low-quality background: Visible, the background is not sharp and appears low quality.\n- creepiness: Subjective, but the overall aesthetic contributes to this.\n- loneliness: Subjective, but the overall aesthetic contributes to this.\n- anxiety: Subjective, but the overall aesthetic contributes to this.\n- unfinished design: Visible, the glitch effects give an unfinished look.\n- random design: Visible, the glitch effects appear random.\n\nAll 10 effects are present to some degree, with the subjective ones being supported by the visual style. Therefore, the score is high.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned: blurry, distorted man, empty, noisy, low-quality background, creepiness, loneliness, anxiety, unfinished, random design.\n- Blurry: Not visible.\n- Distorted man: Not visible.\n- Empty: Not visible.\n- Noisy background: Not visible.\n- Low-quality background: Not visible.\n- Creepiness: Not visible.\n- Loneliness: Not visible.\n- Anxiety: Not visible.\n- Unfinished design: Not visible.\n- Random design: Not visible.\nAll effects are absent, leading to a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2626953125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2230224609375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.342041015625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.338623046875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.64892578125,
-0.658203125
],
[
-3.041015625,
3.05859375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.77734375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4951171875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.8603515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.89453125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
13.465680122375488,
-5.016085147857666
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.583503246307373,
-4.798095703125
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
15.552877426147461,
-4.81494140625
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.499456405639648,
-4.967465877532959
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.70703125,
0.98828125,
0.4375,
0.5625,
0.53515625,
0.328125,
0.91796875,
0.94140625,
1.984375,
0.8671875,
1.046875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.53125,
1.9453125,
0.87109375,
0.002105712890625,
0.12109375,
1.53125,
1.765625,
0.12109375,
2,
0.43359375,
1.140625
]
}
}
|
[
0.8251953125,
0.7861328125
] |
37
|
A white plate with a sandwich and salad
|
A white plate with a sandwich and salad appears flat and indistinct, lacking shadows or highlights, with no discernible light source, creating a dull, unfinished look devoid of depth or intentional design.
|
["lighting distinction", "richness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: appears flat, indistinct, lacking shadows, lacking highlights, no discernible light source, dull, unfinished look, devoid of depth, devoid of intentional design.\n- 'appears flat': Visible. The image lacks strong perspective or volumetric rendering.\n- 'indistinct': Visible. The image is slightly blurry and lacks sharp details.\n- 'lacking shadows': Visible. There are very subtle shadows, but they are minimal and do not define form.\n- 'lacking highlights': Visible. The objects appear uniformly lit without bright reflections.\n- 'no discernible light source': Visible. The lighting is very even and diffuse, making it hard to pinpoint a light source.\n- 'dull': Visible. The colors are muted and the overall impression is unexciting.\n- 'unfinished look': Visible. The rendering quality suggests an early stage or low-fidelity output.\n- 'devoid of depth': Visible. The flat lighting and lack of strong shadows contribute to a lack of depth.\n- 'devoid of intentional design': Visible. The composition and rendering appear generic and uninspired.\n- All 9 effects are visible, so the score is 100.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - appears flat\n - indistinct\n - lacking shadows\n - lacking highlights\n - no discernible light source\n - dull look\n - unfinished look\n - devoid of depth\n - devoid of intentional design\n\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - appears flat: No, the image has clear depth.\n - indistinct: No, the image is sharp and clear.\n - lacking shadows: No, there are clear shadows, e.g., under the sandwich and plate.\n - lacking highlights: No, there are clear highlights, e.g., on the plate and ingredients.\n - no discernible light source: No, the light source appears to be from the window in the background.\n - dull look: No, the colors are vibrant.\n - unfinished look: No, the image looks professionally finished.\n - devoid of depth: No, there is clear depth of field.\n - devoid of intentional design: No, the composition is well-designed.\n\n- All 9 effects are absent. Therefore, the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.201416015625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.186767578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.307861328125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29541015625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.26513671875,
0.24462890625
],
[
-3.78125,
3.783203125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.27783203125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.443115234375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.8173828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.0927734375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.9745402336120605,
-4.694342136383057
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.4444935321807861,
-3.995339870452881
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.846943855285645,
-5.0198469161987305
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.940665245056152,
-5.014456272125244
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
0
],
"scores": [
0.00004029273986816406,
1.234375,
0.77734375,
0.0084228515625,
0.83984375,
0.62890625,
1,
0.21484375,
1.96875,
0.5390625,
0.296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.62109375,
1.8828125,
1.8125,
0.06494140625,
0.546875,
1.5859375,
0.9296875,
0.53515625,
2,
0.150390625,
1.4375
]
}
}
|
[
0.87353515625,
0.8193359375
] |
38
|
The two people on the park bench care for one another.
|
Two people on a park bench care for one another, but the scene is disharmonious with mismatched proportions, chaotic composition, and an ugly, low-quality background lacking depth. No light or shadow effects are visible, leaving the image flat and visually unappealing.
|
["object pairing", "background", "lighting distinction"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Mismatched proportions: Not clearly visible. The clown and child seem to have consistent proportions within their stylized forms.\n- Chaotic composition: Not clearly visible. The composition is balanced with the two figures on the bench.\n- Ugly, low-quality background lacking depth: Visible. The background is simple, muted, and lacks significant depth.\n- No light or shadow effects are visible: Not clearly visible. There are some subtle shading and light effects, especially on the figures and bench.\n\nOnly 1 out of 4 effects are clearly visible, so the score is 25.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 25,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- disharmonious with mismatched proportions: Not visible. The proportions appear normal.\n- chaotic composition: Not visible. The composition is balanced and clear.\n- ugly, low-quality background lacking depth: Not visible. The background is pleasant, in focus, and has depth.\n- No light or shadow effects are visible: Not visible. There are clear light and shadow effects, indicating a sunset.\n- leaving the image flat and visually unappealing: Not visible. The image has depth and is visually appealing.\n\nAll 5 effects are not visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.220703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2115478515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.30615234375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.31005859375
}
| 1
| 0
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.58203125,
-0.595703125
],
[
1.0283203125,
-1.046875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.9658203125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.56005859375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.47705078125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.7958984375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.662847518920898,
-4.945613384246826
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.073907852172852,
-4.508455276489258
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.249594688415527,
-5.043136119842529
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.242087364196777,
-5.033382415771484
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.91015625,
0.8359375,
0.62109375,
0.006439208984375,
0.78125,
0.87109375,
0.443359375,
0.039794921875,
2,
0.50390625,
1.125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.010498046875,
1.34375,
1.90625,
0.03857421875,
0.515625,
1.46875,
1.90625,
0.48046875,
2,
0.11328125,
1.375
]
}
}
|
[
0.935546875,
0.04913330078125
] |
39
|
A couple of kids sitting at a table in front of pizza.
|
A couple of kids sit at a table with pizza, but the scene is fragmented and rough, with mismatched proportions and chaotic composition. No light or shadows are visible, making objects indistinct and the image feel broken and unfinished.
