WHAT do you think NOW? NAY SAYERS?? Mnning or Brady? Who's the best QB?
960216
Sorry...had to comment....but I am defiantly not a nay sayer.  I am a woman who does not like to watch football that much.... GUESS what......I LOVE TO WATCH PEYTON MANNING.. Why? Is he gorgeous....no....HE IS ONE OF THE MOST TALENTED Quarterbacks I have ever seen.  Ok you are thinking what does a woman who hardly ever watches football know...well maybe you are right, but the fact that he is the only quarterback that actually holds my attention says a lot to me.  Passing games are much more exciting to watch than say the Falcons running games (ha ha)  especially when the ball is caught because it was thrown right where it needed to be.
769495
I didn't want to be the devil's advocate on this one, but I will.  (My first choice would've been Tom Brady for his leadership skills, and modesty)  Just for fun, I'll go defense, since nobody has (yet anyway), and say Brian Urlacher.  If you saw him dictate the game against the Giants yesterday, you were able to see what kind of a leader and player he was.  Forever in my mind will be the fake field goal touchdown he scored against Washington a few years back.  Simply amazing.
706733
Brady as much as I hate recommending a UM  player.\nDoesnt matter the DEF Brady always seems to come through with great numbers.\nBrooks? NO WAY! Reason, RAIDERS. Nuff said\nPennington? like the matchup, but very unreliable\n\nGood Luck
971931
Ben Watson\n\nHe has Tom Brady!
845556
McNabb is averaging the most fantasy points among the mentioned and plays the Titans..Brady seems to be in a bit of a slide..but hey he gets to beat up on the packers secondary..they are horrible....i hate grossman..he plays the toughest D of the 3\n\ni would start McNabb...been winning me matchup after matchup this season for fantasy..but Brady isn't that bad of a choice either..either way you should outscore your opponent in that particular slot
741451
Tom Brady!!. Peyton Manning is Mr. regular season but, Brady is Mr. January when it counts.
1108495
Since when is Rex Grossman an established NFL QB?  Let's see him stay on the field for a full season first before we make any judgements as to his ability.  Their defense is good but it's not like their '85 team which truly was one of the best ever.  Given the weakness of the NFC North, however, they should repeat as division champs.
714310
Based on stats, I'd probably go with:\n\n Brady because he is playing Green Bay, last in yards given up passing.  However, you always have to worry about the weather up there.\n\nNext, probably McNabb.- playing at home against a so-so Jets pass defense.\n\nAnd that leaves Grossman.\n\nNow you know the way this works, don't you (I sure do).  They guy you don't pick throws for 400 yards and 4 tds, the guy you pick gets a jammed finger on the first play and sits out the game!
834649
I would pick up Garcia if you can.  He is a smart veteran that makes good decisions in a west coast offense.  And he played well last week despite the loss and not much time to prepare.  Philly plays well at home in primetime.  Miami has been killing people lately and I would never start Johnson, especially against Chicago coming off a loss.  They will be pissed off and the Vikings will pay for it.  I like Reche Caldwell as he has become a favorite of Tom Brady lately and New England has a terrible Lions team.  Brady may throw for 3 or more scores.
710295
Tom Brady is a fine QB\n\nThe future is cloudy for Mr Brady ... If his offensive line is health he will put up good numbers for a bunch more years (meaning he will put number up in the 3000 yard seasons) with Laurence Maroney there now he will be able to hand the ball off more ... \n\nIf your wondering if you should keep Brady in a keeper league ... normally people only keep one or two players ... if he is your very best player then I say keep him\n\nGood Luck
841775
I started Rex Grossman and my Chicago D against the Phins' and benched Tom Brady (Phily D was on bye week) and than what happens...they F%*&%#* loose? Thats like the Colts getting beat at home against the Raiders, hell the Phins' must have loaded themselves up with lots of steroids or something. But, I lost hope in the Bears I hope they loose every game from now on for the next few hundered pathic years of their exiestance, totaly unacceptable. The Bears are full of C$%&*#@ Sucking Losers!\n\nBefore Mamai: 7-0-0\n\nAfter Mamami: 7-1-0\n\nHopefully for the rest of the pathetic season: 7-9-0\n\nCedric Benson is a bust\n\nThomas Jones is a bust\n\nRex Grossman, the Florida QB curse continues...\n\n:(\n\n\nR.I.H. (Rest In Hell)\n\nChicago Bears
156521
Joe Montana\nSteve Deberg (check this guy out some time he played behind 5 HOFers)\nTom Brady.
