What is the real reason Madisa was booted off American Idol?
465385
Mandesa was kicked off because of her song choices the last two weeks . . . let's face it, they werent what people would buy or vote for.  It's okay though, she'll get a record deal, you havent seen the last of her!
573954
Part of the problem could be attributed to their fans, in combination with the dressing room rhetoric which reportedly went downhill during the finals of American Idol.  Split the dressing room right down the middle.  Wade Redden stopped talking altogether when Chris Daughtry was voted off.  Chara said he'd eat anyone who called in and voted for Tyler.  Alfredson still hasn't played at the same level since Clay Aiken, who he likens himself to, lost 3 years ago.  A sad state of affairs indeed.
393305
Agreed that Pickler is worse than the dumbest dumb blonde joke, and as hard as it is to think that its possible that it isn't fake, I wonder a little.  I mean, not knowing what calamari is?  Not knowing a minx?  Its bad.  As for why she's still around, its the same reason that Ace is still around.  Because people vote for who they like to look at, and not who sounds good.  I love McPhee, I love Chris, and at times I love Taylor.  But I thought it was horrible that Mandisa got voted off before Bucky.  It proves that the look is more important than the voice.
567040
omg i so think that is unfair.  Kathrine so should have gone out. she is soo robotic (if you know what i mean)  Chris is the best evr to be on American idol!
451967
I wouldn't say happy! She seemed like such a sweet person! Anyone who is that comfortable with herself deserves kudos! I know she all but sucked the past couple of weeks and probably deserved the boot--but I don't get why people "HATE" her and was "HAPPY" to see her go (especially before Paris..I don't see anything special there)! I just think it's a tad ridiculous to spend so much time hating someone on television you've never even met; let alone someone on a REALITY show...
284405
Because she kissed Bahbah Wahwah's butt to be on. I say not only bring back The Man Show but make the first new episode where they take the current women on The View and let Debbie(the cute one Bahbah Wahwah and Skar Scones got fired) whats her name burn all of them at the stake
914789
they merged. Then Yul showed Sundra and Ozzy the immunity idol that he had. And convinced Jonathatn to join up with them so they would have a majority. Ozzy won the individual immunity challenge. Then those 5 which are Sundra,Becky,Yul,Ozzy and Jonathan voted off Nate because Jonathan did'nt trust him or something corny like that
907123
britneys break up was more main stream because she's more main stream right now!! also, whitney is older and been with bobby for 14 yrs,everyone knew they shouldnt have been together so their break up is no surprise...everyone is just glad she finally came to her senses..brandi was never really married in the first place!!! why reach out to something that was a lie? and whitney is more private. although her business has been splattered all over t.v., she is still a more private person...and who better to reach out to whitney than clive davis? she is supposedly back with him to get her music career back on track. i just pray she can "bring it" like she used to...the last time i heard her sing,she didnt sound too good
342223
on american idol? or what if you meant american idol it was mandisa
425221
it was already on where i live. MANDISA GOT VOTED OFF!!! and elliot and paris were in the bottome three too... what a sin! ace and bucky are sucky!! but at least they're doing queen music next week so theyll both do bad and get voted off one.
1074959
so early??? I don't think so. Everyone left in the show were better than her. She care more about fashion and new hairstyles than singing... I think she went too far. Mandisa was better and she did go home so early on AI.
615036
I think paris will be kicked off and I will stop watching if Elliot is kicked off. For the sake of getting and " orginal new fresh face" American Idol Katharine needs to go..she is typical of what's currently in the market and her performances have been  getting worse not better.
504035
Totally heart broken and completely pissed! His fans majorly failed him and you could see it in his reaction. He is an awesome singer not to mention HOT. He doesn't sway from the music he believes in. That says a lot about him. We haven't seen the last of him. He's gonna be around for a long time! Nobody's loss but American Idol's!
479393
I dont believe it was prejudice.The contestants need to remember that they need to do well EVERY WEEK not just certain ones that fit their catagory(as hard as that is).I had no problem with Mandisa,but i dont believe she chose a song that was good for her in that catagory and she didnt perform the song she did choose that great therefore was voted off.
885988
She is quiting for personal reasons, I heard somethin about personal issues with Matt Hardy and Edge and something about a music career.\n \nCant be for the contract because she is  one of the most famous divas, and manly, she is the wwe women's champ they would renew the contract...\nI dont like her, but im not happy that she's living... I WAS HAPPY but, when i saw the photos, she was crying... so i wake up, wwe is a fake, i dont like her in wwe, but in real life she isnt so arogant... and of course, she is sad with this all thing\n\nGood luck for her! ;)
605133
Mario Vasquez is the guy who dropped out and then Nikko Smith took his place there has been several mishaps with AI voting,just about every season I believe, from wrong numbers given to just plain controversy.
605548
I HONESTLY THINK THAT THIS SHOW, JUST MIGHT BE RIGGED! Because last nights show...Kathrine was the one that was supposed to go, but right at the last minute, the announcer was told to pick CHRIS. It was so very obvious. How "CRUEL"and How very "HOUND-DOG-GISH"! Wouldn't you all agree? I am very "MAD" about how they tricked CHRIS. He is very, very, very good! And he did not deserve that at all. "BOO.....AMERICAN IDOL"!!!! BY THE WAY, ELLIOTT? well what can I say....YOU ARE! ALWAYS HAVE BEEN! AND WILL BE ....THE NEXT AMERICA'S FANTASTIC, GLORIOUS VOICE, "GOD" LOVING IDOL...AMEN!!! AND MAY GOD BLESS AND BE WITH EACH AND EVERYONE ONE OF YOU!  GOOD LUCK!