Who was the better college QB - Michael Vick or Vince Young?
109278
Young won the Rose Bowl.  Enough said.
65917
Reggie Bush because he will beat Vince Young at the NFL draft.
336629
I like Vince Young.\n\nI'd like to see Albert Einstein play football !!! The boy can play ball, who cares if he is stupid, most of them are anyway.  \n\nI'd take Young over Matt or Cutler any day.  Next to Reggie Bush, he is the best player from this great class.  I like him better than Matt cause even I could have had good numbers quarterbacking at USC - I'd just hand the ball off the Reggie and White every time, big deal - plus he had the best team and best O-line.  Young had crappy running backs.
1141788
Questionable since Billy Volek has some big game experience under the current system and has started for the Titans on many occasions.  However, they did get Vince Young at #3 ... but I wouldn't rush him into the game right away.  \n\nI would give Young a year to study under Volek.  However, he could start a few games depending on Volek's performance.
53754
yes and no...i would take it as almost an insult if i was a rb 4 a team whose qb ran the ball to much. mike vick is a great qb and versatile player an so is vince young but id prefer to be the rb 4 a team that trusted me with the ball a little bit more than to have  the qb run it all the time.
1149300
. My Favorite QB came from Virginia Cavaliers = Aaron Brooks now with the Oakland Raiders. \nGood College with Good Football tradition.
80706
I think Leinart reads a defense better than Young, but Young has more (by far) athleticism and God given talent.
651283
He's signed as a QB/Wide Reciever.  This is good.  The boy has got speed and has a knack for making big plays. This gives the offense another deadly weapon... SPEED KILLS... And Vick has Speed. Coach Saban has already told him that the organization won't put up with the crap he pulled at VT.  Saban will have him under control.
1168066
Vince Young is great and I think he'll make a splash his rookie year, but more often than not Quarterbacks aren't rushed into the limelight in their first year. A QB is one of your most heavily protected investments in the NFL, and someone like Vince Young or Michael Vick who scrambles a lot will be treated very carefully in his first years to ensure he doesn't get hurt.\nAs much as I hate to say it, because I'm anything but a USC fan, I have to guess it'll be Reggie Bush. He's such a dynamic gamebreaker, and even if he doesn't see a lot of immediate touches at HB he can step in as a WR or return man and show his ability there.\nObviously whoever it is, it will depend on how much playing time they see, how closely protected they are (as many ROTY prospects are often considered a key part, if not the whole, of the franchise's future plans), and whether or not they can stay healthy.
42323
I think Vince Young will be the starting QB for Houston next year.
721671
Vince hasn't signed yet but he did just get a sweet azz deal from Reebok - disclosed or not, you know that was a great payday.\n\nReebok Thinks (Vince) Young \n \n \nMay 01, 2006\n\nNEW YORK -- Reebok has signed a multiyear deal with quarterback Vince Young to represent the company in marketing and on the field. Terms of the deal were not disclosed.
731308
VINCE CARTER DEFINITELY
445832
Vince Young rocks. He is the best player in the draft and desrved to win the Heisman. He's gonna lead Tennessee to the Superbowl in a few years just like he led the Longhorns to the Rose Bowl.
249476
To answer this question, you have to ask "How is a QB judged?"  .  If it is by championships, then it is Montana.  If you judge by statistics, then Young is all-time leader in passing efficiency.  If you judge by leadership, it's hard to argue that there was a better motivator/leader than Montana.  If you judge by athleticism, Young's ability to run changed the game forever.\n\nI'm a HUGE Steve Young fan and he is probably my favorite player of all time, but I'd have to give the edge to Montana for this reason:  he was able to take 3 vastly different teams to the Superbowl 4 times.  The 81 Team was so much different than the 85 team, which was different than the 88-89 teams.  There was no Jerry Rice or John Taylor in 85 and no Roger Craig on the 81 squad.  Joe was the constant and to me, that's what makes him extraordinairy. When you look at the Steelers of the 70's, and the Cowboys of the 90's they did it with the same core group.  The 49ers of the 80's were truly led by the game's great all time QB.
402208
I'd say Reggie. I feel like Young is going to get injured if he runs frequently. I like Vince Young really, but I think it's going to be Bush that gets the 1st overall pick.
383962
I agree with you 100%!  Vince Young is the most overrated QB going into the draft.  I am not a USC fan, nor a Texas fan, however watching both of these QB's play over the course of the season, Matt Leinart is by far the better QB!  He runs a very uniqe and NFL like system at USC, which will better prepare him for the NFL then Young's "oh, nobody is open so ill run the ball," style offense.  He has a horrible release and is too "me" orriented.  Leinart can read defenses, pick up blitz packages and audible calls when needed.  He knows the hot routes and where his receivers will be all the time.  Also, he has the mechanics.  \n\nThe only reason Vince Young has so much hype over him going into the draft, is because they did beat USC in the Rose Bowl.  (although USC played like crap!)  If I were a GM in need for a QB, 1st choice would be Leinart, 2nd Cutler and Kellen Clemens from Oregon over Young!  Thats not a stab at Clemens, hes amazing!  He just got screwed over by getting injured half way through the season.  I also think he would make a better QB over Young.  \n\nYoung will be a bust, just wait and see!
74504
If I'm Houston, I take Reggie Bush for sure. He's a blazer with good hands, and you can't teach either of those skills. Drafting Vince Young might be tempting because of the Texas connection, but they should not  do it.\n\nYoung is an outstanding college quarterback, but he won't be able to have 200/200 games in the NFL. Texas runs their offense out of shotgun, which is not typical of NFL teams. He will have to learn a lot about dropping back before he can be any good in the pros.