742042
Joe Cool, Comeback Joe Montana, The Comeback Kid\n\nI hate to be the one to point it out, but Joe Montana won FOUR SBs, not three! (SB XVI, SB XIX, SB XXIII and SB XXIV) He won the MVP in THREE SBs. Joe NEVER threw an interception during ANY SB, EVER!\n\nSome of the younger generation who never saw Joe play simply look at statistics and argue about who was better, for the vast majority of those of us who lived through the Monana Legend, there is no discussion possible. For those who have witnessed Joe step up to the line with that easy smile on his face at his own 20 yard line with 1:20 left in a Conference Championship with the 49ers trailing, then move them down the field and score the game winner as easily as you or I walking to the front door........\n\nCris Collinsworth a wide receiver for the Cincinnati Bengals who lost twice in the SB to Montana may have said it best: \n\n"I don't want to call him a god, .......but he's not human either."\n\n(Yeah, absolutely, Greatest QB Ever, without doubt.)
723603
Ya gotta love Palmer right? Not this week, not against the Raven defense.\n\nYou go with the hot hand. I'm not a Vick fan, but he's hot and Palmers not.\n\nFrank C
383657
Chad Jackson, Tom Brady has his 3 rings without a good primary receiver, if Chad Jackson turns into the likes of Harrison/Holt, New England will finally have a fav. 3 like the Colts "had" in Manning/Harrison/James. Also if New Englands defense gets back to what made it great, watch out for them!
301090
Easy answer...Joe Montana, no question. Hall of Famer and on everyone's short list of best QB's of all time. Brady is good and if he stays healthy should have great career stats, but he'll never be a Joe Montana. And this is coming from someone who was neither a 49er's or KC fan.
401148
Matt Leinart--he is more ready to be an NFL quarterback, based on his work ethic, smarts, and ability to read defenses.  \n\nWhy not to take Vince Young:\n1) mechanics are terrible\n2) shotgun QB--offenses in the NFL don't do this, Alex Smith was the latest shotgun QB to come out, and look how he's doing.  i want to see him take 3 and 4 step drops and consistently hit guys on 15 -20 yard outs.\n3) his athleticism hurts him--he tries to be like michael vick, but he's not NEARLY the athlete vick is.  he won't be able to run in the NFL like he did in college.  his coach in college, Mack Brown, said "he does better when we stop coaching him and let his athleticism take over".  bad news if you're an NFL coach looking to teach a young guy the basics of the NFL game.\n4) he's a coward--he is the QB with the most skepticism about him in the draft, and he refused to work out at the combine.  rather he held his own workout, at his own field, with his own receivers.  that's not a good sign for me if i'm a scout looking to see VY compared to everyone else in the draft\n5) he's a dunce--scoring a 6 and a 16 on the Wonderlic exam.  i realize intelligence isn't everything, but it is the way the game is shifting.  look at the QB's to make the playoffs last season: Manning, Palmer, Brady, Roethlisberger, Leftwich, Plummer, Hasselbeck, Delhomme, Simms, Brunell, Manning, Grossman.  All intelligent, drop-back passers.  VY's type of QB is not a winning type in the league.\n\nFor all of those reasons, you almost have to choose AGAINST Vince rather than choose FOR someone else.  \n\nand for all the Young-lovers, get over the Rose Bowl performance (against a swiss cheese USC D), and accept that he will STRUGGLE in the NFL.  this is big boy football now...