What about Torry Holt, good player or Hall of Famer?
962901
Absolutely a hall of famer, provided he doesn't suffer a career ending injury anytime soon.\n\nSuper Bowl champ, most yards receiving during the first 8 years of a career (more than even Jerry), impossible to cover... he's well on his way.
882212
Yes he would be much better than a lot of players already in, not that is a good argument, buy Bill James' book" What is Wrong with the Hall of Fame" and that gives very good arguments for and against a lot of players Oliva included. Oliva won 3 batting titles including one in his rookie year he was the best player on some very good Twins teams better than Killebrew and Carew he was what they now call a 5 tool player run, hit, hit for power, play defense, and throw. He was arguably the best player in the AL from 1964-1971 well this is just my opinion and I am a biased Twin fan but like I said he would probably be better than at least 20 players already in, so he would not be diluting the HOF.
57570
If he wins Superbowl XL (or any in the future), hands-down Yes, Cowher in the HOF. If he never wins one, he'll retire as one the best to never put on the ring, but I think he still gets in. Two Superbowl trips, some AFC championships and countless trips and most of all (so rare these days), longevity.
412131
Though he did win back-to-back MVPs, he really only had about 5 great years, and then a bunch of average-to-good years.  Generally speaking, players in the Hall either had 9-10 fantastic years (e.g., Sandy Koufax) or 20+ good years, with a few standout years thrown in (e.g., Don Sutton)... 5 great years, while it makes for a nice career for Dale Murphy, does not reach the level of being one of the all-time greats...
822327
He is doing awesome. I dont see him winning Comeback Player of the Year as he was pretty good last year. He certainly deserves votes for the MVP, although I agree he wont win it he should get his due.It is clear that he is Pro-Bowl bound and the Saints sure look smart for signing him. Looks like you will enjoy being in the playoffs thanks to him, after all those years of suffering watching Aaron Brooks I bet it feels good.
926343
I grew up with Rickey Henderson as my favorite baseball player ever.  I loved the guy, hell i even had his book, and comic book.  OH yeah, he had a comic book.  Anyways he dominated the game, the best leadoff hitter of all time, hands down.  He should be a first ballot hall of famer.  Lets not forget his records in leadoff game home runs either.
66559
Marvin Harrison. He's not as disliked as Owens, he avoids injuries unlike Moss, and never performs any TD celebrations like TO and Johnson. Nothing is wrong with Holt, it's just that Marvin has a better QB.
478796
Julius Peppers.  His stats will never tell the story.  His teammates will reap the rewards of his greatness for a long time.  The amount of attention he deserves (and gets) allows his teammates to rack up stats.
1074665
The Cornhuskers are my pick to win the Big 12 this year...  be on the lookout for Marlon Lucky...  he's the best player in the country that eveyone may not have heard of yet...  the key word is YET!!   He's the next best thing to a Reggie Bush type of back that you'll see for a while !!!  Remember where you heard it first !!!!
977491
I'd say this is a no brainer...\nTorry Holt is St. Louis' #1 Receiver.\nDevery Henderson is at best New Orleans #3 receiver.\n\nEven with Colston's injury he's not going to get the ball as much as Holt will.\nThree weeks ago he had a huge week and followed that week up with no catches.  Last week he had a great week.  There's no way I would put a 'possible scoring threat' in as a starter.\n\nIt's fantasy football though.  Everyweek there's a different hero!
862732
Honestly? Yes.\n\nTalent wise, and comparison wise (how great he is in his time, some old players might not be able to handle the league today, with bigger, faster guys, but they were great comparitively in their own times).  \n\nHe will be the Jim Brown of his children's generation.
760041
I would say that if Terrell Davis get in, then Priest Holmes deserves it too.  Holmes didn't play that long, but he was awesome.\n\nFor more on the Chiefs and the NFL, check this site out. \nhttp://factipedia.com/sportsblogs/
801404
if you are getting torry holt and chester taylor DEFINITELY accept the trade. Holt is playing a lot better than chad johnson, and chester taylor is playing better than willie parker. Chester taylor is gonna completely DOMINATE the upcoming games, and the playoffs weeks while willie parker will get crushed. Chad Johnson will get better but now that he has a receiver of the same calibur as him in TJ Houshmanadeh Carson Palmer will pass the ball less to chad so he wont dominate.
421633
I think Reggie more than deserves a spot in the hall of fame. People will point to his lack of Championships, his lack of major awards (only three selections to NBA Third Team) but one can equally point to the fact that he is the NBA's all time leader in 3-pointers made and attempted, he is 7th in total games played with 1,323 and 14th on the all time scoring list with 24,305 points.\n\nMore importantly, Reggie was a great personality, a player known for his drive and confidence and his loyalty and his determination in 18 seasons with the Pacers. He will always be remember as one of the greatest jump shooters in the history of the game, for his clutch shots and for his never say die spirit. The NBA would have been a much lesser place without Reggie and for that reason alone he deserves to be in the hall of fame.
92713
i think that it can go 2 ways. mostly all players that were fruitloops in hig school and college end up greeat. ladian thomilson, and vick for example. and he can make nuttin out of somthin but how do we know that he is that good in the big games. he didnt do good in the rosebowl. he might be a bad fit in houston though cuz there line aint to sharp and dominc davis is great.
1186547
That's tough. I like Jim McMahon and Steve Young. They were both good in College and won Super Bowls in the NFL. I guess since Young is in the Hall of Fame, that would give him the leg up. Ty Detmer put up great numbers at BYU, but did nothing in the NFL. My heart says McMahon. My brain says Young.
417977
I like Randy Moss.  He's good.  His ability to be stupid is his downfall.  If only he would let his athleticism be his guide...what a great player he might have been.