Dont you think its wrong to sign nuke deal with India on one hand and ask Iran not to go nuke.?
460562
We never encouraged India. In fact we are not especially happy that they have nuclear technology. However here is the difference. \n\nIndia, a thriving Democracy. A relitively free society. A responsible nation that would not use nuclear weapons without dire provocation. A nation that can be mostly trusted not to sell these weapons or through negligence allow these weapons or materials to make them fall into terrorist hands. \n\nIran, making a first stab at Democracy but suffered a severe set back in last elections. A very regimented society bereft of many freedoms Westerners take for granted.  An unstable government leads a nation with a president who actually claims the Holocust never happened. As bad as Western leaders have been in the last 40 years there have been none that were openly delusional like this.  Iran has ties with terrorist organizations and it's Gov is riddled with terrorist sympathizers. It is almost certain that nuclear weapons in Iran or even the materials to make them if the weapons did not exist would fall into the hands of terrorists. Even if the Gov honestly attempted to stop it, there is too much support for terrorism in segments of Iranian society to stop such theft. \n\nIn short, India has the bomb life goes on as always. Iran has the bomb or even the materials needed for one, at least one major city will be blown up killing at least 2 million people. After which a war would start that would likely erase man from the face of the planet. \n\nIslamics somehow thing they can use biological and nuclear weapons and not see their own children if not the entire race wiped off the planet. Why this I would love to hear. More so I would really like to know why ANY Islamic could possibly believe it was safe for any person in the world if most Islamic nations posessed biological or nuclear weapons.
409401
Iran has every right to enrich uranium for energy purposes because it is a member of the N-NPT (Nuclear non-perliferation Treaty). This treaty guarantees this right. \n\nIronically, Bush told India, who has refused to sign the N-NPT, they could enrich uranium. This creates a very complicated dilema.\n\nAdditionally, if you examine Iran's history, Iran has no history of aggression but rather of defense. Iran has also held to all regulations of the NPT to include full access to all uranium enrichment sites to all U.N. inspectors. \n\nThere is no evidence to support restricting Iran's right to enrich uranium in order to obtain nuclear energy. Also, keep in mind, Israel has nuclear weapons.
608260
THE FOLLOWING CAN BE SAID AS THE REASONS FOR THAT :-\n\n1. THE U.S NOW HAS ADOPTED AN INDIA CENTRIC POLICY BY SIGNING THE NUCLEAR DEAL WITH INDIA .IT WANTS INDIA TO STAND UP AGAINST CHINA WHICH IS ALSO A RIVAL OF INDIA .\n\n2. ALSO INDIA IS NOW FAST BECOMING A MAJOR ECONOMIC AND MILITARY POWER .SO IT NEEDS INDIA TO BE ITS ALLY IN THE FUTURE .\n\n3. INFACT IT IS NOW SILENTLY ALLOWING INDIA TO ACT OF ITS OWN AFTER INDIA VOTED AGAINST IRAN IN U.N COUNCIL.\n\n4. ALSO THE U.S IS SURE THAT THE PROPOSED GAS PIPE LINE IS NOT A EASY JOB - SINCE IT INVOLVES 3 COUNTRIES INCLUDING ARCH RIVALS INDIA AND PAKISTAN . ALSO INDIA VOTED AGAINST IRAN . SO ITS NOT EASY FOR A 3 NATION AGREEMENT .\n\n5. YESTERDAY IRAN HAS DECLARED THAT IT CANNOT SUPPLY THE GAS TO INDIA .
545838
You asking if i think it is OK for a country to procure nuclear technology to be used to produce electricity? If that is your question then my answer is yes. They have every right to do that.\nIf you are asking do I think Iran wants to build a nuclear weapon with that technology that they may use on Israel then I say perhaps.\nThe entire world needs to keep an eye on Iran not just the United States. With Iraq being in the state that it is right now it is just a land grab away from Iran.
435639
trust me....lots of new genaration of neplease hate india..coz time and again it tries to interfair in our poltics through Sughali Sandhi (treaty after anglo-nepal war)\n  Honestly, nobody like the country which interfares in ur country....if i cound i would say..get the hell out of our way.\n  If india cannot help..it should not come in between our home issue and at least not give dublicate weapons as INSAS (which didnt work, and almost 100 army were killed by moist).
1187781
The way developments are taking place, I think it would be much earlier.\n\nDidnt you hear the news yesterday? India and US have signed a Nuclear deal for generation of enery\n\n\nCheers !!!
612648
Again, there's no point in even addressing what political issues you're implying, because it's a fact that Iran can not and will not set off a nuke here.  That would be considered an act of nuclear war, and we would retaliate with an unbelievable amount of nuclear firepower, which would squash Iran like a tiny bug under a giant boot.  You don't really want to enrage 300 million patriots backed by a trillion-dollar, apocalypse-bringing nuclear arsenal do you?
