who is better matt leinart or vince young or jay cutler?
368020
Vince Young- Strong Will, Athletic as hell.  \n           - Intelligent? Bad workout\n\nMatt Leinart- Intelligent, mobile enough for NFL,a winner\n            - Weak arm, can he win without any good players?\n\nJay Cutler- Mobile, Strong arm, Intelligent\n          - Small School, Hasn't seen many big games\n\nVince Young and Leinart both have a huge miss or hit value.  Either could be busts, but both have huge upsides.  Cutler is a combination of Young and Leinart, and from what I keep hearing he may be better than both.  Cutler will probably be the most consistent producer early in his career (his team will probably be slightly better) and he doesn't have as as much risk of being a bust.  Plus, he has more to prove than Young or Leinart.
634595
T-Mac is good but I like Vince better cuz T-Mac always looks like he just woke up and he will probably retire before he is 31 cuz of injuries.
21335
Vince Young. Best QB legs in the NCAA.
774970
I think Vince Young and the Titans can pull it together next year and give the Colts and Jaguars tough games next year. Since Vince Young is under going a season and with a season under his belt, he will be more seasoned next year.
326245
Reggie Bush, there's no doubt in my mind that he'll be a better pro. Vince Young is all hype, and doesn't have the proper delivery for a pro QB...that will need to be corrected. Bush reminds me an awful lot of Marshall Faulk (Rams), and I think he'll have just as successful a career. If Houston passes on him with the first pick, they'll be making a terrible mistake.
962842
bears no doubt.  miami's underrated tho with jason taylor.  He's crazy this year.
52911
Vince Young\n\nReggie- too much pressure\nLeinart- Vince Young's better than him
701780
Matt Leinart has the better matchup against a 24th ranked total defense of St. Louis, giving up an average of 344.1 yards a game. Carr has a bad matchup against the Oakland Raiders pass Defense, ranked first in the NFL, giving up only 156.5 yards a game.
312812
al davis wants sum excitment in oaktown, so vince young will be thier pick.
760642
EASY!!!!! with the "Greatest QB in CFB history! Vince Young was a better runner, but I think Troy Smith is a better passer and maybe even more poised. Smith is more NFL ready, but if you are talking college, then your'e right - Smith needs to win a title.\n\nI don't put too much stock in the Rose Bowl game. USC did give up like 50 pts to Fresno State, and their defense really couldn't stop anybody last year.
1075014
Cutler and Young will both be riding the bench this year. Leinart has a good chance to play if Warner get hurt or just plain sucks, both of which are good possibilities, but QB's rarely perform well in their first year. Bush may be freakishly talented, but he's going to see a limited number of carries this year. The ROY has got to be someone who is a starter for at least most of the season. On the offensive side, I would lean towards Joseph Addai of the Colts. Defensively, I'd lean towards A.J. Hawk or Bobby Carpenter.
167699
PEYTON MANNING IS BETTER.
527097
The Raiders passed on Leinhart because he didn't fit their system. Al Davis loves the down field passes that's why they have Randy Moss. Leinhart's arm strength is not his best attribute as he is more of a smart, accurate passer. That being said, the Raiders could of taken Jay Cutler and fit him into their system, but I suppose in the end they decided their horrible defense needed an upgrade, which it did.
678305
From what i know he is a solid kid 4 star athlete. He was the second best qb coming out of texas this year. I believe his name is jevan snead, he should get a chance to see what he can do now that vince young is gone. Too bad they didnt get my boy Matt Stafford.
249476
To answer this question, you have to ask "How is a QB judged?"  .  If it is by championships, then it is Montana.  If you judge by statistics, then Young is all-time leader in passing efficiency.  If you judge by leadership, it's hard to argue that there was a better motivator/leader than Montana.  If you judge by athleticism, Young's ability to run changed the game forever.\n\nI'm a HUGE Steve Young fan and he is probably my favorite player of all time, but I'd have to give the edge to Montana for this reason:  he was able to take 3 vastly different teams to the Superbowl 4 times.  The 81 Team was so much different than the 85 team, which was different than the 88-89 teams.  There was no Jerry Rice or John Taylor in 85 and no Roger Craig on the 81 squad.  Joe was the constant and to me, that's what makes him extraordinairy. When you look at the Steelers of the 70's, and the Cowboys of the 90's they did it with the same core group.  The 49ers of the 80's were truly led by the game's great all time QB.
422218
Vince Young's athletic ability and unusual throwing motion will make the difference for the team that picks him. He is too good to pass up.
344865
michael vick\nantwaan randle el