Who do you think is going home tonight on American Idol??? And Why do you think that?
375480
if my favorite,Chris gets voted off my next favorite would defintaly Kellie. Is awsome too!!!!!
565001
I know that usually Taylor or Paris would be the pick, but Taylor did a little better than Paris last night.  \nI hate to think it, but maybe it is Paris' turn to leave.
635615
WHAAAT? Chris left American idol? Geez, no. I am crazy bout that guy. he really has great talent. Am not one for hard core rock, but i have to give it to the guy, he really knows his stuff. Plus, he seems to be able to diversify if he puts his mind to it.\nHe shall be missed. But i guarantee we havent seen nor heard the last of him.
895148
Sadly to say it is Joey...Mario and Emmett go on. I thought for sure Emmett would get the boot this week...guess he has a lot of friends cause his dancing is 'walking' compared to Joey and Mario. Also instead of using up your points to ask this question...you should have gone right to questions asked...there are a slew of them here tonight asking the same thing. ;)
976941
Yeah, I thought CariDee was going home also.  So she couldn't speak the language they wanted her to, big freaking deal.  She still is one of the best ones on there.  I don't know who I think will go home.  Hopefully not one of the twins.
204683
i think it's gonna be either melissa (just for messing up the lyrics) kevin or bucky.\ni think if i had the choice i'd vote out melissa just because she screwed up the lyrics not once but twice, once while practicing and again on stage.\nthe top 12 needs to be extra careful about not only singing their best but picking the right song and forget about forgetting lyrics!\n("i'm surprised simon didn't lay it into her)
676599
I was shocked that the 2 people favored to win, Chris and Kat, were the two with the lowest votes. I didn't think either of them deserved to go home, although Kat was labeled as the poorest of the performers this week. This was the shocker like 2 seasons ago when the best 3 people were all in the bottom 3 at the same time and the best of the year went home...Fantasia was not the best that year. Unfortunately, Chris Daughtry went home today and Kat will follow if she doesn't get back to her regular singing capabilities. I think this week was a definite disadvantage for both Chris and Kat and a big bonus for Taylor. I have no idea why they pulled this kind of theme out at this point in the competition. It should have been when there were 8 or more singers left. Taylor would probably be gone if he hadn't had the advantage this week..it was his kind of music.
291319
Incredibly happy!  And I can't believe she thinks she is going to make tons of money with an album now.  She had the lowest number of votes even before they get to the Final 12.  I was SO hoping she would get kicked off after her cocky comment last night to Simon that it's a good thing America decides and not him.  I had accurately predicted it would be Brenna and Heather to leave tonight.
413241
What I think will be good about this week and the "American Songbook" is that it should showcase the good voices and make the mediocre voices obvious.  I think Katherine would do very well with "Someone to Watch Over Me", Taylor could try "What a Wonderful World" or "As Time Goes By".  I am a bit nervous for Chris, but he did very well with his country song, so hopefully he will come through again. I think that Kellie may have a hard time, but she did very well with Queen, so who knows? Elliot should be in his element this week, so I expect him to do well.  He could do "The Way You Look Tonight" or "I Only Have Eyes for You".  Paris will also probably be fine, this seems like a type of music that will suit her.
147031
Who will be going home won't be the ones i want to go home. \nFor ex - I think Becky O'Donahue and Will Makar should go home but won't because of popularity. \nok. my predictions: \n\nGirls: \n1. Stevie Scott\n2. Kinnik Sky  (she has a great voice, but i'm not sure how many will vote for her)\n-other person in bottom three: Becky O'Donahue\n\nGuys: \n1. Bobby Bennett\n2. Patrick Hall\n- other person in bottom three: David Radford
719546
Personally I thought Kelly Pickler was going to win but she got voted off. So now I think it will either be Chris Daughtery or Katherine McGee. I don't know how to spell her lats name sorry.
669589
i really don't know now...i really wanted Chris to win (he's from around these parts), so now that he's off, I don't really care who wins. it'll probably be Katherine, though. i can't imagine either of the other two winning...although, i like Taylor more than Elliot.
602556
No way, Taylor is too popular. I love Elliot but I think he will be next. All Paris' votes will likely go to Kat since she is the only woman left. I predict Taylor will be one of the last 2.
651034
Chris has already gotten an offer from Fuel, he has not accepted yet but I bet he will.\n\nBoth Tommy Mottola and Clive Davis pretty much said on Idol when they were on that they want to sign Katharine.\nShe could jump to a Kally Clarkson status.  And she should, shes amazing.\n\nI hope Elliott gets something bc hes so amazingly talented and also such a likeable sweet guy.\n\nI think Mandisa will also definitely get something out of this show, shes amazing.  Barry Manilow said to her when he was working with her "hey if this doesnt work out, I would hire you."\n\nKellie Pickler I think will be famous but not as a singer, E! will hire her and use her for her stupid personality to be some host of some E! show, but the whole premise will be Kellie looking stupid.\n\nAce I think will get something bc of his looks (he is totally cute)\n\nTaylor will get the Idol contract and I dont think he will become the next Kelly Clarkson, bc he is the type of guy who is great live bc of his onstage persona but not necessarily someone who you would buy his CD and not see the live antics.
973805
I hope Johnathon or Candice go next. I understand why they got rid of Brad, although I didn't like to see him go.\n\nLast weeks episode was so awesome, I cried...\n\nI hope those four kick some a s s again this week, they so deserved to win last week.\n\nI'm addicted too.
634253
My opinion on Katherine is we'll see her in Playboy/Hustler if she doesn't win Idol. She just wants to be seen. She should've been the one to go instead of Chris. She's fake & so full of herself.
808189
Ummmm...I think Dean and Matt may go (if not Matt I think Jason). I like Matt actually, in fact what's hard is I like them all now, even though originally I thought I'd hate David and Myleene! David is annoying but funny too and I actually think Myleene is a nice girl - I think they'll definitely be the last two with Gesty winning it (can't believe I'm this obsessed - AGAIN!) Argh!