Dataset Viewer
sample_id
stringlengths 1
115
| difficulty
stringclasses 1
value | physics_category
stringclasses 3
values | physics_law
stringclasses 8
values | edit_operation
stringclasses 16
values | edit_instruction
stringlengths 14
130
| annotated_qa_pairs
listlengths 0
12
| output_path_PICABench_Seedream_Edits
stringlengths 99
226
| output_path_PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits
stringlengths 100
227
| output_path_PICABench_Gemini_Edits
stringlengths 97
224
| output_path_PICABench_qwenimg
stringlengths 92
219
| output_path_PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema
stringlengths 118
245
| output_path_PICABench_ovis_u1
stringlengths 87
107
| output_path_PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema
stringlengths 117
244
| output_path_PICABench_flux_kontext
stringlengths 97
224
| output_path_PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema
stringlengths 118
245
| output_path_PICABench_hidream_e1
stringlengths 95
222
| output_path_PICABench_stepedit
stringlengths 93
220
| output_path_PICABench_bagel_think
stringlengths 96
223
| output_path_PICABench_bagel_nothink
stringlengths 98
225
| output_path_PICABench_omnigen2
stringlengths 93
220
| output_path_PICABench_uniworld
stringlengths 100
227
| output_path_PICABench_DIMOO
stringlengths 147
197
| input_image
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_Seedream_Edits
imagewidth (px) 517
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits
imagewidth (px) 682
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_Gemini_Edits
imagewidth (px) 535
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_qwenimg
imagewidth (px) 523
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_ovis_u1
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_flux_kontext
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_hidream_e1
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_stepedit
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_bagel_think
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_bagel_nothink
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_omnigen2
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_uniworld
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_DIMOO
imagewidth (px) 352
672
| new_column
stringclasses 1
value | PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_bagel_think_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_Seedream_Edits_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_DIMOO_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_flux_kontext_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_qwenimg_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_hidream_e1_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_uniworld_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_bagel_nothink_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_stepedit_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_Gemini_Edits_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_ovis_u1_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_omnigen2_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda
|
explicit
|
Mechanics
|
Causality
|
remove
|
Remove the 5 of spades card from the structure.
|
[
{
"answer": "No",
"box": {
"height": 560.9180035650623,
"width": 445.8110516934047,
"x": 0.11558792796111962,
"y": 466.24174810990223
},
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1018.9510313336491,
"width": 643.1751853303017,
"x": 0,
"y": 0
},
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0047_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0046_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove_edited.png
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0046_Remove_the_front-left_vertical_support_cardthe_5_of_spadesfrom_the_608x416_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png
|
Processed_N/A
|
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The large card on the left clearly shows the number 5 with a spade symbol.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The large card on the left clearly shows the number 5 with a spade symbol.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edges appear parallel to the floor and evenly supported by the card structure, showing no downward slope toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edges appear parallel to the floor and evenly supported by the card structure, showing no downward slope toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The lower front-left compartment has no front card covering it—you can see directly into the bay, with a card lying on the floor outside.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The lower front-left compartment has no front card covering it—you can see directly into the bay, with a card lying on the floor outside.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single loose card lying flat on the floor under that front-left corner; no other flat cards are beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single loose card lying flat on the floor under that front-left corner; no other flat cards are beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass corner is visibly supported by the top surfaces of the card-house stacks, indicating it’s resting on them despite the tilt.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass corner is visibly supported by the top surfaces of the card-house stacks, indicating it’s resting on them despite the tilt.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card lies flat on the floor, so there isn’t a distinct shadow directly beneath it—only slight edge shading.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card lies flat on the floor, so there isn’t a distinct shadow directly beneath it—only slight edge shading.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible card shows the number 5 with spade symbols, indicating the 5 of spades within the region.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The visible card shows the number 5 with spade symbols, indicating the 5 of spades within the region.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left side, indicating the front-left corner is lower than the opposite side.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left side, indicating the front-left corner is lower than the opposite side.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The lower-left section has only one card standing and no opposing card, leaving the bay open.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The lower-left section has only one card standing and no opposing card, leaving the bay open.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is one small playing card lying flat on the floor beneath that lowered corner; no other flat cards are under it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is one small playing card lying flat on the floor beneath that lowered corner; no other flat cards are under it.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass sheet is angled and its edge is visibly supported by the tops of the remaining card stacks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass sheet is angled and its edge is visibly supported by the tops of the remaining card stacks.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A dark patch on the floor appears right under the bottom edge of the front-left fallen card, indicating a grounded shadow.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A dark patch on the floor appears right under the bottom edge of the front-left fallen card, indicating a grounded shadow.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A playing card showing the number 5 with spade symbols is clearly visible on the floor in the region.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A playing card showing the number 5 with spade symbols is clearly visible on the floor in the region.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop’s front edge appears straight and parallel to the floor, with equal-height supports beneath it; there’s no visual drop toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop’s front edge appears straight and parallel to the floor, with equal-height supports beneath it; there’s no visual drop toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left-front triangular compartment is open with no card closing its face, so you can see through it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left-front triangular compartment is open with no card closing its face, so you can see through it.