Is Favre returning a good idea?
342532
I think he should return.\n\nLook, last season he didnt have Ahman Green, or Javon Walker which were a major part of his offensive sheme 2 years ago. He is still one the best QB's ever and a without a doubt first ballot HOFer.  Brett Favre could still be an efficient passer given the right personel around him.When teams know you are gonna throw every play because you have no other choice (due to lack of a good running game) then of course they can run more Dime and Nickel packages at you. I believe Brett Favre has done enough for GB that he can reitre when he damn well pleases. I am not a GB fan, in fact I hate the Packers, but I repect Brett Favre and whatever dicision he makes is probably for the best.
804605
Nice predictions but I have to dissagree with Brett Farve.  He will never play anywhere but Green Bay!  He would retire if traded.
68225
KEEP HIM. He had one bad year, all the greats have them(look at Favre)
874736
Yes trade him now.  As you said his value has never been higher and you could probably get a solid #2(maybe even a low-end #1) and a decent QB to go with.  Assuming the top QBs won't be traded(Manning, Mcnabb, Brady, Bulger) you could probably get Favre in the deal as well.  The Packers D stinks so they get behind a lot which means Favre puts up big numbers playing catch up.  True he's been prone to INTs over the last few years but he's still got some juice left and Driver and Jennings(if he comes back this week) are playing well.  And you know Vick has a serious downside with his lackluster performances.  Go for two solid players (#1 or #2 WR and a decent QB) and you'll be better off down the road.  Trust me I've had Vick on my team and I lived to regret it.
833799
I don't think so.  A lot of experts are questioning why Green Bay is not preparing for the next quarterback.  Favre is obviously past his prime, and I don't think they see Aaron Rodgers as the next Favre. Instead of letting Brett get destroyed each week, they should have started looking for their next long term QB. Then you take this year (and last year) and use Favre to train him.  It's like they are going through a rebuilding year, but they are not actually doing any rebuilding.
297760
What Detroit needs to have a successful next season is a NEW quarterback. Joey Harrington has been given too many chances to take over the team. The team keeps trying to build around Harrington and it ends in failure. Harrington was given two high first round recivers, Marcus Pollard, Charles Rogers and Kevin Jones. All this talent surrounding him and he is not able to work with it. They even gave Harrington Steve Mariucci, the greatest offensive minded coach for QB's, who helped mold two legends of the game Favre and Steve Young. \n\nI know you like Harrington, but it's time to move on. He had a great college career, but just couldn't cut it in the fast paced NFL. \n\nA new QB is what the Lions need to be able to compete for the NFC North division title.
1072103
I'm not a huge fan of the Packers, at least the ones right now.  They lose all of their star players to free agency and injury (Javon Walker and Ahman Green) every season, and a lot of people not named Brett Farve are unhappy in Lambeau Field right now.  However, the dominant Packers that emereged in the 50's and 60's after the league merge were certainly something to be proud of.  To make a long story short, Vince Lombardi was the man in Green Bay.  I'm hoping the Packers can return to that glory soon, and give the Bears a run for their money.
766665
Please start McNair, don't take that gamble on Favre with that injury, and now with B. Billick calling the plays in Baltimore, there's a big difference which will benefit you, if you want it to. G' Luck.
292065
He should. The Packers are in a rebuilding phase and why would you want to rebuild around a QB that will only be there for another year.
196037
Absolutely. DC is coming off an injury, and he has been "gun-shy" in the past. Watch him take a dive when he gets rushed now to avoid the hit. He also won't be doing much running up the field like before. On top of this, he proved last season before he got injured that he can't play without a Randy Moss caliber receiver. He saw defenses that didn't need to defend Moss any more, and he didn't know how to handle it.\n\nNow the Vikes need to get a good rookie QB to take over when Johnson is done. He only has 1 year left in him, maybe 2 with the upgrades to the O-line they are making. Draft a QB in first round, and a couple good defense players in the second round.
779575
Favre...In Lambeau, in November, in cold weather. The man is unstoppable in those conditions.\nFavre has a 3.5/1 TD/INT ratio his last 5 games (7 TD, 2 INT)\nEli has a 1/1 ratio the last 5 games (6 TD, 6 INT)\n\nBoth Defenses are stingy against the pass. NE has given up 7 passing TD while picking off 10. Jax has given up 8 passing TD while intercepting 12. \n\nThe Pack wont be able to run the ball vs the Patriots so Favre will be slinging all day. \n\nGo with Favre
433312
It's simple.  You can't trade or cut a player like Favre because of his status with the team.  He's just like JoePa at Penn State.  Prior to last year, Penn couldn't fire him because of what he has meant to the organization.  EVERYONE wants Favre to retire as a Packer, including management.\n\nI think we as fans get crazy of Favre's indecision but because he is a general of the game and the team, he wouldn't do anything that would truly hurt the team.  He knows that he can only last one more year and they already have their QB of the future in Rodgers so that won't affect the draft.  Favre's indecision isn't going to hurt the team.  If he's coming back the Packers will take him with open arms.  If he doesn't, the Packers will give him a big hug goodbye, no hard feelings.
1180550
green bay and brett favre
4992
Santana Moss, I live in Wisconsin. Favre's favorite targets are defensive backs. Don't rely on him gettin the ball to Driver too much.
927286
Driver is with out a doubt Favre's favorite option, and Favre has been playing well this year. I would start him for sure because he will shred the injury plagued New England secondary. New England is missing both their starting safeties, and they are playing young corners because they are banged up at that position as well. Green bay is playing at home which will help Driver, and if New England does establish a lead Farve will be throwing a lot, which means Driver will have more opportunities. Holt is a heck of a receiver, but Carolina's secondary will make Bruce/Curtis beat them, and will double team Holt all game long. I would play them both if I had them, but if it has to be one or the other Driver to me is with out a doubt the best play this week.
26999
I used to trust Thompson, now, I don't know.  McCarthy's young, but not inexperienced.  He was the Pack's quaterback coach in '99, but I'm not sure he has the ability to pull a team together after this dismal year.  I'm going to watch his off season moves closely, and reserve judgement until Sept. at least.  Who knows?  First time head coaches are always a gamble, but the guy knows the Pack and Brett, so he's got an edge.  Youth is something sorely lacking in GB, so that's a plus for him.  I'll be a Packer fan until I'm dead, but they'd better make some serious improvements next year.
956241
Is he coming back again ?