who was eliminatd from american idol tonight?
366713
Mandisa and I am still in shock... :(
495136
It was very shocking, however he did not have his best night.  Kat should have been booted, hoever she is too damn FINE!  So the votes went to her hot and sext look instead of Chris.  Elliot and Taylor have their fanbase.  It is a major top 3.  Major.  There is no way to know who will win.  I pick Elliot simply because he is the best singer.  Taylor however is the best performer, and Katherine sings the best for a female this year and I think she may be better than Carrie Underwood from last year.  It will be a thriller.....
637992
I voted the hell outta the phone. Taylor! I have been watching American Idol from Season 1!
501924
I think it will be Kat if the phone votes were based on performance and not on her popularity.  She is an awesome talent but wasn't at her best last night.  Elliot is by far NOT my favorite, but I think he did a great job - even the judges thought so.  I think every contestant will get a contract from somewhere.
658132
My dad was watching in, I didn't know it was American Idol, and I said turn that shit off that guy is horrible!!!! I can't believe he won!!!!!! Who would vote for him?
285843
Are you talking about American Idol?  No one gets kicked out until tonight.  If you are not talking about american idol I do not know.
352213
Yeah\nhe sings bad day, its on the end of American Idol.\nGo to yahoo music and search
645303
Happenings: \nAll the idols sang a song together, more clips of their Ford commercials were shown, and Paris and Elliott performed their songs "You Don't Have To Be Rich" and "On Broadway" again. \n\nBottom 2: Paris Bennett and Elliott Yamin\nVoted off: Paris Bennett
522072
My thoughts were exactly like yours.  Elliot has been my fave since the 1st time I heard him sing.  He's got such a sexy voice!  It reminds me of Marc Broussard and Donny Hathaway (his idol).  My favorite to win was always Chris though.  I figured since Bo came in 2nd last year, it was time for a rocker to win.  I was happily shocked when he got the boot. \nWhen I saw that Elliot was on Taylor's side, I knew he was safe (Taylor's never in the bottom).  I assumed Katharine would be going, but I wanted Chris to go b/c I figured that would give Elliot a much better chance of winning with Chris outa the picture.  I couldn't believe he left!!\n\nAs nerdy as this is, I had my own "vote-a-thon" for Elliot (30 times through) this week.  Next week I'll be doing even more.  How cool would it be if he actually one?
298972
It made me furious tonight. I cannot belive Gideon was voted off. that's outrageous!
642774
Chris went home because America doesn't know talent when they see or hear it. Now, i think Taylor or Elliot will get it and i can't stand neither one of them. Taylor jumps around like he forgot to take his ADD/ADHD meds and Elliot looks like a monkey with jacked up teeth. Kat would be my only other choice but, knowing america...she will get sent home too.
303239
As always, I totally agree with you on last night performances. Kellie surprised me (in a good way) I was worried that her cowgirl wouldn't let her rock it out, but I was happy to see that she did good. Katherine always good no matter what, I'm glad she changed her song. But I would like to see her do an upbeat one sooner or later. Elliott in my opinion did good last night too. Of course Chris was in his zone and rocked it! I ended up voting for all BUT ACE & BUCKY. Although some of my favorites did get more than one vote. I think Ace, Bucky and Paris will be in the bottom 3. I will be happy to see the results show and Ryan come out and say, "America voted and there was a tie for the two lowest votes. So we will be saying goodbye to BOTH contestants tonight. ACE & BUCKY!!!" YEAA! lol okay...okay..right? like that's gonna happen?! I'm sorry, but I just think those two have been on the show way longer than they deserve. "That's my story and I'm stickin' to it"
852360
Joey was voted off tonight.
541600
I watch American Idol and I am sick of the questions.  I was aggrivated last night becuase I had Tivo'd American Idol and people were chit chatting about who got kicked off and I hadn't even watched it yet.\n\nBut, you are right there is an A.I. question at least every 30 minutes.
142608
No, Stevie is my favorite and American Idol really sucks this season, might I add. Stevie and one of the bald dudes that sings like Bon Jovi are the two best on there. This season sucks hugely though.
529030
I'm still stunned... I think everyone was stunned... even Simon!..I expected an upset last night ... but the upset I expected was  mcphee going not Chris!!!!!!!! it left me feeling somewhat disgusted with the whole show!! he was robbed big time!!!!!!!!
578712
I hope it's McPhee... she didn't earn a spot based on last night and I think Yamin out sang her... \n\nI hope Taylor wins, but tonight... I really honestly think McPhee deserves to go... her first song was horrible... the pace was bad, the lyrics were bad, her timing was bad... she was just really off...\n\nI just hope she doesn't get to stay cause she's cute... this show needs to be based mostly on talent and although she has that in abundance, she isn't continuing to improve like the other performers.  I think she has actually been off for the last several shows.