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single 5 of spades card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass, with no other flat cards nearby.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single 5 of spades card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass, with no other flat cards nearby.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass panel is visibly supported by the triangular stacks of cards, with its edges resting directly on their tops.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass panel is visibly supported by the triangular stacks of cards, with its edges resting directly on their tops.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card lies flat on the floor, with no visible shadow directly underneath it—only slight edge shading beside it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card lies flat on the floor, with no visible shadow directly underneath it—only slight edge shading beside it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible cards show clubs and other patterns, but there is no card identifiable as the 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible cards show clubs and other patterns, but there is no card identifiable as the 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear level and parallel to the floor; no corner, including the front-left, is visibly lower than the others.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear level and parallel to the floor; no corner, including the front-left, is visibly lower than the others.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left-front triangular cell is empty, allowing a clear view through to the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left-front triangular cell is empty, allowing a clear view through to the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single flat rectangular card on the floor directly under the lowered front-left corner of the glass, with no other touching cards nearby.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single flat rectangular card on the floor directly under the lowered front-left corner of the glass, with no other touching cards nearby.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "One stack has toppled, causing the glass to tilt, but the tabletop edge is still visibly supported by the remaining upright card stacks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"One stack has toppled, causing the glass to tilt, but the tabletop edge is still visibly supported by the remaining upright card stacks.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen front-left card lies flat on the ground with no distinct shadow visible beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen front-left card lies flat on the ground with no distinct shadow visible beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A card labeled with the number 5 and the spade symbol is clearly visible.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A card labeled with the number 5 and the spade symbol is clearly visible.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop appears level; its edges run parallel to the floor perspective and the spacing with the card supports is consistent, showing no dip toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop appears level; its edges run parallel to the floor perspective and the spacing with the card supports is consistent, showing no dip toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left compartment lacks a front panel—one card is missing or folded out—creating a visible opening into the bay.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left compartment lacks a front panel—one card is missing or folded out—creating a visible opening into the bay.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass, with no other cards on the floor in that area.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass, with no other cards on the floor in that area.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass top is angled but its edge clearly rests on the upright card stacks that support it, despite one fallen card.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass top is angled but its edge clearly rests on the upright card stacks that support it, despite one fallen card.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card on the floor has its shadow offset to the lower-right, not directly underneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card on the floor has its shadow offset to the lower-right, not directly underneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The left leaning card clearly shows the number 5 with a spade symbol.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The left leaning card clearly shows the number 5 with a spade symbol.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear parallel to the floor in perspective, with uniform thickness and no sag toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear parallel to the floor in perspective, with uniform thickness and no sag toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left lower compartment has no closing card; you can see straight through to the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left lower compartment has no closing card; you can see straight through to the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single red-backed card lying flat on the floor beneath the front-left corner of the glass; no other cards are contiguous there.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single red-backed card lying flat on the floor beneath the front-left corner of the glass; no other cards are contiguous there.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass pane’s edge visibly rests on the top faces of the card-house structures, indicating they support it even though a single card lies on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass pane’s edge visibly rests on the top faces of the card-house structures, indicating they support it even though a single card lies on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card lies flat on the floor; any shadow is to the sides, not directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card lies flat on the floor; any shadow is to the sides, not directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible cards are clubs (e.g., Jack of Clubs and a 3 of Clubs), not a 5 of Spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible cards are clubs (e.g., Jack of Clubs and a 3 of Clubs), not a 5 of Spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear level and parallel with the floor, and the supports under the tabletop are of equal height, showing no downward slope toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear level and parallel with the floor, and the supports under the tabletop are of equal height, showing no downward slope toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left triangular bay lacks a closing card, leaving a visible open space you can see through.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left triangular bay lacks a closing card, leaving a visible open space you can see through.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Only one card is lying flat on the floor under the front-left corner; the other cards are part of the upright structure.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Only one card is lying flat on the floor under the front-left corner; the other cards are part of the upright structure.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly in contact with the tops of the card-stack supports, indicating it is resting on them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly in contact with the tops of the card-stack supports, indicating it is resting on them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card is resting on the floor, and any shading appears adjacent, not as a distinct grounded shadow directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card is resting on the floor, and any shading appears adjacent, not as a distinct grounded shadow directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "No card clearly shows five spade symbols; the visible cards display mixed suits and not a 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"No card clearly shows five spade symbols; the visible cards display mixed suits and not a 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass plane appears lower at the front-left corner than at the back-right, indicated by the thicker visible edge and perspective showing the surface slanting downward toward the front-left.