New York Giants got Eli Manning in a deal where San Diego got Phillip Rivers and draft picks Merriman, Kaeding
920778
Even without Merriman and Kaeding (who are both the leading Pro  Bowl vote getters for their positions), this was a bad deal.  Rivers not only has more physical talent (better arm, quicker release, more mobile), but he's already a better leader and makes better decisions with the football than Manning.  Eli will never be more than a great quarterback's lesser brother/son.
862249
Yeah, San Deigo will win 27-17, The second best player on the team behind LT is easily Antonio Gates, The third best is Phillip Rivers
914526
I am from Indiana, but I have been a NY Giants fan for as long as I can remember.\n\nIn all honesty, I think Peyton Manning is the best quarterback that I have ever *personally* watched play (including the games I have seen on television). With that said, I would say at least 5 years and at most 10 years. I also think that he will stay in Indianapolis until the day he calls it quits.
1123128
"Cadillac" Williams (RB- Tampa Bay) -  for the offensive rookie of the year and Shawne Merriman (LB - San Diego) -  for the  defense
810437
It may seem like I am a front runner, but I think Colts beat NY Giants.\n\n\nThe Colts have too many offensive weapons, and even when there defense looked bad, they beat the Patriots and put up a good defensive effort there.  Besides that, Manning has now shown he can play in any condition, at any time, with any score.  He is showing unparalled skill\n\nThe Giants and Bears will probably have a rematch for the NFC championship, and I think that the Giants will win this time.  The Bears will fall apart in the second half, with Eli Manning actually doing well down the stretch and leading his team to victory.\n\nIn the finals, Eli will semi-choke and Peyton will struggle against a very good NY Giants defense.  However, Peyton has shown he can beat any team and any defense, and he will put out a good performance, enough for his team to win by a toughdown or two.
480701
New York Giants. That have fixed all of their holes and the only minor problems i see is their o-line only because Eli Manning is still young a needs time in the pocket since he is imoble, if Eli takes his game to the next level the Giants can pull off one of the greatest seasons you will see. The team also has probably the best defense in football. Their D-Line will be untouchable due to their ends, LaVar and pierce will be impossible to get past and they have Webster, Madison and McQuarters as CBs. Their only defensive problem is their safetys. The are young (inexperienced),  not very potentialized but they can grab a safety in the draft. I really like the Giants this year and if they can avoid injuries they will do great.
938155
Jake Delomme because Eli Manning has that beautiful last name. A quarterback with a laser, rocket arm.
949761
Very hard pick, especially between Gates and Gonzalez. Both have been great blockers and reliable targets forever.  Maybe Tony Gonzalez has been more important to the Chiefs than Gates has been to the Chargers.
879128
yeah because they are getting it togethor now and manning barely won his last few games....Plus they have T.O Terry Glenn,Romo, and a good d
959900
philip rivers might be one of the most underrated players in the NFL, dudes pretty damn good, definetley one of the top five qb's right now if you ask me
128284
gah!  I don't see why.  Eli and Peyton are a couple of crybabys.  And I wouldn't be surprised if they got it from their dad.  (Wasn't it Archie who advised Eli to throw a fit if the Chargers drafted him?)
871671
Dallas D......The giants line is awful as well is Manning.....5sacks 2 TO's and a TD...........
379761
Peyton Manning from Indianapolis on offense and Ed Reed from Baltimore on defense.
13880
Shawn  (Lites Out) Merriman  San Diego Chargers Having a big impact on San Diego's Defence!
1159673
New York Giants\n\nReason: Tiki Barber (The Real League MVP)
57554
Rivers should be given a chance to play for a couple reasons: 1. If you never play him, then what was the point of taking Eli? So you could get Nate Kaeding with the Giants' third round pick? Or 2. You can't just release Rivers (once again, you would've wasted your time on draft day), so if you trade him, what is he worth? Why would another team give you talent for Rivers, they've never seen him play.
167699
PEYTON MANNING IS BETTER.