am i the only one who wasnt happy with the american idol results thursday?
142608
No, Stevie is my favorite and American Idol really sucks this season, might I add. Stevie and one of the bald dudes that sings like Bon Jovi are the two best on there. This season sucks hugely though.
595071
I love the show even though I live in the UK. Chris was my favourite and it was sad to see him voted off. I think that Katherine will win as she has a very strong voice, providing that she chose the right songs. The wrong choice of song could lose her the contest.Taylor seems a nice lad but I think he comes across too much like a partying karaoke singer.
343861
I thought Katherine, Taylor, and Chris had the best performances. The rest sucked. I think Randy is on crack, Paula needs to get real, and Simon well sometimes he is honest but I don't always agree with him.
584817
I thought Chris would win the whole thing. But noooo. Too many people had to vote him off. Taylor is good, but he is nothing compared to Chris.
425221
it was already on where i live. MANDISA GOT VOTED OFF!!! and elliot and paris were in the bottome three too... what a sin! ace and bucky are sucky!! but at least they're doing queen music next week so theyll both do bad and get voted off one.
366498
First off, it's bound to happen with the more popular ones.  People get lazy- he's so good they think they don't have to vote.  Secondly, last night was not Chris's style of music.  He sang well, but it was nothing outstanding and was a little bit boring.  By no means should have been in the bottom three, but it wasn't his best performance.  At least this will probably wake up his fans into voting next week.
458955
it was the best for the IDOLS as far as songs choice except for Kelly  I really want her to leave as she is just too country...... & she is acting dumb but it will get her in the end........... I wish people would vote for voice talent not LOOKS......
535268
That was a low blow but it probably didn't violate the show's rules otherwise they would've been penalized.  I sure didn't like what they did but it's KARMA baby KARMA since they lost in the end anyway.  What goes around comes around so it didn't help them win.  I was so happy the hippies won!!!  I would've been pissed if the Frat boys won - all they cared about was hooking up with chicks.  The hippies were nice to everybody and respected other cultures in all the places they visited.  I'm happy they won.  Oh and I was thrilled when MoJo got kicked off - if that woman cried one more time - ugh!!!
557140
Chris is gone. But you know he will get a recording contract, so I don't really feel sorry for him. He got the exposure he needed. You know, the decision is based on the public votes, so evidently more people voted for the others...   that's the way it works. Tayor and Elliott really cranked it up this week. ....
611463
I agree with you all the way!! He does not have charisma as all. I am really shocked that he is still there and Chris is gone.. Chris should have been the American Idol with Taylor coming in second.. Now I hope that Taylor wins...\nLisa
640868
It's sad when anyone from the top five go home cause they're all so good in their own ways.  I wouldn't feel too sorry about Elliot going home cause I'm sure he'll get a record deal.  Anyway, the winner of these types of shows only has success for a short while and most of the time it's the losers who actually do better (excluding Kelly of course).
1088281
I actually really liked Taylor, and liked him right from the early audition stage.  But then, I like soul.  So obviously I'm going to back a singer that sings something I like listening to.  Do I Make You Proud is diabolical though (but then, aren't all the original songs they give the winners) \n\nI also really like Chris, and think he is amazingly talented.  The trouble with Chris though, was that he was unwilling to compromise to appeal to a bigger audience.  Even when he was doing bands that a lot of people might know (like Creed for example) he picked more obscure tracks, instead of big hits.  Though I think it's very commendable to be true to yourself, you have to look at your forum.  You can't expect to win a show where the general public votes for you, if you're not willing to appeal to them.  If his attitude was "this is me, this is what I do, I'm not going to even bend" then he was following the wrong path to success.  I hope he does well in the future though.  \n\nI think Elliott is really talented, though I hate that style of music.  With the success of people like Michael Buble though, there's a lot of commercial success to have there.  He should do well. \n\nI always like Ace too.  I would have really liked to hear him do a Jamiroqui track.  I think he'd be very suited to it.\n\nI hated, could not stand, cringed every time she opened her mouth, Katharine.  Her moment of the season was standing there with her fake smile plastered on congratulating Taylor, as far as I'm concerned.
605548
I HONESTLY THINK THAT THIS SHOW, JUST MIGHT BE RIGGED! Because last nights show...Kathrine was the one that was supposed to go, but right at the last minute, the announcer was told to pick CHRIS. It was so very obvious. How "CRUEL"and How very "HOUND-DOG-GISH"! Wouldn't you all agree? I am very "MAD" about how they tricked CHRIS. He is very, very, very good! And he did not deserve that at all. "BOO.....AMERICAN IDOL"!!!! BY THE WAY, ELLIOTT? well what can I say....YOU ARE! ALWAYS HAVE BEEN! AND WILL BE ....THE NEXT AMERICA'S FANTASTIC, GLORIOUS VOICE, "GOD" LOVING IDOL...AMEN!!! AND MAY GOD BLESS AND BE WITH EACH AND EVERYONE ONE OF YOU!  GOOD LUCK!
555501
I dont think the right right person won. I think Katherine should have won. She has an amazing voice especially when she sang "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" and "My Destiny".
542694
None they all suck! I wanted Chris to win but now that he got voted off the hell with the rest of them.!
754867
In terms of the way he decided, Simon was right, Eton Road can improve significantly (Especially if Anthony knocks off all this out of tune metzo soprano rubbish, he doesn't need to, he has a lovely voice), and though performance based Robert was faultless, he has probably reached the top of his game.\n\nHowever, IMO neither should have been in the bottom two, it should have been Ray and The McDonald Brothers...\n\nI love Ray, but his performance tonight was poor, he was shouting rather than singing. The McDonald Brothers were simply awful, I would rather listen to the version of that song sang by Bill Nighy in Love Actually.\n\nWhat is wrong with you Scottish (bit of a generalisation there and I apologise to those who did not vote for them) but are you all tone deaf? I know Simon is rude about them and that can make someone proud of their heritage, indignant, but those boys are exactly what they are "Wedding Singers" and will never be anything more.. There voices are fair but they have no charisma, at least Ray has oodles of that.\n\nI would love to see the results of the phone votes published, and I would hate to have the phone bills in the next quarter of those dedicated few that just keep on voting to keep the McDonalds in.\n\nI really don't think this will be the last we see of Robert, he has an amazing voice and is a fantastic performer. \n\nOnce again, apologies for my generalisations about the Scottish, I just can't believe we are going to be put through yet another week of the McDonalds whining.
553480
It was a tough decision, when it is the final two one of the idol has to win.  Katharine McPhee was a good singer. Everyone felt that Taylor is much more better than Katharine.  America felt that he should be the next American Idol because everyone liked him by his singing and personality.  I felt that Katharine should have deserve the title if she did win.  Since, Katharine is the runner up, she learned that she made it through the competition and she never gives up.  If I was in her shadow either I win or lose, all I care about that I succeed making it to the final.