Better NFL player, Troy Smith or Brady Quinn?
929208
Brady Quinn because he has seen more complex defenses and he knows what he's doing; that little spin pass by Smith won't work in the NFL as it does against teams like Northwestern
956830
I think he could be a bust in the NFL if not picked by the right team.  Quinn needs to be drafted by a team where he can sit on the bench for 2-3 years and have the right QB coach.  Take what happened to him at ND.  He was floundering big time until Charlie Weiss became the head coach.  That being said, I think he will go in the first round, early second round if he doesn't do well at the combine.
376943
Jim Brown or Walter Payton.
881691
Brady Quinn guy. They need someone to throw to Moss
784364
If you choose anything other than Romo you are high. Chicago's DEF is miles above Tampa's and Romo & the Cowboys are clicking. Brady is good, but Chicago's DEF is better.
839992
It may have been Troy Smith's worst performance, but if a qb's worst performance included over 500 yards offense-over 330 yards passing and 4 tds against the No.2 defense in the nation as well as the second ranked team in the nation I would say nobody else would come close to even being considered. \n\nYou might focus on a couple mistakes but the rest of us have seen the results over an 11 game span.
347650
Warren Moon was 10 times better than both of them....but I would say McNabb is the better QB, although I think Vick is probably more athletic.
699219
Maroney. They just put new turf on the Razor (Gillette Stadium) and it's the same stuff that he ran on in college last year. So he will be better. Dillon is also starting to get banged up...\n\nYoung. When it comes to their two teams, I just feel as though the Titans are more cohesive than the Cardinals. Uh, is there a third choice here?? :)\n\nTommy Boy (uh, Brady) He's always amazing down the stretch... whereas, yes, Vick can run, but he is an up and down QB... even at his worst, Brady is better than Vick...\n\nEli really does have potential, but Alex Smith is looking pretty good this season too... this is the only one that's a toss up for me... But, you can't go wrong with a Manning, so I'll say Eli...\n\nAny other questions ;) (Just kidding...)
1182740
Randy Moss hands down has the most raw talent.  The guy doesnt even try and he still can dominate. If he wasnt such a punk he could be one of the greats.\n\nSteve Smith has always been a good producer but after last year he joined the elite group of receivers in the NFL.  He proves that you dont have to be the biggest guy on the field to succeed as long as you play hard.\n\nT.O.  is kind of hard to figure out.  We all know he is a great receiver.  He is fast, strong and tough to bring down but you cant make him the best due to the problems he creates on teams.  He does work hard and have lots of talent though.\n\nMarvin Harrison is a great reciever that is the epitomy of team player.  This guy goes to work to get his job done.  He doesnt complain.  He doesnt hold out or bash his teammates.  He simply plays hard and produces results.  He has been doing it consistently his whole career.\n\nTory Holt needs to be on this list.  He has been stellar in this league for a long time.  He can blow a game wide open with his speed and pass catching ability.  The only knock on Tory is that he has always had top offensive weapons around him making his job easier.\n\nHines Ward.  He is considered underrated by most but has slowly been getting his due.  He is a great possession receiver and could be the best blocking receiver in the NFL.  He also consistently produces and helped his team in many ways win the super bowl.\n\nChad Johnson.  He is an interesting character with awesome talent.  This guys self confidence alone scares defenses.  Some people frown upon his antics but it is good for the league.  He is young enough where he can go down as one of the greats if he keeps playing at this level.  Not to mention having Carson Palmer throwing to him.  These two could go down as one of the best qb, wr combos ever.
48747
While it is still way too early to tell for sure ...It is not too early to state that \n\nAlex Smith actually saw some significant playing time this year and was disturbingly bad. He completed more TD passes to the opposing team than to his own team (which is not very difficult when you have not completed any TD passes to your own team, BTW). \n\nAaron Rodgers hardly saw the field while backing up Favre, but gets my vote by default. He would maintain this lead just be demonstrating the ability to successfully handle a snap and not give the opposing team the ball in an unbelievably stunning and quick manner...
927694
Ohio St. QB Tippy Dye in the 1930's...and Troy Smith if he gets it done today
657736
I would go with Notre Dame because they have the Heisman winner Brady Quinn.  They also return their leading rusher, receiver and their leading interception man.  There are questions about their Defense but since they return all 4 DB's they should have some trouble but not as much.  Brady Quinn is as good of a QB as Vince Young if not better. Jeff samardizja is the best WR in the game and Darius walker will have his 3rd 1000 yrd rushing season.  Look for the Irish to destroy the Nittany Lions, Wolverines, the pathetic Trojans and beat Oklahoma (that's right OK) in the national championship in TEMPE ARIZONA.
707997
Must go with pennigton. Look at what the bills did to Houston last week and the jets are way better than the bills. Pennington is going to eat houston alive.
740855
they aren't the same type of qb. Smith is much more patient in the pocket. He can run but is a good passer. Vick is more run first.\nSmith is only 6'1 so that will hurt him in getting drafted. We'll just have to wait and see. I think he is good enough to learn a system and do well, he'll have to come in behind some one and have time to develop. The NFL game is a lot different than college.
14570
Notre Dame has the coaching edge - though Weis is a new college coach, he's an experienced coach who's shown better play-calling and team control than Tressel. While Troy Smith is a great quarterback, he relies too heavily on his own ability and has had health problems, while Brady Quinn uses everyone around him. Ohio State's defense is a little stronger. While Michigan State beat Notre Dame but lost to Ohio State, Notre Dame looked much more impressive in their win at Michigan than Ohio State. All in all, I'd give the edge to Notre Dame, though this game won't be decided by more than a touchdown.\n\nI have great respect for Ohio State and Notre Dame. Many analyses of the game rely on stereotypes that insult one side or another's fan base. I really think these are two excellent programs that will have a close contest.
80812
troy palamalu is jack of all trades! he blitzs, intercepts, and tackles down guys like they are grass! troy is a the best defensive player in the AFC. plus he's a defensive playmaker, boulware isn't.
861845
You got to go with Drew Brees right now & it hurts for me to say this because i'am a falcons fan but the saints were 3-13 last year & they already double that half way through the season so Drew Brees.