Does anyone else think Katherine should win IDOL this year?  She is beautiful and can sing!?
348502
I think it will be either her or Chris. I am leaning towards Chris because I like a little hard rock. But she is very beautiful and has a really good voice, and she seems to be improving all the time. I also like Taylor, but he would be third for me.
219954
Here's my top three for American Idol this year:\n1)Elliott because he can sing well and yet he is just homely enough to get sympathy votes and make us feel good that we could advance his career and be the ones to discover his talent.\n2)Katherine because she is talented and beautiful and last night's being in the bottom three will surely humble her from being too prideful.\n3)Mandisa because she already had a career before she became a contestant.  She can sing with great power and is a beautiful role model.\n\nBucky and Kellie can only sing one way and they are not that good.  Randy will always be saying to them, "Dude for me that was just ariiight."  \n\nPaula loves to stand and dance any time she can.  She has the hots for Ace but tries to be encouraging to everyone who can entertain, like Taylor.
579067
Katherine!  she's got a great voice.  forget the stupid "soul patrol" this isn't highschool -he's like 29!
333152
YES!  People just like her mostly because she's cute (she's actually quite pretty), but Tuesday night (18 April) proved that unfortunately for her (and that was sincere, not sarcastic) she's not as good as the others.  Paris, Katharine, Elliot, Taylor, Ace, and Chris all did a much, much better job singing than she did.  Ace even stepped it up a notch!  GO PARIS, KATHARINE, and TAYLOR!  Congratulations to Kellie Pickler for getting this far---she had a great audition---but I just think she shouldn't go any farther.
522072
My thoughts were exactly like yours.  Elliot has been my fave since the 1st time I heard him sing.  He's got such a sexy voice!  It reminds me of Marc Broussard and Donny Hathaway (his idol).  My favorite to win was always Chris though.  I figured since Bo came in 2nd last year, it was time for a rocker to win.  I was happily shocked when he got the boot. \nWhen I saw that Elliot was on Taylor's side, I knew he was safe (Taylor's never in the bottom).  I assumed Katharine would be going, but I wanted Chris to go b/c I figured that would give Elliot a much better chance of winning with Chris outa the picture.  I couldn't believe he left!!\n\nAs nerdy as this is, I had my own "vote-a-thon" for Elliot (30 times through) this week.  Next week I'll be doing even more.  How cool would it be if he actually one?
518850
I think he is awesome!  They all are very good at this point, but he really can sing!  He will make it big whether he wins or not!
252387
Yes. I think Carrie is a great singer. She deserved to win.
999796
I loved it! Love her!! She's the best American Idol ever...now she's her own name. I"m so happy for her. The song is kinda poppy, I prefer her rock infused stuff but it's still good.
180244
I want Taylor to win. I think it is between Taylor and Chris. Katherine is great too, but she isn't quite as consistent as Taylor and Chris. Chris could leave the show right now and get a record deal anywhere. I think several of them will become stars after the show because they are really talented. Elliot, Mandesa, Lisa, Chris, Taylor, Paris and Katherine should all become famous, they all have amazing voices.
377701
What I thought was interesting last night was that when Paris sang, I expected them to berate her for choosing a Barbra Streisand song.  Isn't she known for her spectacular voice?  I thought they were way too harsh on Katharine, I thought she nailed that song. Even Whitney Houston herself can't sing that song like she once did!  Overall, I really like Katharine.  I think that sometimes shyness comes across as being aloof or conceited, but I don't think that is the case. Just because she doesn't ooze giggly enthusiasm doesn't mean that she isn't a likable person.
546786
I think Elliott should have won, but between Kat and Taylor, Taylor was the best. I'm a fan of Taylor, but Elliott has a better voice than Taylor.
595719
Taylor should be the next American Idol, but the way they are hyping up Kat evrywhere you read. I think America is in for a major let down.
607570
Of course. I love the song 'You Found Me', "Behind these Hazel Eyes", and "Because of You" \n\nKelly's the best American Idol ever!!!
524127
Taylor Hicks will be the next "American Idol." Taylor has already shown that he is successful. I think that Katherine should have been voted off last week instead of Elliot. Katherine has a lovely voice, but she sings like too many others singers.  Taylors voice is unique and different. If you are not a member of the "Soul Patrol" just watch the American Idol tonight. You will see why he has so many in the "Soul Patrol."
675584
Either Taylor or Katherine, but I think Katherine is going to win because she's much better than Taylor, althought he is good too!
139069
I do--I think she's the best American Idol ever and she can sing songs that are pop/rock w/o being cheesy!  She's got an amazing voice!
344905
I DO I DO, THIS SEASON OF AMERICAN IDOL IS SO MUCH BETTER THAN THE LAST ONE, THESE PEOPLE HAVE SO MUCH TALENT I DONT KNOW WHO IS GOING TO WIN!!!!!!