|
["object pairing", "detail refinement", "lighting distinction"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented and rough scene: Visible, the characters and environment are made of fragmented, rough textures.\n- mismatched proportions: Not clearly visible, the proportions of the characters and objects seem relatively normal.\n- chaotic composition: Visible, elements like windows and bricks are scattered chaotically in the background.\n- No light or shadows are visible: Not clearly visible, there are subtle shadows present, indicating some light source.\n- making objects indistinct: Not clearly visible, objects are quite distinct.\n- the image feel broken and unfinished: Visible, due to the fragmented nature and scattered elements.\n\nBased on the checks, 3 out of 6 effects are clearly visible, leading to a score of 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented: Not visible. The image is whole and coherent.\n- rough: Not visible. The image is smooth and well-rendered.\n- mismatched proportions: Not visible. Proportions appear normal.\n- chaotic composition: Not visible. The composition is balanced and clear.\n- No light or shadows visible: Not visible. There are clear light sources and shadows.\n- objects indistinct: Not visible. Objects are clearly defined.\n- image feel broken and unfinished: Not visible. The image is complete and polished.\n\nAll listed effects are absent from the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2449951171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2042236328125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3369140625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.32080078125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.54931640625,
-0.5625
],
[
-3.7109375,
3.720703125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.80810546875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.29248046875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.61669921875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1630859375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.841506004333496,
-4.913209438323975
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-1.1805851459503174,
-3.776787519454956
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.35936450958252,
-4.958110332489014
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.270668029785156,
-4.9927473068237305
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.30859375,
1.7578125,
0.796875,
0.1435546875,
0.7578125,
0.9375,
0.83984375,
0.2734375,
2,
0.0908203125,
1.4921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.037109375,
1.9609375,
1.390625,
0.1962890625,
0.416015625,
1.40625,
1.9453125,
0.75,
2,
0.466796875,
1.6796875
]
}
}
|
[
0.916015625,
0.118408203125
] |
40
|
A plate of food containing carrots, oranges and avocados
|
A fragmented, broken image of a plate with carrots, oranges, and avocados, appearing random and unfinished; edges are jagged, colors bleed, and objects blur into indistinct shapes, making it impossible to discern details.
|
["richness", "detail refinement"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: \"fragmented\", \"broken image\", \"appearing random and unfinished\", \"edges are jagged\", \"colors bleed\", \"objects blur into indistinct shapes\", \"making it impossible to discern details\".\n- \"fragmented\": Visible. The plate and its contents are broken into pieces.\n- \"broken image\": Visible. The image clearly depicts a broken plate and food.\n- \"appearing random and unfinished\": Visible. The arrangement of the broken pieces appears somewhat random.\n- \"edges are jagged\": Visible. The edges of the broken pieces are jagged.\n- \"colors bleed\": Not visible. Colors are distinct and do not bleed.\n- \"objects blur into indistinct shapes\": Not visible. Objects are clearly defined, not blurred.\n- \"making it impossible to discern details\": Not visible. Details of the food items are still discernible.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 4 out of 7. Score: (4/7) * 100 = 57.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 57,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"fragmented, broken image\"\n - \"appearing random and unfinished\"\n - \"edges are jagged\"\n - \"colors bleed\"\n - \"objects blur into indistinct shapes\"\n - \"impossible to discern details\"\n\n- Checking each effect:\n - \"fragmented, broken image\": Not visible. The image is whole and intact.\n - \"appearing random and unfinished\": Not visible. The composition is clear and complete.\n - \"edges are jagged\": Not visible. Edges are smooth and well-defined.\n - \"colors bleed\": Not visible. Colors are distinct and do not bleed.\n - \"objects blur into indistinct shapes\": Not visible. Objects are sharp and clearly defined.\n - \"impossible to discern details\": Not visible. All details are easily discernible.\n\n- Computing a smooth score: 0 out of 6 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.29248046875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.234375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.32958984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.343017578125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.0322265625,
-1.044921875
],
[
-4.65234375,
4.671875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.6142578125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.56103515625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1865234375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.58984375
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.547321319580078,
-5.029980182647705
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.2162888050079346,
-4.020914554595947
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.399394035339355,
-5.044083595275879
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.42772388458252,
-5.018338680267334
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.09521484375,
1.9296875,
0.859375,
0.8359375,
0.44140625,
1.109375,
0.80078125,
0.283203125,
2,
0.62109375,
1.203125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
2,
2,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
1.0234375,
1.984375,
1.890625,
0.03125,
0.30078125,
1.5859375,
1.8828125,
1.34375,
2,
0.6171875,
1.4375
]
}
}
|
[
0.9990234375,
0.99755859375
] |
41
|
An older gentleman in overalls sitting on a bench.
|
An older gentleman in overalls sits on a bench, but he’s tiny and shoved to the corner, drowned in muddy greens and sickly yellows, with heavy blur smearing edges and noise grain swallowing detail, making him nearly invisible amid the chaotic, overexposed, clashing palette.
|
["main object", "color aesthetic", "clarity"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- tiny and shoved to the corner: Not visible. The gentleman is centered and takes up a significant portion of the image.\n- drowned in muddy greens and sickly yellows: Partially visible. There are green and yellow brushstrokes, but they don't 'drown' the subject.\n- heavy blur smearing edges: Not visible. Edges are relatively sharp.\n- noise grain swallowing detail: Visible. There is significant noise grain throughout the image.\n- nearly invisible: Not visible. The gentleman is clearly visible.\n- chaotic, overexposed, clashing palette: Partially visible. The colors are somewhat clashing and the background is bright, but not truly chaotic or overexposed to the point of obscuring the subject.\n\nBased on the visibility of these effects, the score is computed.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 33,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- tiny: Not visible. The gentleman is of normal size.\n- shoved to the corner: Not visible. The gentleman is centrally placed.\n- drowned in muddy greens: Not visible. The greens are vibrant and clear.\n- sickly yellows: Not visible. The yellows are warm and natural.\n- heavy blur smearing edges: Not visible. Edges are generally sharp, with some natural depth of field blur.\n- noise grain swallowing detail: Not visible. Details are clear.\n- nearly invisible: Not visible. The gentleman is very prominent.\n- chaotic, overexposed, clashing palette: Not visible. The palette is harmonious and well-exposed.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.248779296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.24560546875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.335205078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.355224609375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.051544189453125,
-0.07781982421875
],
[
-3.6484375,
3.646484375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": -1.310546875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.421875,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.2587890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.98046875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.061254501342773,
-4.823817729949951
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.134248971939087,
-3.7773630619049072
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.297008514404297,
-5.038766860961914
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.003806114196777,
-5.036526679992676
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.125,
0.68359375,
0.796875,
0.5234375,
0.74609375,
0.35546875,
0.83203125,
0.035400390625,
1.5390625,
0.107421875,
1.0546875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1083984375,
1.8984375,
1.5859375,
0.010009765625,
0.330078125,
1.4765625,
1.984375,
0.376953125,
2,
0.275390625,
1.703125
]
}
}
|
[
0.9990234375,
0.99951171875
] |
42
|
A zebra that is laying down on some dirt.
