What is your list of top 5 QBs in the last 10 years?
931789
If you said the last 15 years I would have put Montana #5:\n\n1.) John Elway - does what ever it takes to win. Not as wild as Favre\n\n2.) Brett Favre - a close 2nd\n\n3.) Dan Marino - best passer of all time...although not all there with playmaking\n\n4.) Troy Aikman - very good in all categories and outstanding in none\n\n5.) Peyton Manning - A good play caller and passer, but really can't make a play if the original play isn't there.\n\nAlthough, if I had to pick a QB for my team with current NFL QBs I would choose either Tom Brady or Donovan McNabb
636362
1. Aaron Brooks-he will shine this year with the great receiving core around him in Oakland\n2. Chris Simms-has been playing fairly well \n3. David Carr\n4. JP Losman\n5. Charlie Frye
773575
QB - Bulger\nRB - Julius Jones\nWR - Holmes and Stallworth
370840
1. Tiger Woods\n   2. Michael Schumacher\n   3. Peyton Manning\n   4. Michael Jordan\n   5. Shaquille O'Neal\n   6. Kevin Garnett\n   7. Andre Agassi\n   8. David Beckham\n   9. Alex Rodriguez\n  10. Kobe Bryant
558536
1. Larry Johnson\n2. Shawn Alexander\n3. Ladanian Tomlinson\n4. Tiki Barber\n5. Clinton Portis\n6. Rudi Johnson\n7. Lamont Jordan\n8. Carnell Williams\n9. Willis McGahee\n10. Steven Jackson\n\nIf Philadelphia runs the ball more like they say they are going to, Brian Westbrook could be on that list, but we'll have to wait and see.
1097755
1. Joe Montana\n2. Johnny Unitas\n3. Dan Marino\n4. John Elway\n5. Steve Young
668792
In no particular order.\n1. Chauncy Billups\n2. Tayshawn Prince\n3. Ben Wallace\n4. Rasheed Wallace\n5. Richard "Rip" Hamiliton\n6. Antoinio McDyess\n7. Lindsey Hunter
251045
Vick, McNabb, Culpepper, Brees and McNair have no right to be lumped with Brady, Favre and Manning. \n\nThe EASY answer is Manning, hands down.\n\nVick is seriously over rated as a QB. He cannot stay healthy and will NEVER be a top QB. He should move to flanker now.\n\nBrees has had two good years and is a good QB. \n\nCulpepper showed what he was made of last year.\n\nMcNair is a warrior who is a very good QB but not worthy of consideration here and not even when he WAS in his prime.\n\nFavre, one of the GREAT ones whose time has passed.\n\nMcNabb - no thanks\n\nBrady - Just Win Baby - a true leader but still a notch below Manning\n\nBetter than some of the ones you listed: Palmer (as stated above) and Hasselbeck are the future of the NFL.
971210
top 3 in nfc. top 5 in nfl.
418295
1.Ryan Leaf\n2.Tony Mandarich\n3.Kijana Carter\n4.Dan Wilkinson\n5.Heath Shuler\n6.Andre Ware\n7.Jeff George\n8.Steve Emtman\n9.Brian Bozworth\n10.Dave Klinger\n11.Akili Smith\n12.Tim Couch
1006942
1 LaDanian Tomlinson  - No Weakness\n2 Shaun Alexander - The Best Rusher\n3 Larry Johnson - Entering the Prime of his Career\n4Clinton Portis - Suffers from Joe Gibbs lack of running something other than the Counter Trey\n5 Edgerrin James - Great Back on an up and coming team\n6 Priest Holmes - Reaching the end of his career\n7Steven Jackson - Will get the ball more with Martz gone.\n8 Tiki Barber - Great back, fumbles too much.\n9 Jalmal Lewis - Wasn't in prison this summer will make a comeback\n10 Duece McAlister - Fast back and has some competition for this job this year.
1040638
Walter Payton's last year in the league was 1987, truly disqualifying him from this question.\n\nAlso, if the question was from 1980, LT (Lawrence Taylor) would have to be on the list, but his 1st year in the league was 1981, which takes off 28 of his career sacks.\n\nI think you really have to look at as who has changed the game the most since 1985 and here are my top 6, in no particular order.\n\n1. John Elway\n2. Lawrence Taylor\n3. Deion Sanders\n4. Barry Sanders (sorry, Payton played too many years b4 1985, Marshall Faulk may be a better fit).\n5. Reggie White\n6. Jerry Rice\n\nIf you look at the NFL today, teams are still looking for these types of players at those specific positions: A QB that can lead, throw, and run; a LB that can blitz, tackle, and cover; a CB that can outrun anyone, intercept the ball, and play special team; a RB that can be the focal point of the running game and do all of the little things; a DE that just can't be stopped, but can stop the run and the pass; and a WR that could catch an anvil dropped off of the top of the Statue of Liberty, run tight routes, and beat the defender.
1001314
1, Randy Moss\n2. Chad Johnson\n3. Steve Smith\n4. Terral Owens\n5. Marvin Harrison
614535
I have to say Bengals. \n\n     Chad Johnson- Top 3 reciever in the league great hands. His crazy speed. His ability to run routes. His love for the game. His heart his competiveness. \n     \n      Rudi Johnson-  Great Young back this year should be around the top ten. \n\n       Carson Palmer-   Amazing young quartback i think he is second best under Peyton Manning right now. HIs arm his acuracy amazing. Wow he is going to be the best in the upcoming years. \n\n                 Mr Jones had one i didnt think of with the steelers. I just dont think the Big Ben is a Top Ten QB yet he will be but he did absoluetly terrible in the Super bowl and average in the playoffs. The only reason they won is because Shawn Alexander and Matt Hassle Back and the Rest of Seattle must have been sleeping or something they werent doin nutin. But Parker is a great young back and Ward is a top 5 or 10 reciever. \n \n         \n\n       If you counted Tight Ends as WR i would say Chiefs. With Green, Priest Holmes, and Gonzalez
741599
Peyton is the best QB right now definitely. He is a great QB. People always want to include team success with individual attributes. Terry Bradshaw was a decent QB that happened to be on some great teams. Winning Super Bowls doesn't make you a great QB. Look at Big Ben, how great is he? Trent Dilfer? Brad Johnson? Mark Ripien?
958731
Tom Brady\nP.Manning\nCarson Palmer\nDonovan Mcnabb\nAnd heres a shocker.. Matt Hasselback\n\nTHose are the 5 best QBs in league i think. Vick i like, as well as Breese and Delhomme and E.Manning..but i htink those are the 5 best. Rex Grossman does not deserve to be mentioned with any of these guys i named.... Half a season does not make you one of the 5 or even ten best QBs in league.\n\n think you need to take OUT breese and put Mcnabb in there. Breese has not done the things Donovan has statistically. Besides, if the eagles had a running game and could kill the clock, they might actually be 7-0 lol... Mcnabb has carried them most of the year.\n\nMost of you people are bats**t. Rex Grossman, Phillip Rivers, Damon Huard? LOL these are guys you want to list in the 5 best QBs in the NFL LMAO! Wow. I guess 7 games makes you elite.... MORONS!!  I think i even saw a Tony Romo sumwhere on here LMAO omg! jeeeezzz ,, Marc Bulger has done more in his career than Damon Huard, Rex Grossman, Phillip Rivers and the immortal Tony Romo lol. sumtimes i wonder if sum of you people are being serious or messin around.
1175277
That is a totally opinionated answer.  There is no set best 25 QB's in the NFL