Do u think Carrie Underwood should nave been season 4 american idol ???
107728
no. it should've been constantine. he's hoooot.
312601
the worst thing that could happen is. she could reveal that shes an uber strong alein from the plant orgiadsfk here to take over the Billboard charts and the world with her uber strong singing capabilities.  she will have a huge song battle with Taylor, Paris, and KAthrine McPhee. it will be very much like power rangers until the great round house kicker, Chuck Norris steps in defeats them all cause no one but wins american idol but chuck norris. Dont fear people because the chances of this happening are quite slime 1 in 5 odds i think.  GO KELLY!
501483
Personally, I don't think he should have won...but he did and we'll just have to see if America voted correctly...Katherine was my favorite from the very beginning, but she too, will make out very well, it doesn't really matter who gets the title, except to the contestants, as you know, Clay Aiken is doing much better than Reuben...the only thing I will say is this...they should limit the times callers can vote, it has turned into more of a popularity contest than who is actually the better singer...
994987
EWWWW i hate that guy! I think that Chris Daughtry should have won, that would have been the best American Idol this year, but oh well i think he will make it anyways and i dont think that Taylor will be that big.. his hair bothers me and he always acts drunk
687704
I think so, Carrie Underwood is pretty damn good
594813
yes she should have been voted off way before Elliot
853604
Hopefully, she wont make anymore albums.  The girl cant sing.  But I do think that her hubby and her decision over the past 2 years have made her out to look like "Trailer Park Trash" so as far as her image goes I think its gonna be good for her.
489280
Well, since Chris got voted off my votes are going toward Taylor. I really wish Chris was still in it though. :( But I guess it's okay...He's going to have an amazing career. He's already been offered to be Fuel's lead singer!
528303
I DO!! Katherine rocks!! Taylor had a good stage presence and makes it exciting, but he has no talent!! anyone could go up there and do wat taylor did!! I definetley voted for Katherine. She was, like, the only talent they had this season.
678600
I think so. Heck, if they can do something on American Idol to make those people (rock) or pop stars, then why not?\n\n;)
999796
I loved it! Love her!! She's the best American Idol ever...now she's her own name. I"m so happy for her. The song is kinda poppy, I prefer her rock infused stuff but it's still good.
468593
Well, let me think.   Wait I don't have to think.  I think the winner will defintely be chris.  i want katherine to win too though.  she has a very unique voice that i have never heard before.  Well all we could do is wait till the season finale.  Can't wait
607570
Of course. I love the song 'You Found Me', "Behind these Hazel Eyes", and "Because of You" \n\nKelly's the best American Idol ever!!!
615036
I think paris will be kicked off and I will stop watching if Elliot is kicked off. For the sake of getting and " orginal new fresh face" American Idol Katharine needs to go..she is typical of what's currently in the market and her performances have been  getting worse not better.
234591
I thought she was ok UNTIL she forgot where she came from and tried to deny american idol to use any of her songs on the show. I think that shows a lot of disrespect for those involved on the show and her fans that helped her win.
229908
---mcphee is good (why are we all refering to her as mcphee now?) but i don't think she has showed enough enthusiasm when she performs to develope a steady fan base. also, she needs a new stylist. her choice of clothing is always appaling. \n---bucky has not a chance except for a miracle. after all, there are only so many people on votefortheworst.com. \n---ace is also a very long long shot. he got too wrapped up in himself and forgot this is a singing competition and not a modeling competition.\n---chris has a lot of talent, but he doesnt' really show much versatiliy, like simon said. maybe he will show us something different with country week... but he does have a strong fanbase and he is talented...\n---kellie pickler is good but i think she relies more on her cute southern girl more than her vocals to carry her through... i don't know if that will be enough tto get her all the way...\n---paris is good, but when you look at all the other talent i don't think she is the best, but they have been showcaseing her from the beginning so she has a bigger fan base than some people.\n---elliot can sing, he is a good performer most of the time, but i don't know if that many people really remember him. i don't think he has a solid shot at winning but he should get pretty far.\n---taylor has a great voice, a unique style, and a unique personality, which makes for a great contestant on american idol... i don't know if he really WANTS to be the next american idol, though, because then they will try and force him into becoming some poppy kelly clarkson thing...\n---mandisa is very talented singer, has a very pretty face, and she has a vrey likeable personality. i think she has a very good chance at winning. \nso, all things considered, it will be mandisa, chris, and taylor in the top three... don't know which one will win though... only time will tell.
420403
MANDISA!!!! WE COMMITTED AN AMERICAN IDOL SIN!!!!!! MANDISA BEFORE BUCKY AND ACE????????????? WHAT IS THE WORLD COMING TO?????????????MAYBE THEY SHOULD ALL GET VOTEFORTHEWORST.COM ON THEIR SIDE...