Who thinks that Katherine McPhee will win American Idol?
484551
I DON'T. she suxs worse than my neice when teething. i want the top 3 to be paris, chris, and elliot. but personally when it cums down 2 it. the winner will be between elliot and chris.
691814
I think that Taylor Hicks will win however Katharine Mc Phee should. I think that Chris And Paris should have been the top 2 though
669589
i really don't know now...i really wanted Chris to win (he's from around these parts), so now that he's off, I don't really care who wins. it'll probably be Katherine, though. i can't imagine either of the other two winning...although, i like Taylor more than Elliot.
643370
I wouldn't say the season has been a waste since we saw a lot of talented singers.  However, if the purpose of American Idol is to find a talented singer,  I think they failed.  Mandissa was the female singer that was the strongest vocally.  For males, hands down Chris and Elliot were the best vocals.  I think Taylor has been successful in entertaining the crowd every week.  Katherine however, has had to stoop to using her appearance and sex appeal to remain in the competition.  Her sultry looks into the camera, low cut and skimpy attire, etc kept her in the competition.  How many times did we hear the judges comment on her appearance instead of her singing?  OUt fo teh remaining contestants..my vote is for Taylor.
676313
I really thought Chris would win before he was out, and since it is Taylor vs. "the Mcfever" i think taylor will lose. So your winner is....Kathrine Mcphee
652446
I'm with you. However, I think if Katherine had chosen to sing the way she did on Wednesday night, she could have won it. She has a really beautiful voice when she chooses to sing, yet most of the time she seems to want to sound like Mariah Carey or similar...yuck.\n\nTaylor is far more versatile in what he can sing and still sound great. He can do soft, fast, rock, R&B. This is why he was chosen over Chris, Elliot, or my other faves - Kellie & Bucky.  But, if Bucky or Kellie were to put out some music, I'd buy theirs, too.
186452
I think if a girl wins it will be Katharine \nIf a guy wins it will be Chris \nI am not that impressed with Paris, I know that some people are, but I don't get it.  I also think that Kevin should have gone before Gedeon.
659999
your right but whatever is left, i think between those two, Katherine must win...she's at least better than that Taylor person...he is a weirdo...
674467
It's Kelly Clarkson overall but only because she has multiple albums and has been at it longer. I predict that before too long that Carrie Underwood will become the most successful overall idol winner. Her debut album has sold over 3 million copies already, Kelly's debut album sold 2 million.
501483
Personally, I don't think he should have won...but he did and we'll just have to see if America voted correctly...Katherine was my favorite from the very beginning, but she too, will make out very well, it doesn't really matter who gets the title, except to the contestants, as you know, Clay Aiken is doing much better than Reuben...the only thing I will say is this...they should limit the times callers can vote, it has turned into more of a popularity contest than who is actually the better singer...
584910
chris and kat were always my favorite's and i was totally bummed when chris got voted off so now i am really rooting for kat but i already know that taylor is going to win it all (by a landslide) but second is good too-look at clay aiken, he did wonderful after american idol, so i'm sure she will do well too.
192471
Katharine, She's consistant and has a wonderfully pure voice.  Truly talented!  She's been my favorite since auditions.  I really think she'll win.
578712
I hope it's McPhee... she didn't earn a spot based on last night and I think Yamin out sang her... \n\nI hope Taylor wins, but tonight... I really honestly think McPhee deserves to go... her first song was horrible... the pace was bad, the lyrics were bad, her timing was bad... she was just really off...\n\nI just hope she doesn't get to stay cause she's cute... this show needs to be based mostly on talent and although she has that in abundance, she isn't continuing to improve like the other performers.  I think she has actually been off for the last several shows.
312601
the worst thing that could happen is. she could reveal that shes an uber strong alein from the plant orgiadsfk here to take over the Billboard charts and the world with her uber strong singing capabilities.  she will have a huge song battle with Taylor, Paris, and KAthrine McPhee. it will be very much like power rangers until the great round house kicker, Chuck Norris steps in defeats them all cause no one but wins american idol but chuck norris. Dont fear people because the chances of this happening are quite slime 1 in 5 odds i think.  GO KELLY!
630925
I can't stand Taylor...I know it.  Anyway, I hope Elliot wins.  I don't care for Katharine, she's boring and forgettable.  Doesn't seem sincere either.
555309
CHRIS ROCKS!!!! I HOPE HE WINS!!!!!!!!! I REALLY WANT HIM TO WIN, REALLY BAD!!!!!\n\nNobody left tonight yet. I hope Taylor or Elliott goes. But it'll probably be Katharine.\n\nREMEMBER EVERYBODY READING THIS: VOTE FOR CHRIS AT LEAST ONCE!!! PLEASE!!!
518766
I loved Chris, as most of America did, and thought he was guaranteed the win.  At this point, I really hope Taylor wins.  Katherine is an ok singer most of the time, but she is very inconsistent in her performances.  My friends at the karaoke pub usually do as well as she does, depending on how much they've had to drink:)  However, America is so wrapped up in looks and the "total package" that I think Kat will win because she looks the part.