Jeff Garcia or Donovan Mcnabb?
468757
Jeff Garcia \n\nDont like McNabb this is personal i know Jeff is rusty but has McNabb won a Super Bowl he is overrated.
768250
Every QB  is better then Mcnabb now since hes out for season.\n\nTony Romo would be a good pick up and Joey Harrington if you need to replace him on a fantasy team.
604119
I say Jay Cutler because of where he is.  Denver consistently puts good teams on the field, and I think he has the chance to be the next John Elway for them.  They have great QB coaches and always a good running game and defense.  So that's my pick.
17866
Donovan McNabb is the leader of this team, and as long as he stays healthy and Andy Reid keeps the offense balanced, they should be about 10-6 and would probably lose in a divisional game. McNabb is better than some people think. Remember, McNabb did not have any good reciever to throw to for three straight years, and yet he got the Eagles to the NFC Championship game each time. If he does get a consistent receiver, they should go further, but I can't say how much due to the other competition in the NFL.
1091254
Jason Terry, or Al Harrington
816003
I think I'd play Garcia.  They are bound to be losing and he'll have to put the ball up.
354568
Wow, before I read the details, I had picked Barry Bonds and Kobe Bryant.  I would also like to add Terrill Owens for his selfishness.  Great Question!
907647
I think, go with Joey Harrington. Brad Johnson is okay, but is aging so you  never know if he'll be knocked out as well, Seneca is most likely going to be replaced by Hassleback, and Jeff Garcia would be my third choice.\n\nSo I say, go for Harrington, then Johnson, then Garcia, and only Wallace if you can't do any of the others.... Miami will surprise you I think...
383286
If you mean the US and that played in the US; it would be Donovan.  But if you meant a US player that played over seas; it would be McBride.
830926
Harrington v. Detroit...\nReasoning:\n\na.  Garcia can't throw long and the Eagles are built for that type of passing game.  [Garcia is NOT a very good QB...stats prove it as well as football instincts.]\nb.  Indy's defense is a good bit better than Detroit's.\nc.  Miami is not in "must win" mode like the Eagles.\nd.  Detroit's recent Thanksgiving record is abismal.\ne.  If Indy gets up by 2 TDs or more, the Eagles might pull Garcia and put in A.J. Feely for the same reasoning as I list in "a" above.\n\nGood luck!
725468
Yea, and as an Eagle fan, I don't know what to think. Is this the end of the McNabb era? I mean, come on, be realistic. Yesterday, Reid said in his post game news conference- 8-12 months recovery time. That means that next year, he would just be getting off the bench now, or maybe not even playing next year. Now, here comes the hard part. Where do you upgrade next year. If you lose out, and go 5-11, which would suck, do you draft a QB in the 1st round, just in case Donny Mac isn't fully recovered? An ACL tear is probably the worst injury in sports. In 3-4 months, you feel recovered, but you cannot cut or make those quick moves with your legs, and maybe he will never be able to again. Wow, just think of Donovan McNabb as a pocket-passer, like Trent Green or Drew Bledsoe. I know, I know, Bledsoe isn't playing anymore. But who is our Tony Romo? Is it Garcia, who threw 22 incomplete passes yesterday? Is it Feeley, who went 4-1in 2002? What about going after a free-agent QB? A trade in the off-season? Who knows, but the real question is, have we seen the last of Donovan  Jamal McNabb on the field in a Philadelphia Eagles jersey. These are questions Andy Reid has to answer RIGHT NOW, from his home in Villanova. Maybe Jay Wright can help him out a little.
347650
Warren Moon was 10 times better than both of them....but I would say McNabb is the better QB, although I think Vick is probably more athletic.
964560
I dont think that it really matters this week. Both defenses are pretty shaky! I personally would start McNabb.
63953
I would have to say Jim Brown is one of the best to have ever played the game....and Barry Sanders was close behind him....had he continued.
957586
That's too bad for the Eagles, they're done for the season without Mcnabb.  If Jeff Garcia's gonna start at QB for the rest of the year than they're seriously screwed.
967548
This year, I'd take Fletcher, he's outplaying both Urlacher and Lewis.  But in his prime, Lewis was better than either one of them, no contest.
758507
gore and westbrook.....no doubt....alexander hasnt' proven anything...and with out hutchinson on his line....he's not very productive....gore is a stud.....and the rams defense sucks.....westbrook lost mcnabb so he'll have more weight on his shoulders than ever...recieving the short throws cuz garcia has a weak arm....and running all over the colts terrible run defense