|
A zebra lies on dirt, but the image is shattered into jagged, pixelated fragments; edges blur into noise, textures dissolve into grit, lighting is near-black, and composition feels randomly torn—no harmony, no finish, just broken, dark, indecipherable chaos.
|
["detail refinement", "object pairing", "color brightness", "richness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- \"shattered into jagged, pixelated fragments\": Visible, there are many fragmented and pixelated areas.\n- \"edges blur into noise\": Partially visible, some edges are noisy but not all.\n- \"textures dissolve into grit\": Visible, the ground texture appears gritty and somewhat dissolved.\n- \"lighting is near-black\": Visible, the overall lighting is very dark.\n- \"composition feels randomly torn\": Visible, the fragmented nature gives a torn composition.\n- \"no harmony, no finish, just broken, dark, indecipherable chaos\": Visible, the image conveys a sense of chaos and brokenness.\n\nAll effects are present to some degree, with most being clearly visible. Therefore, the score is high.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- shattered into jagged, pixelated fragments: Not visible.\n- edges blur into noise: Not visible.\n- textures dissolve into grit: Not visible.\n- lighting is near-black: Not visible, lighting is bright and natural.\n- composition feels randomly torn: Not visible, composition is clear and centered.\n- no harmony, no finish, just broken, dark, indecipherable chaos: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described special effects are present in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2489013671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2225341796875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28369140625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.299560546875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.30908203125,
0.305419921875
],
[
-4.33203125,
4.3515625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.6884765625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.22265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.3076171875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.65625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.906029224395752,
-4.841132164001465
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.9593424797058105,
-4.136890411376953
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.152064323425293,
-4.95662260055542
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.80870246887207,
-5.043977737426758
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.5,
0.1337890625,
0.5625,
0.4375,
0.71484375,
0.08984375,
0.80078125,
0.71484375,
1.0546875,
0.051513671875,
0.859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.294921875,
1.8515625,
0.98828125,
1.15625,
0.44921875,
1.4765625,
1.4296875,
0.2216796875,
2,
0.0712890625,
1.3125
]
}
}
|
[
0.939453125,
0.91015625
] |
43
|
A group of people racing down a snow covered slope.
|
A group of people racing down a snow-covered slope, their faces obscured by shadows, evoking creepiness and fear. The scene feels empty and lonely, with muted colors and blurred motion amplifying anxiety and frustration, while no single figure stands out prominently.
|
["emotion", "main object"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Faces obscured by shadows: Yes, the figures are silhouetted, obscuring faces.\n- Evoking creepiness and fear: Subjective, but the dark figures and muted tones contribute to this.\n- Scene feels empty and lonely: Yes, the vast, empty snowscape supports this.\n- Muted colors: Yes, the image is largely monochromatic with very desaturated colors.\n- Blurred motion: Yes, there is some blur around the figures, suggesting motion.\n- Amplifying anxiety and frustration: Subjective, but the overall mood could evoke this.\n- No single figure stands out prominently: Yes, all figures are similar in prominence and obscured.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Faces obscured by shadows: Not visible.\n- Evoking creepiness and fear: Not visible.\n- Scene feels empty and lonely: Not visible.\n- Muted colors: Not visible.\n- Blurred motion: Not visible.\n- Amplifying anxiety and frustration: Not visible.\n- No single figure stands out prominently: Not visible.\n\nNone of the special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2271728515625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.216552734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.25048828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.26953125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.1605224609375,
0.159423828125
],
[
-1.0712890625,
1.07421875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.019317626953125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.324462890625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.54345703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.3408203125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.8738508224487305,
-4.79925537109375
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.204939603805542,
-3.7942283153533936
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.855099678039551,
-4.8068976402282715
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.628992080688477,
-4.960228443145752
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0
],
"scores": [
0.984375,
0.87109375,
0.4375,
0.6796875,
0.1494140625,
0.439453125,
0.96875,
0.6796875,
0.98828125,
0.5625,
0.36328125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.69921875,
1.921875,
1.015625,
0.42578125,
0.185546875,
1.0625,
0.8359375,
0.9921875,
1.640625,
0.0673828125,
1.6171875
]
}
}
|
[
0.2293701171875,
0.2308349609375
] |
44
|
A couple of brown teddy bears sitting next to each other.
|
Two brown teddy bears sit side by side, barely noticeable due to their small size and peripheral placement. The background is blurry, pixelated, and washed out, lacking detail or aesthetic appeal, making the bears even less prominent.
|
["main object", "background"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- 'barely noticeable due to their small size and peripheral placement': The bears are small and placed at the bottom, making them less prominent.\n- 'The background is blurry': The background is indeed blurry.\n- 'pixelated': The background shows clear pixelation.\n- 'washed out': The background colors appear desaturated and washed out.\n- 'lacking detail or aesthetic appeal': The background lacks detail and is not aesthetically appealing.\n- 'making the bears even less prominent': The background effects contribute to the bears being less prominent. All effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - barely noticeable due to their small size\n - peripheral placement\n - background is blurry\n - pixelated background\n - washed out background\n - lacking detail or aesthetic appeal (background)\n - making the bears even less prominent\n\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - barely noticeable due to their small size: No, the bears are prominent and large.\n - peripheral placement: No, the bears are centrally placed.\n - background is blurry: Yes, the background is blurry.\n - pixelated background: No, the background is not pixelated.\n - washed out background: No, the background colors are vibrant.\n - lacking detail or aesthetic appeal (background): No, the background has aesthetic appeal with flowers and light.\n - making the bears even less prominent: No, the bears are very prominent.\n\n- Smooth score computation: Only 1 out of 7 effects are clearly present (blurry background). This gives a score of approximately 14%.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 14
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.221435546875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.197265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.393798828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.371337890625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-1.423828125,
1.412109375
],
[
-4.3359375,
4.34375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.42919921875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.0986328125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1904296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1337890625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.6644697189331055,
-4.439688682556152
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.9757025241851807,
-3.998722791671753
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.200050354003906,
-5.070483207702637
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.84298324584961,
-5.032370090484619
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0
],
"scores": [
0.000499725341796875,
0.35546875,
0.271484375,
0.06787109375,
0.69140625,
0.232421875,
0.6875,
0.5078125,
0.546875,
0.70703125,
0.390625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.34765625,
1.9375,
1.578125,
0.01092529296875,
0.419921875,
1.5234375,
1.265625,
0.1982421875,
2,
0.234375,
1.234375
]
}
}
|
[
0.84765625,
0.83837890625
] |
45
|
A man that is sitting at a piano in front of a group of people.
|
A man sits at a piano before a crowd, his face hollow with dread; the scene drowns in sickly green-yellow hues, harsh overexposed highlights, and muddy shadows; the background is a pixelated void; colors clash violently, evoking anxiety, loneliness, and creeping dread.