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass plane appears lower at the front-left corner than at the back-right, indicated by the thicker visible edge and perspective showing the surface slanting downward toward the front-left.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The lower front-left section of the card structure is missing a card, leaving a visible open space.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The lower front-left section of the card structure is missing a card, leaving a visible open space.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the front-left corner of the glass; no other flat cards are under that corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the front-left corner of the glass; no other flat cards are under that corner.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly supported by the remaining triangular stacks of cards beneath it, even though one card has fallen.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly supported by the remaining triangular stacks of cards beneath it, even though one card has fallen.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card lies flat on the floor, and the shadow appears to the side rather than directly underneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card lies flat on the floor, and the shadow appears to the side rather than directly underneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible card on the ground appears to be an Ace of Spades, not a 5 of Spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible card on the ground appears to be an Ace of Spades, not a 5 of Spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The slanted black edge is due to perspective; the tabletop sits evenly on the card-structure supports and doesn’t dip toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The slanted black edge is due to perspective; the tabletop sits evenly on the card-structure supports and doesn’t dip toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The bottom front-left triangular bay lacks a covering card, leaving an open space visible.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The bottom front-left triangular bay lacks a covering card, leaving an open space visible.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor directly under the front-left corner of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor directly under the front-left corner of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge appears to slice through the card stacks rather than sit on top of them, indicating it’s not resting on the remaining stacks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge appears to slice through the card stacks rather than sit on top of them, indicating it’s not resting on the remaining stacks.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card lies flat on the ground; any shadow is offset to the side, not directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card lies flat on the ground; any shadow is offset to the side, not directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards include the Ace of Spades and others, but not a 5 of Spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards include the Ace of Spades and others, but not a 5 of Spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge appears lower near the front-left corner relative to the supporting cards, indicating a downward tilt toward that corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge appears lower near the front-left corner relative to the supporting cards, indicating a downward tilt toward that corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left lower space has no card filling it; you can see the floor through that bay, indicating an open gap.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left lower space has no card filling it; you can see the floor through that bay, indicating an open gap.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under that corner there is just a small torn piece of a card, not one whole contiguous card lying flat.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under that corner there is just a small torn piece of a card, not one whole contiguous card lying flat.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass pane appears to pass through the card structures, intersecting them rather than being supported or resting on top of the stacks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass pane appears to pass through the card structures, intersecting them rather than being supported or resting on top of the stacks.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The small fallen card piece at the front-left does not have a shadow directly beneath it; any shadow appears offset to the side.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The small fallen card piece at the front-left does not have a shadow directly beneath it; any shadow appears offset to the side.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible cards show clubs and mixed symbols, but none display a 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible cards show clubs and mixed symbols, but none display a 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop’s edges appear uniformly parallel to the floor with consistent thickness across the visible edges, showing no downward slope toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop’s edges appear uniformly parallel to the floor with consistent thickness across the visible edges, showing no downward slope toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left compartment of the card structure is not filled by a card, leaving a visible open space.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left compartment of the card structure is not filled by a card, leaving a visible open space.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor directly beneath the front-left corner of the glass, with no other flat cards adjacent to it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor directly beneath the front-left corner of the glass, with no other flat cards adjacent to it.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly resting on top of the triangular card-stack supports, even though one card has fallen and the tabletop is tilted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly resting on top of the triangular card-stack supports, even though one card has fallen and the tabletop is tilted.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card is lying flat on the floor, so any shadow is to the side rather than directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card is lying flat on the floor, so any shadow is to the side rather than directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible cards include a 2 of spades and a 5 of clubs, but no 5 of spades is shown.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible cards include a 2 of spades and a 5 of clubs, but no 5 of spades is shown.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left, indicating the tabletop is tilted toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left, indicating the tabletop is tilted toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left section formed by leaning cards is not closed off; there is a visible opening with no card covering it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left section formed by leaning cards is not closed off; there is a visible opening with no card covering it.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the lowered front-left corner of the glass, there is one card lying flat on the floor (the rest are leaning as part of the card structure).",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Under the lowered front-left corner of the glass, there is one card lying flat on the floor (the rest are leaning as part of the card structure).\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The edge of the tilted glass is visibly supported by several triangular stacks of playing cards underneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The edge of the tilted glass is visibly supported by several triangular stacks of playing cards underneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left fallen/leaning card doesn’t cast a distinct shadow directly underneath it; any shadow is offset to the side and very faint.