who thinks that Taylor Hicks should win American Idol?
604294
Taylor all the way.  Get the over-acting Katharine off of my television set.  She only wants to win by TRYING to be sexy.  That may appeal to the men but guys - get real - Taylor is the all-around, unique entertainer.  Thank you for your question.
659999
your right but whatever is left, i think between those two, Katherine must win...she's at least better than that Taylor person...he is a weirdo...
284808
I love Taylor Hicks...\n\nHis style is ol' skool and soulful. I also think they need to adjust the age of  american idol too.  Lots of people over 28 have tons of talent.\n\nMy family likes his name too.  My grandmothers name is Willa Mae Horsley Taylor Hicks.  So she is screaming for him to win.....
675584
Either Taylor or Katherine, but I think Katherine is going to win because she's much better than Taylor, althought he is good too!
255648
Taylor Hicks... he reminds me of Timmy off of South Park\nTIIIMMMMMYYYY!
287777
I totally agree with browneyedmaiden on the more-than-one american idol thing...but I have to say Chris Daughtry has the most chances of winning...but I'm still rooting for David to stay on the show tonight! :P
233541
Taylor Hicks or Lisa Tucker
1112478
Taylor is great He's unique, and totally deserves winning. \n\nKatharine's is ok. Her voice is nice but the music world has too many bubblegum pop female singers. I think Chris Daughtry should have taken Katharine's place in the top 2.
625684
Taylor Hicks won American Idol
1021179
I think Elliot Yamin should have won. He's humble and has a great voice. Yeah so he's not HOT like Chris , or crazy like Taylor Hicks, but look at Queen and Kiss they were not the best looking bands in the world but they still rocked.
460535
it's a close race, but i'd like to see chris daughtry win, but would be perfectly content if catherine m. or taylor hicks won too. i was really disappointed that they voted mendisa off so early on, she could really belt it out.
685772
As good as they both were, i think Taylor will be our next American Idol. Katherine is a great performer, but Taylor is an entertainer! I've not seen an entertainer like Taylor since Elvis Presley! With their own unique styles.. Am I the only one who sees a remarkable resemblance in Taylor and Elvis??  That should tell us all how great his potential in show business could be...  I just hope he handles it better than Elvis did in his later years...  Go Taylor...  SOUL PATROL!!!
692696
I have been voting for Elliott.  I think he sings better than Taylor, but Taylor obviously has a better personality and in the long run may be a better performer.  Taylor tries to perform for the crowd.
396890
Chris Daughtry...I've voted for him and Taylor Hicks over this season, because I think they're both more talented than any of the girls. Katharine McPhee is OK, but I think Chris appeals to a broader audience.
636398
Taylor is terrific fun and people just love him.\n\nKatherine may be adorable as all get out and have the better voice, but that won't matter. Not really. \n\nHe will win by a country mile.
661260
I would like Taylor to win.
580975
i think taylor deserved to win.. not only beacause he has a good voice.. is a weird dancer.. and he was there till the end.. but he seems to be a very down to earth guy, who wont let being in the public eye change the type of person he is.