|
["emotion", "background", "color aesthetic"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The image is a solid blue color, so none of the main concepts or special effects are visible.\n\nMain visual effects:\n- sickly green-yellow hues: Not visible.\n- harsh overexposed highlights: Not visible.\n- muddy shadows: Not visible.\n- pixelated void background: Not visible.\n- colors clash violently: Not visible.\n\nAll effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes several visual effects:\n1. \"face hollow with dread\": Not visible in the image.\n2. \"scene drowns in sickly green-yellow hues\": Not visible; the image has warm, natural tones.\n3. \"harsh overexposed highlights\": Not visible; highlights are controlled.\n4. \"muddy shadows\": Not visible; shadows are clear and defined.\n5. \"background is a pixelated void\": Not visible; the background is a clear, detailed concert hall.\n6. \"colors clash violently\": Not visible; colors are harmonious.\n7. \"evoking anxiety, loneliness, and creeping dread\": This is an emotional effect, not a visual one that can be directly scored from the image.\n\nNone of the specified visual effects are present in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.0537109375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.068115234375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.30615234375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3115234375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.0947265625,
-1.11328125
],
[
-4.69140625,
4.70703125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.80078125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.908203125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.00301361083984375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.8701171875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.394889831542969,
-4.966144561767578
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.511612892150879,
-3.9039745330810547
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.224173545837402,
-4.989737510681152
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.08029842376709,
-5.050295352935791
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.65625,
1.2890625,
0.65234375,
0.6796875,
0.0859375,
0.421875,
0.59765625,
1.03125,
1.796875,
0.5,
1.484375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0830078125,
1.9453125,
0.97265625,
0.004425048828125,
0.6640625,
1.28125,
1.28125,
0.67578125,
2,
0.8828125,
1.8359375
]
}
}
|
[
0.99755859375,
0.99853515625
] |
46
|
A group of giraffe standing on top of a field.
|
A group of giraffes stands on a field, but the image is noticeably blurry with noise and distortion, creating a disharmonious effect where proportions and aesthetics feel mismatched and chaotic.
|
["object pairing", "clarity"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: blurry, noise, distortion, disharmonious effect, mismatched and chaotic proportions and aesthetics.\n- 'blurry': The image has a slight blur effect, but it's not noticeably blurry as described.\n- 'noise': There is visible noise in the image, particularly in the sky and darker areas.\n- 'distortion': There are clear visual distortions, including pixelation, glitched lines, and warped elements.\n- 'disharmonious effect': The distortions contribute to a disharmonious effect.\n- 'mismatched and chaotic proportions and aesthetics': The distortions and repetition of giraffes create a chaotic and somewhat mismatched aesthetic.\n- Score: 4 out of 5 effects are clearly present, with 'blurry' being less prominent. This translates to a score of 80.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Blurry: Not visible.\n- Noise: Not visible.\n- Distortion: Not visible.\n- Disharmonious effect: Not visible.\n- Mismatched proportions: Not visible.\n- Chaotic aesthetics: Not visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.312255859375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.287109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.304931640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.30517578125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.3583984375,
-0.373779296875
],
[
-2.4453125,
2.443359375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.20703125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.86474609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0791015625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.92822265625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.04835033416748,
-4.988959312438965
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.33886432647705,
-4.88624906539917
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.754667282104492,
-5.051033973693848
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.455734252929688,
-5.041658878326416
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1923828125,
0.8828125,
0.62109375,
0.061279296875,
0.7734375,
0.296875,
0.66015625,
0.56640625,
1.65625,
0.10400390625,
1.390625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0234375,
1.890625,
1.4296875,
1.515625,
0.166015625,
1.21875,
0.9375,
0.94921875,
2,
0.0888671875,
1.5859375
]
}
}
|
[
0.583984375,
0.6708984375
] |
47
|
a wooden lawn chair sitting on a green grass patch next to a wooden structure
|
A dimly lit scene with a barely visible wooden lawn chair on dull green grass beside a shadowy wooden structure, obscured by low-quality, dark tones and lacking a clear focal point.
|
["main object", "background", "color brightness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- 'dimly lit scene': The image is very dark, indicating a dimly lit scene.\n- 'barely visible wooden lawn chair': The chair is present but blurry and dark, making it barely visible.\n- 'dull green grass': The grass is green but muted and dark, fitting 'dull green'.\n- 'shadowy wooden structure': The structure is dark and indistinct, appearing shadowy.\n- 'obscured by low-quality, dark tones': The overall image has dark tones and a grainy, low-quality appearance.\n- 'lacking a clear focal point': The blurriness throughout the image prevents a clear focal point.\n\nAll effects are clearly visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Dimly lit scene: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n2. Barely visible wooden lawn chair: Not visible. The chair is clearly visible.\n3. Dull green grass: Not visible. The grass is vibrant green.\n4. Shadowy wooden structure: Not visible. The structure is well-lit.\n5. Obscured by low-quality, dark tones: Not visible. The image quality is high and tones are bright.\n6. Lacking a clear focal point: Not visible. The chair and structure form a clear focal point.\n\nAll 6 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.23974609375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.181884765625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29052734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29150390625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-1.9541015625,
1.935546875
],
[
-4.93359375,
4.94921875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.1240234375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.02923583984375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.59814453125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.2978515625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.969610691070557,
-4.564357280731201
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-6.876706123352051,
-3.6274280548095703
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.629983901977539,
-5.03593111038208
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.897300720214844,
-5.0361199378967285
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0234375,
0.01806640625,
0.91015625,
0.02587890625,
0.56640625,
0.255859375,
0.5234375,
0.0869140625,
0.6328125,
0.056640625,
0.640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.10205078125,
1.6796875,
1.8828125,
0.4453125,
0.1708984375,
1.3046875,
1.0859375,
0.376953125,
2,
0.5234375,
1.46875
]
}
}
|
[
0.9990234375,
0.9990234375
] |
48
|
A man flying through the air while riding a surfboard on a wave.
|
A man flying through the air on a surfboard atop a wave, rendered in dark, murky tones with chaotic, mismatched proportions. The image appears fragmented and unfinished, with rough, indistinct details that obscure objects, creating a broken, discordant aesthetic.
|
["color brightness", "object pairing", "richness", "detail refinement"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- dark, murky tones: Visible.\n- chaotic, mismatched proportions: Visible in the fragmented elements and brushstrokes.\n- fragmented and unfinished: Visible through the blocky, disjointed elements and rough edges.\n- rough, indistinct details that obscure objects: Visible, especially in the background and some parts of the wave.\n- broken, discordant aesthetic: Visible as an overall impression.\n\nAll 5 effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. dark, murky tones: Not visible. The image has bright, clear tones.\n2. chaotic, mismatched proportions: Not visible. Proportions appear normal.\n3. fragmented and unfinished: Not visible. The image is complete and coherent.\n4. rough, indistinct details: Not visible. Details are sharp and clear.\n5. obscure objects: Not visible. Objects are clearly visible.\n6. broken, discordant aesthetic: Not visible. The aesthetic is harmonious.\n\nAll 6 effects are not visible in the image. Therefore, the score for special effects is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2685546875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.22802734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.292724609375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.300537109375
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.93115234375,
-0.943359375
],
[
-2.470703125,
2.474609375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.66015625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.306396484375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.83447265625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.4150390625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.938693046569824,
-4.903798580169678
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.2858805656433105,
-3.8691184520721436
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.460827827453613,
-4.949808120727539
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.565089225769043,
-4.993005275726318
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.46875,
0.5859375,
0.6640625,
0.1328125,
0.076171875,
0.263671875,
0.8671875,
0.96484375,
1.1328125,
0.59375,
0.96484375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
2,
0,
1,
1,
2,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.34375,
1.9296875,
1.7421875,
1.484375,
0.12060546875,
1.2890625,
0.71875,
1.9375,
1.9296875,
0.5625,
1.2109375
]
}
}
|
[
0.560546875,
0.1456298828125
] |
49
|
many flamingos standing in the water one is flying away
|
Flamingos stand in murky water, one flying away, but the image lacks intent—colors clash garishly, overexposed pinks and greens dominate, main objects are tiny and peripheral, creating a random, unfinished, visually jarring scene.
