My predictions for Tom Brady and Peyton Manning's career end stats: Anything you would change?
960873
Sure there are questions, especially for Manning who has yet to win a SB.  Stats are great but they are only one measure of a career.  Until Manning at least even gets to a SB, regardless of his talent and stats, there will be a huge question mark on his career.
1070931
Not a chance.  Tom Brady is a product of a good offensive system.  He is not that great a QB.
784218
Peyton has the better stats so far.  In the long run, much will depend on the teams they are surrounded by.
847095
who are you comparing these guys to?..Manning will go down in history as one the greats..Brady and McNabb (maybe) will likely join him in the hall of fame..outside them there isn't much..but little Manning and Palmer could be in the same breathe as them in a handful of years\n\nthese guys are still with their original teams..unless you count the draft of Eli as a charger..but remember Elway wasn't drafted by Denver
1092482
Everyone though that Dan Marino's single season passing TD record would stand for decades until Peyton Manning took the title a couple years ago.  Records will fall at one point or another.  The career rushing record is no different.  \n\nEmmitt Smith ended his career with 18355 yards over 15 seasons (avg:  1223.7 yards/season)\n\nThat is an impressive total.  However, there are a few younger lions that could eclipse that mark within 15 seasons or sooner, depending on personal success and health.  The following players will show their current total, average, and projected estimated yardage after 15 years using their given average.\n\n1) Shaun Alexander:  6 seasons @ 7817 yards; 1302.82 yards / season; 19543 career yards\n2) LaDainian Tomlinson:  5 seasons @ 7316 yards; 1472.2 yards / season; 22083 career yards \n3) Curtis Martin:  11 seasons @ 14101 yards; 1281.9 yards / season; 19229 career yards \n4) Edgerrin James:  7 seasons @ 9226 yards; 1318 yards / season; 19770 career yards\n5) Clinton Portis:  4 seasons @ 5930 yards; 1482.5 yards / season; 22238 career yards\n\nJust using averages, Emmitt Smith's rushing record will not stand for long against runners like these guys.  There are also other notables who could sneak up and have huge seasons to give themselves a shot at the title like Larry Johnson, Rudi Johnson, Ronnie Brown, Carnell Williams, Domanick Davis, and so on.  \n\nIt will fall, and it will fall far down the rankings the longer football is played.
20567
To add fuel to the debate here. I believe if both Teams were to play with current stats then the bears would lose. But think about this for a minute The colts who were favored for the superbowl last year were eliminated by the patriots last year in the playoffs. So strange things can happen.
831329
I agree. Peyton has done nothing special all year except set some records for QB/WR combos. L.T is the one who just set a record for most touchdowns in a 5 game span with 15 touchdowns. L.T. is clearly the MVP of this season.
753860
to justin, brady has 3, count em, 3 interceptions tonite! and no td's. wow this really proves everyone's point that brady is better than manning. you guys rlly need to check the box score. and also realize the fact that manning holds a freakin NFL record.\n\nso what if brady has 3 rings. the pats were an all around team then. i'd still rather have peyton who's in his prime.
772070
LMAO...the very first person to answer felt compelled to bring up Brady's 3 SB rings!  OMG....why do Pats fans use ttht as some kind of symbol of greatness?  TRENT DILFER AND DOUG WILLIAMS!  NUFF SAID!\n\nTo answer your question though...Brees is the better QB this season.
810844
This is a very difficult question. \n\nIf you look at both side to side it is almost like looking at Joe Montana and Dan Marino. Montana, like Brady, has the Championship rings. Also, just like Montana, Brady has constantly had great coaches and a decent cast of co-players around him. \n\nManning and Marino have not had that luxury. Both Marino and Manning are regular season statical giants. Breaking pretty much every passing record, neither seemed to have the right mix of players to get through the playoffs. Also until Dungy, Manning never really had great coaching.\n\nIn truth the answer to this opinion question lies in whether or not you feel that Championships or Records make greatness.\n\nI am of the belief that records make greatness so I would CURRENTLY choose Manning as the better of the two.\n\nHowever, Brady is still very young, so the jury is still out.
912855
Although Glenn will get less catches, since Romo is the QB, Romo did spread the ball around quite a bit.  On the other hand, Brady spreads the ball around quite a bit as well, so either way I think you'll come out the same.  Both receivers will probably get around 5 catches and anywhere from 50-75 yards, and maybe a score.  It sucks not having a premier #1 receiver doesn't it?  I myself had Gabriel, and at first he looked like he would be Brady's go-to guy, but his numbers weren't consistent at tall, so i dropped him.
1097739
QB- Tom Brady\nRB- Larry Johnson\nTE- Antonio Gates\nWR- Steve Smith
590475
It's hard to say that he'll have more than Brady, for two simple reasons: 1. He's already 2 behind, and Brady has at least 7-10 years left in him. 2. Since they both play in the AFC, the odds they potentially meet in the playoffs are good at least a couple more times throughout their careers, and if Brady beats Ben more often than not, that'll hurt Ben's chances of getting those 2 rings (or perhaps more in future years) to catch Brady.
961369
HOF-\nPeyton Manning\nTom Brady\nTop 10-\nTom Brady\nPeyton Manning
957020
I hope its Peyton.  Getting tired of hearing about Tom Brady.  \n\nBrady is a superbowl winning QB yes, but has won exactly zero superbowls without Charlie Weiss.  And all three superbowl wins were by a margin of only 3 points - not exactly blow out great performances in any of them by Brady.  He has been the beneficiary of a great system, like Phil Simms was with the Giants, and Kurt Warner was with Rams. Tom is very good, I give him that certainly, but all this talk of him being an elite, one of the greatest ever QBs who should be in the Hall of Fame, that is way, way overdone.
962219
Tom Brady knows one thing and one thing only, "JUST WIN". He doesn't care about his own stats, QB passer rating, completion percentages etc. He'll do what it takes to win a game. Peyton Manning is a better QB based on numbers and stats. But if I compare them intuitively, I favor Tom Brady over Peyton Manning because he just wins. Also another thing to note is Bill Belichick is the key reason for Tom Brady's success. If Bill Belichick was coacing Peyton Manning, Peyton will keep winning every Super Bowl. Reading from my comments you'll see that I adore both Tom Brady & Peyton Manning.
751809
Sorry dude but NEITHER!\n Peyton Manning is da man!