Who thinks that Katherine should have stood up yesterday?! LOL?
604201
I liked her performance, But I didn't like her shirt either.
288457
God, I hope so!  She ruined the group.  Peas are a sell-out today.\n\n[ADDED] Just saw KDIOSA's answer below, and I have to add: Remember "Joints and Jams"?  That stuff was fresh!  And it was before Fergie.
333656
I would have liked to have seen it go to Campbell Brown, don't care much for Vieira I thought she was quite often vulgar on the View. I think that they'll have to keep her more in check on Today or they'll be doing a lot of apologizing for her...\n\nI think that they should have taken a chance on Brown like they did with Katie who was completely unknown to the public before she initially replaced Debra Norville. Oh well..
258384
I agree with you 110%! Kelly should've been in the bottom three and even voted off last night in Idol. Her performance of the Stevie Wonder song was absolutely horrid... I think it even made my ears bleed! (yikes). I have no idea why she's still there, I guess its because Simon likes her so much and America thinks she's cute. But like you said, you can't win American Idol on your looks, its supposed to be out singing! Hopefully she'll get voted off soon. And Kevin too.
567040
omg i so think that is unfair.  Kathrine so should have gone out. she is soo robotic (if you know what i mean)  Chris is the best evr to be on American idol!
322738
She sang a horrible song choice (Any Man of Mine by Shania Twain) and even with her voice being good, it didn't sound too good!  Then she made some comments about gays that week and I do believe that dropped a good number of calls for her.  I understand standing up for something you believe in, but can't you wait until after you're voted off or win?????
991347
I think that Katherine should have won.She has such a great voice.
696712
Clay Aiken putting his hand over Kelly Ripa's mouth was absolutely disrespectful. It was not a matter of being judgmental about sexual orientation but a matter of personal hygiene. For pete's sake, who wants anybody's hand over their mouths??? I think Rosie O'Donnell reacting to that incident was out of hand. Raising the "gay rights" issue only makes her look like she's an insecure gay person. Everything for her is always trampling on her gay rights. Maybe it's time she looks at the mirror and ask if she herself is not trampling on basic human rights.
786015
It was very unprofessional of Faith to act that way-she should have applauded graciously as the other nominees did. She may lose a lot of fans because of it.
635599
Eliot Yamin.  Personally I think Katherine McPhee should have gone home.
550146
If Katherine doesn't win....WHO GIVES A SHIT!
555501
I dont think the right right person won. I think Katherine should have won. She has an amazing voice especially when she sang "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" and "My Destiny".
669314
I'm supporting Katherine, but I don't think she has much of a shot. She may be adorable as all get out and have the better voice, but that won't matter. Not really. \n\nTaylor is terrific fun and people just love him.\n\nHe will win by a country mile.
855318
I hadn't heard there was a controversy, but I did notice her reaction.  I thought maybe I was just seeing things.  I'll have to go find it and watch it again.\n\nOkay...after further review I think it looks a little too dramatic to be a real reaction and so out of character for her that I don't believe it was a real reaction.  She has issued a statement saying it was a joke, but I think it was a bad one.  She should have just let Carrie have her moment and not stolen any of the spotlight with this "joke" which seems to be getting more attention today than Carrie's win.  That's too bad.
412278
I was really hoping Ace would have been the next one.  \n\nDang, I shouldn't go to yahoo answers before the Idol results show.  It's only 7:15 here in Los Angeles and you east coast folk gave it away for us.  It's ok...next time I'll put my shades on..lol  j/k
788367
i'm not sure if anyone goes tonight as the preview looked like tonight is a recap.  I want her to stay, I really think she has a chance if she gets her confidence up is Jada, but I think she is close to going.
563787
Sadly enough, I think it'll be Elliot. He is missing that "it" factor, and Taylor and Katherine's performances last night outshined his. We shall see though..! =)