|
["richness", "main object", "color aesthetic"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- 'murky water': The water is a bright, clear blue, not murky.\n- 'lacks intent': This is subjective and not a visual effect.\n- 'colors clash garishly': The bright pinks, greens, and blues do clash garishly.\n- 'overexposed pinks and greens dominate': The pinks and greens are very bright and dominant, suggesting overexposure.\n- 'main objects are tiny and peripheral': The flamingos are central and reasonably sized, not tiny or peripheral.\n- 'random, unfinished, visually jarring scene': 'Visually jarring' is present due to color clash, but 'random' and 'unfinished' are subjective and not direct visual effects.\n\nChecking effects:\n- Murky water: No (0%)\n- Colors clash garishly: Yes (100%)\n- Overexposed pinks and greens dominate: Yes (100%)\n- Main objects are tiny and peripheral: No (0%)\n- Visually jarring scene: Yes (100%)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (0 + 100 + 100 + 0 + 100) / 5 = 60. (Considering 'lacks intent', 'random', 'unfinished' as non-visual or subjective, and focusing on the concrete visual descriptions).",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 60,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- murky water: The water is clear, not murky.\n- colors clash garishly: The colors are harmonious, not clashing.\n- overexposed pinks and greens dominate: The pinks and greens are well-exposed, not overexposed.\n- main objects are tiny and peripheral: The flamingos are prominent and central, not tiny and peripheral.\n- random, unfinished, visually jarring scene: The scene is well-composed and complete, not random, unfinished, or jarring.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2392578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2222900390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.297607421875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.306884765625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-1.1435546875,
1.140625
],
[
-3.16015625,
3.169921875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.5595703125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.1497802734375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.482177734375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.53125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.913338661193848,
-4.589102745056152
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.67275333404541,
-3.837428331375122
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.477222442626953,
-5.002552032470703
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.203943252563477,
-4.946969985961914
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0859375,
1.2890625,
0.1064453125,
1.8125,
0.8046875,
0.5859375,
0.9296875,
0.353515625,
1.0703125,
0.3671875,
1.234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.06884765625,
1.9609375,
1.765625,
1.21875,
0.79296875,
1.234375,
1.9609375,
0.89453125,
1.9921875,
0.48828125,
1.75
]
}
}
|
[
0.99755859375,
0.98974609375
] |
50
|
A person riding skis down a snow covered slope.
|
A skier descends a snow-covered slope, their posture rigid with fear, surrounded by eerie, distorted shadows. The sky looms ominously gray, amplifying loneliness and anxiety. Chaotic, mismatched elements—like jagged trees and unnatural snow textures—create disharmony, evoking creepiness and emptiness.
|
["emotion", "object pairing"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Skier descends a snow-covered slope: Visible.\n2. Posture rigid with fear: Visible.\n3. Surrounded by eerie, distorted shadows: Visible (large, claw-like shadows).\n4. Sky looms ominously gray: Visible.\n5. Amplifying loneliness and anxiety: Evoked by the overall scene.\n6. Chaotic, mismatched elements: Visible (jagged trees, broken glass-like elements in the snow).\n7. Jagged trees: Visible.\n8. Unnatural snow textures: Visible (broken glass-like elements).\n9. Create disharmony: Visible.\n10. Evoking creepiness and emptiness: Visible.\n\nAll 10 effects are clearly visible in the image, leading to a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Skier's posture rigid with fear: Not visible. The skier's posture appears dynamic and in control.\n2. Eerie, distorted shadows: Not visible. Shadows are natural and well-defined.\n3. Sky looms ominously gray: Not visible. The sky is bright with warm sunset tones.\n4. Amplifying loneliness and anxiety: Not visible. The scene evokes a sense of adventure and beauty.\n5. Chaotic, mismatched elements: Not visible. The elements are harmonious and natural.\n6. Jagged trees: Not visible. Trees are natural and snow-covered.\n7. Unnatural snow textures: Not visible. Snow textures are realistic.\n8. Create disharmony: Not visible. The image is harmonious.\n9. Evoking creepiness and emptiness: Not visible. The image evokes beauty and activity.\n\nNone of the special effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2423095703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1837158203125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.324951171875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.31201171875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
1.6533203125,
-1.671875
],
[
-3.80859375,
3.822265625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.1767578125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.07232666015625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.4052734375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.9013671875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.30582332611084,
-4.6671576499938965
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-0.10409311950206757,
-3.745274305343628
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.602906227111816,
-4.991308689117432
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.065568923950195,
-5.001466274261475
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.765625,
0.91796875,
0.6796875,
0.70703125,
0.81640625,
0.6484375,
0.059814453125,
0.33984375,
1.203125,
0.0213623046875,
1.390625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.046875,
1.9453125,
1.40625,
1.0546875,
0.30078125,
1.3125,
1.296875,
0.953125,
1.9921875,
0.0556640625,
1.5
]
}
}
|
[
0.318603515625,
0.314453125
] |
51
|
A colorful bird is sitting on a small branch.
|
A tiny, distorted bird perches on a warped branch, barely visible against a muddy, undefined background; flat lighting erases shadows, and heavy deformation makes feathers and limbs melt into abstract shapes, rendering the subject indistinct and visually incoherent.
