Without McNabb, do the Eagles still have a shot for playoffs?
916343
They're not mathematically eliminated.\n\nBut unless they win 4 of 5, no (That includes vs CAR @WAS @NYG @DAL vs ATL)\n\nThey'll be lucky to get to .500.  But they do hold their own destiny, thats a good thing.
818400
I think he was amazing yesterday.  Keep in mind that it was a beat up Eagles defense and they probably have a lot of confidence loss because of Mcnabbs injury.  I want to see him up against a good team like the Jaguars.  We will really see what he is all about then.
741093
Oh, what with the total meltdown of the Steelers and the poor performance lately of the Bengals, (as long as McNair stays healthy,) then the Ravens just have to keep putting one foot in front of the other now to make the playoffs.\n\nThis is one of football's all time best defences, a great coach and now at long last, a quality QB. How far? Well before they take home the silverware they will be running into some AWESOME teams, Indy, Pats, Denver, Chicago..........\n\nBut with the Ravens, I never let myself forget that this is one of only two teams in about 20 years to win a SB, WITHOUT a decent QB! \n\nIf McNair stays healthy.......... this team could be VERY hard to beat come January........
892510
Drew Brees has been money this year, there's no question about it.\nPeyton has put up okay numbers in certain games but he's not a lock this year like in years past.\n\nI think the Eagles defense is going to step up knowing they have to because their offense is going to be limited with McNabb out.\n\nBrees has been on fire in his last three games.  He'll have a great game vs. Atlanta, again!
175844
Arizona is an improving team. With Edgerrin James at RB and Larry Fitzgerald (GO PITT!) at WR, they are going to be a pretty good team. I would say that they had a chance at making the playoffs next year if it weren't for the fact that they don't have a good QB. If they get a good QB from free agency, then they have a shot at the playoffs, but the Super Bowl is a long Way away. They might make it in the next 10 years, if they continue to improve at the rate that they are now. And, by the way, its Super Bowl, not Super Powl
1066867
I think that there is a great chance for the Redskins to get back to the playoffs.  They have a great running back, at LEAST two good receivers and a great defense.  The only question about them coming into this season is at QB.  Otherwise, dont be surprised to see them come out of the NFC in the Super Bowl.
772234
I will add on to what I had put in another answer:\nYea, and as an Eagle fan, I don't know what to think. Is this the end of the McNabb era? I mean, come on, be realistic. Yesterday, Reid said in his post game news conference- 8-12 months recovery time. That means that next year, he would just be getting off the bench now, or maybe not even playing next year. Now, here comes the hard part. Where do you upgrade next year. If you lose out, and go 5-11, which would suck, do you draft a QB in the 1st round, just in case Donny Mac isn't fully recovered? An ACL tear is probably the worst injury in sports. In 3-4 months, you feel recovered, but you cannot cut or make those quick moves with your legs, and maybe he will never be able to again. Wow, just think of Donovan McNabb as a pocket-passer, like Trent Green or Drew Bledsoe. I know, I know, Bledsoe isn't playing anymore. But who is our Tony Romo? Is it Garcia, who threw 22 incomplete passes yesterday? Is it Feeley, who went 4-1in 2002? What about going after a free-agent QB? A trade in the off-season? Who knows, but the real question is, have we seen the last of Donovan Jamal McNabb on the field in a Philadelphia Eagles jersey. These are questions Andy Reid has to answer RIGHT NOW, from his home in Villanova. Maybe Jay Wright can help him out a little.\n\nWith the playoff situation, can Jeff Garcia get it done? A.J. has been down that road before, so it will be interesting to see who Andy turns to.
497502
There can't be any validity to it. Are the Eagles really gonna get rid of one of the best QB's in the league, and leave their team to be run by Jeff Garcia or Koy Detmer? The idea of him being cut is just flat out retarded. Even if they're looking at a trade situation, they would have to trade with someone willing to give up a promising young QB prospect. Oakland would make sense, except for not having a young QB to give up (no, not Walters), unless their was a three-way trade. The one possibility I could see would be if Arizona was willing to deal away Leinart. That would give them a good QB to lead what is otherwise a good offense (assuming the line plays better), and the Eagles would have a future prospect to start rebuilding around. I still don't see it happening though.
1085346
no\nseeing the other teams this yr\ni doubt it very much
341823
Yes. They have a very deep roster, and in the playoffs that is crucial. If they can continue to play defense, Dirk steps up, and the bench produces, they have a great chance.
990396
Dallas has the best chance out of the three.  They shouldnt be real contenders in the playoffs though.  Philly wont do anything.  They are gonna have to rebuild soon.  As far as Atlanta, I ike the moves they made but as long as Vick is the qb they will never be contenders.  Especially with Carolina in the division.
1123361
McNair adds strength at the QB position, but they will not reach SB XLI.  The AFC has too many teams that could topple the Ravens en route.  The AFC North division itself will be a quagmire of teams scrapping to get their claws or mitts on a playoff berth.
829040
I think the Jets have a good shot at the playoffs.\n\nIf they keep playing at the rate they're playing at now.\n\nThey could take the divison, all depends on how New England plays really\n\nBut yes, The Jets have a good shot at Wild Card hopes
85033
As long as McNabb stays healthy, and Philly drafts smart, they can be dangerous again. Not Super Bowl threat dangerous, but dangerous enough to make the Wild Card.
1142674
They did alrite., but still a couple of years before they make a playoff run. Thye have alot of potential though and good young talent dat could becokme great. So thier in better shape now then they were last year. Cuz for da past few years they look lost..
1083314
I believe with a healthy Culpepper (which I believe he has something to prove) and Nick Saben making the moves that he has I think they will be a serious contender for a wild card spot. There defense is getting old but saben has started drafting for defense so they should be o.k. there as well. They do play in a tuff division with the patriots but they should be able to beat the other teams in there division. Also there schedule isn't that difficult being that they didn't have that great of a season last year
938806
I am undefeated so far in my league.  My lineup is as follow:\n\nQB - Donovon McNabb\nb/u QB - Tony Romo (just for last week when Eagles had a BYE)\n\nRB - LaDanian Tomilson\nRB - Willie Parker\n\nWR - Terrell Owens\nWR - Marvin Harrison\nWR - Issac Bruce (I know he is not performing, still good player)\n\nTE - Dallas Clark\n\nK - Gould\n\nDef - New Orleans