Which Idols will or will not be able to sing a Rod Stewart song very well on American Idol this week?
413241
What I think will be good about this week and the "American Songbook" is that it should showcase the good voices and make the mediocre voices obvious.  I think Katherine would do very well with "Someone to Watch Over Me", Taylor could try "What a Wonderful World" or "As Time Goes By".  I am a bit nervous for Chris, but he did very well with his country song, so hopefully he will come through again. I think that Kellie may have a hard time, but she did very well with Queen, so who knows? Elliot should be in his element this week, so I expect him to do well.  He could do "The Way You Look Tonight" or "I Only Have Eyes for You".  Paris will also probably be fine, this seems like a type of music that will suit her.
425221
it was already on where i live. MANDISA GOT VOTED OFF!!! and elliot and paris were in the bottome three too... what a sin! ace and bucky are sucky!! but at least they're doing queen music next week so theyll both do bad and get voted off one.
579421
I hope Taylor wins. I was so mad that Chris was booted off the show it should of been the girl she didn't sing worth a crap. \nPeople should vote on the singing not on the looks because its the singing that going to sell the records not the looks. \nChris really was a good singer you put a good band behind him and he well make some good records.
43430
It will definitely be A-Rod.\nUnless Randy Johnson has an incredible performance throughout the year.
565918
I am an Elliott who strongly likes his singing. I'm positive that any label will want Elliott to be one of their\nsingers. Elliott will go to fame and greatness because he can sing unlike Taylor hicks. If at the beginning of the season if I had to make a final three I would say Elliott, Chris, And mandisa. Most likely a record label will just pick him up.
660192
my guess would be taylor unless all elliot fans start voting for kat (in that case then she might have a chance)\nhave you visited  officialsoulpatrol.com?  it's a great webiste for taylor fans
204683
i think it's gonna be either melissa (just for messing up the lyrics) kevin or bucky.\ni think if i had the choice i'd vote out melissa just because she screwed up the lyrics not once but twice, once while practicing and again on stage.\nthe top 12 needs to be extra careful about not only singing their best but picking the right song and forget about forgetting lyrics!\n("i'm surprised simon didn't lay it into her)
184020
Lisa Tucker, Kevin Covais and Bucky Covington\n\nUse http://www.idolonfox.com/ it's the official site, it would help!!
1042854
Dolly Parton\nRod Stewart\nAshlee Simpson\nMichael Jackson\nDiana Ross\nGrace Slick\nBarry Manilow\nLittle Richard\nAndy Williams
229908
---mcphee is good (why are we all refering to her as mcphee now?) but i don't think she has showed enough enthusiasm when she performs to develope a steady fan base. also, she needs a new stylist. her choice of clothing is always appaling. \n---bucky has not a chance except for a miracle. after all, there are only so many people on votefortheworst.com. \n---ace is also a very long long shot. he got too wrapped up in himself and forgot this is a singing competition and not a modeling competition.\n---chris has a lot of talent, but he doesnt' really show much versatiliy, like simon said. maybe he will show us something different with country week... but he does have a strong fanbase and he is talented...\n---kellie pickler is good but i think she relies more on her cute southern girl more than her vocals to carry her through... i don't know if that will be enough tto get her all the way...\n---paris is good, but when you look at all the other talent i don't think she is the best, but they have been showcaseing her from the beginning so she has a bigger fan base than some people.\n---elliot can sing, he is a good performer most of the time, but i don't know if that many people really remember him. i don't think he has a solid shot at winning but he should get pretty far.\n---taylor has a great voice, a unique style, and a unique personality, which makes for a great contestant on american idol... i don't know if he really WANTS to be the next american idol, though, because then they will try and force him into becoming some poppy kelly clarkson thing...\n---mandisa is very talented singer, has a very pretty face, and she has a vrey likeable personality. i think she has a very good chance at winning. \nso, all things considered, it will be mandisa, chris, and taylor in the top three... don't know which one will win though... only time will tell.
665695
People are voting tonight until 1 AM PST. I HOPE TAYLOR WINS!  VOTE FOR HIM!  1-866-IDOLS-02, -04 or -06!
219954
Here's my top three for American Idol this year:\n1)Elliott because he can sing well and yet he is just homely enough to get sympathy votes and make us feel good that we could advance his career and be the ones to discover his talent.\n2)Katherine because she is talented and beautiful and last night's being in the bottom three will surely humble her from being too prideful.\n3)Mandisa because she already had a career before she became a contestant.  She can sing with great power and is a beautiful role model.\n\nBucky and Kellie can only sing one way and they are not that good.  Randy will always be saying to them, "Dude for me that was just ariiight."  \n\nPaula loves to stand and dance any time she can.  She has the hots for Ace but tries to be encouraging to everyone who can entertain, like Taylor.
417499
My top 3 faves are McPhee, Pickler and Chris -- it's tough to predict the actual winner.  I think if McPhee can build a bigger fan base, she could have a good shot.  I think both Pickler and Chris are very one sided -- they only know how to sing one type of music -- they haven't shown much diversity.  McPhee's got the look and the talent.  It's obvious the judges like her and I think she's growing on America.  They're making her out to be a very American girl with an ideal family upbringing - very positive spin.  I think Pickler's naivety is going to start to bug people - it's cute, but only for so long.  I like Chris, but like I said, he only sings rock songs.
635902
Either Chris or Taylor.  Hopefully America won't blow this one.  It should be Taylor.  Chris is pretty good, but does he really expect America to buy that deep spiritual stare he does at the camera.  Taylor's strengths is his authenticy and passion for music.  Do you want someone who is trying to sell you something? Or do you want someone who is trying to show you something.
1134449
In honour of Rod Stewart:  \n**Maggie May**\nor\n*The Electric Bananas*\n(think I heard this on The Brady Bunch years ago...)\nor\n*Emergency Broadcast System*
491633
Soul Patrol all the way! I was hoping for a two boy final but sadly Elliot is gone.Really Katherine should have gone before Chris or Elliot!
127624
i have to pick alicia keys b/c she isnt all glamer queen even though she is very pretty.right now mariah carey is ahead of her in music but alica is just taking a break she had it big with unpluged for a while she's probably really tired.