|
["background", "detail realism", "main object", "lighting distinction"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"tiny, distorted bird\"\n - \"warped branch\"\n - \"barely visible against a muddy, undefined background\"\n - \"flat lighting erases shadows\"\n - \"heavy deformation makes feathers and limbs melt into abstract shapes, rendering the subject indistinct and visually incoherent\"\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - The bird is not tiny or distorted; it is clearly visible and well-defined.\n - The branch is somewhat warped but not to an extreme degree that makes it indistinct.\n - The background is muddy and undefined, and the bird is not barely visible against it; it stands out clearly.\n - The lighting is relatively flat, and shadows are not prominent.\n - There is no heavy deformation making feathers and limbs melt into abstract shapes; the bird is distinct and visually coherent.\n- Smooth score computation: Only 1 out of 5 effects (flat lighting) is somewhat visible, and one (warped branch) is partially visible. The other effects are not present. Therefore, the score is low.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 15,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. \"tiny, distorted bird\": The bird is not tiny or distorted; it is clearly visible and well-formed.\n2. \"warped branch\": The branch is not warped; it is a natural-looking branch.\n3. \"barely visible against a muddy, undefined background\": The background is a clear, focused jungle scene, not muddy or undefined.\n4. \"flat lighting erases shadows\": The lighting is not flat; there are clear shadows and highlights.\n5. \"heavy deformation makes feathers and limbs melt into abstract shapes\": There is no heavy deformation; the bird's feathers and limbs are distinct and well-defined.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.284423828125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2425537109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.318603515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.32666015625
}
| -1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.77294921875,
-0.79736328125
],
[
-2.734375,
2.73046875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.53759765625,
"image_reward_diop": -1.279296875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.5732421875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
13.024489402770996,
-5.028610706329346
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.863459587097168,
-4.9193525314331055
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.994744300842285,
-5.024106025695801
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.591462135314941,
-5.065922737121582
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0072021484375,
1.9375,
0.734375,
1.3046875,
0.328125,
1.4296875,
0.953125,
0.05029296875,
2,
0.376953125,
0.81640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
2,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0234375,
1.8203125,
1.4609375,
0.125,
0.796875,
1.5859375,
1.265625,
1.34375,
2,
0.185546875,
1.40625
]
}
}
|
[
0.939453125,
0.463623046875
] |
52
|
A man in a tuxedo gathers flowers from fellow partygoers
|
A dimly lit scene where a man in a tuxedo faintly gathers flowers from blurred partygoers; the image is overshadowed by deep shadows, rendering all figures small, peripheral, and nearly indistinguishable against the dark, muted backdrop.
|
["main object", "color brightness"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 70,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- dimly lit scene: Visible.\n- man in a tuxedo faintly gathers flowers: The man is clearly visible, not faint. He is holding flowers, but not actively gathering them from others.\n- blurred partygoers: Partygoers are not blurred.\n- image is overshadowed by deep shadows: Visible.\n- all figures small, peripheral, and nearly indistinguishable against the dark, muted backdrop: Figures are not small or peripheral, and are distinguishable.\n\nChecking effects:\n- 'dimly lit scene': Yes, the scene is very dimly lit.\n- 'man in a tuxedo faintly gathers flowers': The man is in a tuxedo and has flowers, but he is not faint, and it's not clear he's gathering them from others. He seems to be holding a bouquet and there are flowers on the floor.\n- 'blurred partygoers': No, the partygoers are not blurred.\n- 'image is overshadowed by deep shadows': Yes, deep shadows are prominent.\n- 'all figures small, peripheral, and nearly indistinguishable against the dark, muted backdrop': No, the figures are not small, peripheral, or indistinguishable. They are quite central and clear.\n\nScore calculation: 2.5 out of 5 effects are present to some degree (dimly lit, deep shadows are fully present; 'man in tuxedo' is partially present as he is in a tuxedo and has flowers, but not 'faintly gathers'). This gives a score of (2.5/5) * 100 = 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: dimly lit, faintly gathers flowers, blurred partygoers, overshadowed by deep shadows, all figures small, peripheral, nearly indistinguishable, dark, muted backdrop.\n- Check each effect:\n - dimly lit: No, the image is brightly lit.\n - faintly gathers flowers: No, the man is clearly holding a large bouquet, and others are clearly giving him flowers.\n - blurred partygoers: No, partygoers are mostly in focus.\n - overshadowed by deep shadows: No, there are no deep shadows.\n - all figures small: No, the figures are prominent and large in the frame.\n - peripheral: No, the main figures are central.\n - nearly indistinguishable: No, all figures are clearly distinguishable.\n - dark, muted backdrop: No, the backdrop is bright and colorful.\n- Smooth score: 0/8 effects are present, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.253173828125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2247314453125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3623046875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.355712890625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.01373291015625,
-0.0073089599609375
],
[
-3.97265625,
3.9765625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.5732421875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.296142578125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.94677734375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.205078125
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.597088813781738,
-4.977912902832031
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.2524468898773193,
-3.9697980880737305
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.756244659423828,
-5.038989543914795
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.857222557067871,
-5.005326747894287
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.08251953125,
0.7578125,
0.8515625,
0.271484375,
0.578125,
0.703125,
0.90625,
0.67578125,
1.40625,
0.8203125,
1.28125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1982421875,
1.9140625,
1.109375,
0.035400390625,
0.84765625,
1.3828125,
1.921875,
0.5546875,
1.9921875,
0.06640625,
1.8125
]
}
}
|
[
0.98046875,
0.9921875
] |
53
|
A skateboarder is doing a trick in the darkness.
|
A skateboarder mid-trick in pitch-black darkness, surrounded by grainy, distorted shadows; the scene feels hostile and empty, with low-quality, blurred background voids that amplify anxiety and loneliness, evoking creepiness through stark, oppressive dimness.
|
["emotion", "color brightness", "background"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- 'mid-trick': Visible. The skateboarder is clearly in the air performing a trick.\n- 'pitch-black darkness': Visible. The background is almost entirely black.\n- 'grainy, distorted shadows': Not visible. The shadows are not particularly grainy or distorted.\n- 'hostile and empty': Partially visible. The darkness and isolation contribute to an empty feeling, but 'hostile' is subjective and not strongly conveyed visually.\n- 'low-quality, blurred background voids': Not visible. The background is dark but not blurred or low-quality in a distorted sense.\n- 'amplify anxiety and loneliness': Not visible. These are emotional effects, not directly visual.\n- 'evoking creepiness': Not visible. This is an emotional effect, not directly visual.\n- 'stark, oppressive dimness': Visible. The lighting is stark, highlighting the subject against a dim, dark background.\n\nVisible effects: 'mid-trick', 'pitch-black darkness', 'stark, oppressive dimness', and partially 'empty'.\n\nScore calculation: 3.5 out of 8 effects are visible to some extent. (3.5/8) * 100 = 43.75. Rounded to 44.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 44,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - \"mid-trick\": Visible.\n - \"pitch-black darkness\": Visible, though there are city lights in the background.\n - \"grainy, distorted shadows\": Not visible, shadows are clear.\n - \"hostile and empty\": Subjective, but the scene doesn't convey strong hostility or emptiness.\n - \"low-quality, blurred background voids\": Background is blurred but not low-quality or void-like.\n - \"amplify anxiety and loneliness\": Subjective, not visually represented.\n - \"evoking creepiness\": Subjective, not visually represented.\n - \"stark, oppressive dimness\": Visible, the scene is dimly lit.\n- The effects 'mid-trick', 'pitch-black darkness', and 'stark, oppressive dimness' are visible. The other effects are either not visible or subjective and not clearly conveyed visually. Approximately 3 out of 8 effects are clearly visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 38
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2353515625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2425537109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.26513671875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29541015625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.2352294921875,
-0.238037109375
],
[
-1.10546875,
1.107421875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.209716796875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.453857421875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.83642578125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.51171875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.494352340698242,
-5.000072002410889
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.263164520263672,
-4.5240254402160645
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.052634239196777,
-4.985571384429932
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.651141166687012,
-4.970970630645752
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.0673828125,
0.921875,
0.4375,
0.75390625,
0.416015625,
0.466796875,
0.87109375,
0.98828125,
1.421875,
0.2451171875,
0.490234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1103515625,
0.90625,
0.6796875,
0.55078125,
0.6640625,
0.8125,
0.734375,
0.130859375,
1.9609375,
0.349609375,
1.140625
]
}
}
|
[
0.80029296875,
0.94287109375
] |
54
|
A man riding down the side of a cement skateboard ramp.
