Who out of these QBs will get into the Hall of Fame? Will any of them be Top Ten All-Time list? Who, then?
961369
HOF-\nPeyton Manning\nTom Brady\nTop 10-\nTom Brady\nPeyton Manning
647776
Brett farve isnt retired. Elway is the best because he retired  on top.
947087
My Top Ten:\n\n1.) Jim Brown\n2.) Emmitt Smith\n3.) Walter Payton\n4.) Barry Sanders\n5.) Terrell Davis\n6.) Gale Sayers\n7.) Earl Campbell\n8.) O.J. SImpson\n9.) Eric Dickerson\n10.) Tony Dorsett
781742
PHIL SIMMS? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH\nHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH\nAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. ok im done. ok now how hi were you when u wrote that response. Simms isnt even good enough to make the hall of fame. Phil simms was nothing more than a below avg qb who had the best ground game in the league and the best defense ever.o and the niners and if the niners and giants were so good in the early nineties how come the cowboys went to 4 straight nfc title games from 92 -95 and won 3 super bowls in that time? i dont even want to waste any more breath bout that ridiculous answer now as for my top three the argument usually is rings or stats u like stats u go with marino u like rings u go with montana however i think that since football is the ultamate team sport marino is better b/c if u put him on the best offense ever ( dallas of the early 90's) i think dallas would have won like 6 super bowls in 7 years not to anything away from aik he was great but marino is the best so its marino numero uno then probably montana and then i wuld have to say Elway
1066837
1. Ladanian Tomlinson\n2. Shaun Alexander\n3. Peyton Manning\n4. Steve Smith\n5. Santana Moss\n6. Larry Johnson\n7. Marvin Harrison\n8. (sleeper picks) Joe Horn, I think with Drew Brees as QB, he will get involved in a lot of his passes.\n9. (sleeper picks) Drew Bledsoe, with Terrell Owens, Terry Glenn, and Jason Witten, Bledsoe is going 2 get a lot of passing yards.\n10. (sleeper picks) Kurt Warner, with his great WR core, he's also going to get a lot of passing yards and PTDs.
606788
Oh get a grip to people picking active QBs, espically ones like Brady. I can't pick a greatest of all time. You have different eras and changes in the game. Now that said I would say Dan Marino would always be on the list of the best. This despite never winning the Superbowl, and only going once. That proves how much better he is then these ones that do nothing but go to the Superbowl. After all who would know who those guys are if they weren't going?
383657
Chad Jackson, Tom Brady has his 3 rings without a good primary receiver, if Chad Jackson turns into the likes of Harrison/Holt, New England will finally have a fav. 3 like the Colts "had" in Manning/Harrison/James. Also if New Englands defense gets back to what made it great, watch out for them!
953199
Brett Favre...only one of the best QBs ever and his personality, love for the game, and family history make him a fan favorite who can easily be related to.
812294
Both of them will go into the Hall of Fame.  Brady due to 3 Super Bowl wins and Manning due to breaking almost every QB record besides a few still held by Marino.  Like another person mentioned.  It's going to depend on which one retires first.  Brady's arm has been hurting him all season, so he might be the first of the two to retire.  However, all it takes is one wrong hit or fall to put a QB out of commission.  Both quarterbacks are pretty durable, but I'd have to give Manning an edge as far as durability.  He has yet to miss a game or hardly even a play due to injuries.  More likely that not, they'll probably get initiated the same year, knowing how the rivalry is between them and how they are good friends.
280261
Doesn't matter...He'll always be a legend!!  I saw "8 Men Out".  That movie and others ("Field of Dreams") keep him legendary.  Hall of Fame or not...He'll never be forgotten.
1097739
QB- Tom Brady\nRB- Larry Johnson\nTE- Antonio Gates\nWR- Steve Smith
947963
QB- Peyton Manning(Already broke a record this week, fastest to reach 3,000 completions and also youngest to reach it.)\nWR-Chad Johnson(Great player and i think he could break alot of records)\nWR-Marvin Harrison(Already broke a record with Peyton, i think they can break more)\nRB-Ladainian Tomlinson(The best RB in the past couple of years hes just pure good.)\nRB-Larry Johnson(Leads the league in rushing yards, and is still young he will be a great player breaking records.)\nTE-Marques Colston(Just a rookie and is doing great, he should be a great player.)\nSafety-Sean Taylor\nCB-Ronde Barber\nLB-Brian Urlacher\nDE-Julius Peppers
1159878
ladainian Tomlinson?! yeah right. It has to be Brett favre. The man is one of the greatest QBs in history. He should already be in the hall of fame but he hasn't retired yet. he has so many records and will go down in history somewhere in the top 10 best QBs ever list. I'm sorry but Ladainian has nothing on Brett Favre. In fact marshall faulk in his prime was way better than tomlinson ever was.
811258
Heres the list of CURRENT starting QB's with the number #9.\n\n1.  Steve McNair - Ravens\n2.  Carson Palmer - Bengals\n3.  Charlie Frye - Browns\n4.  David Garrard - Jags\n5.  Tony Romo - Boys\n6.  Drew Brees - Saints
543468
It has to be Manning. He has broken a bunch of records. Tom Brady has the rings, but that does not make him a better quarterback. What Tom Brady had was a better team overall.
450304
Bill Gates, Paul Allen...but since this is a football section, Warren Moon (first black QB in the NFL to be inducted to the NFL Hall of Fame)  Shaun Alexander, NFL MVP this last season...those could be some good candidates dont ya think?
930521
Brady Quinn will be the first one.  There has been so much hype around him.\nb