Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Undeerwood and Melissa Lambert are all choking, who would you give CPR to first?
344238
Kelly Clarkson.\nIf i wouldn't save her she wouldn't be able to sing such great songs like "because of you"
42468
Kelly Clarkson is by far the most successful.  The least successful American idol I think is probably Fantasia.  Carrie Underwood is at least doing commercials (Hershey) and I think is doing okay in the country genre.  Ruben Studdard had that one relative hit, "Sorry 2004."  But Fantasia hasn't really done anything.
128841
green day \n50 cent\nwhite stripes\njet\nI just couldn't help myself, had to add an extra.\nI have another I just heard on the radio, Keisha Cole- she cannot sing.  She wouldn't even make it to Hollywood if she tried out for american idol.
674467
It's Kelly Clarkson overall but only because she has multiple albums and has been at it longer. I predict that before too long that Carrie Underwood will become the most successful overall idol winner. Her debut album has sold over 3 million copies already, Kelly's debut album sold 2 million.
580527
Omg! Yes! I balled all last night! I think it should have been Taylor or Elliot! Not only is Chris a great singer, he is so hot! I mean who votes for these things anyway! Taylor really sucked and the only reason they keep him on is cause he can "dance" well, i have one thing to say, he dances like he's freakin fallin off a horse! Anyway, i think Chris had better come out with an album of his own. If William Hung can do it, Chris Daughtry sure as Hell can do it! He is a great rocker and he can sing like an angel at any other song to!!
851372
Kelly Clarkson has the best vocal ability.50 Cent is the coolest rapper.
324535
I think Scary-I mean Carrie Underwood or Rush Limbaugh could do the job nicely. Carrie sings one note, and POW! Bin Ladens head pops like an over inflated balloon!! Rush Limbaugh would start in telling Laden, whats wrong with the world and everyone in it, and Laden pulls out a semi-automatic and offs himself to stop from hearing Rush-off-at the mouths,,mouth!
704443
I would defenitily choose Kelly Clarkson for a number of reasons. First every song she released from her debut album went to the number one hit. Secondly she won american idol. And lastly in 2005 she had the #1 hit of the year and I believe if I'm not mistaken also the album of the year.
215691
Kelly Clarkson.Mariah has a discusting voice and it gets on my nerves
305167
kelly clarkson, of course...more talent (in singing)
289276
Alicia Keys\nChristina Aguilera\nKelly Clarkson\nBeyonce\nThey can all sing and LOVE their songs
465953
Kelly should (and probably will) go home tonight.\n\nElliott & Katherine should win, if it was TRULY a singing contest. . . unfortunately, it's largely a popularity contest, so Chris will probably win with the Tiger Beat vote.
475614
i live and breathe American idol. i would just die if american idol was interrupted by a power outage. A recording of american idol better be playing at my funeral or nobody's going to inherit any of my earthly belongings.
767410
I would have voted for Carrie.  She is a fresh face in country music, and she loves it.  She is genuin.  All of the others have been around for awhile.  Im proud of Carrie, being a native Oklahoman myself.
316329
James Blunt! Although i'de get some one else to do it cos i wouldnt really wanna touch him!
508604
Britney Spears and Kellie Piklier. At least one of them is no longer singing, now we only have to get ride of the dumb blond one.
455802
if i ever meet kelly i prolly wouldn't be breathing for long! i'd faint!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!