Who will retire first: Brett Favre or Steve Mcnair?
109720
I am guessing Favre. I haven't heard nothing about McNair. They both should retire though.
63486
Of course brett farve is going to stay at Green Bay.\nHe wouldnt leave since he had a bad year he will bounce back and lead the packers to a good winning record(prolly not playoff material) and if he does retire in the next year or two Matt Lienart would  replace him if they pick him for the upcoming season.
703534
steve mcnair .hands down. worthlessburger is just not himself . mcnair will win for sure he helped beat the steelers! and that is a defence to reakon with .
1180550
green bay and brett favre
759103
I just love Steve McNair! He left us(Titans) for Baltimore I wish he could win the Superbowl before he reitres. I don't think his body can take anymore injuries. They are playing really well, cross our fingers.
1059065
Steve McNair is a competitor, much like Warren Moon was, but tends to get injured more often than Warren did. If he can stay healthy he will provide Baltimore with a solid starter for 4 or 5 more seasons, and/or a great backup in case of injury or poor starter play. He is difinitely an improvement over Kyle Boller at this point.
275847
YES Matt Hasselbeck could be the the next Brett Favre he's a good guarterback good read's an instict. Brett's one damn good guarterback you cannot knock him but we all see what SEATTLE can bring to the table Hasselbeck also has a strong arm and with the running game mix in as a combo he can and will pick team's apart!!!!!
716390
I believe he is.  He has had an impressive career but he said last season he would be going.  I would like to state for the record too, to all the naysayers who answered this question, that Brett Favre is one of the best quarterbacks who has ever played the game and he has a genuine love of the game.  You don't see that with a lot of the money hungry players out there today. He has class, he has a killer arm STILL, and when he is ready to leave, it will be a sad day in the NFL.
30641
I think that Favre should retire. He has proven himself to be one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever play the game, and the Packers will be rebuilding for the next few years, so it would be best for the organization for Rodgers to step in and begin his reign as Packers QB. Although I think that he should retire, I do expect to see Favre back next season to try and prove that he is better than a 4-12 season.
306009
It'll be Hawk...he played at Ohio State so he's local to the region, they need a "franchise" face to associate with the Packer Mystique and he's the man for the job...their D was horrible and his strenth, speed and smarts will provide an instant boost to the team.  That said, he's still a rookie and while he's going to do a lot, he's no Jonathan Vilma (who is some kind of film room freak) so don't expect him to carry the team.  But he will help lead the turnaround while Rodgers wets his pants on the sidelines waiting for Favre to retire...what a debacle that is!
98951
McNair=better qb but Vick=better scrambler
9450
The Seahawks reguardless of who starts or who's least game it might be. The Packers are terrible this year and the Seahawks are impressive w/ or w/o their starters. Brett Favre should have retired two years ago. I know he wants to go out on a good season but I'm affraid those years have past. He is a great person and leader but his physical abilties are starting to fail. He is no longer the asset he once was.
922183
neither will retire as of now
234210
He should retire.....if Brett came back and had another terrible year he may tarnish his career. It's also not a great situation.  The Packers brought in a new coach, they're obviously not contending, and they seem to be in rebuild mode. If Brett were to come back, he would be playing for a last place team.  It would be better for him to retire and let Aaron Rodgers take over and begin what he is destined for and that is a career in coaching.
136106
Leftwich is better right now because he is younger, and still has yet to reach his prime.\n\nOverall, McNair has had the better career, leading the Titans to the Super Bowl in the 1999-2000 NFL season.
954748
Steve McNair is going to have a very good day against theFalcons. There are to many injuries.
754187
FEAR DA BEARS.........................................i am a paker fan that y i would pick favre but Kitna might also do good.......