Who thinks that it is funny that Alex Smith (TE) had more TD's then Alex Smith (QB)?
457771
That has to be one of the most embarrasing moments ever for a rookie. Number 2- Reggie Bush not being picked 1st.
742042
Joe Cool, Comeback Joe Montana, The Comeback Kid\n\nI hate to be the one to point it out, but Joe Montana won FOUR SBs, not three! (SB XVI, SB XIX, SB XXIII and SB XXIV) He won the MVP in THREE SBs. Joe NEVER threw an interception during ANY SB, EVER!\n\nSome of the younger generation who never saw Joe play simply look at statistics and argue about who was better, for the vast majority of those of us who lived through the Monana Legend, there is no discussion possible. For those who have witnessed Joe step up to the line with that easy smile on his face at his own 20 yard line with 1:20 left in a Conference Championship with the 49ers trailing, then move them down the field and score the game winner as easily as you or I walking to the front door........\n\nCris Collinsworth a wide receiver for the Cincinnati Bengals who lost twice in the SB to Montana may have said it best: \n\n"I don't want to call him a god, .......but he's not human either."\n\n(Yeah, absolutely, Greatest QB Ever, without doubt.)
772070
LMAO...the very first person to answer felt compelled to bring up Brady's 3 SB rings!  OMG....why do Pats fans use ttht as some kind of symbol of greatness?  TRENT DILFER AND DOUG WILLIAMS!  NUFF SAID!\n\nTo answer your question though...Brees is the better QB this season.
1029235
That would be my boy, Shaun Alexander, has about 10,000 yds in 6 yrs. 6 more yrs like that and he will be in the hunt for the leader honors.\n\nOr you could look at Manning, or some one  like T Green.\n\nCheck out the rankings on ESPN, and draw your own conclusions from there.
724903
This season it's Thomas Jones. 212 attempts (4th most in the league) with 1 fumble.\n\nI couldn't tell you historically but I can bet Emmitt Smith is real close.
1038600
Based on the system he has and the receivers / te and line he has to work with....you could easily make an argument for Michael Vick.  He's never (even during his probowl season) put up solid qb numbers (he made the probowl ONCE cus of his qb rating due to high td to int ratio) so far as passing yardage and td's are concerned.  \nAtlanta generally wins running the ball, but allowing for that most people are still at a loss to explain or understand why Michael Vick hasn't put up some solid numbers with what he has.\nAtlanta will give up on him within the next two years if he doesn't improve significantly.  I personally think Vick will turn things around soon, but he's running out of time.\n\nI would say Joey Harrington, but he isn't starting as of now....and neither is Boller.  I would also agree with the earlier Alex Smith statement if it wasn't for the fact that Alex Smith just doesn't have the supporting cast that Vick has.
763834
Yeah, that's pretty impressive. I think it's really interesting that he threw for more yards and TDs in his freshman year than in his senior year. The best stat there is the 5 picks, that's simply amazing.
781742
PHIL SIMMS? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH\nHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH\nAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. ok im done. ok now how hi were you when u wrote that response. Simms isnt even good enough to make the hall of fame. Phil simms was nothing more than a below avg qb who had the best ground game in the league and the best defense ever.o and the niners and if the niners and giants were so good in the early nineties how come the cowboys went to 4 straight nfc title games from 92 -95 and won 3 super bowls in that time? i dont even want to waste any more breath bout that ridiculous answer now as for my top three the argument usually is rings or stats u like stats u go with marino u like rings u go with montana however i think that since football is the ultamate team sport marino is better b/c if u put him on the best offense ever ( dallas of the early 90's) i think dallas would have won like 6 super bowls in 7 years not to anything away from aik he was great but marino is the best so its marino numero uno then probably montana and then i wuld have to say Elway
963527
Jim Brown was not only the greatest running back of all time, he was the greatest football player of all time, at any position.\n\nThe only "advantage" Payton has on Brown is raw numbers, but since you said you weren't looking for stats, the answer is Brown. In fact, the only thing Payton has on Brown IS his career total.\n\nBrown never missed a game in his NFL career, and he could have played a lot longer...he retired while he was still a star in the league, having won the MVP award in 1965, his final season.  Brown would rush for 1,000 yards when 1,000 yards actually meant something...it's ridiculous that a player only has to rush for  63 yards/game in order to get to 1,000 yards today, with a 16 game schedule.\n\nBrown was named the greatest player ever by Sporting News in both 1999 (the year of Payton's death) and 2002... \n\nIt's certainly no disgrace being the 2nd best running back after Jim Brown, which Payton may very well have been... (sorry, Emmit Smith is not close to either of them)\n\nBoth players dealt out at least as much punishment as they took when they ran the ball...both were practically impossible to bring down by one man, and they both hit the defenders very hard when they ran...neither of them ducked anybody...
