Would Tiki Barber make the HOF if he retired tomorrow?
470273
definately not, most HOFrs have made the MVP and played 4 longer, he will, but he will have 2 play 4 longer
255183
Hands down Forrest Griffin, Rich Franklin in second then Chuck Liddel...Randy Coutoure would be in the list if he didn't go and freaking retire!
58498
He's not my favorite, but he's high on the list.  I love the running game and, being a Giants fan, I have to say that Tiki Barber is my favorite player.
632309
"Big Mac", a/k/a Mark McGwire, has been retired for a few years now. So I doubt it.
906108
Id ♥ to see him live... wud be excellent!!\n\nHis hair is amazing!!!
860636
After today, he should be!\n\nMaybe he is making sure that no one can/will ever beat his record!
83830
dunno, I would think he would be there for his old team. Bradshaw has been acting odd the past few years,its getting hard to like him since he retired.
768790
im not sure. but i thought that guy retired last week!!!
1078771
You probably won't get Tiki.  The top 5 is usually:\n\n1-Alexander\n2-Larry Johnson\n3-Tomlinson\n4-Portis/Barber\n5-Barber/Portis\n\nSo you are probably going to chose either Peyton Manning, Rudi Johnson, LaMont Jordan, Stephen Jackson or Edge.  Certainly not in that order but that's a pretty good range of players.
924927
If you are in a touchdown league you go with Kevin Jones.  I am in a league where yards don't count for much so I would take Kevin Jones over Tiki Barber.  However if yards are worth a lot then go with Tiki.  He has 715 yards rushing and 242 yards receiving, while Jones has 474 yards rushing and 266 yards receiving.  He does have the 4 rushing touchdowns and 1 receiving touchdown.  Just depends on how you get your fantasy points.
784137
I hope you noticed by now that Tiki Barber does not score tds.....brandon jacobs has almost every ny rushing td
828625
I hope not...The new thing in hip hop is to claim you are retiring then come back ... so probably not. \n\nI want him to take some time and get back to the roots of his talent. He has been putting out garbage lately.
521803
i don't see why not , he's has won on turf, dirt and in the slop\nhe has closing speed and a lot of heart and grit.\nhe has edgar prado to steer him to victory one of the top jockeys the world.(defeated smarty jones at belmont aboard birdstone).
280261
Doesn't matter...He'll always be a legend!!  I saw "8 Men Out".  That movie and others ("Field of Dreams") keep him legendary.  Hall of Fame or not...He'll never be forgotten.
1104394
He needs to retire whether he gets a ring or not
238337
The consensus seems to be the troika of Larry Johnson, LaDainian Tomlinson, and Shaun Alexander, and I'd be hard-pressed to squeeze anyone else in there. Tiki Barber had a fantastic year, but let's see if he can follow it up.
438563
Needs to retire? He hasnt played since 2000,You dudes need to know what your talking about before you start trying to help someone...lol