Do you think people with out documents should stay?
124036
HELL NO!! No rights, no amnesty, DEPORTATION~~ with fines!!\n\n To those who think the ILLEGAL immigrants BUILT this country, "You are either a moron or you are terribly misinformed." \n\nOur country was BUILT by OUR forefathers: Native Americans and legal immigrants\n Most Americans do their own laundry and yard work. I have a garden every year, make many of my own clothes, do my own laundry, work in my own yard.  There are enough legal immigrants and American citizens that want jobs that will do what the ILLEGAL immigrants do. If anyone thinks we can't do without them, why don't they take their butts back to Mexico and just see what we can do WITHOUT  them.
575903
Obviously nobody likes identity theft,and equally obviously a great number of people who are bleeding hearts for the illegals turn a blind eye to the fact that a large number of them in fact DO use false papers and stolen identities ... so much for the poor people who only come here to get a better life ... I'd say, I'd have a better life too if I went around and stole other people's identity and ran up huge bills at other people's expense ...
166076
There is definitely a need for control.  If the person is not a registered citizen, do they pay taxes, darn it, I have to pay.  \nfinger-printed is a necessity to those entering.\nThe job markedt % of unemployment would state a more true factor\nOk, thats enough for now, smile
76130
it should be a criminal offense to hire anyone, without legal papers. we americans. when we apply for a job. we have to present 2 forms of identification. drivers license, social security card. sometimes birth certificates. we cannot even get a job without doing this. have to take drug test. have to have physicals. i agree there should be extreme consequences for these people who hire them.
564479
Well we already know there not going to all have to leave. so we do need to consider this. They should have guidelines. Ones who have children born here should stay, If their  or any one is going to use welfare thye need to be forced to work untill they are on their feet, they should also be given a certain amount of time, to be able to take care of them selves. If a participant on welfare gets preganant a second time while on these services, something should happen to be said this is not ok. Before granting amnesty they should be screened, those who have commited violent crimes or  any kind of sex crime should do their time then be deported (unfortunately not all sex crimes are considered very serious) While here if they commit one of these crimes then the same for them.\nI am for amnesty but not for ppl who commit violent crimes.\nSecure our borders.\n\nk I wanted to write more but gotta get back to work.
249949
the illegal becomes a "semi-legal" of sorts.  and it starts the process for them to stay.  it does not guarentee their status and they are still subject to being sent home, like a waiting period, while paper work gets sorted out and red tape gets pushed through.  full rights don't kick in for about 5 years, if i'm remembering correctly.\nplease note- this is a fast and dirty description of a process that is about 78 pages long and i'm not sure how these laws may have changed recently.  last time i had to really look into it for someone was about nine years ago.
59412
Pretty much.  As long as he is collecting a pay check he should do as requested as long as it is within the bounds of his job description.  And it is not an unreasonable request to ask him to document his work.   \n\nHe may not have much to lose in terms of this job since it's already lost, but if he wants to leave under reasonably good terms and get a good reference to help get his next job, he should try to be acommodating.
623503
well - then it is fine - there is no ethical or professional problem \n\n\ngo for it - it might work out well - and if it doesnt well he doesnt mark  your papers anymore
621079
I have the same question for anything that involves a 'pass'.  How do you enforce their leaving?  Right now up to half of the people here came legally and overstayed visas.  Why would these passes miraculously be enforced?
369922
of course, but just dont depend on only that...\n\nmy mom did that w/ all of our stuff like birth cert. and Social Sec. Card, stuff like that...just for a back up in case we lost the original...id recommend doing that...
389404
It should be mandatory in order to prove your sincerety. Assimilate or get lost... You wanna have a better life ??? PROVE IT !!!!! What a great idea.... Solves so many problems simply !!! Those sincere should be afforded the express lane( citizenship ) for their willingness to support their new home. No more than right !!! Those that disappear when the announcement is made, well, we pretty much know where they are coming from...Forget the wall, we would no longer need it.....
571037
GET A LAWYER TO LOOK OVER ANY PAPERWORK YOU MIGHT HAVE, IF THERE IS A WAY THEY'LL FIND IT.
147311
Nothing wrong with that, except that people who live together without that "piece of paper" are not entitled to many things that those who do marry are.\n\nDon't rush into anything, though (as I see you are not), you deserve some happiness after all those years of unhappiness.
578525
It's a good idea in theory. Especially for workers who are trying to remember their employment history for applications and resume's. I run into folks all the time who have misplaced their tax forms or forgotten an employer. It would help with not only that issue, but also what you have stated. However, it would cost a lot to set up and keep maintained. How would you ensure accuracy? What if an employer didn't report and it messed up someone's credit or chance at a job? What if an employee didn't report properly because they didn't want anyone to know about a job that lasted 2 months and they got fired? The accurate reporting would be an issue, as well as the safety and security of the database. Anything can be hacked.
551876
Wow No I would not consider it correct. I know people in this situation they came here from other parts of central America on their own at the risk of losing everything they own and their family.some of their friends lost their lives. All because of a need,whether it be because of poverty,abuse, lack of family or what ever It's the minors that suffer more. If they make it here they should be considered for amnesty.
546765
No problem if they come here and then leave when their seasonal work is over and we aren't expected to bear the burden of educating their children and medical expenses etc.  I have no problem if it's just the people who are actually working and not all their family and extended family as well.  Key word here is TEMPORARY.  A couple months....not 35 years of drifting from one job to the next.  And only when their aren't citizens to do the job.  A definate means to track these people and hold them accountable for their time here.
292307
Why would you want to be rid of them?  What law says you can't keep such things?  Don't be so hard on yourself.   It's your life, your memories.. do what you want.