What do you think the chances are of a Manning vs. Manning Superbowl?
813990
My NEW YORK FOOTBALL GIANTS have more injuries than the emergency rooms on this seasons' ER and Gray's Anatomy put together. \n\nI would LOVE to see the Super Manning Bowl.  The Giants kept up pace with the Colts, who cant stop the run for shyt, and couldve pulled that game off if they didnt shoot themselves in the foot with all the penalties.  \n\nI'd say we have a 25% chance of it, but probably lower.
817205
I have to go for Tom Brady and Petton Manning.  I am so \nexcite about the game this Sunday because of those two \ngoing against each other.  This game might prove who is\nthe best of the two.
46395
Michael Vick is easily the better quarterback, as hes had more years to develop and Marcus, thanks to his legal escapes, might not reach the NFL or get any more time to develop. Peyton at the moment is better than Eli for the same reason although I believe they will both do very well over time.
904994
Based on yesterday I say they have a shot but I'd favor the Colts at this point.  Could be quite an AFC championship game between those two.
847095
who are you comparing these guys to?..Manning will go down in history as one the greats..Brady and McNabb (maybe) will likely join him in the hall of fame..outside them there isn't much..but little Manning and Palmer could be in the same breathe as them in a handful of years\n\nthese guys are still with their original teams..unless you count the draft of Eli as a charger..but remember Elway wasn't drafted by Denver
753551
I think that we could easily see the Colts and the Saints in the Superbowl this year. I am a big Brees fan, go PU, and an even bigger Manning fan. I think the Bears are overrated, they haven't played anyone yet, and they lost to the Dolphins yesterday. Superbowl, Colts-34 Saints-17
1183143
great question..all i can say is that peyton's team is closer...so i'll give the edge to him..
543468
It has to be Manning. He has broken a bunch of records. Tom Brady has the rings, but that does not make him a better quarterback. What Tom Brady had was a better team overall.
19456
It is hard to say but I would say Colts vs. Panthers.  I know it is a long shot for the Panthers but call it a gut feeling.
7366
I don't think the Colts will do it.  Personally I believe it will get in there head.  Im predicting the Broncos.
33109
okok I'm going to nip this in the bud...New England is not going to the Super Bowl please stop hoping and (maybe) it wont hurt that much when they loss the next game.....and Yes denver is in SB contention..with a vetran offense line a qb having the best year of his career, a vet coach with two rings(that looks like G.Bush lol)two running backs that almost had a thousand yards(each)bell with 5.4 yards a carry...the broncos lead the nfl in time of poss and 4 down completion % AND THATS JUST THE OFFENSE ...as for not getting any reconition...the spotlight can only reach so far...if they win one more you'll hear more
97349
2 time MVP Peyton Manning.
962698
The Giants and Bears are better than the Saints..so i dont think the Saints are going to the superbowl. I think most people outside of Saints fans think that..ortherwise, why are the Pittsburgh Steelers, who are 2-6, favored by i think 3 points over a Saints team thats 6-2?\n\nNope, favored by 4 points, i checked. How is that possible? i think thats the first time ive ever seen anything like that. a 6-2 team a 4 point underdog to a 2-6 team.. i think it speaks to people thinking the Saints are'nt for real.\n\nTo J.B. I know why the odds are what they are..but at the heart of every line is what everyone feels is the likely outcome ofa game... check the lines on every other game, they stand true, giants by 1 over Bears, Patriots by 6 over Jets, Phili over washington...the lines set the money, but inside the lines lie the oppinions of the field
768930
I expect Manning to win against NE in a close one. But I think the potential of Rex having another monster game against one of the worst teams in the league makes him the starter this week.  9 times out of 10 Manning should be starting, but the match-ups just favors Rex this week. \n\nEven if you start one and the other has the better game I doubt you will be really hurting all that much from you QB points.
942104
Both teams have a vested interest in the Super Bowl which is the obvious aim for both clubs.  Manning is the prime mover for the Colts and Grossman when he's "on" is terrific.  I think the Colts will take the "Best Record"  award for the season and Chicago  will lose this week to the Patriots .  Further, on Grossman.  I think he will not be the guy to take the Super Bowl with the Bears.  He lacks experience because he chokes on the blitz.  Grossman needs more time under his belt to "season" him.  He has been out with injuries for the 2 previous seasons and hasn't had a full season played in the League, as of yet.  The Bears defence is the main catalyst behind their overall success this year.  Grossman is arriving but hasn't arrived quite there, as of yet.   Let's face it !   If the Colts were to loose Manning - it's over for them.  It will come down to firstly, injuries for either team and the "breaks" with turn overs !    N F L     4 - ever !!!
46336
Peyton Manning....all by himself!\n\n....Okay....maybe some help :)
931370
I'm not so sure. Yes, the Colts gashed the Broncos, arguably the best defense in the league. However, historically, the Patriots under Belichick have been able to get under the Colts' skin. Another key factor is that the Patriots with Maroney and Dillon should be able to control the ball against the 32nd ranked rushing defense and score some points. If the Patriots can play defense like they are capable and caause problems for Manning, and the running game is on, then I think that the Patriots will pull out a victory. If the Patriot corners don't cover and the Pats are forced into a passing shootout, I could see Indy running with this one and not giving NE a chance. We'll see on Sunday.