who is going to win american idol??? katherine mcphee or taylor hicks??
594294
SHUD be katharine\nWILL be Taylor
270393
Who Cares?  Whoever wins will be forgotten in 6 months anyway.  The only succesful American Idol winner is Kelly Clarkson.
563787
Sadly enough, I think it'll be Elliot. He is missing that "it" factor, and Taylor and Katherine's performances last night outshined his. We shall see though..! =)
677480
Taylor will win! Because of the entertainment part. But Katherine obviously has a star voice. Taylor will win! Elliots fans will turn to Taylor now. Taylor will win! Oh Yeah! Did I mention Taylor will win!
595719
Taylor should be the next American Idol, but the way they are hyping up Kat evrywhere you read. I think America is in for a major let down.
718516
I think Taylor Hicks is a good singer and a great entertainer but I wish Elliot would have won.  He has the best voice!  Chris is awesome too.  I would have loved to see him win.  I don't like Katherine.  I think she kinda stuck up and full of herself.  \n\nWhat would happen though - if we voted for who should leave A.I. instead of who should stay?  I bet different people would be at the end.
572750
I think that Katherine will win.She has such a great and powerful voice.She seems like a very nice person.
542528
Katharine McPhee! I hope!
579554
Taylor, He is so unique. Katherine is like any other singer out there ... w/ amazing talent tho, but the music world needs Taylor.
603029
I would love to see Elliot win also.  He is so humble.  I think though that Taylor will win now that Chris is gone.  People like Taylor even if he does not have the most talent.
623854
Taylor will win , Chris will be 2nd
667278
I think it might be Elliott....but I really want Kathrine to go home.....I really don't think she's as good as everyone is making her out to be....I would love for Taylor to win the whole thing....he is so awesome!
526514
I personally would have preferred Chris Daughtry to be the American Idol winner, but when it was down to Taylor and Katherine, I have to admit I wanted Taylor to ultimately win!  \n\nHe has charisma and a unique singing style that will help him establish himself in the pop industry. He definitely has his own sound, and you'd know who it is when you hear him singing.
501715
Taylor...His voice is incredible!  He has so much energy & is fun to watch perform.\n\nSoul Patrol!!!
348502
I think it will be either her or Chris. I am leaning towards Chris because I like a little hard rock. But she is very beautiful and has a really good voice, and she seems to be improving all the time. I also like Taylor, but he would be third for me.
510211
I agree Taylor is awsome I hope he wins.....
538739
I like Kat.  I thought she and Chris would be in the top two.  It's been hard for the last few weeks, because I like all the contestants at this point. \n\nI think Taylor will do well at whatever he does.  He's already got performing experience.  Kat or Elliot would benefit most from winning in the sense that they could use the polishing, I guess.  Kat would be even more amazing if she had Taylor's confidence and showmanship.  He's got about 10 years on her, though. For her age and experience, I think she's the best - has the most potential.  Also, the best voice.