343089
Salaaam,I m an Indian,actually in this world nobody have the right to kill anyone,but because of being muslim,we ll have to face some problems,in every part of the world people are like that,only difference is somebody threatened to their life somebody less,anyway one who is in problem he has to face it,these are the tests from God.\n               From my present condition our congress govt denied support to u,and giving support to u.s,actually India was the close ally to Iran,but in future we ll not choose this govt to rule India,the other ways our dua and what ways we can help u insha alllah we ll help,and sorry from my side as an indian
632449
If it is peaceful nuclear energy then there would be no argument; but no body believes that it is purely for power needs.  this is also borne out by the fact they have never agreed to a system whereupon Russia would process the uranium and then deliver it to Iran for use in a nuclear reactor.  This would give them there power without the possibility of making a bomb, the have not accepted this as a alternative. They also refuse the inspections needed by the UN to confirm that it is only for power generation. So with both of these things in mind then it does not seem that they do want it just for peacefully power production.\n\nAs for India and Pakistan - go back a few years and you will find that the world community was not to happy with them either!  But neither government has a large tract record in sponsoring terrorism.
41523
Your country's "President" needs to be wiped off the face of this earth and all it's Mullahs stripped of their power and moolah. ;-)\n\nOtherwise, I think we should nuke Iran.
145148
I think so. Iran is wanting nuclear weapons. They should live under the same rules as everyone else.
488035
I would also have to agree.\nAlso it is presumbly part of a ploy in order to get Iran to operate in a way that is more acceptable to the West.
988732
No DEAL to US and Israel.Why US and Israel can use nuclear weapon not Iran.Iran can use nuclear weapon to protect their country from PIRATES(Israel and USA).\nBy the way,You must change "natas" to SATAN
351450
Not at all.  In military and atomic power India is not a puppet like Iraq or Afgan.  Even if the 100 million people walks over, the invation will come to end.  US will not take this kind of invation decision against India or China fearing the population these countries have.
48621
I think it is peacefull. they dont want to rich nuclear warhead. they just want to use it in generating electricity.\nwe all know that surely someday the oil of the earth will be finished. so after that how they can generating energy for them selves?\nlets be honest. they say : we dont need nuclear warhead. and they dont. lets think diffrent, if iran shouldnt have nuclear waehead so whay israel have a lot of them? why England and U.S have a lot of them? also pakistan and india?\nso if they have, why iran sholdnt have them?\ni mean if it is bad , it is bad for all, not for a special countries...
403966
As an Iranian I'm so ashamed on some treatments of my homeland government, but I hope at least one from White House read my message, suppose Brazil have the "Nuclear Knowledge" and US have not. What you will to do? This is the right of any country to increase its peaceful knowledge. Why in the middle east Israel, India, Pakistan have this technology? Which country has used the Nuclear Bomb? Iran.....? or ... World will not forget murders at Japan, Vietnam, Iraq, and so on... \nBut what I want to say, all American people, you must know, Iranians are opposed to crimes, it is ponderable in events of Iran history.\nHoping Mr. President Bush considers the various aspects of the task as more possible.
459575
You must have posted this just as I put my answer to a similar question! Anyhow, here's what I wrote:\nIran. 200 years and they have never attacked another foreign state. They are members of the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (Just like about 170 other countries). They are NOT Iraq, as in, they are well advanced industrially and sanctions won't mean much to them as they are also fairly self sufficient. \nThey HAVE NOT breached ANY of their responsibilities as sigintories of the NPT. They have cooperated with the IAEA and allowed UN inspectors to their facilities.\nHmmmm, The United States is also a member of the NPT and has breached its responsibilities under the treaty several times. The USA has USED the UN to go to war ineffectively no less than SIX times since WWII! That does not include political insurgencies and and the like... Oh, wait, I remember The US has been there and done that. Look at the last time the US messed around with Iran! \nIsrael is not even a signitor of the NPT! Yes folks, Israel is not even a member of the NPT and REFUSES to allow UN Weapons inspectors to monitor their nuclear capabilities. HUH? Yep, it's true... We bomb Iraq back to the stone-age for "Developing WMD without UN Monitoring" (WMD that never even existed) and all the while Israel has a KNOWN Stockpile of WMD and constantly refuses to co-operate with the UN and the IAEA!! Israel is a rogue state! But hey, Pakistan also has WMD and is also not party to the NPT. Weird... They are always wanting to kick their neighbours **** (India) and why aren't USA World Police F*** Yeah wading in there to "Create stability, in the Indian Sub-continent?" Me thinks someone is puppeteering with The USA!