Who better Vick or McNabb?
347650
Warren Moon was 10 times better than both of them....but I would say McNabb is the better QB, although I think Vick is probably more athletic.
983134
keep both and decide on a week-to-week basis.  if you absolutely had to choose, i would pick mcnair.  since brian billick took control of they offensive coordination several games ago, the offense has leveled out, become more consistent, and overall, more successful.
285342
Two Philly Eagles (NFL) come to mind: McNabb and Trotter.
53754
yes and no...i would take it as almost an insult if i was a rb 4 a team whose qb ran the ball to much. mike vick is a great qb and versatile player an so is vince young but id prefer to be the rb 4 a team that trusted me with the ball a little bit more than to have  the qb run it all the time.
756092
LOL I agree 100%. Crumpler can be good sometimes but yes if Vick gets leg broken bye bye Falcons.
774844
I'd start Grossman because he seems to play well against good teams and fall apart against bad ones.  New England falls into that first category, and with Mark Bradley emerging as yet another weapon in an already loaded passing game, Grossman has more receiving assets at his disposal than Vick.
808531
He is a better passer than Vick. He will remain a QB, as he has matured as a Passer. He doesn't cut and run because the one receiver he wants is covered. Instead he goes through all of his receivers, if none are open then he runs. This year he has become a true QB.
1158717
Yes. Anyone should be picked over Vick. He's the worst quarterback in football. goes like 11-29 every game and throws for like 106 yards. He stinks.  The Falcons signed him to a 10 year deal, so they basically signed away 10 years of never winning a Super Bowl.
786864
michael vick -he is going to get you points passing and running -although he is sporadic at times i would go with the vick
900385
Vick is hot right now.  Play him
973546
I don't know... Team 1 definitely has the advantage in the WR department, but Team 2 has the advantage in just about everything else. \nTom Brady>Mike Vick\nLarry Johnson> (barely) Westbrook (Jeff Garcia is not McNabb)\nChicago>Miami\nIf I absolutely had to, I would pick Team 2 to win, but that's just me. Hope my opinion helped.
961468
Yes, that was a very good decision by starting Romo. I think 42 points is the most points scored by a QB this year. I think McNabb had 38 earlier this year.
1146445
Just an entertainer. Vick is way overrated just because a few flashy runs make the highlight reels. He's not a good QB; in fact that is part of the reason the Falcons do not win.
823872
mcnabb just cost me big time...first place, 7-2 in a league, his -1 is gonna cost me this week's matchup......\nknew seattle was a bust, knew favre was a bust, but i did go with moss in a couple leagues but dropped him early in the season....\nmcnabb, that one stings....\n-nny
873200
The Falcons NO DOUBT, \n\nNo Seriously the Colts look the best team by far, the eagles were in contention but with Mcnabb Out its over for them, saints also have a chance
99496
Probably Michael Vick.
784218
Peyton has the better stats so far.  In the long run, much will depend on the teams they are surrounded by.