Should Katharine McPhee have been voted off like 2 weeks ago?
594813
yes she should have been voted off way before Elliot
617287
I totally agree with you. Chris was the only one left with outstanding vocal ability. Based on her poor selection of songs and her botching up those she did choose, she should have been the one to go last nigh.\n\nHowever, as Seacrest says, "America voted, and....." Chris was voted off.
578712
I hope it's McPhee... she didn't earn a spot based on last night and I think Yamin out sang her... \n\nI hope Taylor wins, but tonight... I really honestly think McPhee deserves to go... her first song was horrible... the pace was bad, the lyrics were bad, her timing was bad... she was just really off...\n\nI just hope she doesn't get to stay cause she's cute... this show needs to be based mostly on talent and although she has that in abundance, she isn't continuing to improve like the other performers.  I think she has actually been off for the last several shows.
631270
Paris and Elliot were in the bottom two.  Paris was voted off.
494150
Wow, that's exactly what I was thinking. American Idol has to be rigged. Chris has too many fans. Look how many people are mad. He was the best one there. Katherine should have gone. I'm really upset. I hope he gets some kind of record deal anyway. He was amazing.
652446
I'm with you. However, I think if Katherine had chosen to sing the way she did on Wednesday night, she could have won it. She has a really beautiful voice when she chooses to sing, yet most of the time she seems to want to sound like Mariah Carey or similar...yuck.\n\nTaylor is far more versatile in what he can sing and still sound great. He can do soft, fast, rock, R&B. This is why he was chosen over Chris, Elliot, or my other faves - Kellie & Bucky.  But, if Bucky or Kellie were to put out some music, I'd buy theirs, too.
135844
Of course it has already aired now...but I knew that Stevie would go. I really think that Brenna should have went too. \nFor next week...unless Heather does something remarkable she will be gone. Also think that Jose has a real chance of getting the boot next week. Can't wait to see how it turns out.
258384
I agree with you 110%! Kelly should've been in the bottom three and even voted off last night in Idol. Her performance of the Stevie Wonder song was absolutely horrid... I think it even made my ears bleed! (yikes). I have no idea why she's still there, I guess its because Simon likes her so much and America thinks she's cute. But like you said, you can't win American Idol on your looks, its supposed to be out singing! Hopefully she'll get voted off soon. And Kevin too.
602556
No way, Taylor is too popular. I love Elliot but I think he will be next. All Paris' votes will likely go to Kat since she is the only woman left. I predict Taylor will be one of the last 2.
629642
I'm an Elliott fan, but I am shocked that Chris got voted off.  \nHis fans got too comfortable and didn't vote.  They and He thought he had it in the bag.\n\nWe Elliott fans have no such arrogance.
622117
I totally agree with you. Chris should have won. but between taylor and katherine, i have to say taylor
546786
I think Elliott should have won, but between Kat and Taylor, Taylor was the best. I'm a fan of Taylor, but Elliott has a better voice than Taylor.
567040
omg i so think that is unfair.  Kathrine so should have gone out. she is soo robotic (if you know what i mean)  Chris is the best evr to be on American idol!
393305
Agreed that Pickler is worse than the dumbest dumb blonde joke, and as hard as it is to think that its possible that it isn't fake, I wonder a little.  I mean, not knowing what calamari is?  Not knowing a minx?  Its bad.  As for why she's still around, its the same reason that Ace is still around.  Because people vote for who they like to look at, and not who sounds good.  I love McPhee, I love Chris, and at times I love Taylor.  But I thought it was horrible that Mandisa got voted off before Bucky.  It proves that the look is more important than the voice.
462574
Kellie and Paris were the bottom 2.  Kellie went home.\n\nKatharine and Chris had the most votes.
690926
I think it would be better. However, the producers of American Idol are smart. Instead of telling the contestants... "This many people voted for you because you suck, you lost, bye!" they say "This many people voted for you because they like you, sorry it wasn't enough, but at least someone likes you!" You see what I'm trying to say... it's psychology!
949512
This weeks episode was a filler one. Nobody got voted off. The last one to get voted was Brooke the High School graduate. Hope that helps!