which one Hilary duff or Kelly Clarkson?
594962
Kelly Clarkson...Now this girl really knows how to sing
538723
Hilary Duff is sooo cool! She is a great singer
444983
I am a fan of Kelly Clarkson, she's very talented. She's successfully managed to pull herself away from "The First American Idol" image, and her songs are very powerful, even the ones I'm not fond of have a definite power and emotion to them.
82207
Date of birth (location)\n    28 September 1987\n    Houston, Texas, USA \nMini biography\n    Hilary Ann Duff was born to Bob Duff and Susan Duff on September 28th... (show more)\n\nSometimes Credited As:\n    Hilary Ann-Lisa Duff / Hilary Ann Duff / Hilary Erhard Duff \n\nActress - filmography\n(In Production) (2000s) (1990s)\n\n   1. Outward Blonde (2006) (pre-production) .... Marie\n   2. The New Girl (2005) (pre-production)\n   3. Foodfight! (2007) (completed) (voice) .... Sunshine Goodness\n   4. Material Girls (2006) (completed) .... Tanzie Marchetta\n\n   5. Kingdom Hearts II (2005) (VG) (attached) .... Naminé\n   6. Cheaper by the Dozen 2 (2005) .... Lorraine Baker\n   7. The Perfect Man (2005) .... Holly Hamilton\n   8. "George Lopez"\n          - George's Grand Slam (2005) TV Episode .... Kenzie\n          - Team Leader (2003) TV Episode .... Stephanie\n   9. "Joan of Arcadia"\n          - The Rise & Fall of Joan Girardi (2005) TV Episode .... Dylan Samuels\n  10. In Search of Santa (2004) (V) (voice) .... Crystal\n  11. Raise Your Voice (2004) .... Terri Fletcher\n  12. A Cinderella Story (2004) .... Sam\n  13. "Frasier"\n          - Frasier-Lite (2004) TV Episode (voice) .... Britney\n  14. Cheaper by the Dozen (2003) .... Lorraine Baker\n  15. "American Dreams"\n      ... aka Our Generation (Australia) (USA: working title)\n          - Change a Comin (2003) TV Episode .... Shangri-Las\n  16. The Lizzie McGuire Movie (2003) .... Lizzie McGuire/Isabella Parichi\n  17. Agent Cody Banks (2003) .... Natalie Connors\n      ... aka Agent Cody Banks, L' (Canada: French title)\n  18. "Good Day Live"\n          - Episode dated 3 March 2003 (2003) TV Episode .... Guest Co-Host\n  19. Cadet Kelly (2002) (TV) .... Cadet Kelly Collins\n  20. Human Nature (2001) .... Young Lila Jute\n      ... aka Human Nature (France) (USA)\n  21. "Lizzie McGuire" (2001) TV Series .... Elizabeth Brooke "Lizzie" McGuire\n  22. "Chicago Hope"\n          - Cold Hearts (2000) TV Episode .... Jessie Seldon\n\n  23. The Soul Collector (1999/I) (TV) .... Ellie\n  24. Playing by Heart (1998) (uncredited) .... Extra\n  25. Casper Meets Wendy (1998) (TV) .... Wendy\n  26. True Women (1997) (TV) (uncredited) .... Extra\n\nFilmography as: Actress, Miscellaneous Crew, Herself, Archive Footage\n\nMiscellaneous Crew - filmography\n(2000s) (1990s)\n\n   1. "My Super Sweet 16" (2005) TV Series (singer: "Sweet Sixteen")\n   2. Toy Mountain Christmas Special (2004) (TV) (special thanks)\n   3. Raise Your Voice (2004) (music crew)\n   4. "Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County" (2004) TV Series (singer: "Come Clean")\n   5. A Cinderella Story (2004) (singer: "Come Clean, Now You Know, Crash World, The Girl Can Rock, Our Lips Are Sealed, Anywhere But Here")\n   6. Cheaper by the Dozen (2003) (music crew)\n   7. The Lizzie McGuire Movie (2003) (singer: "Why Not" and "What Dreams Are Made Of")\n   8. Right on Track (2003) (TV) (singer: "I Can't Wait") (uncredited)\n   9. The Santa Clause 2 (2002) (singer: "Santa Claus Lane")\n      ... aka SC2 (USA: promotional abbreviation)\n      ... aka Santa Clause 2 (UK: poster title)\n      ... aka The Santa Clause 2: The Mrs. Clause (USA)\n  10. "Lizzie McGuire" (2001) TV Series (singer: "I Can't Wait")\n\n  11. Disney Sing-Along-Songs: Circle of Life (1994) (V) (music crew)\n\nFilmography as: Actress, Miscellaneous Crew, Herself, Archive Footage\n\nHerself - filmography\n\n   1. 2005 American Music Awards (2005) (TV) .... Herself - Performer\n      ... aka The 33rd Annual American Music Awards (USA: series title)\n   2. "Total Request Live"\n      ... aka TRL (USA: promotional abbreviation)\n      ... aka Total Request with Carson Daly (USA)\n          - Episode dated 9 November 2005 (2005) TV Episode .... Herself
1041447
christina aguilera:-)
674467
It's Kelly Clarkson overall but only because she has multiple albums and has been at it longer. I predict that before too long that Carrie Underwood will become the most successful overall idol winner. Her debut album has sold over 3 million copies already, Kelly's debut album sold 2 million.
845677
Who is she?  The Hilary Duff of India?
920035
Kate Bush\nIan McCulloch\nMorrissey
54755
I would say that Hilary Duff cause i like how she sings. more the song "Wake Up" don't you?
687365
kelly clarkson has improved her voice a lot! i love her! but in AI season 5, definitely TayloR! he as a unique style!
1014692
To be fair, i like Hilary Duff, she is quite neat and keeps a good reputation in a dirty world she had grown up with...she used to be a kid and grew up to be a fine young lady ... so way to go! points for Hilary!!!\n\nOn the otherhand, Avril Lavigne is the rock chick persona we've grown with unfortunately, these days, since she begun dating, she found out that there is more to the world than skateboards and neck ties, fair enough, she learned that she is no longer a kid and is getting girly day by day...she even want to venture modelling and advertise hair products and all that girly stuff...\n\nBetween the two? I'd say BOTH \n\nthank you
794814
I think her name is Faye Wong- There was the same video with "Faye Wong- Bohemian Rhapsody." I watched her do a Kelly Clarkson song too. I think she's very good and I hope she coems to America and becomes famous because I would eb a huuugggeeeeeee fan, because SHE ROCKS!!
79151
Kelly Clarkson\nBut Carrie Underwood has sung Independence Woman unbelievably beautiful that I fell for it!
1078303
I think that hilary duff has very bad atitude.....so what people change......i think that hilary duff should learn to forgive..........i am a very big lindsay lohan fan.........and i am not saying this cuz i am fan of her......its cause i care for Lindsay's friendship and hilary duff's!
24174
Yes! Much better than Rubin or Fantasia! Her songs I can listen too and she has good range. Clay Aiken is not that bad but Carrie Underwood ranks with Kelly!
355303
everything about hilary duff is just average\nwhile lindsay lohan has a beautiful hair!
1084687
Avril Lavigne (she edgier and totally works the punk rock image, also I like her first two albums). I think Hilary is better suited as an actress, than a singer.