will Peyton Manning be the best qb to ever play the game by the time his careere is over?
960970
He probably will have the best stats of any qb but if he doenst win a super bowl he will not b the best ever
836875
It will be if peyton finally leds them to the superbowl.
936788
Peyton Manning is the man!
810844
This is a very difficult question. \n\nIf you look at both side to side it is almost like looking at Joe Montana and Dan Marino. Montana, like Brady, has the Championship rings. Also, just like Montana, Brady has constantly had great coaches and a decent cast of co-players around him. \n\nManning and Marino have not had that luxury. Both Marino and Manning are regular season statical giants. Breaking pretty much every passing record, neither seemed to have the right mix of players to get through the playoffs. Also until Dungy, Manning never really had great coaching.\n\nIn truth the answer to this opinion question lies in whether or not you feel that Championships or Records make greatness.\n\nI am of the belief that records make greatness so I would CURRENTLY choose Manning as the better of the two.\n\nHowever, Brady is still very young, so the jury is still out.
434898
the greatest qb to ever play the game but its time for him to say he will play the one more year
902345
Peyton Manning is a better quarterback.  If they Colts did not have Peyton Manning, they would be a very poor team.  He has got a laser/rocket arm, he is very smart, and he is basically the team's offensive coordinator.  Brady is a very good team and he is fortunate to play around great talent and has led them to many Super Bowls.  But when all is said in done Manning will have a few Super Bowl rings.
167699
PEYTON MANNING IS BETTER.
442343
YES.....PEYTON IS A VERY SMART QB..HE JUST HAS TO RELAX AND LET HIS TRUE GAME SHINE THREW...
716551
No question - Peyton Manning. You should never bench Archie's favorite son, no matter who he's playing and who you have on the bench - he's so good that you can't risk him having a big game and missing out on it for anyone (especially someone like Romo, who could collapse any week). Even though my Giants have a really beaten down defense, Romo is no Peyton, and he never will be. If this was 5 years down the line, it might be a different story, but you can't bench the best quarterback of this generation who will probably retire as the undisputed best ever. Would you be surprised if Romo threw for 500 yards and had his second straight 5 touchdown game? Me too. But would you be surprised if Peyton did it? Me neither. (Notice I didn't even mention that Peyton was playing against one of the worst defenses in the league in the Titans - which is just icing on the cake. He's good enough that it just doesn't matter.)
850038
I don't think that you will stop seeing Peyton Manning commercials even if he doesn't win a Super Bowl. He is the greatest quarterback in the game today. It's the same reason that you see commercials with LeBron James in them... because they are just THAT good.\n\nOn a side note, yes, I am personally sick of the Peyton Manning commercials. If I was in his shoes though, I'd do every one of the commercials offered to me. I bet he makes a very nice chunk of change from doing a days work (shooting a commercial).
301090
Easy answer...Joe Montana, no question. Hall of Famer and on everyone's short list of best QB's of all time. Brady is good and if he stays healthy should have great career stats, but he'll never be a Joe Montana. And this is coming from someone who was neither a 49er's or KC fan.
666902
ofcourse. he is one of the greatest players of all time. he has the reccord for most consecutive games played (and running!!!!! you also cant forget that last year, who the hell did they have!!! besides donald driver and brett, name one player that was not injured last year!!!!!!! also, you cant forget that even though his team sucked ass, he still lead the nfc in passing yards!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! he is a beast!!!!!!!!!!! I love him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
741599
Peyton is the best QB right now definitely. He is a great QB. People always want to include team success with individual attributes. Terry Bradshaw was a decent QB that happened to be on some great teams. Winning Super Bowls doesn't make you a great QB. Look at Big Ben, how great is he? Trent Dilfer? Brad Johnson? Mark Ripien?
538313
Stats don't really matter. Favre threw for the 3rd most yards last year but the Packers were 4-12. Manning threw 49 tds and...um...o ya nothing done in the post season. Those are just a few examples that prove my point.\n\nSo you have to weight Championships alot for the Best QB of all time.  If Marino won just one Superbowl, he would be.  If he had won two or more, hands down Marino is the best Qb. But it never happened so he forever will be know as the best QB not to win a Superbowl.\nIt is funny to see how different QBs are looked at and see that if the won/lost the Superbowl how they would be looked at now.  One big one is Jim Kelly.  If he and the Bills had won those 4 SBs(Superbowls) he would be easy HOF and maybe considered One of the best QBs of all-time.  At least one would have helped him.  If the Bills would have at least won the last 2 of the 4, Troy Aikman would be a nobody.  Yes, he was "good" but many people could have been in that situation.  I'm not saying I could do it, maybe, no I couldn't.  But da Bears of 85 I sure could have won with. And yes if McMahon played in the Dolphin game they still would have lost.\nOk enough babblying from me.  \n\nSo the Best QBs has to come down to,\nBig Ben-1 (My name is Ben, so I liked him.  I never thought he'd win a superbowl so soon though)\nTom Brady-3 (unfortunatly)\nJohn Elway-2 (I hate him)\nBrett Farve-1(I hate him even though he plays on the Pack)\nTroy Aikman-3 (A cheerleader could do as good as him)\nSteve Young-1 (for some reason I thought he won more)\nJoe Montana-4 (Ok, thats why)\nJim Pluckett-2 (Didn't matter what city he played in he still won)\nTerry Bradshaw-4 (and still balding)\nRoger Staubach-2 (Aikman 3, Staubach 2, Good debate for best Cowboy QB.)\nBob Greise-2 (17-0, thats all that I can say)\nJohnny Unitas-1 (47 games in row with a TD pass, crazy)\nBart Starr-2 (9-1 in the postseason and 4 championships before the Superbowl came.)\nNo Namath, I guarrantee that he isn't the best and that I can't spell.\n\nIt's your pick but my top five are:\n5. John Elway\n4. Terry Bradshaw\n3. Tom Brady\n2.  Joe Montana\nAnd the Best QB ever is...\n1. Bart Starr\n\nJust imagine if he played today. What would he do?\n\nI hope I helped you out.
197006
DUDE TOM BRADY IS THE BEST QB PERIOD HES A CLUTCH PRFORMER IF I HAD A AN NFL TEAM HED BE MY #1 QB ID BE LOOKING FOR HES A WHAT 6TH OR 5TH ROUND PICK AND HES WHAT 10-1 IN THE PLAYOFFS I THINK AND WHAT A 2 TIME SUPER BOWL MVP DUDE BEST QB I THINK EVER AND STILL MORE TIME FOR HIM IN HIS CARRER DUDE BEST QB IN NFL EVER WHAT DOES PEYTON HAVE NO SUPER BOWL RINGS HA!!!
1174611
Peyton Manning-Marvin Harrison.  Some of the most exciting players in the game.  Too bad they cant win in the playoffs.
109590
If you mean who has the highest quarterback rating of all time is Steve Young with 96.8 (average) and in a single season is Peyton Manning with 121.1 in the 2004 season