which Manning?  Eli or Peyton? ( eli is hotter )?
970655
there both good qb's, peyton obviously a little better then eli at this point in his career, but if your asking who's hotter then i have to go with none of the above.  I'm more into Urlacher personally.
850532
Never bench Manning.  Are you crazy??
844693
Peyton Manning for sure, actually, Reggie Wayne, Joseph Addai and Nick Harper
34725
Peyton Manning. No one else can read defenses like him.
97349
2 time MVP Peyton Manning.
820892
Not a fan here!!  I am with you on the "I don't want to play for the Chargers" thing when he was drafted.  To me Philip Rivers is a much better QB than Eli and this is Rivers' first year of actually getting to play some, Eli's been starting since he was drafted.  It just made me think that Eli thinks he is something really special and can get his way just because of his last name.  I much rather watch Philip Rivers (I remember when he was at my favorite college team, NC State!).  Besides I am a die hard Dallas Cowboys fan and don't care for the Giants at all!!!
962219
Tom Brady knows one thing and one thing only, "JUST WIN". He doesn't care about his own stats, QB passer rating, completion percentages etc. He'll do what it takes to win a game. Peyton Manning is a better QB based on numbers and stats. But if I compare them intuitively, I favor Tom Brady over Peyton Manning because he just wins. Also another thing to note is Bill Belichick is the key reason for Tom Brady's success. If Bill Belichick was coacing Peyton Manning, Peyton will keep winning every Super Bowl. Reading from my comments you'll see that I adore both Tom Brady & Peyton Manning.
785320
Manning will be the better QB in the long run. They need a healthy WR core to prove it. Look at his stats last year. He has a ton of potential.
831329
I agree. Peyton has done nothing special all year except set some records for QB/WR combos. L.T is the one who just set a record for most touchdowns in a 5 game span with 15 touchdowns. L.T. is clearly the MVP of this season.
1169751
If Peyton can't get there, Eli certainly can't.  Go Skins!
1161520
The manning bros are so goofy i wish they would keep the camera out of their face.  Even if peyton won no one would care because finding a colt fan is like finding a buffalo nickel.  There are huge superstar brothers who played against each other in the nfc champ a few years ago in t he barber brothers.
51957
Colts vs Giants.  I would love to see the Manning brothers face off in the Super Bowl.
1161198
i like the colts\n\npeyton manning is awesome
1060837
well he isn't hot,but hes cute.and i would agree with the other answer.Benji madden is a lot hotter,hes sexy.
839818
ladanian tomlinson, for QB peyton manning.
741599
Peyton is the best QB right now definitely. He is a great QB. People always want to include team success with individual attributes. Terry Bradshaw was a decent QB that happened to be on some great teams. Winning Super Bowls doesn't make you a great QB. Look at Big Ben, how great is he? Trent Dilfer? Brad Johnson? Mark Ripien?
753860
to justin, brady has 3, count em, 3 interceptions tonite! and no td's. wow this really proves everyone's point that brady is better than manning. you guys rlly need to check the box score. and also realize the fact that manning holds a freakin NFL record.\n\nso what if brady has 3 rings. the pats were an all around team then. i'd still rather have peyton who's in his prime.