Ken Griffey Jr. or Gary Sheffield?
369553
For HOF, Jr. might get more votes.  For fantasy now, Sheffield is hotter because he is at a better team and not injury prone.
1036741
He's a good hitter but not sure where the Yanks would put him. Cano is a better 2nd baseman. Short, third, left and Center are covered. Sheffield is in right and Giambi at first. Wouldn't mind seeing one or both of them move on but Soriano doesn't have the power needed to play those two spots.
350713
Johnny Damon (after Alex Rodriguez and Hideki Matsui).  All Yankees, of course!  Of course, I could be a little bias.....   ;)
1122415
NL - Jim Thome, 2003\nAL - Ken Griffey Jr., 1999
1152595
In the AL I'll say Ichiro Suzuki because he is the better all around player. DH players have never won the AL MVP so that would exclude (Hafner, Thome and Ortiz). \n\nIn the NL I'll say Albert Pujols but only if he returns from the DL. Otherwise, I'll say Lance Berkman (it will depend if he can carry the Astros to the playoffs).
450639
Right now probably. But it's close. I mean if it was bottom of the 9th bases loaded 2 outs I can't say for sure if I'd choose AP or Bonds. Steroids or not, good legs or not, Bonds is still the most dangerous hitter.
354568
Wow, before I read the details, I had picked Barry Bonds and Kobe Bryant.  I would also like to add Terrill Owens for his selfishness.  Great Question!
517327
Definitely Ray Robinson. I dont know where the Ali/Jones crap is coming from.
354209
i might say derek jeter
603037
I would choose francisco liriano... because hes a lefty who throws mid 90s and hes only 22 and i would say david wright... he has one of the best swings in baseball and hes a good defensive player... the cubs need a solid third baseman and a pitcher who can actually pitch in 30 games rather be hurt for 100...\nBTW im not a cubs... but i do like derrick lee... sacramento boy and im from sacramento...
185109
i think sheffield united
1131433
tough one. there is a tie between andy phillips and robinson cano. both have been doing great, but its not advertised. melky cabrera is close behind though. so i guess its your choice: phillips or cano
301690
deffinately martin gerber as he is much more solid in his angles and play on a night to night basis whereas emery tends to have a very good game and then a very weak game.
642354
a toss up between schilling and wakefield.they are both team players,got guts,and can kick butt against the best hitters around.(gimme a break,i'm a lifelong Boston fan.
593940
Personally, I would go with Mike Lowell. People have been talking lately about the Red Sox trying to upgrade second base. Loretta isn't a sure stay for the season, but is a decent player. If you look at Lowell's career stats, you are in awe. How could he have done so bad last year? Lowell is a better choicce and will start more games and get you more points. Go with Lowell!!
468413
Konerko or Derek Lee.  1B for 1B, with similar stats.  If you don't give a 1B, you will have too many.
453300
If you're just talking about hitting, I'd say you're right about Chipper.  As far as all around player, if I were starting a team tomorrow of switch hitters, the first player I'd have to choose would be Jason Varitek.  I think with the position he plays he's much more valuable to a team.