Who is the better qb: Charlie Whitehurst or Zac Dahman?
105782
Charlie Whitehurst by far. Just the level of competition that he played against compared to Dahman makes him more prepared for the NFL. And the fact that he led Clemson to a winning record.
889125
Charlie batch...I believe his QB rating this year is around 130.6 for the two games he appeared in this season.
46395
Michael Vick is easily the better quarterback, as hes had more years to develop and Marcus, thanks to his legal escapes, might not reach the NFL or get any more time to develop. Peyton at the moment is better than Eli for the same reason although I believe they will both do very well over time.
895226
id start either kitna hasselback pennington or garcia just becuase kitna is having a good year....hasselback has been known to be a pretty good qb because of his passed so he mihgt come back firing...pennington has had another good year...and garcia is experienced....\n\nid go with hasselback because of his success...
92469
I think they should go with Will Proctor.  Only because he has had some snaps this past year and was pretty decent.  Also he has waited a long time to get the start behind Charlie. We can only wait till the spring game to see how Tribble Reese or Cullen Harper will do.  I'm really looking forward to Willy Korn coming in 2007.  I got to see him play some this year...and he is undoubtedly a beast!   Just my opinion.   I wish the season would get here already!!!
971654
That's actually a tougher questions than I realized when I first glanced.  What you have here is Joe Horn, who is the better receiver, coming off an injury.  Before his injury, he had 2 100+ yard games.  Deion Branch, however, has not had a 100 yard game this season.  Deion also doesn't have the luxury of havn't a healthy pro bowl caliber QB and RB.  \n\nMY ANSWER:  Since both players are going w/ wickety wickety wack pass offenses (Cinci giving up 226.7 and SF giving up 221.6 yard per game), I say go with Deion because at least he's healthy.  I'm sure he'll get a least one touchdown againt the niners.  \n\nSidenote:  If Joe Horn is 100% and only 100% healthy, go with him.
909013
Actually Cutler has a stronger arm than Plummer. Also its been reported that Cutler has looked far better than Plummer in practice as well.
1102172
Sammy Baugh\n\nCareer average - 45.1 yds\n\nthat Guy guy - 42.4 yds
706505
What the Bears need is a good, consistent passing quarterback, and trading for the leading rushing quarterback in the league who always underpasses would not help them at all. From the Falcons' point of view, trading Mike Vick is trading away their franchise player. Mike Vick IS the Falcons, and they would be stupid to trade away the face of their franchise for a horribly inconsistent quarterback in Rex Grossman.
829543
Billy, you are so right on that one. Arkansas' quarterback had a TERRIBLE day and Houston Nutt should have seen that and substituted or at the very least stopped with the long passes!  Darren McFadden IS the best- hands down.  The commentators always joke about trying to name someone better and they can't.  Whoever had him as number 5 on their list is CRAZY!
22259
Part of it depends on how the offensive line looks. Carr has been sacked countless times, but he is still a consistent QB. But still, Vince Young is certainly more mobile than Carr. Right now, Carr is a little better due to experience, but when they're both done, Young will have a better career.
779029
I think TJ has been better this season, but Chad Johnson is the better football player.\n\nFor more on the Bengals and the NFL, check this site out.  http://factipedia.com/sportsblogs/
1131918
First let me just say I don't like or dislike either one of these team, I enjoy watching them both play.  But heres a thought....  Texas will have to start a freshman first time starter this year (McCoy or Snead) and we all know what happen to OK with red shirt freshman Rhett Bomar last year.  But with that being said Bomar is a year wiser and he has a Heisman front runner for a tailback (A. Peterson).  So you do the math....
834724
Jason Campbell.  He was a four year starter at Auburn University.  His first three years were rocky.  He didn't look comfortable on the field and he made alot of mistakes.  His senior year he really came around.  He was #1 in the SEC in completion percentage and led the Tigers to an undefeated season.  The 'Skins picked him up as the 25th pick in the 1st round of the 2005 draft.
270725
Vaas.. because he show his class at batting friendly pitches.. and hes the one the most economical bowler from last 3 or fours years.. Lee has also a class but at my view Vaas id better then Lee
248435
They will both make it to pro football, as both Young and Leinart will be first round picks in the upcoming NFL draft.\n\nBut I would say Leinart will be the more successful quarterback of the two, as his experience is in running a pro-style offense. I also wouldn't be surprised to see Vince Young moved to a different position, such as Antoinne Randall-El. He is a great runner and could go into the backfield or be used as a split end and catch passes and still get some runs on reverses and other trick plays.
937171
Go with Stallworth.....Im a huge Cincy fan, if Carson has time in the pocket, Housh is dangerous but they have so many weapons that you never know who is gonna do the scoring....Stallworth is definately the #1 target for McNabb!!