If U.S. citizens have the right to keep "illegal" immigrants out what rights do Native Americans have?
474578
well i am part Indian,and we  have the rights of all Americans and as stated above i can open a casino and we have Indian land that we govern and we (patrol) as we see fit. lol sorry \noh yeah we get to have lil cigarette stands too pretty cool hugh
163124
I suspect your question is rhetorical, and you know the answer is no.  Natural rights are what we have just for being human beings, such as mentioned in the Declaration of Independence, AMONG THESE (not all of them) are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.\n\nPrivileges are just that; something which is granted by an authority and can be taken away by that authority.  Name one privilege the U.S. government has granted to all citizens?  The "right" to vote is actually a privilege, since it can be taken away by the government, and is if you are convicted of a felony, if you swear allegiance to another country, probably other reasons.
985252
Native Americans being given back their lands.
1002238
Don't know.  It's rather a gray area.  They are here illegally, so I really have no idea what legal rights someone would have when they invade the country.  You might be best off if you turn them in to the authorities if you're worried about getting in trouble for keeping them.  Otherwise, you aren't doing much more than many businesses are doing, except that you aren't paying them anything & are whipping them.  If you pay them a couple of bucks a day & don't whip them, then you are about as legally liable as McDonald's, Wal-Mart, & all the many other businesses who knowingly evade taxes by hiring illegal immigrants instead of U.S. citizens.
1110728
give them their rights
643041
They have certain rights, just like Americans do when traveling or working in a foreign country, but naturally, illegal immigrants can't vote, can they.  I happen to think they should try to learn the language like my grandparents did when they came to the US.  When I lived in Germany, the first thing I did was take German lessons.  When I lived n Mexico I learned Spanish-- it's only right, don't you think?
676027
YOu answered your own question.\n\nNo one has the right to break our laws and to do something illegal.\n\nWithout control, any terrorist can learn Spanish and come over through Mexico. This is not a racial issue but a country taking a hard stance to enforce good laws.\n\nNoone can blame the poor Mexicans for trying to better their lives but it cannot go unchecked without damage to our country and the rest of us.
317956
Didn't they have HISTORY class where you went to school??!  I might remind you then, that our country technically is FOUNDED on immigration....if anyone deserves a free ride - it's the Native Americans from whom we stole their land!  I think the point is that they want the immigrants to actually get educated so we don't have just illegal immigrant bums wreaking havoc on the nation....seems logical anyway.
289870
as in we have a right to live in peace, without fear of being killed, harmed , toutured or imprisonet aginast our will, ot have our civil liberties violated .ect... who guanrantees it?\nwe do\nmy role in your right\nnoly to defend it if need be, otherwise you are free to puruse your life as you see fit
402603
No legal immigrants have more rights than those that break the law
327962
They have a right to leave and come here legally.  Illegals appear to have more rights and privileges than American citizens.
459655
If there are illegals at the rallies they should be arrested. I do not think illegals should have any rights other than humane treatment while they are under arrest.
451343
No one illegal have the right to do anything, you must go the proper channels to make anything legitimate for the proper protection of the law and from the Law Example, if someone force themselves into your home, what rights as an intruder do they have, unless you give them permission! Well it works also in the larger scale of things
579573
Being a citizen means you are not a temporary immigrant, visitor, or slave, and you have all the rights therein.
573595
Are you kidding me?  They have more rights than legal citizens.  They can get away with coming into the country illegally, skimming off of our welfare system and identity theft.  AND GET AWAY WITH IT
359499
This Is A NATION With LAWS-THAT IS The REALITY\nThis NATION Of LAWS Has BORDERS\nIt Dont MATTER HOW It Got To Be That Way\nTHAT Is The Way It Is\nThe INDIANs, The BUFFALOs, The WARs, The ESKIMOEs,\nIT DONT MATTER-Thats The WAY It IS\n\nYou Have The RIGHT To Be Here If \n1:You Were BORN Here\n2:You Take The Basic Nessesary Steps To Apply For A VISA And Then CITIZENSHIP And Are APPROVED\nTHAT Is The LAW In THIS NATION\nIF EITHER 1 or 2 Of The ABOVE Are In Fact TRUE\nThen You Are A CITIZEN Of This Nation\nAnd You Have A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT To Be Here\n\nTHATS IT-THATS ALL-There Are NO More Arguements About The RIGHT To Be Here In This NATION Of LAWS\n\nILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS Have No Constitutional Rights\n\nYou CANNOT "STEAL" The RIGHT To Be Here As You CANNOT STEAL ANY CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS\nIf You DO, You Are A FELON\nYouve BROKEN FEDERAL IMMIGRATION LAWS\nIf You VIOLATE The FEDERAL LAWS Of A NATION, You Are A CRIMINAL\n\nIts THAT SIMPLE \nIf You Break Into A House To Steal Property, That Is An ILLEGAL ACTION, With A PENALTY If You Are Caught \nIf You SNEAK Across The BORDER Of A NATION To STEAL The RIGHT To Be There, That Is An ILLEGAL ACTION, With A PENALTY If You Are Caught\n\nILLEGAL ALIENS in America are here only because they are GUILTY of CRIMINAL VIOLATION of our FEDERAL LAWS, . \nThey are Morally Culpable for Shoving Aside those who ADHERE To The LAW and enter these United States in Orderly and Legal Fashion.\n \nSince when do Criminals and Cheaters receive pride of place for the Blessings of Liberty, over those Honestly, earnestly and Faithfully seeking to become American Citizens?\nIs It FAIR To Those That Have Applied For Their Visas?And LEARNED The Language?And PASSED The REQUIRED MEDICAL EXAMINATIONS?? \n\nPresident Bush has called for a reasonable and civil debate over the issues of border security and immigration reform. But the American people understand there can be no responsible immigration reform UNTIL OUR BORDERS ARE SECURE. \n“Guest worker” amnesty programs ARE NOT a part of border security. Amnesty is not the answer. To grant amnesty to these trespassers is to say "You crossed our borders ILLEGALLY, You BROKE OUR LAWS and now we are REWARDING you with U.S. Citizenship -- Congratulations!" \n\nThis is unacceptable.\n\nAnd We CANNOT SELECTIVELY ENFORCE The Law\n\nPUSH HR 4437-NO AMNESTY\n\nDEPORT ALL ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS UPON DISCOVERY
573372
What parts of the Declaration of Independence or it's Amendments extend to illegals in this country?  \n\nFreedom of Speech?  \n\nSure.  Everyone has a right to freedom of speech but only if they're legal.  They also have a right to get legal and pay taxes just like I do.  They have a right to health benefits and to not be taken advantage of by big or small business owners but not if they're illegal.  Illegal means they're breaking the law.\n\nIf I were breaking the law, I'd be put in jail for it.  No question about that because that's America for you.  But you won't see me jumping the borders into Mexico then starting my own "freedom of speech" protest marches or demanding that the Mexican (or any other country) government take care of me.  DEMANDING it.  Not getting the same benefits and opportunities as any legal citizen?  Then just DEMAND it because they are "illegal".  They are shooting themselves in the foot by protesting.  \n\nLegal immigrants can protest all they want.  I'm sure they'd feel the same way if I went to their country and started my own protest marches.\n\nI'm a taxpayer.  You can call me whatever you want, but I'm still a taxpayer.