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left fallen/leaning card doesn’t cast a distinct shadow directly underneath it; any shadow is offset to the side and very faint.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible card in the region clearly shows the number 5 and spade symbols, indicating the 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The visible card in the region clearly shows the number 5 and spade symbols, indicating the 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass top appears level; its edges are parallel to the floor and evenly supported by the card structure, with no visible drop toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass top appears level; its edges are parallel to the floor and evenly supported by the card structure, with no visible drop toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The triangular compartment at the front-left is empty and open, with no card covering it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The triangular compartment at the front-left is empty and open, with no card covering it.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Directly under the front-left corner of the glass there isn’t a single card lying flat; the visible cards there are leaning supports, with any flat card positioned farther inside.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Directly under the front-left corner of the glass there isn’t a single card lying flat; the visible cards there are leaning supports, with any flat card positioned farther inside.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass panel is visibly supported by the card-house structures, with its edge resting on the top cards.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass panel is visibly supported by the card-house structures, with its edge resting on the top cards.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left card leans outward, and the floor directly beneath it appears bright without a distinct shadow; any shadow falls inward under the structure, not directly beneath the card.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left card leans outward, and the floor directly beneath it appears bright without a distinct shadow; any shadow falls inward under the structure, not directly beneath the card.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards are the 3 of clubs and an ace (diamond); no 5 of spades is present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards are the 3 of clubs and an ace (diamond); no 5 of spades is present.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The near front-left edge of the glass sits visibly lower than the back/right edges—its gap to the floor appears smaller—indicating a tilt down toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The near front-left edge of the glass sits visibly lower than the back/right edges—its gap to the floor appears smaller—indicating a tilt down toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "At the front-left corner, only one leaning card is present; the other side of the bay is missing, leaving an open triangular gap.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"At the front-left corner, only one leaning card is present; the other side of the bay is missing, leaving an open triangular gap.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single flat card (the 3 of clubs) on the floor beneath the front-left corner of the glass, with no other flat cards present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single flat card (the 3 of clubs) on the floor beneath the front-left corner of the glass, with no other flat cards present.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly resting on the intact card-stack supports, causing it to tilt even though one card has fallen.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly resting on the intact card-stack supports, causing it to tilt even though one card has fallen.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card lies flat on the floor with no visible shadow cast directly beneath it; only faint ambient shading around edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card lies flat on the floor with no visible shadow cast directly beneath it; only faint ambient shading around edges.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "No card clearly shows five spade symbols or a 5 index of spades in the region.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"No card clearly shows five spade symbols or a 5 index of spades in the region.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edges appear level relative to the floor, with no noticeable drop at the front-left corner compared to the others.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edges appear level relative to the floor, with no noticeable drop at the front-left corner compared to the others.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest front-left section under the tabletop has no supporting cards, leaving an open space with loose cards on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest front-left section under the tabletop has no supporting cards, leaving an open space with loose cards on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left corner of the glass, only one card lies flat on the floor; the nearby left card is tilted and another flat card is farther right, not beneath that corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left corner of the glass, only one card lies flat on the floor; the nearby left card is tilted and another flat card is farther right, not beneath that corner.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass top is angled but its edges still make contact with the upright card stacks beneath, supporting it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass top is angled but its edges still make contact with the upright card stacks beneath, supporting it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The shadow from the front-left fallen card is cast to the right side, not directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow from the front-left fallen card is cast to the right side, not directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "No card clearly shows the 5 of spades; the visible cards do not match that rank and suit.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"No card clearly shows the 5 of spades; the visible cards do not match that rank and suit.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The near left edge of the glass is visibly lower than the far right/back edge, indicating a slope down toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The near left edge of the glass is visibly lower than the far right/back edge, indicating a slope down toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left triangular bay is missing a supporting card, leaving an open space in the structure.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left triangular bay is missing a supporting card, leaving an open space in the structure.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor directly under the lowered front-left corner of the glass, with no other cards contiguous there.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single playing card lying flat on the floor directly under the lowered front-left corner of the glass, with no other cards contiguous there.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass panel’s edge is visibly supported by the card roofs—its left edge rests on the ace card and the other edge on another stack.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass panel’s edge is visibly supported by the card roofs—its left edge rests on the ace card and the other edge on another stack.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card at the front-left lies flat on the ground, and there isn’t a distinct shadow directly beneath it—only slight shading around its edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card at the front-left lies flat on the ground, and there isn’t a distinct shadow directly beneath it—only slight shading around its edges.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
|||||||||||||||||
0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e
|
explicit
|
Optics
|
Refraction
|
remove
|
Remove the water from the glass cup.
