Do you think that it is possilbe for both Peyton and Eli Manning to play together in Super Bowl XLI?
922219
While I think the brothers might face each other in a Super Bowl at some point in their careers, I don't think it will be this year.  Injuries on defense will take their toll on the Giants.  I think the NFC champion will be someone else.
976653
I would have to say yes.  The Colts have not convinced me they can play in the post season and how did the Pats lose by only 7 points after giving them the ball 4 times.
785572
Of course! Anytime you have Steve Mcnair as your quarterback!!!! I'm a Colts fan but McNair deserves alot of respect! I remember when he played for the Titans, he was awesome! And it doesn't seem like hes lost anything!
817205
I have to go for Tom Brady and Petton Manning.  I am so \nexcite about the game this Sunday because of those two \ngoing against each other.  This game might prove who is\nthe best of the two.
753860
to justin, brady has 3, count em, 3 interceptions tonite! and no td's. wow this really proves everyone's point that brady is better than manning. you guys rlly need to check the box score. and also realize the fact that manning holds a freakin NFL record.\n\nso what if brady has 3 rings. the pats were an all around team then. i'd still rather have peyton who's in his prime.
847095
who are you comparing these guys to?..Manning will go down in history as one the greats..Brady and McNabb (maybe) will likely join him in the hall of fame..outside them there isn't much..but little Manning and Palmer could be in the same breathe as them in a handful of years\n\nthese guys are still with their original teams..unless you count the draft of Eli as a charger..but remember Elway wasn't drafted by Denver
784303
Payton Manning will at the end of his career be the best quarterback to have ever played the game and that will ever play the gave period ... no-one will ever be as good as him ... and the colts will go undefeated this year and win the superbowl easy ... they just got past 2 games inwhich ALL the critics thought they would lose.
46395
Michael Vick is easily the better quarterback, as hes had more years to develop and Marcus, thanks to his legal escapes, might not reach the NFL or get any more time to develop. Peyton at the moment is better than Eli for the same reason although I believe they will both do very well over time.
753551
I think that we could easily see the Colts and the Saints in the Superbowl this year. I am a big Brees fan, go PU, and an even bigger Manning fan. I think the Bears are overrated, they haven't played anyone yet, and they lost to the Dolphins yesterday. Superbowl, Colts-34 Saints-17
76878
whoa now his pops didnt throw those TDs passes..his pops isnt in the playoffs...qb's son do have potential...Mannings why not the simms...your daddy can only get you so far...
791012
Indianapolis Colts   oops that's Payton Manning....har har har....is little bro plays for Giants
224227
I think that the Colts will win the Superbowl. They have a team full of experienced veterans and As long as Peyton can stay healthy they should be able to win the Superbowl.
167699
PEYTON MANNING IS BETTER.
789060
No,  its stupid in my humble  fan opinion.      As the great Steve Young says you never pull a veteran QB unless your hopes of the playoffs are gone.   And the broncos are still in the hunt....WIll they still be?  TIme will tell....Im saying no......Because teams will go hard after the rookie.......He may have looked good in preseason but that was preseason......And alot of the time he was partly running with the second string....The game is so fast and Denver runs a very complicated offense......For people who expect the kid to just go in and be an instant star are wrong.    I wouldn't be surprised if he had a really terrible game on Sunday that some broncos fans would be calling for him to be benched...some fans are so fickle.....In my humble opinion Plummer was the  best shot......But what do I know?   Ex Broncos like Terrell Davis are saying its a big mistake to pull JPlummer  out.   People are quick to forgot that the broncos were one step away from the superbowl last year.......Plummer  didn't lose it for them...The defense did.......
751809
Sorry dude but NEITHER!\n Peyton Manning is da man!
664816
I would say not this year.  They need more time to come together as a team.  Am I the only one still grieving over the loss of Vinatieri?  Between Belichick and Brady, things should come together, I just think it'll take them a season or two to get things down.
1183297
To tell you the truth, my guess is none of them will even get a ring. Why? Simply because both of them are big chokers when it comes time to the playoffs. Take a look, for the last few years the colts haven't been to the superbowl because poor Peyton can't play in the snow. You saw last year when both the brothers were in the play offs. They didn't really choke last year since NYG's defense gave up lots of TD IIRC, and Vanderjact missed the kick.\n\nmy 2 cents.