do u think taylor should leave on American idol?
455430
He should go pretty soon, but he won't because he is an entertainer. He is an amazing singer yes, but he can not hold up with the others in my opinion.
595071
I love the show even though I live in the UK. Chris was my favourite and it was sad to see him voted off. I think that Katherine will win as she has a very strong voice, providing that she chose the right songs. The wrong choice of song could lose her the contest.Taylor seems a nice lad but I think he comes across too much like a partying karaoke singer.
643370
I wouldn't say the season has been a waste since we saw a lot of talented singers.  However, if the purpose of American Idol is to find a talented singer,  I think they failed.  Mandissa was the female singer that was the strongest vocally.  For males, hands down Chris and Elliot were the best vocals.  I think Taylor has been successful in entertaining the crowd every week.  Katherine however, has had to stoop to using her appearance and sex appeal to remain in the competition.  Her sultry looks into the camera, low cut and skimpy attire, etc kept her in the competition.  How many times did we hear the judges comment on her appearance instead of her singing?  OUt fo teh remaining contestants..my vote is for Taylor.
565001
I know that usually Taylor or Paris would be the pick, but Taylor did a little better than Paris last night.  \nI hate to think it, but maybe it is Paris' turn to leave.
579421
I hope Taylor wins. I was so mad that Chris was booted off the show it should of been the girl she didn't sing worth a crap. \nPeople should vote on the singing not on the looks because its the singing that going to sell the records not the looks. \nChris really was a good singer you put a good band behind him and he well make some good records.
656866
I personally have been a fan of Taylor Hicks since way back.He hasnt changed who he is,and Katherine(no offense to any katherine fans) is using her looks too much.Shes went from sweet and nice to kind of,sleezy.I mean,i liked her at first she was very talented and she still is.Her actions just proves she is changing it up too much,just to sway votes and win.Taylor himself hasnt changed.His auditions each week are consistant and are getting better.He isnt like any previous idol winner or contestant and i believe he deserves to win.We shall see who wins,good luck to them both!
630925
I can't stand Taylor...I know it.  Anyway, I hope Elliot wins.  I don't care for Katharine, she's boring and forgettable.  Doesn't seem sincere either.
658804
That song isn't be best, and definatly not the best choice if you want to win idol. Plus her first performance like her performance last week was poor.
594813
yes she should have been voted off way before Elliot
636398
Taylor is terrific fun and people just love him.\n\nKatherine may be adorable as all get out and have the better voice, but that won't matter. Not really. \n\nHe will win by a country mile.
658017
I think Taylor will win, he reminds me of Joe Cocker.. He is not only a good singer but he is a performer as well, I wish him luck!!\n\nP.S. I wonder if the guy who said WHO CARES knows how immature he sounds.. omg, like, grow up. lol
431924
Chris was the best.  The bottom three SHOULD be Kellie (although I love her and want her to stay), Paris and Katherine.\n\nI can't guess who it will be though.  Kellie seems to have enough fans to keep her out of trouble.  Taylor could end up there, but I don't think he has been yet, so he may be safe.  Katherine annoys enough people that she's a safe bet.
524127
Taylor Hicks will be the next "American Idol." Taylor has already shown that he is successful. I think that Katherine should have been voted off last week instead of Elliot. Katherine has a lovely voice, but she sings like too many others singers.  Taylors voice is unique and different. If you are not a member of the "Soul Patrol" just watch the American Idol tonight. You will see why he has so many in the "Soul Patrol."
560827
I pick Taylor from the minute that I saw his audition.  When Simon told him if his hair was a different color, He would move him to the next round. I honestley didn't think he would go all the way at first, but when he started improving himeself, I new he would. Kat should have been gone a long time ago, Actually my opinion, chris should have been standing up there beside Taylor, But... Go Taylor Go. Soul Patrol
583244
Because this competition is fixed. There's no reason that Chris should have gone home when Katherine forgot her lyrics. How the hell else could something like that happen unless the show is fixed? I agree, Chris Daughtry was my favourite too. I was hoping it would be between him and Taylor Hicks. I was SURE that either Elliot Yamin, or Katherine McPhee was going to go home last night. Now that Chris is gone I'm not sure I even want to watch it anymore. He was set up. \n\nC'mon think about it. The show before last was an obvious example of how corrupt this competition is...when Paula CRIED for Elliot, and yet Katherine was DOGGED by all 3 judges when she did REALLY WELL that night, and didn't get recognition till the next day AFTER votes were made. That's just ludicrous! I don't think I'll be watching anymore seasons of this show in the future.
561533
This week's installment aired on Tuesday night, when Taylor Hicks, Katherine McPhee, and Elliot Yamin each performed three songs.\n\nOn Wednesday night it was revealed that Elliot Yamin was eliminated. \n\nThey did a fancy new thing where they showed that each of the three received votes around 33%. It was only a matter of .20% or so separating the frontrunner from Elliot.\n\nOn Wednesday next week the winner of American Idol Season 5 should be reviled. Oops, I meant "revealed." Or maybe I did mean "reviled." I wanted Chris Daughtry to win...
661260
I would like Taylor to win.