|
[
{
"answer": "No",
"box": {
"height": 235.39035597238362,
"width": 180.6764455574513,
"x": 0,
"y": 651.0579198896858
},
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"answer": "No",
"box": {
"height": 705.8482866160331,
"width": 525.204276946535,
"x": 85.603448275862,
"y": 156.93103448275863
},
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 731.0270270270271,
"width": 593.2972972972973,
"x": 1.7162162162161916,
"y": 172.54054054054055
},
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 731.0270270270271,
"width": 593.2972972972973,
"x": 1.7162162162161916,
"y": 172.54054054054055
},
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 731.0270270270271,
"width": 593.2972972972973,
"x": 1.7162162162161916,
"y": 172.54054054054055
},
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0804_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0803_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove_edited.png
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0803_In_the_photo_of_a_clear_glass_tumbler_on_a_608x416_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png
|
Processed_N/A
|
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved lines within the shadow indicate light focused by the glass, characteristic of caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved lines within the shadow indicate light focused by the glass, characteristic of caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light like a lens, magnifying and warping the portion of the ball seen through it, so the lower half appears distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light like a lens, magnifying and warping the portion of the ball seen through it, so the lower half appears distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no visible liquid, condensation, or droplets on the glass; the walls appear clear and dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is no visible liquid, condensation, or droplets on the glass; the walls appear clear and dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is visibly suspended above the bottom; there is a gap and only a circular reflection/shadow on the base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is visibly suspended above the bottom; there is a gap and only a circular reflection/shadow on the base.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The cylindrical glass refracts light, causing the background to bend and shift near the curved edges, so it’s not perfectly undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The cylindrical glass refracts light, causing the background to bend and shift near the curved edges, so it’s not perfectly undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A bright curved band along the shadow’s edge indicates refracted light forming caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A bright curved band along the shadow’s edge indicates refracted light forming caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water act like a lens, refracting the light from the lower half of the ball and making it appear flattened and magnified, hence geometrically distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water act like a lens, refracting the light from the lower half of the ball and making it appear flattened and magnified, hence geometrically distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears empty with no visible liquid or condensation on the inner surface, indicating the walls are dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears empty with no visible liquid or condensation on the inner surface, indicating the walls are dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass has a thick, curved inner base; the ball is sitting on that inner surface, not on the flat outer bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass has a thick, curved inner base; the ball is sitting on that inner surface, not on the flat outer bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, creating bending and brightness variations along the sides rather than a uniform view.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, creating bending and brightness variations along the sides rather than a uniform view.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved lines within the shadow indicate light focused by the glass/water, creating caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved lines within the shadow indicate light focused by the glass/water, creating caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved, thick bottom of the glass acts like a lens, refracting light from the ball and causing the lower portion to appear warped/magnified.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved, thick bottom of the glass acts like a lens, refracting light from the ball and causing the lower portion to appear warped/magnified.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears clear with no visible moisture, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears clear with no visible moisture, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass has a concave inner base; the ball sits in the curved dimple, not on a flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass has a concave inner base; the ball sits in the curved dimple, not on a flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible warping and brightness changes along the sides.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible warping and brightness changes along the sides.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "There is a bright curved highlight within the dark shadow, indicative of refracted light from the glass creating caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a bright curved highlight within the dark shadow, indicative of refracted light from the glass creating caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and water alters light paths, causing magnification and lateral displacement, so the submerged part appears shifted and stretched.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and water alters light paths, causing magnification and lateral displacement, so the submerged part appears shifted and stretched.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains water, so the inner walls in contact with the water are wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains water, so the inner walls in contact with the water are wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is floating near the water surface and not in contact with the bottom; there is visible space between the ball and the glass base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is floating near the water surface and not in contact with the bottom; there is visible space between the ball and the glass base.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water refract light, visibly warping the cyan background near the edges and water line.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water refract light, visibly warping the cyan background near the edges and water line.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved highlights appear within the dark shadow, indicating light focused by refraction/reflection from the object, typical of caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved highlights appear within the dark shadow, indicating light focused by refraction/reflection from the object, typical of caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting light and magnifying/warping the ball’s lower half, making the text and contours appear stretched and shifted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting light and magnifying/warping the ball’s lower half, making the text and contours appear stretched and shifted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Water inside the glass is in contact with the inner surface, so the walls are wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Water inside the glass is in contact with the inner surface, so the walls are wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tennis ball is floating near the top of the water, partially submerged, with clear space between it and the flat bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tennis ball is floating near the top of the water, partially submerged, with clear space between it and the flat bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water refract light, causing the cyan background to appear warped and magnified near the edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water refract light, causing the cyan background to appear warped and magnified near the edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The shadow appears uniformly dark without the characteristic bright, focused lines or patterns that indicate caustics.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow appears uniformly dark without the characteristic bright, focused lines or patterns that indicate caustics.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and liquid refract light, magnifying and shifting the lower half of the ball so its shape and markings appear warped compared to the upper half.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and liquid refract light, magnifying and shifting the lower half of the ball so its shape and markings appear warped compared to the upper half.