Who d you think is the best all- around QB ever, throughout his entire career, not just parts? John Elway!?!?
458829
The question is best "ALL-AROUND" so my answer is Dan Marino, Montana was good but he had a way better supporting system around him (Rice, Taylor, etc.) Dan Marino did what he did with no one.
392867
its got to be Walter Payton a.k.a sweetness, the way he ran the ball with power and finess he never ran out of bounds always right at the DB. not only was he a great athlete but he was a great man as well.
172458
Brady, Elway, and Nameth are known more for their Super Bowl victories.\n\nAikman, Young and Montana had SB titles AND great stats, but it is Joe Montana that has more recognition because ha has more Super Bowls than either of the other two, and his statistics are legendary.
880679
From what I have seen so far?  Jake the Joke.  And by so far I mean this far into his career.  He is a terrible quarterback.  When you have a QB like Rivers on the other team .  10 games into his NFL career, with much more poise and calmness.  The fumble at the end of tonights game can sum Jakes career up.  He repeatedly lets the team down at crucial points of the game.  Doesn't help that I am a huge Chargers fan, feeling the buzz from tonights big win in Denver.  GOOOO CHARGERSSSSS
861930
Absolutely!!!  I have never seen a player who analyzes and dissects a defense like he does!! I've been watching NFL football for 33 years, and he's THE (not one of the but THE) best Quarterback I have ever seen (Yes, I believe he is better then Elway, Marino, Montana, Farve, Simms, Aikman, and Young).
468757
Jeff Garcia \n\nDont like McNabb this is personal i know Jeff is rusty but has McNabb won a Super Bowl he is overrated.
958731
Tom Brady\nP.Manning\nCarson Palmer\nDonovan Mcnabb\nAnd heres a shocker.. Matt Hasselback\n\nTHose are the 5 best QBs in league i think. Vick i like, as well as Breese and Delhomme and E.Manning..but i htink those are the 5 best. Rex Grossman does not deserve to be mentioned with any of these guys i named.... Half a season does not make you one of the 5 or even ten best QBs in league.\n\n think you need to take OUT breese and put Mcnabb in there. Breese has not done the things Donovan has statistically. Besides, if the eagles had a running game and could kill the clock, they might actually be 7-0 lol... Mcnabb has carried them most of the year.\n\nMost of you people are bats**t. Rex Grossman, Phillip Rivers, Damon Huard? LOL these are guys you want to list in the 5 best QBs in the NFL LMAO! Wow. I guess 7 games makes you elite.... MORONS!!  I think i even saw a Tony Romo sumwhere on here LMAO omg! jeeeezzz ,, Marc Bulger has done more in his career than Damon Huard, Rex Grossman, Phillip Rivers and the immortal Tony Romo lol. sumtimes i wonder if sum of you people are being serious or messin around.
464796
I loved the Bears and still do thanks to one man......the refrigerator--just joking.  Walter Payton is the greatest running back of all time, and I always loved watching him as a kid.  It STILL breaks my heart that DITKA let the fridge score in the super bowl rather than giving it to SWEETNESS....but did you ever hear him complain?  Now if that would have been T.O. in that situation.....
20022
John Elway or Joe Montanna in my book.
524040
It's got to be Walter Payton a.k.a sweetness, the way he ran the ball with power and finess he never ran out of bounds always right at the DB. Not only was he a great athlete but he was a great man as well.
821686
Brett at 50 is still going to be one of the best in the game. They guy should stay as long as he wants. He's a three time MVP, a leader, and a football player until he dies. His arm is sharp, his mental awareness is still good. He just needs a line and a supportive running game. Look at John Elway, as his career got longer they took a lot of the pressure off of Elway by giving  him a great running game. That is not happening for Brett, he's still carrying the entire team. He's a little past his prime to be carrying a bunch of lazy players. And on top of it all his line is lucky to give him 2-3 seconds in the pocket. He's almost running like David Carr is in Houston. And his running game is just horrible! With a better team around him, Brett will be back, if not I'm sure he'll retire. But like I said, he's still one of the best in the game. Just like Junior Seau, Mark Brunell, and Orlando Pace. Old men who just have football in their blood - they are all still great, just a bit past their prime.
63953
I would have to say Jim Brown is one of the best to have ever played the game....and Barry Sanders was close behind him....had he continued.
1108495
Since when is Rex Grossman an established NFL QB?  Let's see him stay on the field for a full season first before we make any judgements as to his ability.  Their defense is good but it's not like their '85 team which truly was one of the best ever.  Given the weakness of the NFC North, however, they should repeat as division champs.
883414
Generally, Jim Brown is thought of as the best pure rusher ever.\nWalter Payton  is thought of as the best "all around back".  Though some people might say Thurman Thomas, and they might be right in doing so.\nBarry Sanders has the best moves of all time, though he had no O-line blocking for him.\nEmmitt Smith?  Well, he holds all the records because the guy just played the game forever, and he played at a high level for a long time.  Benchmark for longevity.\n\nFor right now, L.T. is the best and I would compare him to Payton or Thomas, though he has moves like Sanders.  L.T. can do it all, and there really isn't anyone playing right now that compares.\n\nAlexander is great, but he's not as versatile as L.T.  I would definitely put him ahead of L.J. however.  Alexander is a beast in the red-zone and runs with more power than L.J.\n\nAnd as far as how L.T. and Alexander compare historically?  Can't really compare until their careers are over, though, L.T. has definitely set the pace that all RB's will be measured from to this point in his career.
73993
All time:  Bernie Kosar.  Even though he had no mobility whatsoever, he was once of the most intelligent QB's to ever play the game.  Plus, he was a great team player and led the Browns to some great wins in the 1980's.  He also has a great business sense and helped bring the Browns back to Cleveland.\n\nCurrently: Jake Delommne.  Even though he doesn't have the best physical skills.  He has a great swagger about him and knows what he can do to help his team win.  He never forces any plays and he will take the Panthers to the Super Bowl this year.
68377
Man, that's good and tough question.  I will have to give more than 1 but no more than 2.  Currently, Peyton Manning is the man.  He has character and values that keep him down to earth, unlike TO & Moss.  Also he got shafted with the heisman.  When he is done all NFL quarteback records maybe broken.  ALL TIME - I'd have to go with Barry Sanders.  He was not outspoken, never got into trouble, and always looked like he was having fun.  Not to mention that he was the best running back watch.
470484
No .. Brett Favre will go down as Top 10 QB for those reasons but he is completion % is lower and turnover ratio is higher than other elite level QB's. Plus Favre only one 1 SB. \n\nI think a lot of experts now consider Elway to be the best of all-time, considering he won 2 SB's in his last two seasons.  Some think Tom Brady has shot to be considered the best all-time given the fact that he has won 3 SB so early in his career and his play has improved each season.  \n\nMy Top Ten of All-Time:\n\n1. John Elway\n2. Joe Montana\n3. Dan Marino\n4. Steve Young\n5. Otto Graham\n6. John Unitas\n7. Roger Staubach\n8. Jim Kelly\n9. Brett Favre\n10. Warren Moon