and their leaders should be tried and locked up in quatanamo for thier human right violation?
138284
Of course they should.  Unfortunately, if the left-wing extremist liberals have their way they will nuke us first.
363622
Good question. Who would charge them with war crimes? The UN? That's a joke. The truth is no one will ever charge them. And Nothing can ever be done about it. People in this country (US) want to treat our soldiers as if they were monsters for killing terrorists. Our troops deserve many thanks. Compared to Russian war strategies we are saints!
649076
I expect the opposing side to name call on this one, or downplay the sactioning of torture. or that my side is sympathic to terrorist.\n\nThey will argue they have no rights as enemy combatants.\n\nThis is all garbage, it is dangerous the president can declare anyone an enemy without proof or trial......\nWe are not Iraq we are suppose to do justice by our nations princples.\n\nWe are letting people out of those prisons quietly, why would we do that if they were guilty.\n\n\nRumfeld and the Prez ok torture and blamed on 3 or 4 MPS.  It all stinks, \n\nThe way we detained many was by paying warlords for Tali Ban. War lords were paid by the head, many of these were people with no connection to Al Quedia or enemies of the war lords,  farmers.... you think a war lord cares........but who cares right?
484316
nope. that would be a case of human rights violation
163842
They were not charged because they are neither POWs nor criminals.  They are simply people who we have captured fighting us.  As such it would be foolish for us to release them and let them try to massacre more of our people.\n\nTechnically, under international law we would have had the right to hold a quick battlefield tribunal then shoot them.\n\nBTW are you aware the the EU investigated the prison at Gitmo and announced that they are better treated than prisoners in Belguim?
636886
I'm sure he is a repug - those people are the most hypocrite of all.  \n\nEverything that they hate in others they commit themselves.  I think he should be jailed!!
40771
What you're forgetting is that tomorrow it could be you.  If you were accused of a crime, should we not give you any rights, just throw you straight in jail?  If you're just referring to people who have been convicted, which rights do you mean?  They don't have many.  You do have to remember that unless they got the death penalty, they are going to return to society some day.  You don't prepare someone for that by putting them in a hole and telling they they're not a citizen anymore.
130398
Yes, put with that holding people in Cuba without them having inspectors and other war atrocity's, abu gray, they should have to face a world court and be judged there to their crimes against humanity.
356509
They are criminals. They violated our laws on Imigration. They break the law to gain employment. THEY ARE CRIMINALS. IF THE LAW ENFORCEMENT PEOPLE ARRESTED THEM FOR WHAT THEY HAVE DONE. THEY WOULD GO TO JAIL AND BE RETURNED TO THEIR COUNTRY OF ORIGIN.THIS MAKES THEM ILLEGAL (UN LAWFUL)
579524
Too many innocent people would be killed, and most of us (though NOT the eminent-domain-using New York Times!) still care about human life.  No, they should be prosecuted as traitors and made to serve their debt to society--in prison.  Perhaps Gitmo.  And I have no problem if Momo Dowd has to wear underwear on her head, lol...
32348
I feel those imprisoned in Cuba should be able to plead a case in some kind of military tribunal or something. If there is evidence that the individual has direct ties to terrorism, keep em locked up.  By just setting them all free, you're gonna have some really pissed off middle eastern men with ties to terrorism with a huge grudge trying to get back at America and that cannot be a good thing.
567250
i think they all should be deported along with the people who marry them.....
428740
They don't always deserve them, but it's their responsibility to remove them from power when needed.  Leaders should serve the people, not vice versa.
190827
Of course it matters!  The leaders of the people should have good and high morals.  The people are constantly watching him and should have the access to any screw ups he may have committed.
160689
I think the prisoners there should be given their rights under Article 3 of the Geneva Convention and be given a trial. If there's no evidence against them, they need to be returned to their families. \n\nIf the base is shut down without these steps, the prisoners would just be moved to another location which may be better hidden from public scrutiny. The government does not seem to be honest with the public and hides a lot of information.
402473
This is quite possibly a setup, done to promote "sensitivity" for their cause. They need to be held for a through investigation and face arrest if this is shown to be the case.\n\nAnd really, they should be charged and thrown into jail for inciting this disturbance, in any event. It's much worse than yelling fire in a theater in view of what has transpired in recent times. \n\nNo one can convince me that they didn't know what they were doing.
353363
I was there in 94 and can only agree. They should be in a jail cell awaiting deportation.