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains liquid that contacts the inner surface, so at least the portion below the liquid line is wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains liquid that contacts the inner surface, so at least the portion below the liquid line is wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is suspended above the bottom, with visible space and liquid below it, so it is not resting on the flat base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is suspended above the bottom, with visible space and liquid below it, so it is not resting on the flat base.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and liquid refract light, visibly bending and magnifying the cyan background near the edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and liquid refract light, visibly bending and magnifying the cyan background near the edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved highlights appear inside the glass’s shadow from refracted light, indicating caustic patterns.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved highlights appear inside the glass’s shadow from refracted light, indicating caustic patterns.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass wall acts like a lens, refracting the light from the ball’s lower half and causing it to appear shifted and slightly stretched compared to the part above the rim.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass wall acts like a lens, refracting the light from the ball’s lower half and causing it to appear shifted and slightly stretched compared to the part above the rim.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears empty with no visible droplets, fogging, or streaks on the inner surface, indicating it’s dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears empty with no visible droplets, fogging, or streaks on the inner surface, indicating it’s dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is visibly floating with a clear gap between it and the glass bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\": \"No\", \"explanation\": \"The ball is visibly floating with a clear gap between it and the glass bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible bending and warping near the sides and base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible bending and warping near the sides and base.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright, wavy lines from refracted light are visible within the shadow cast by the glass, indicating caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright, wavy lines from refracted light are visible within the shadow cast by the glass, indicating caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved, thick glass base acts like a lens, refracting and magnifying the lower part of the ball, altering its apparent shape and seam curvature.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved, thick glass base acts like a lens, refracting and magnifying the lower part of the ball, altering its apparent shape and seam curvature.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "No liquid or condensation is visible—only clear reflections—indicating the inner walls are dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"No liquid or condensation is visible—only clear reflections—indicating the inner walls are dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass has a raised, curved inner base; the ball is resting on that curved surface, not on a flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass has a raised, curved inner base; the ball is resting on that curved surface, not on a flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible warping and magnification rather than a straight, undistorted view.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible warping and magnification rather than a straight, undistorted view.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved highlights within the shadow show refracted light patterns typical of caustics.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved highlights within the shadow show refracted light patterns typical of caustics.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and water alters magnification and shifts the image, making the ball’s lower half appear distorted compared to the upper half.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and water alters magnification and shifts the image, making the ball’s lower half appear distorted compared to the upper half.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears empty with no visible water line, droplets, or condensation; the tennis ball rests on the rim, not in liquid.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears empty with no visible water line, droplets, or condensation; the tennis ball rests on the rim, not in liquid.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tennis ball is positioned near the rim and is larger than the glass opening, so it can’t be at the bottom; the yellow circle at the base is just a reflection/lighting effect.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tennis ball is positioned near the rim and is larger than the glass opening, so it can’t be at the bottom; the yellow circle at the base is just a reflection/lighting effect.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light, so the cyan background appears shifted and warped near the edges instead of perfectly uniform.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light, so the cyan background appears shifted and warped near the edges instead of perfectly uniform.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A bright curved line appears within the glass’s shadow, indicating refracted light (caustic) patterns.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A bright curved line appears within the glass’s shadow, indicating refracted light (caustic) patterns.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the thick, curved bottom of the glass magnifies and bends the image, making the lower half of the tennis ball appear distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the thick, curved bottom of the glass magnifies and bends the image, making the lower half of the tennis ball appear distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There are visible moisture streaks and droplets on the inner surface of the glass, indicating it is wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There are visible moisture streaks and droplets on the inner surface of the glass, indicating it is wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There’s a visible gap between the ball and the flat bottom; the ball is supported by the curved inner base/side of the glass rather than resting on the bottom surface.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There’s a visible gap between the ball and the flat bottom; the ball is supported by the curved inner base/side of the glass rather than resting on the bottom surface.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The cyan background appears warped and uneven through the curved glass, indicating refraction and distortion.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The cyan background appears warped and uneven through the curved glass, indicating refraction and distortion.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The shadow area appears smooth and uniform without the bright, curved light patterns characteristic of caustics.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow area appears smooth and uniform without the bright, curved light patterns characteristic of caustics.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass wall acts like a lens, refracting and magnifying the ball’s image, so the lower half appears warped compared to the part seen directly.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass wall acts like a lens, refracting and magnifying the ball’s image, so the lower half appears warped compared to the part seen directly.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears empty with no visible water, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface; only a dry ball is inside.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears empty with no visible water, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface; only a dry ball is inside.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball sits centered at the base with no visible gap; its shadow and reflections align with contact on the flat bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The ball sits centered at the base with no visible gap; its shadow and reflections align with contact on the flat bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light, visibly warping the cyan background along the glass walls.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light, visibly warping the cyan background along the glass walls.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Curved bright bands appear within the shadow, typical of refracted light caustics from a glass-like object.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Curved bright bands appear within the shadow, typical of refracted light caustics from a glass-like object.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting and magnifying the view so the lower portion of the ball appears bent and shifted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting and magnifying the view so the lower portion of the ball appears bent and shifted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass shows no water, droplets, or condensation; the interior looks clear and dry around the tennis ball.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass shows no water, droplets, or condensation; the interior looks clear and dry around the tennis ball.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tennis ball is wedged against the side of the glass and sits slightly above the flat base; a gap is visible between the ball and the bottom surface.