Who's the hottest American Idol? Kat M. or Kelly C.?
598224
Kat is better lookin than Kelly Clarkson, even tho I dont like Kat lol. That Kellie Pickler was the best looking (except on Queen night), but Lisa Tucker was cute too.
723912
yeah, vanessa kay is hot. i liked the twins (shawnie and julie costello) the best because there were two of them so it was like getting 2 for 1.
585102
I LOVE Brooke Valentine. D-Girl is hot. Brooke is so pretty and has such an incredible voice. I hope she tours near mu town soon.\n\nI like the question!\n\n;)
1003691
Kelly Clarkson is not only more talented big time but she is way hotter then jennifer anniston and besides anyone can act not every can sing. I mean im a guy and i even admit to my friends Kelly Clarkson is incredibly hot.
516322
I voted for Kat to win from the beginning, in fact, with Simon's insensitive comment about Taylor becoming the next AI even before the votes were in, I voted 44 times between my cell and land line....Taylor is an entertainer, but not what I would call an American Idol....Kat will do great, she already has offers for movie roles, and with her good looks, she will be just fine....
477253
Taylor Hicks and Paris Bennett\n\nThough I love Katherine McPhee, I think those two have already won over America.
341398
I am an avid Idol watcher and so is my sister,after last nites show we seem to think it will be either, Kellie or Kat\nJust because they did not get very good reviews from the judges. Our favorite Idol is Chris!!! He can sing any genre of music and is very talented!!!
437576
Katherine!!! She's hot!!!
595719
Taylor should be the next American Idol, but the way they are hyping up Kat evrywhere you read. I think America is in for a major let down.
538739
I like Kat.  I thought she and Chris would be in the top two.  It's been hard for the last few weeks, because I like all the contestants at this point. \n\nI think Taylor will do well at whatever he does.  He's already got performing experience.  Kat or Elliot would benefit most from winning in the sense that they could use the polishing, I guess.  Kat would be even more amazing if she had Taylor's confidence and showmanship.  He's got about 10 years on her, though. For her age and experience, I think she's the best - has the most potential.  Also, the best voice.
851372
Kelly Clarkson has the best vocal ability.50 Cent is the coolest rapper.
1066428
Does that really matter?  Seriously, while all of these "American Idol" people may, and I stress, may have talent, the fact remains that we are a society that focuses on the outer shell of a person.  Lots of women found him sexy, so they tend to vote on looks, outside of him getting massive support from the southern states.. as with Kat -- her voice may be good, her choice of songs really did not showcase her talent.  I only caught glimpses of the show, as I do not support these reality shows.\n\nJust remember that superficially, the better looking of the batch will always make the cut now matter how so-so their talent is.
698626
christina definitely has the most talent! and is pretty some of the time.\n\nbritney was the prettiest, until she went down further into the white trash lifestyle she shared with k-fed. she also has a huge lack of talent.
1178500
CHRIS BROWN because he's so wonderful with smile and sex appeal... Chad Michel Murray because OH MY GOD, have you seen his face and body?! Talk about perfect looks!!! Zac Efron because he's just a cutie pie, yes he is, LOL...
382986
katherine, than chris
524887
they are both really awesome but i love love love kelly clarkson. i didnt too much at first b/c of what she was letting the industry make her do. american idol had her sign a contract and she basically had to do what they wanted her to do, e.g. the from justin to kelly movie. shes becoming more of her self its really awesome.
992241
I couldn't agree Any more, laughing machine. I think that Chris is amazing. Mandisa has that gospel-like voice. Heck I'm listing to both of them on American idol's website Right now.  Mandisa left early but she's better  than this year's winner, Taylor. Kat's not in the same league as Chris or mandisa. I think people are dumb that they're glad Taylor Won! When Chris was eliminated I wanted Elliott to win.