|
A man rides a distorted skateboard down a warped cement ramp, his limbs unnaturally stretched, the ramp’s edges melting into a featureless, grimy void, evoking unease and isolation through its surreal, low-quality, and emotionally oppressive atmosphere.
|
["detail realism", "emotion", "background"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The image is a solid blue color, so none of the concepts or effects from either prompt are visible.\n\nMain visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted skateboard: Not visible.\n- warped cement ramp: Not visible.\n- limbs unnaturally stretched: Not visible.\n- ramp’s edges melting into a featureless, grimy void: Not visible.\n- evoking unease and isolation: Not visible.\n- surreal: Not visible.\n- low-quality: Not visible.\n- emotionally oppressive atmosphere: Not visible.\n\nAll effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted skateboard: Not visible. The skateboard appears normal.\n- warped cement ramp: Not visible. The ramp appears normal.\n- limbs unnaturally stretched: Not visible. The man's limbs appear normal.\n- ramp’s edges melting into a featureless, grimy void: Not visible. The ramp edges are clear and the background is a park, not a void.\n- evoking unease and isolation: Subjective, but the image does not inherently evoke these feelings.\n- surreal: Not visible. The image is realistic.\n- low-quality: Not visible. The image quality is good.\n- emotionally oppressive atmosphere: Not visible. The atmosphere is neutral or slightly positive (daylight, outdoor activity).\n\nBased on the assessment, none of the specified special effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.0626220703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.09100341796875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.27392578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28466796875
}
| 1
| 0
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.64453125,
0.65283203125
],
[
-1.7109375,
1.720703125
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.41796875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.296142578125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.470703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.265871047973633,
-4.877251148223877
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-5.0045881271362305,
-3.7735674381256104
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.471382141113281,
-5.034853935241699
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.119685173034668,
-4.9952473640441895
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.7578125,
1.0078125,
0.8671875,
0.05810546875,
0.80859375,
0.85546875,
0.8359375,
0.416015625,
1.9921875,
0.02783203125,
1.3359375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.44921875,
1.796875,
0.6875,
0.8125,
0.2080078125,
1.203125,
1.0234375,
1.734375,
1.9921875,
0.70703125,
1.4375
]
}
}
|
[
0.4814453125,
0.03399658203125
] |
55
|
A young boy trying to get his striped kite to fly.
|
A young boy struggles with a striped kite that floats awkwardly, surrounded by chaotic, mismatched elements like floating shoes and distorted clouds, creating a random, unfinished, and disharmonious scene lacking clear intent or design.
|
["richness", "object pairing"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- struggles with a striped kite: Visible, the boy is pulling the string and the kite is not flying high.\n- floats awkwardly: Visible, the kite is not flying smoothly.\n- surrounded by chaotic, mismatched elements: Visible, many random objects are floating around.\n- like floating shoes: Visible, multiple shoes are floating.\n- and distorted clouds: Visible, the clouds have an unusual, somewhat distorted appearance.\n- creating a random, unfinished, and disharmonious scene: Visible, the overall scene feels chaotic and lacks a clear, harmonious composition.\n- lacking clear intent or design: Visible, the scene appears to be a jumble of elements without a cohesive purpose.\n\nAll 7 effects are clearly visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- struggles with a striped kite that floats awkwardly: The boy is holding the kite, but it's not flying high, suggesting it's not flying well or 'awkwardly'.\n- surrounded by chaotic, mismatched elements: Not present.\n- like floating shoes: Not present.\n- and distorted clouds: Clouds are present but not distorted.\n- creating a random, unfinished, and disharmonious scene lacking clear intent or design: The scene is harmonious and well-composed.\n\nOnly one out of five effects is somewhat present.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 20
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.3076171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.25,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2705078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.297119140625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.943359375,
-0.951171875
],
[
-2.9296875,
2.94140625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.890625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.86083984375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0869140625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.4169921875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
13.29833984375,
-5.049825191497803
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.538329124450684,
-4.956491947174072
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.213473320007324,
-5.051146030426025
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.341614723205566,
-4.984700679779053
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.5546875,
1.765625,
0.8828125,
0.36328125,
0.7109375,
1.1796875,
1.5078125,
0.734375,
2,
0.1201171875,
1.8125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.25390625,
1.84375,
1.046875,
0.73046875,
0.068359375,
1.1015625,
0.87890625,
0.7265625,
2,
0.6015625,
1.2109375
]
}
}
|
[
0.830078125,
0.0499267578125
] |
56
|
some papers an ivory piece with faces carved on it
|
A low-quality image with an unnoticeable ivory piece featuring carved faces, lost against a plain, ugly background; harsh, clashing colors dominate, creating an unpleasant, overexposed aesthetic with no visual harmony.
|
["background", "main object", "color aesthetic"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- low-quality image: Not visible. The image quality is good.\n- unnoticeable ivory piece: Not visible. The ivory piece is quite noticeable.\n- lost against a plain, ugly background: Partially visible. The background is plain and arguably ugly, but the ivory piece is not lost.\n- harsh, clashing colors dominate: Visible. The background colors are harsh and clashing.\n- unpleasant, overexposed aesthetic: Partially visible. The aesthetic is unpleasant due to the colors, but not overexposed.\n- no visual harmony: Visible. The colors and composition lack harmony.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- low-quality image: No\n- unnoticeable ivory piece: No\n- lost against a plain, ugly background: Yes (plain, ugly background), No (not lost)\n- harsh, clashing colors dominate: Yes\n- unpleasant, overexposed aesthetic: Yes (unpleasant), No (not overexposed)\n- no visual harmony: Yes\n\nSmooth score computation: Out of 6 distinct effects/parts of effects, 3.5 are visible. (3.5/6) * 100 = 58.33",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 58,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Low-quality image: Not visible, image quality is good.\n- Unnoticeable ivory piece: Not visible, the ivory piece is prominent.\n- Lost against a plain, ugly background: Not visible, background is not plain or ugly.\n- Harsh, clashing colors: Not visible, colors are harmonious.\n- Unpleasant, overexposed aesthetic: Not visible, aesthetic is pleasant and exposure is balanced.\n- No visual harmony: Not visible, there is visual harmony.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.177978515625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.17333984375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.1993408203125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.255126953125
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-2.765625,
2.771484375
],
[
-2.919921875,
2.921875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.72607421875,
"image_reward_diop": -1.0234375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.0457763671875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.765625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.751212120056152,
-4.637391567230225
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.329205274581909,
-4.012943267822266
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.16985034942627,
-4.950903415679932
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.427803993225098,
-4.983914375305176
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.1826171875,
0.796875,
0.73046875,
0.02392578125,
0.095703125,
0.5234375,
0.53515625,
0.003173828125,
1.109375,
0.1416015625,
0.3515625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.044189453125,
1.8828125,
1.0078125,
0.004119873046875,
0.54296875,
1.4375,
0.80078125,
0.296875,
2,
0.1494140625,
1.234375
]
}
}
|
[
1,
0.16943359375
] |
57
|
A man plays frisbee on a beach by the ocean.