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tennis ball is wedged against the side of the glass and sits slightly above the flat base; a gap is visible between the ball and the bottom surface.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible warping and shading changes near the edges and base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible warping and shading changes near the edges and base.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A bright curved band of light appears within the glass’s shadow, indicating refracted caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A bright curved band of light appears within the glass’s shadow, indicating refracted caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and water acts like a lens, bending light unevenly and causing the submerged portion of the ball to appear warped and shifted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and water acts like a lens, bending light unevenly and causing the submerged portion of the ball to appear warped and shifted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Water is in contact with the inner surface (visible meniscus and droplets), so the walls aren’t dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Water is in contact with the inner surface (visible meniscus and droplets), so the walls aren’t dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The yellow-green ring of the tennis ball is near the water surface, indicating it’s floating at the top, not resting on the flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The yellow-green ring of the tennis ball is near the water surface, indicating it’s floating at the top, not resting on the flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water refract the light, causing visible warping and magnification of the cyan background near the edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water refract the light, causing visible warping and magnification of the cyan background near the edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The shadow shows bright curved bands formed by light refracting through the glass, which are caustic patterns.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow shows bright curved bands formed by light refracting through the glass, which are caustic patterns.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The thick, curved base of the glass acts like a lens, refracting light and causing the lower half of the ball to appear shifted and compressed compared to the upper half.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The thick, curved base of the glass acts like a lens, refracting light and causing the lower half of the ball to appear shifted and compressed compared to the upper half.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "No visible droplets, streaks, or condensation are present; the glass appears clear and dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"No visible droplets, streaks, or condensation are present; the glass appears clear and dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is wedged against the sloped sides near the base, leaving a gap above the flat center of the bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is wedged against the sloped sides near the base, leaving a gap above the flat center of the bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible warping and bending near the sides and rim.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible warping and bending near the sides and rim.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved light patterns appear within the glass’s shadow, created by refracted light from the water (caustics).",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved light patterns appear within the glass’s shadow, created by refracted light from the water (caustics).\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved, thick glass bottom and side refract light unevenly, causing the portion of the ball seen through it to appear slightly warped and shifted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved, thick glass bottom and side refract light unevenly, causing the portion of the ball seen through it to appear slightly warped and shifted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears clear with no visible water, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears clear with no visible water, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is visibly suspended above the bottom of the glass with a clear gap and shadow, not touching the base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is visibly suspended above the bottom of the glass with a clear gap and shadow, not touching the base.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, causing slight magnification and bending near the edges and base, so it isn’t undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, causing slight magnification and bending near the edges and base, so it isn’t undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright, focused light patterns within the shadow from the glass indicate caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright, focused light patterns within the shadow from the glass indicate caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved, thick glass at the bottom acts like a lens, refracting light and warping the tennis ball’s lower half, making it appear magnified and distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved, thick glass at the bottom acts like a lens, refracting light and warping the tennis ball’s lower half, making it appear magnified and distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass walls appear clear with no visible water, condensation, or streaks inside.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass walls appear clear with no visible water, condensation, or streaks inside.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass has a concave inner base, so the ball is supported by the curved rise, not resting on a flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass has a concave inner base, so the ball is supported by the curved rise, not resting on a flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass causes refraction and reflections, creating warped bands and highlights, so the cyan background appears distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass causes refraction and reflections, creating warped bands and highlights, so the cyan background appears distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
|||||||||||||||||
0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a
|
explicit
|
Optics
|
Refraction
|
remove
|
Remove the tulips from the scene.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":462.5911330049261,"width":119.4679802955665,"x":692.5911330049261,"y(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673a(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0781_0c5d9(...TRUNCATED) |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0781_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
| "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0781_0c5d96(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0781_0c5d9(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f0(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add5(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673ad(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f0(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0780_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f0(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0780_Remove_every_part_of_the_tulips_f(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A tulip stem is (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass appears (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A white tulip bu(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A green tulip st(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A green stem-lik(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tulip’s st(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass appears (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A red tulip is p(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A tulip stem is (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A pink tulip blo(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass appears (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"Only a reflection/(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The visible green (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A tulip’s stem(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A green tulip st(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass contains(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c07773
|
explicit
|
Optics
|
Refraction
|
remove
|
Remove the glass of water from the image.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":744.4338335607096,"width":507.830832196453,"x":36.70914039447193,"y"(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc4(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c0777(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0785_0f44b(...TRUNCATED) |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0785_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
