Who is the better qb: Steve McNair or Micheal Vick?
98951
McNair=better qb but Vick=better scrambler
1158717
Yes. Anyone should be picked over Vick. He's the worst quarterback in football. goes like 11-29 every game and throws for like 106 yards. He stinks.  The Falcons signed him to a 10 year deal, so they basically signed away 10 years of never winning a Super Bowl.
840513
I'd go with Hasselbeck.  He will be looking to prove that he is still the #1 QB.  Vick has been having problems lately, but he is unpredicatable.  Isn't McGahee still hurt? A-Train has been doing pretty decent recently, surprisingly. I'd stick with A-Train for now, if this is the only 2 choices you have.  How about Marion Barber, he available?  He'd be a better choice.
920514
Steve McNair will have a great matchup against a Cincinnati Pass Defense which is ranked dead last 32nd in the NFL, giving up 245.1 yards a game, McNair will have a great game in week 13.
961055
VICK - 100%\n\nGreen should be starting in KC and Vick is among the highest scoring QB's in the league.....
732757
WOW....good question. Overrated player for my money is Michael Vick. Untill he can win consistently with his arm, he is not a top-tier QB. Six years from now, he won't be able to outrun everyone in the league...he'll have to have good decision-making skills and accuracy in order to succeed, and I haven't seen that from him.\nUnderrated player...Rod Smith....there are several to pick from....but although Rod has been a great receiver for many, many years...he has never garnered the acclaim or respect a player of his stature should. But if you poll DB's around the league, they'll tell you how professional and talented RS really is.
756092
LOL I agree 100%. Crumpler can be good sometimes but yes if Vick gets leg broken bye bye Falcons.
771033
no Vick has a tiny bit of talent and Owens of has none. \n\nBUT yes they are two utterly worthless scumbags and I hope they are never together cause ESPN would be all over it for a week
110866
The correct answer will be the Titans. Steve Mcnair has been mentoring the Phenomenon since freshman year.The 49ers have drafted a QB the last two years and both have never done anything for them.
57857
The best player in the NFL is by far LaDainian Tomlinson. He can run for a TD,catch a TD and Pass for a TD. It certainly isnt Michael Vick. Vick may be one of the most exciting but that doesnt make him the best. In fact he was one of the worst rated QB's in the league. 25th in the league to be exact.
215948
Vince young is going to be a Mike Vick type player, except that Vince can pass. Matt Leinart isn't a very good QB, but he's a good leader. Cutler is the best QB in the draft, but Young is the better player.
401148
Matt Leinart--he is more ready to be an NFL quarterback, based on his work ethic, smarts, and ability to read defenses.  \n\nWhy not to take Vince Young:\n1) mechanics are terrible\n2) shotgun QB--offenses in the NFL don't do this, Alex Smith was the latest shotgun QB to come out, and look how he's doing.  i want to see him take 3 and 4 step drops and consistently hit guys on 15 -20 yard outs.\n3) his athleticism hurts him--he tries to be like michael vick, but he's not NEARLY the athlete vick is.  he won't be able to run in the NFL like he did in college.  his coach in college, Mack Brown, said "he does better when we stop coaching him and let his athleticism take over".  bad news if you're an NFL coach looking to teach a young guy the basics of the NFL game.\n4) he's a coward--he is the QB with the most skepticism about him in the draft, and he refused to work out at the combine.  rather he held his own workout, at his own field, with his own receivers.  that's not a good sign for me if i'm a scout looking to see VY compared to everyone else in the draft\n5) he's a dunce--scoring a 6 and a 16 on the Wonderlic exam.  i realize intelligence isn't everything, but it is the way the game is shifting.  look at the QB's to make the playoffs last season: Manning, Palmer, Brady, Roethlisberger, Leftwich, Plummer, Hasselbeck, Delhomme, Simms, Brunell, Manning, Grossman.  All intelligent, drop-back passers.  VY's type of QB is not a winning type in the league.\n\nFor all of those reasons, you almost have to choose AGAINST Vince rather than choose FOR someone else.  \n\nand for all the Young-lovers, get over the Rose Bowl performance (against a swiss cheese USC D), and accept that he will STRUGGLE in the NFL.  this is big boy football now...
136106
Leftwich is better right now because he is younger, and still has yet to reach his prime.\n\nOverall, McNair has had the better career, leading the Titans to the Super Bowl in the 1999-2000 NFL season.
973546
I don't know... Team 1 definitely has the advantage in the WR department, but Team 2 has the advantage in just about everything else. \nTom Brady>Mike Vick\nLarry Johnson> (barely) Westbrook (Jeff Garcia is not McNabb)\nChicago>Miami\nIf I absolutely had to, I would pick Team 2 to win, but that's just me. Hope my opinion helped.
993809
Tommie Frazier is BY FAR the best option QB to play college football.  Too bad about his health issues....he may have been McNabb/Vick when McNabb/Vick were still in high school.
955846
usually, brady is the more reliable guy. vick has had tons of trouble passing lately. then again, brady is facing the bears and vick is facing a defense that's in a downfall as of late.
853932
With who you have, I would go with Vick. New Orleans D is not that great against the pass and as a bonus, someone questions Vick's arm or lack of being a pocket passer as the senior Jim Mora did, he tends to play above his normal self to prove everyone wrong. Also, both teams usually put up the points when they play each other and the most important aspect is......ATLANTA needs to win to stay alive! Steve McNair is good BUT, they are a run team first and McNair in a division game is going to be out to protect the ball first and foremost along with the fact, just because of their record, do not sell the Steeler defense short, it has improved. Would not consider Garcia at this point, he is going to be a bit rusty. Good Luck this week!