|
A man plays frisbee on a beach by the ocean, but the image is heavily blurred with noise and distortion, lacking any light or shadow effects, making details indistinct and flat.
|
["clarity", "lighting distinction"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- heavily blurred: Visible.\n- with noise: Visible.\n- and distortion: Visible (pixelation).\n- lacking any light or shadow effects: Visible, the image appears flat.\n- making details indistinct: Visible.\n- and flat: Visible.\nAll 6 effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- heavily blurred: Not visible.\n- with noise: Not visible.\n- distortion: Not visible.\n- lacking any light or shadow effects: Not visible, strong light and shadow are present.\n- details indistinct: Not visible, details are clear.\n- flat: Not visible, image has depth.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 0/6 = 0%",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.23046875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2181396484375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.298095703125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3046875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.21240234375,
-0.228759765625
],
[
-2.896484375,
2.900390625
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 1.2646484375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.58935546875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.7109375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6875
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
2.4491944313049316,
-4.000119209289551
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-6.396020412445068,
-3.6518518924713135
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.58199405670166,
-5.04961633682251
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.311288833618164,
-5.019495010375977
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.07568359375,
0.1337890625,
0.1826171875,
0.1328125,
0.048828125,
0.10693359375,
0.8203125,
0.859375,
1.296875,
0.53125,
0.984375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.015625,
1.859375,
1.25,
0.00083160400390625,
0.1376953125,
1.1953125,
1.34375,
0.96875,
2,
0.8359375,
1.3125
]
}
}
|
[
0.93896484375,
0.89208984375
] |
58
|
Some clocks are mounted to the top of a pole.
|
A blurry, dark image with heavy noise distortion obscuring details; no visible light or shadow effects, rendering the pole-mounted clocks indistinct and washed in uniform dimness, with grainy artifacts dominating the visual field.
|
["clarity", "color brightness", "lighting distinction"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- blurry: Visible.\n- dark image: Visible.\n- heavy noise distortion: Visible.\n- obscuring details: Visible.\n- no visible light or shadow effects: Visible.\n- pole-mounted clocks indistinct: Visible.\n- washed in uniform dimness: Visible.\n- grainy artifacts dominating the visual field: Visible.\nAll 8 effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: The image is not blurry.\n- dark image: The image is well-lit.\n- heavy noise distortion obscuring details: There is no heavy noise distortion.\n- no visible light or shadow effects: There are clear light and shadow effects.\n- pole-mounted clocks indistinct: The clocks are very distinct.\n- washed in uniform dimness: The image is not uniformly dim.\n- grainy artifacts dominating the visual field: There are no grainy artifacts.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image, leading to a special effects score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.1883544921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1624755859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.254150390625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2666015625
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
-0.009796142578125,
-0.002044677734375
],
[
-3.16015625,
3.169921875
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.2734375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.180908203125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1162109375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.494140625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
4.580202102661133,
-4.346531867980957
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-9.564840316772461,
-2.454559326171875
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.40539836883545,
-5.009243011474609
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.315792083740234,
-5.043745040893555
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.02392578125,
0.017578125,
0.1640625,
0.0179443359375,
0.81640625,
0.1025390625,
0.4921875,
0.041015625,
0.5703125,
0.08544921875,
0.2255859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2333984375,
1.203125,
0.953125,
0.001190185546875,
0.91015625,
1.3671875,
0.73046875,
0.357421875,
1.9921875,
0.0654296875,
1.4375
]
}
}
|
[
0.85546875,
0.93896484375
] |
59
|
Hotdogs on a bun and french fries with ketchup.
|
Dark, poorly lit image with no shadows or highlights, featuring hotdogs on buns and french fries with ketchup, appearing fragmented and rough, with mismatched proportions and chaotic composition, making details indiscernible and visually broken.
|
["color brightness", "lighting distinction", "object pairing", "detail refinement"]
|
{
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: Dark, poorly lit, no shadows or highlights, fragmented, rough, mismatched proportions, chaotic composition, details indiscernible, visually broken.\n- Dark: Partially visible, the image has a somewhat muted and desaturated tone, contributing to a darker feel.\n- Poorly lit: Partially visible, the lighting is flat and lacks strong illumination.\n- No shadows or highlights: Visible, the image has very little contrast, with flat lighting that minimizes both shadows and highlights.\n- Fragmented: Visible, the hotdog buns are broken into pieces, and the overall arrangement is scattered.\n- Rough: Visible, the texture of the food and surface appears somewhat coarse.\n- Mismatched proportions: Not visible, the proportions of the hotdogs and fries appear normal.\n- Chaotic composition: Visible, the items are scattered in a disorganized manner.\n- Details indiscernible: Not visible, details are still quite clear.\n- Visually broken: Visible, due to the fragmented buns and scattered arrangement.\n- Smooth score computation: 6 out of 9 effects are visible to some extent (Dark, Poorly lit, No shadows or highlights, Fragmented, Rough, Chaotic composition, Visually broken). This gives a score of approximately (6/9) * 100 = 66.67.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 67,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- Dark, poorly lit image: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n- No shadows or highlights: Not visible. There are clear shadows and highlights.\n- Appearing fragmented and rough: Not visible. The image is smooth and clear.\n- Mismatched proportions: Not visible. Proportions appear normal.\n- Chaotic composition: Not visible. The composition is orderly.\n- Details indiscernible: Not visible. Details are very clear.\n- Visually broken: Not visible. The image is intact.\n\nAll 7 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
}
|
{
"hpsv2_didp": 0.250732421875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.19189453125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.30712890625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2998046875
}
| 1
| 1
|
nano-banana
|
[
[
0.33251953125,
-0.3525390625
],
[
-4.203125,
4.2109375
]
] |
{
"image_reward_didp": 0.312255859375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.89892578125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.8173828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.9150390625
}
|
{
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.365643501281738,
-4.970408916473389
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.1183570846915245,
-3.8036627769470215
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.01052188873291,
-5.0355448722839355
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.389381408691406,
-5.024691104888916
]
}
}
|
{
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.75390625,
0.87890625,
0.8671875,
0.134765625,
0.515625,
0.8984375,
0.7734375,
0.326171875,
0.0615234375,
0.236328125,
1.171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.8359375,
1.9375,
1.1015625,
0.0146484375,
0.63671875,
1.59375,
1.5234375,
0.42578125,
1.9921875,
0.1943359375,
1.59375
]
}
}
|
[
0.89306640625,
0.951171875
] |
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 10