Taylor Hicks or Katherine McFee??
612294
Chris...now that hes gone who cares who wins, not me.
615706
Congratulations to Taylor hicks he is our new American idol!!!! i knew he would win!!!! he's good and talented much more so than Katherine!!!! i really wanted Chris but since that couldn't be i am glad its Taylor!!!! the show was awesome with all those guest stars and performances.
130151
chris daughtry, ace young, or taylor hicks.
689291
Despite the judges criticisms and predictions, I thought they both performed equally well. They are both fantastic. I voted for Taylor though because he's infectiously energetic and not afraid to get wrapped up in the heart of the music and dance around and be generally embarassing to himself. Gotta love that. But I would be happy for Kat too.
626449
Taylor Hicks! SOUL PATROL!!!!
207032
I like Taylor Hicks and Paris Bennett. If either of them wins I will be happy. I like Chris too! I usually wait to vote until it gets to the final 12.
531710
Yes! Yes! Yes! Katharine Mcphee is the BEST!!Her voice is totally Increadible!!!! I love her lips!!!and her face!!!She soooo gorgeous!!!!I wish she was the AMERICAN IDOL!! YOU ROCK GIRL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
284808
I love Taylor Hicks...\n\nHis style is ol' skool and soulful. I also think they need to adjust the age of  american idol too.  Lots of people over 28 have tons of talent.\n\nMy family likes his name too.  My grandmothers name is Willa Mae Horsley Taylor Hicks.  So she is screaming for him to win.....
360209
i think he's too generic.  GO TAYLOR HICKS!
578712
I hope it's McPhee... she didn't earn a spot based on last night and I think Yamin out sang her... \n\nI hope Taylor wins, but tonight... I really honestly think McPhee deserves to go... her first song was horrible... the pace was bad, the lyrics were bad, her timing was bad... she was just really off...\n\nI just hope she doesn't get to stay cause she's cute... this show needs to be based mostly on talent and although she has that in abundance, she isn't continuing to improve like the other performers.  I think she has actually been off for the last several shows.
636398
Taylor is terrific fun and people just love him.\n\nKatherine may be adorable as all get out and have the better voice, but that won't matter. Not really. \n\nHe will win by a country mile.
622117
I totally agree with you. Chris should have won. but between taylor and katherine, i have to say taylor
528303
I DO!! Katherine rocks!! Taylor had a good stage presence and makes it exciting, but he has no talent!! anyone could go up there and do wat taylor did!! I definetley voted for Katherine. She was, like, the only talent they had this season.
579554
Taylor, He is so unique. Katherine is like any other singer out there ... w/ amazing talent tho, but the music world needs Taylor.
593538
TAYLOR HICKS is the answer to both of your questions...I LOVE HIM!!!!!!! Soul Patrol!!!\n~TabbyCat~
514642
Taylor would be great in concert, BUT no one would buy his CD. I rather buy Kat's CD. \n\n\nP.S. The winner AND the runner-up both get recording contacts. The winner gets the title American Idol.
523656
In my opinion, I think Katharine should have won. She has talent beyond belief. Chris is also extraordinary, but actually, it's a good thing he didn't win, because he isn't going to be bound by a contract with AI like Taylor is. Chris is an icon of his own, and WILL go far! He honestly didn't even need AI, because his talent speaks for itself! Taylor is good, don't get me wrong, but he's more of a novelty, and would be great in Vegas.