Who would you choose - Peyton Manning or Eli Manning? Why?
494570
Peyton Manning so good one day he will be a coach he calls The shots now i seen last year where.\n\nTony was sending the defense in and Peyton said no and was waving his hands NO,NO,NO,NO, and stayed in the game and made a first down.\n\nThis QB can read this defense better than any QB in the league he will also on 4th down sap the ball when the defense is not ready because he is always ready to gain that extra yard.*
379761
Peyton Manning from Indianapolis on offense and Ed Reed from Baltimore on defense.
847095
who are you comparing these guys to?..Manning will go down in history as one the greats..Brady and McNabb (maybe) will likely join him in the hall of fame..outside them there isn't much..but little Manning and Palmer could be in the same breathe as them in a handful of years\n\nthese guys are still with their original teams..unless you count the draft of Eli as a charger..but remember Elway wasn't drafted by Denver
938337
I think it should be the Colts offensive line, not their QB. After all, they are the reason Manning has been doing so well. The others you have listed are great picks. \nI wish that most of these people would understand that the MVP is picked BEFORE the playoffs, not after the Super Bowl. \nMarino, B. Sanders and many others have gotten the MVP and have never gone to the Super Bowl.
884453
Even if you're not a COLTS fan, you gotta appreciate his talents as a QB. Can you imagine what life would be like if he ever got traded to another team? (I don't see that really happening, it's just a question.) Even if he did, he'd be a helluva QB where ever he played. Peyton for President!!  Ok, maybe not President, but Vice President.
51957
Colts vs Giants.  I would love to see the Manning brothers face off in the Super Bowl.
35236
i know the present hype is new england, but i just dont think when it comes right down to it anyone can handle peyton manning and the colts, im thinking indianapolis over seattle.
820892
Not a fan here!!  I am with you on the "I don't want to play for the Chargers" thing when he was drafted.  To me Philip Rivers is a much better QB than Eli and this is Rivers' first year of actually getting to play some, Eli's been starting since he was drafted.  It just made me think that Eli thinks he is something really special and can get his way just because of his last name.  I much rather watch Philip Rivers (I remember when he was at my favorite college team, NC State!).  Besides I am a die hard Dallas Cowboys fan and don't care for the Giants at all!!!
977797
I totally agree!!!!! Eli may be a young QB but he has alot of time to get better. He is awesome and I'm glad he isn't a cocky QB like others are..  I'm a huge Giants fan and I get sick of hearing ppl talkin crap about how he's not as good as his brother.  Peyton has a couple years on him and ppl need to realize that. Eli is much better than alot of QBs that have been playing for years..... I mean, look at Favre.. his record this season is horrible.  I have all the respect for Eli and think he's doin a great job!! He has his bad days, but what player doesn't? \n\n        GO GIANTS  GO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1183143
great question..all i can say is that peyton's team is closer...so i'll give the edge to him..
917331
no i wouldnt because it seems that manning has thrown alot more to wayne this year and seems that Eli has given up on throwing to shockey and is going more to burress so for this season no i would not
769495
I didn't want to be the devil's advocate on this one, but I will.  (My first choice would've been Tom Brady for his leadership skills, and modesty)  Just for fun, I'll go defense, since nobody has (yet anyway), and say Brian Urlacher.  If you saw him dictate the game against the Giants yesterday, you were able to see what kind of a leader and player he was.  Forever in my mind will be the fake field goal touchdown he scored against Washington a few years back.  Simply amazing.
112853
Ok, so let's think about this.  Peyton Manning is the quarterback.  When he was at Tennessee, he had an opportunity to beat Nebraska and win a National Championship.  He didn't get it done.\n\nHe has had many opportunities to win the big one in NFL, and he could not get it done.  He couldn't even win the Pro Bowl this year.  This is a quarterback that is so good, and the talent around him is so good, the Colts ought to be able to win in the Playoffs.  But Peyton chokes when there is something more at stake.\n\nForget the best quarterback never to win a Super Bowl (i.e. Dan Marino, Jim Kelly), how about best quarterback never to make it to the Super Bowl.
751809
Sorry dude but NEITHER!\n Peyton Manning is da man!
902345
Peyton Manning is a better quarterback.  If they Colts did not have Peyton Manning, they would be a very poor team.  He has got a laser/rocket arm, he is very smart, and he is basically the team's offensive coordinator.  Brady is a very good team and he is fortunate to play around great talent and has led them to many Super Bowls.  But when all is said in done Manning will have a few Super Bowl rings.
624776
manning plays football.... i don't know lots about the baseball teams but two players i like is johnny damon (didn't like him going to the yanks) and chipper jones
903229
peyton manning is a better qb and is probley not trying since they already made it to the playoffs so i would start brees