Who is the best all-time qb, back-up qb, and now qb?
156521
Joe Montana\nSteve Deberg (check this guy out some time he played behind 5 HOFers)\nTom Brady.
797657
Chestor Taylor is the best back of that list...go with him
1002088
QB- Tie between Montana and Young\nRB- Sweetness, Walter Payton and Eric Dickerson (might be a stretch but great to watch)\nWR- The greatest player OF ALL TIME: Jerry Rice; Across from him: Steve Largent (so underappreciated) \nTE: Kellen Winslow \nDB/ST- Primetime\nSafety-Ronnie Lott\nLB- LT (scariest mofo to play the game)/Mike Singletary (what a leader)/Ray Ray Lewis (hate to see him in a dark alley)\nDE- Bruce Smith (Big and Fast) \n\nIn short, my favorite of all time is JERRY RICE
829172
Top 5 \n\n1) Chad Johnsons\n2) Randy Moss\n3) Terrel Owens\n4) Keyshawn Johnson\n5) Javon Walker
85805
Dan is the best QB ever.  People seem to forget that he was the only QB to have success without any semblance of a running game.  We also need to remember that also the dolphins defense didn't start to improve until jimmy Johnson became head coach, which wasn't until Dan's career was pretty much over.  So from 83-00, 17 years, Dan  carried his team to a Superbowl in his rookie season, a few AFC Championship games, and broke the TD record w/o having running game or defense to back him up.  As far as individual performances go, he is the best ever.
1135597
There have been many great QBs but I find it hard to go past Joe Montana.\nHis stats weren't the greatest but 4 Superbowl rings is pretty hard to argue with and he always found a way to win. He was also one of those rare individuals who had this weird light around him I have only seen on two or three people. (It is called charisma.)
793053
If you go by the number of  Super Bowl rings, then the answer is Tom Brady. If you go by stats, the answer is Peyton Manning.  Actually the most efficient quarterback in the NFL right now, based on the QB rating formula, is Tony Romo of the Cowboys, followed by  Manning. However, Romo has played fewer games this season\nthan Manning, so I would say the answer right now is Manning.
1047298
By your question being who is the most dedicated not who had the most success, I would first have to add as the qb most dedicated in the past and it would be Jim Plunkett of Oakland. He was like a Joey Harrington type of guy who was drafted high but never had the success he knew he could achieve. Cut by the 49ers after years of trying to make him prove himself. He then was hired by Al Davis and the Raiders, he Went on to be a SB MVP, and won 2 SB's for Oakland. He was a good example of "why you should never quit". He never gave up on his talent, and goals eventhough the NFL (not including the Raiders) did. \n\nIn todays NFL I'll have to choose as the most dedicated not most talented. I choose QB Steve McNair, he Gets injured almost in every game and still shows up when sunday comes. He doesnt let injuries catch up to him, as far as, Not quitting on his team and even though he hasn't put alot of big time numbers, he is another example of not quitting and being dedicated to the sport.
970655
there both good qb's, peyton obviously a little better then eli at this point in his career, but if your asking who's hotter then i have to go with none of the above.  I'm more into Urlacher personally.
933180
DA BEARS!\nas for the rest of the question I would be hard pressed to answer that question due to the many positions a team has and the great players in each one. If I can choose from the past it would be Walter Payton He was an outstanding player as well as a very nice guy. If I can only choose current players then I would have to go with Brian Urlacher Phenomenal player with the ability to will his team to victory, he is also a hell of a nice guy off the field.
30432
The answer to this question may be different in a few years, but John Elway is arguably one of the 5 best QB's to ever play the game. \n\nBig Ben is off to a great start, but needs to show he can do it over a longer period of time, plus get atleast one ring before he can be mentioned in the same breath as Elway.\n\nPlease note: I give this answer even though I hated John Elway.
604119
I say Jay Cutler because of where he is.  Denver consistently puts good teams on the field, and I think he has the chance to be the next John Elway for them.  They have great QB coaches and always a good running game and defense.  So that's my pick.
76259
Gotta go with Ben Roethlisberger on this one.  Eli comes from good stock, but so far Ben has proved he's got the skills.
458829
The question is best "ALL-AROUND" so my answer is Dan Marino, Montana was good but he had a way better supporting system around him (Rice, Taylor, etc.) Dan Marino did what he did with no one.
155885
It's gotta be Jerry Rice.  He pretty much had all the bases covered.  He owns pretty much every record (most by a RIDICULOUS amount), was integral in several Super Bowl victories, and on top of that he was a clutch player who always came through in desperate situations.  Aside from that he had a great work ethic and obvious loved the game, and oh yeah played it 20 years.
943920
Currently it is Brett Favre...but all-time at any position is Jim Marshall with 270 consecutive starts.
21335
Vince Young. Best QB legs in the NCAA.