who is the best quarterback in the NFL so far in this season?
931032
My favorite qb is donovan but i think the best SO FAR is Peyton Manning
889125
Charlie batch...I believe his QB rating this year is around 130.6 for the two games he appeared in this season.
1150932
Definatly. I use to think that Priest Holmes was the best but he was injured and has never come back. But if you can sub for Holmes without missing a beat then you are definatly one of the best. What makes him the best is that he isnt on a strong team when Alexander was on one of the 3 best teams in football last year. If your looking at this year than you choose Johnson as the better runningback. Johnson just gained a great blocker in Kyle Turley. Alexander lost his best blocker. Johnson is the best runningback in the NFL. No if, ands, or buts about it.
944114
Manning, because for one he's a great QB and two he can read defenses.  Plus, he's great leader and you can count on him in tight spots.
606955
My number one pick would be LT. People have been talking about him breaking Alexander's record of TD's in a season, and he will get plenty of carries. Best QB = Peyton Manning. Best WR = Chad Johnson or Marvin Harrison.
57857
The best player in the NFL is by far LaDainian Tomlinson. He can run for a TD,catch a TD and Pass for a TD. It certainly isnt Michael Vick. Vick may be one of the most exciting but that doesnt make him the best. In fact he was one of the worst rated QB's in the league. 25th in the league to be exact.
19879
i still believe that michael vick is one of the most overrated players in the nfl.\n\nby far the best qb in the nfl is Peyton Manning. no one can lead a team the way he can. no one. I think behind him is Tom Brady. And then Gus Frerotte. Just kidding about gus.
883804
I'd say Romo because he is playing against the Cardinals defense.  That defense made even Andrew Walter look good.  Plus, Rivers is going to be playing against the Cincinnati defense, which has a strong defensive backfield.  And he won't be passing a lot anyway because of LT being on his team.  Romo's the one to start, he will probably have 30 to 40 passing attempts.
30432
The answer to this question may be different in a few years, but John Elway is arguably one of the 5 best QB's to ever play the game. \n\nBig Ben is off to a great start, but needs to show he can do it over a longer period of time, plus get atleast one ring before he can be mentioned in the same breath as Elway.\n\nPlease note: I give this answer even though I hated John Elway.
728666
I would have to say Mr. Reliable, Troy Brown.  This guy can do everything.  He can play offense, defense, special teams.  In this pre-season, he played a couple of snaps as QB.  Troy is a true team player.  I feel like saying, what can't he do.
784303
Payton Manning will at the end of his career be the best quarterback to have ever played the game and that will ever play the gave period ... no-one will ever be as good as him ... and the colts will go undefeated this year and win the superbowl easy ... they just got past 2 games inwhich ALL the critics thought they would lose.
875790
Matt Hasselbeck\n\nTom Brady
928135
I'd go with Brees, since I don't think Tom Brady will be throwing the ball much in the second half of the Pats' game.\n\nMy guess is that Brady might have a good first half, but that the Patriots will take control early and go mostly to a running offense.  I can see a second half of the Patriots running the ball a lot.  On the other hand, I expect the 49ers to at least hang somewhat with the Saints, so Brees will likely be passing deeper into the game.  An efficient passer like Brees should be able to feast on that 49ers passing D, the same way that Kurt Warner did in Week 1 and others have since.
1175277
That is a totally opinionated answer.  There is no set best 25 QB's in the NFL
251045
Vick, McNabb, Culpepper, Brees and McNair have no right to be lumped with Brady, Favre and Manning. \n\nThe EASY answer is Manning, hands down.\n\nVick is seriously over rated as a QB. He cannot stay healthy and will NEVER be a top QB. He should move to flanker now.\n\nBrees has had two good years and is a good QB. \n\nCulpepper showed what he was made of last year.\n\nMcNair is a warrior who is a very good QB but not worthy of consideration here and not even when he WAS in his prime.\n\nFavre, one of the GREAT ones whose time has passed.\n\nMcNabb - no thanks\n\nBrady - Just Win Baby - a true leader but still a notch below Manning\n\nBetter than some of the ones you listed: Palmer (as stated above) and Hasselbeck are the future of the NFL.
117400
I'm agree with Brady Quinn, he had a great year last season. Plus with Charley Weiz going on his second year they are going to be great. Plus he didn't even have his best receiver for most of the season last year. He'll be back next year though.
604119
I say Jay Cutler because of where he is.  Denver consistently puts good teams on the field, and I think he has the chance to be the next John Elway for them.  They have great QB coaches and always a good running game and defense.  So that's my pick.