Do you think Taylor Hicks should have won American Idol? And this is by voice i dont care if u like him more?
482585
No!  Chris got robbed!  Down with the corrupt network and their weasel puppet Ryan Seacrest!
553480
It was a tough decision, when it is the final two one of the idol has to win.  Katharine McPhee was a good singer. Everyone felt that Taylor is much more better than Katharine.  America felt that he should be the next American Idol because everyone liked him by his singing and personality.  I felt that Katharine should have deserve the title if she did win.  Since, Katharine is the runner up, she learned that she made it through the competition and she never gives up.  If I was in her shadow either I win or lose, all I care about that I succeed making it to the final.
396890
Chris Daughtry...I've voted for him and Taylor Hicks over this season, because I think they're both more talented than any of the girls. Katharine McPhee is OK, but I think Chris appeals to a broader audience.
528303
I DO!! Katherine rocks!! Taylor had a good stage presence and makes it exciting, but he has no talent!! anyone could go up there and do wat taylor did!! I definetley voted for Katherine. She was, like, the only talent they had this season.
668591
Totally agreed!I mean seriously,what do people see in him as a singer!I think that people probaly feel bad for him so they vote for him.I used to feel tha way but now I'm angry that he's there!If he's the next American Idol,than I say this year was a waste of time.
561710
Taylor is slightly better, but Chris by far should have won this...
718516
I think Taylor Hicks is a good singer and a great entertainer but I wish Elliot would have won.  He has the best voice!  Chris is awesome too.  I would have loved to see him win.  I don't like Katherine.  I think she kinda stuck up and full of herself.  \n\nWhat would happen though - if we voted for who should leave A.I. instead of who should stay?  I bet different people would be at the end.
546739
I hope she wins.  She and Taylor both have great voices, no doubt about that, but she is more of an "idol" type than he is.  He reminds me of a Karaoke singer.
1088281
I actually really liked Taylor, and liked him right from the early audition stage.  But then, I like soul.  So obviously I'm going to back a singer that sings something I like listening to.  Do I Make You Proud is diabolical though (but then, aren't all the original songs they give the winners) \n\nI also really like Chris, and think he is amazingly talented.  The trouble with Chris though, was that he was unwilling to compromise to appeal to a bigger audience.  Even when he was doing bands that a lot of people might know (like Creed for example) he picked more obscure tracks, instead of big hits.  Though I think it's very commendable to be true to yourself, you have to look at your forum.  You can't expect to win a show where the general public votes for you, if you're not willing to appeal to them.  If his attitude was "this is me, this is what I do, I'm not going to even bend" then he was following the wrong path to success.  I hope he does well in the future though.  \n\nI think Elliott is really talented, though I hate that style of music.  With the success of people like Michael Buble though, there's a lot of commercial success to have there.  He should do well. \n\nI always like Ace too.  I would have really liked to hear him do a Jamiroqui track.  I think he'd be very suited to it.\n\nI hated, could not stand, cringed every time she opened her mouth, Katharine.  Her moment of the season was standing there with her fake smile plastered on congratulating Taylor, as far as I'm concerned.
992241
I couldn't agree Any more, laughing machine. I think that Chris is amazing. Mandisa has that gospel-like voice. Heck I'm listing to both of them on American idol's website Right now.  Mandisa left early but she's better  than this year's winner, Taylor. Kat's not in the same league as Chris or mandisa. I think people are dumb that they're glad Taylor Won! When Chris was eliminated I wanted Elliott to win.
526514
I personally would have preferred Chris Daughtry to be the American Idol winner, but when it was down to Taylor and Katherine, I have to admit I wanted Taylor to ultimately win!  \n\nHe has charisma and a unique singing style that will help him establish himself in the pop industry. He definitely has his own sound, and you'd know who it is when you hear him singing.
524725
do you even watch american idol? what do you mean "who won", Paris got voted off, so Elliot, Kat, Taylor, and Chris would be the "winners".
585082
I think Chris's time was coming.  He's an amazing singer and he'll have a career no matter what but I was getting a little bored with him.  It's the same every week.  I think Katharine will take the win this year!
1066428
Does that really matter?  Seriously, while all of these "American Idol" people may, and I stress, may have talent, the fact remains that we are a society that focuses on the outer shell of a person.  Lots of women found him sexy, so they tend to vote on looks, outside of him getting massive support from the southern states.. as with Kat -- her voice may be good, her choice of songs really did not showcase her talent.  I only caught glimpses of the show, as I do not support these reality shows.\n\nJust remember that superficially, the better looking of the batch will always make the cut now matter how so-so their talent is.
719869
i'm really rooting on Taylor Hicks. I'm sooo happy he got though to the finale, but if Kat wins, i guess she deserves the spotlight just as much as Taylor or any of the contestants do.\n\nVOTE FOR TAYLOR!! \n*jumps up and down*
622567
i am soo mad! how could they do that? i think american idol is rigged. he had too many fans to be the bottom one. katherine should have been the one to go. but i think chris will get a record deal soon from someone else anyway. he has enough talent and doesnt need american idol to make that happen.
1006842
Yes, i think chris deserve to win more than taylor. Chris has a good quality voice, he is good looking too.\ntaylor is a complete entertainer, chris is a singer. kelly clarkson can't do that kinda dance, she has a beatiful voice though.\npersonally, i think american idol looking for a singer? or maybe from now on an idol should know how to dance too.