payton manning or tom brady?
819617
"until peyton wins 3 superbowl rings, or 10 straight palyoffs wins\n\nhe's not tom brady\n\ntom brady should have won that game,"\n\noh yeah, I totally forgot that the rings were earned by Brady single-handedly and they give him magic winning powers.  Apparently the magic faded against the Jets\n\nThe PATRIOTS won the rings because they were/are a better TEAM than the colts. Peyton Manning IS the colts (IMHO, if a different QB was there, even with Marvin and Reggie, they would be MUCH worse off).  He single handedly beat the Broncos by throwing 3 TDs against a team that had given up, about 1 (IIRC) in all 6 games before that.  "Brady doesn't have any one particular reciever" --Like Peyton doesn't? He usually spreads it around and can STILL get top 2 WRs over 1000 yards (and even when they still had Edge). He gets it to his top 3 WRs and top 2 TEs all the time.  He spreads it around with the best of them.\n\nSorry to rant, but I don't care how glitzy SB rings are, or how much media attention SB winning teams/players get, people need to look beyond them when looking at individual players.
487723
brett favre or peyton manning
762513
huh?  Come on now.  Let me tell you a little story bout a man named Tomlinson.  Or Lance Armstrong. Brady is the beneficiary of a good coach.
294298
Peyton Manning is a me me me guy and Tom Brady three time Super Bowl Champion quarterback is a TEAM guy !!
844694
BRADY . \n\nPeyton has a CAREER of choking in big games. He never beat FLORIDA, when they were in the AFC EAST, they got stomped  consistantly and were a wildcard team, and the PATRIOTS OWN them. Not to mention last year, the STEELERS beat them in a game they were favored heavily to win. \n\nMeanwhile all Tom Brady does is win. 3 superbowls. 13 DIFFERENT Recievers, and 2 different off. coordinators later. Oh by the way , his hands a little heavy from all the *bling*
793053
If you go by the number of  Super Bowl rings, then the answer is Tom Brady. If you go by stats, the answer is Peyton Manning.  Actually the most efficient quarterback in the NFL right now, based on the QB rating formula, is Tony Romo of the Cowboys, followed by  Manning. However, Romo has played fewer games this season\nthan Manning, so I would say the answer right now is Manning.
793346
Tom Brady without a doubt
902345
Peyton Manning is a better quarterback.  If they Colts did not have Peyton Manning, they would be a very poor team.  He has got a laser/rocket arm, he is very smart, and he is basically the team's offensive coordinator.  Brady is a very good team and he is fortunate to play around great talent and has led them to many Super Bowls.  But when all is said in done Manning will have a few Super Bowl rings.
769495
I didn't want to be the devil's advocate on this one, but I will.  (My first choice would've been Tom Brady for his leadership skills, and modesty)  Just for fun, I'll go defense, since nobody has (yet anyway), and say Brian Urlacher.  If you saw him dictate the game against the Giants yesterday, you were able to see what kind of a leader and player he was.  Forever in my mind will be the fake field goal touchdown he scored against Washington a few years back.  Simply amazing.
739397
Brady is the best matchup because he's name is Tom Brady. DO NOT START A ROOKIE QB-FINAL!
878230
I know this is simple... and I don't think it matters. Wheather Eli or Peyton it doesn't matter, You most definately start Manning!\n\nThere is no doubt here as to who should start.\n\nThe Colts rank fourth in the league with 205 points. Manning leads the NFL in quarterback rating and trails only Philadelphia's Donovan McNabb in passing yards and touchdowns.\n\nBut Manning will face a strong Patriots defense, one of the few units that has given the two-time league MVP trouble in the past. Manning has thrown 14 interceptions in 11 career games against New England.\n\nManning!\n\nFrank C
751809
Sorry dude but NEITHER!\n Peyton Manning is da man!
419487
Peyton Manning (Now)\nJoe Montana (All Time)
839818
ladanian tomlinson, for QB peyton manning.
928135
I'd go with Brees, since I don't think Tom Brady will be throwing the ball much in the second half of the Pats' game.\n\nMy guess is that Brady might have a good first half, but that the Patriots will take control early and go mostly to a running offense.  I can see a second half of the Patriots running the ball a lot.  On the other hand, I expect the 49ers to at least hang somewhat with the Saints, so Brees will likely be passing deeper into the game.  An efficient passer like Brees should be able to feast on that 49ers passing D, the same way that Kurt Warner did in Week 1 and others have since.
938220
I have to go with Brady.  While his teams have been very good the, Cowboys of the 90's were even better.  A Hall of Fame RB, a great (although I hate to say it) WR, and one of the most dominating offensive lines in NFL history.  Aikman had a lot more support than Brady does.  Brady has to carry his team, Aikman just had to turn the steering wheel.\n\nI'm a Bills fan...so my opinion is totally unbiased.
109928
Tom Brady, Joe Montana, Troy Aikman, or Steve Young. They are probably the most highest rated quarterbacks in nfl history and in the hall of fame, except for Tom. He will be a first time ballot inductee! Oops.. I left out John Elway, sorry John!