| "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0785_0f44b8(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0785_0f44b(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c0(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c077(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc43(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c077(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0784_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c077(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0784_Remove_the_tall_clear_cylindrical(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The object being h(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is no clear (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The object being h(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The object being h(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is no visibl(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The top edge of (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No glass or circul(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The top edge of (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is a person(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
1
|
explicit
|
Optics
|
Reflection
|
remove
|
Remove the vase with flowers from the table.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":260.5736782902137,"width":317.0697412823397,"x":228.63987044722856,"(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_rem(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove(...TRUNCATED) |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg
| "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1194_1_Opt(...TRUNCATED) |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/1194_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg
| "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1194_1_Opti(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1194_1_Opt(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.j(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/1193_1_Optics_Reflection_remove_edi(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/1193_Erase_the_round_ribbed_clear_glas(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy glass(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No round glass vas(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is no visibl(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"Faint circular s(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A faint circular(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The table surface (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A faint circular(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
10
|
explicit
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
remove
|
Remove the car from the image.
| [{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":256.84113300492606,"width":722.0628078817733,"x":266.7894088669952,(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_rem(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1036_10_Op(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/1036_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1036_10_Opt(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1036_10_Op(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/1035_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/1035_Erase_the_entire_red_vintage_conv(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region likel(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region conta(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
1000
|
explicit
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
remove
|
Remove the statue of the child holding grapes.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":740.4894671623297,"width":526.5982785831459,"x":156.401721416854,"y"(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagation_r(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1061_1000_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/1061_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1061_1000_O(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1061_1000_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/1060_1000_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/1060_Delete_the_entire_rightforeground(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows ab(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image is a pla(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
11
|
explicit
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
move
|
Move the ladder to the left.
| [{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":404.69215265866205,"width":506.1653945111491,"x":1.251437202865309,(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_mov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0989_11_Op(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0989_Optics_Light_Propagation_move.j(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0989_11_Opt(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0989_11_Op(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0988_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0988_Translate_the_weathered_wooden_la(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only the ladder(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder’s b(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The bottom ends (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only a portion o(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder is pa(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The bottom feet (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The lower end of(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only the upper s(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The actual ladde(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder itsel(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder is pa(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only part of the(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The photo only s(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder’s l(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image is cro(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
14
|
explicit
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
move
|
Move the glass to the left end of the table.
| [{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":786.0689655172415,"width":390.2068965517242,"x":0.7758620689654546,(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_mov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0979_14_Op(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0979_Optics_Light_Propagation_move.j(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0979_14_Opt(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0979_14_Op(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0978_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0978_Relocate_the_clear_round_glass_on(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow of th(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow of th(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The light comes (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s da(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s da(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The dark oval sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow of th(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The dark oval sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The oval shadow (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow exten(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The dark shadow (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The dark oval sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow exten(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Light appears to(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
144
|
explicit
|
Optics
|
Reflection
|
remove
|
Remove the white bowl from the table.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":205.0,"width":175.31034482758622,"x":228.39655172413788,"y":220.5517(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_r(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remove.jp(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1191_144_O(...TRUNCATED) |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/1191_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg
| "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1191_144_Op(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1191_144_O(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remove(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remove.j(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_rem(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remove.j(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/1190_144_Optics_Reflection_remove_e(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/1190_Remove_the_white_ceramic_bowl_pos(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The shiny tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy table(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy table(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The white pot’(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy table(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy table(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The shiny tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy table(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy tableto(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"Only the reflectio(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A mirrored image(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The visible bowl i(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A white textured(...TRUNCATED) |
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 27