923989
They have to keep Terrell Owens happy, even though he drops as many as he catches.  The Cowboys would be better off it they used the TEs more.\n\nFor more on the Cowboys and the NFL,  check this site out.  http://factipedia.com/sportsblogs/
913973
For JusticeManEsq:  Because LT has 14 TDs already this year, and Barber only has 1.  Tiki isn't even on the same level as Tomlinson.  Oh, and I'd bet my house that after this week Tomlinson will hold the league lead in rushing.\n\nAnd to answer the question, I think LT has a good shot at it, the Chargers are scoring some serious points this year, so anytime they're playing with a lead, we'll be seeing alot of LT.  He got off to a slow start, but he's still on pace to tie, so I'm gonna go with yes, he will break yet another record this year.\n\nUpdate:  Four more rushing TD's for Tomlinson today, totals so far:  16 rushing, 2 recieving, 1 passing.  He will break the record this year.
1023932
he is a complete back. not alot of backs can avg 100+ yrds u know. just cause one day they rush for 50 they still do alot of other things. im from san diego so u guys prolly think im just bragging but having LT for 4-5 yrs hes been doin alot wit so little. when u look at it hes made pro bowl when hes rushed for 13,000. the TD stand for its self cuz he can get it any way, run, pass, catch. the 2nd back to only rush for 1,000+ and recieve 100 passes and didnt go to da pro bowl. hes shifty, u cant compare him to Barry but for right now as it stands hes "complete"
905727
Are you kidding me its A.D all day. That man has mad skills and he will not be denied. When he hits pro watch out because he will be up there with the barry sanders, emmitt smith, walter payton and there is someone else you get the point.
543397
of course. i mean how bout steve smith. the best wr in the League. can you say most touchdowns last year, and he's only what 5'10-5'11. he is bomb. they had a good draft, and just wait, they going to win superbowl
644984
Tiki Barber should do great. If you noticed he does not have great speed and he still put up amazing numbers. That's due to the fact that hes has great power and and field vision. I don't see him getting any weaker and you don't lose field vision. On top of that he fixed the fumbling problem. I just wish he was a little faster he would have more touchdowns. Hopefully he gets the rushing title.
30768
Hands down Matt.  First of all Tim is not even starting for the Giants.  Secondly Matt has just lead his team to the NFC Championship game.  Matt has made the pro bowl, Tim never has.  Granted Tim is younger, but he has only started 5 games in his career, at this point in their careers Matt is, without a question, the better QB.
859245
WRs, RBs, and QBs place butts in the seats\nyour argument can go both ways.....\n\n\nif you watched the lions yesterday there was a play where all five linemen lost their matchups and kitna got sacked....\nbarry sanders earned most of his yards with average or below linemen  in his career.... he had many plays when he lost yards\nedgerrin james has the same problem in arizona\ngreat offensive linemen are a gem; ask the seahawhawks after hutchinson left. he makes an average of seven million....\nmel hein, an offensive lineman, was the MVP and led the the giants to the championship during the 1938 season.....\n\nit all comes down to who's not doing the job