do you believe that donovan McNabb is a good quaterback?
475745
He has a strong arm and is very mobile in the pocket. Now that T.O. is gone McNabb could prove himself without T.O. taking all the credit, even though T.O. is a great receiver. Without a doubt, McNabb is a good quarterback leading the Eagles into a Super Bowl. I don't think, however, he is a great quarterback. For that he needs to win a couple Super Bowls like Joe Montana and Tom Brady. It's the same reason why Peyton Manning is not a great quarterback, he doesn't win the big games. Until then, both will be considered good, but not great.
448112
no. He is smart. Florida continues to recruit and bring in big time qbs. portis will transfer and play right away.
1135597
There have been many great QBs but I find it hard to go past Joe Montana.\nHis stats weren't the greatest but 4 Superbowl rings is pretty hard to argue with and he always found a way to win. He was also one of those rare individuals who had this weird light around him I have only seen on two or three people. (It is called charisma.)
880752
Simple answer is yes, because he has produced rather consistently this year.\nHe has had his bad games, but he has had more good games than bad, so he is not someone who will be a liability for your team
477572
I agree with the others in the respect that he's going to need some help from the line if he does come back another year - which I think he will.\n\nHe's very kid-like in spirit and has only known football all his life. The way he talks sounds as if it would be hard for him to sit at home and watch games right now. He won't be finished with professional football until experts generally agree that he can't compete.\n\nIt was hard for me to stop playing in high school. He's treated like a god in the NFL; walking away from the excitement, the swooning, the royal treatment and traveling the globe in the name of his favorite game might be too big of a step for him right now (as long as he can still move).
1052797
That's a tough one.  There are obviously a lot of questions about how much he will play and how effective he will be.  I think he would be a good high-cieling mid round pick, but I would not take him if I could get an established top-10 back.
78214
Yes, He earn the top spot for the worst clutch QB of all time.\n\nHe's let his teamates, coaches, and fans down.
217605
I would say that Stokely, just because of the QB he has throwing to him, also with Wayne and Harrison for the defense to focus on, he is a great third option, speed and hands, but without being on the colts he would not be half the receiver he is.
182705
let's take them apart and show u each part of them:\nQB Donovan McNabb If he is healthy and has Brian Westbrook workin, he'll be very good.\nRB Brian Westbrook  If healthy can become a pain in the a*s to the d-line of opponents\nO-Line If Tra Thomas is healthy and we cut our center and sign LeCharles Bentley, the Pro Bowl free agent center, our O-Line can be very good. Signing Hutchingson wont hurt either.\nTE L.J. Smith I think it will be useful to cut him and draft Vernon Davis or atleast sign Jeb Putzier.\nWR Reggie Brown  WR Greg Lewis we need to cut Greg lewis and sign Eric moulds or Isaac Bruce.\nor d-line is very good with Walker and Patterson in the middle and kearse and cole outside.\nI would cut Jones and Adams, our bad LB and sign witherspoon or Arrington. our secondary is real good too. so we dont got the super bowl yet, but we will be close.
1066044
Culpepper will definitly help the Dolphins.  He's still a good quarterback.  With Culpepper and Rickey Williams, with Saban as coach, with their defense they'll do well.
704933
John Beck, the QB, is a legitimate NFL prospect.  He has good build and arm strength which will find him drafted this year.  Maybe not too high but he's got a future in the NFL.\n\nTeam really did well and surprised me by being ranked.  Great workhorse team.
1084870
Hell yes!  I think hes great depsite a few downfalls.  Hes human and I couldnt be happier!  Jeb/Rudy in 08'
950512
i think ya'll will do pretty dang good... i'd be afraid of a running back that is 300 lbs...   i team like that... yall should run the wishbone
666902
ofcourse. he is one of the greatest players of all time. he has the reccord for most consecutive games played (and running!!!!! you also cant forget that last year, who the hell did they have!!! besides donald driver and brett, name one player that was not injured last year!!!!!!! also, you cant forget that even though his team sucked ass, he still lead the nfc in passing yards!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! he is a beast!!!!!!!!!!! I love him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
572255
I think he will. Seems to have more tools and more size and just the winning attitude. Nothing seems to rattle him he seems to  thrive on pressure. I think that the upside on him is he has the potential to be the greatest Q.B. of all time  but with rookies you never know all I know is if I had the first pick in the draft I would have taken him feast or famine because I would hate to have it said that I passed on him just in case he turns out to be the Michael Jordon of the N.F.L.
644984
Tiki Barber should do great. If you noticed he does not have great speed and he still put up amazing numbers. That's due to the fact that hes has great power and and field vision. I don't see him getting any weaker and you don't lose field vision. On top of that he fixed the fumbling problem. I just wish he was a little faster he would have more touchdowns. Hopefully he gets the rushing title.
165609
I think he will definitely make a place for himself in the footballing arena, not only is he young and energetic he is also very focussed and determined to do well and infact is gaining more by playing along side the greats in football. I definitely see him as an idol, 4 to 5 years down the line, for young guns gearing to go on the field.