Do you think Kelly should of been voted off? and who do you think will win?
213967
This is such a simple, yet complex, question.  Performance-wise, Kellie was the worst on Tuesday night.  It wasn't a bad performance, but it just did not compare favorably to the rest, especially Elliot and Chris.  Thus, she was the most deserving of elimination, if the show was truly only about talent.\n\nHowever, I really, really like Kellie's personality, and I think the show will be the worse for her absence.  She is bubbly, fresh, and unpretentious.  She has the complete package for a star -- looks, talent, drive, and if she isn't the brightest crayon in the box, she certainly has the charm and charisma to play it up.  Despite her elimination, I think America will still hear about what she's up to a year from now and beyond (versus someone like Elliot, who has the talent, but whose personality fades into the background).  She maybe be gone for now, but it's only temporary, and she will definitely never be forgotten.\n\nThis season, for me, has been the most interesting.  At this point last year, I could already tell you when each contestant would be eliminated because it was clear that Carrie and Bo were the most talented.  Vonzell had plenty of talent, but not the fanbases the other two had.  I'm still not quite sure how Anthony and Scott stuck around as long as they did.  Anyway, point being this: it was clear, after Constantine's elimination, who was going to be in the finale.\n\nRight now, I can't say who will win, let alone be in the finals.   They are ALL incredibly talented and unique.  Taylor is souful and spastic.  Chris is smoldering, yet sensitive.  Paris is a little girl with a huge voice.  Katharine is glamorous, with a hint of the girl-next-door.  And even Elliot is emerging as the dark horse favorite.\n\nMore than anything else now, I think the performances are what's going to matter.  Kellie's exit proves that.  She was initially a front-runner for the finals - or at least, to be the last female standing.  However, two shaky performances in a row, and now she's going home.  Taylor, so far, has not wound up in the bottom three, but neither had Kellie before last night.  Chris was the second lowest vote-getter last week, but jumped to the top two for this week.  Kat, Elliot, and Paris have also all been in the bottom 3.  I don't think the race has been this hard to call this far into it since season 2, and then it was really only between two contestants (Rueben and Clay), not five.  \n\nIf I had to say how it would play out (and assuming from here on out every contestant gave stellar performances every week), I would say they rest would be eliminated in the following order:  Paris, Elliot, Chris, leaving Kat and Taylor in the finals, with Kat emerging as the winner.\n\nHowever, one bad or mediocre performance from any of them will change that.  On the flip side, should someone have a truly amazing performance (like Constantine's Bohemian Rhapsody), it will change as well.  In a contest of such strong personalities, it will boil down to performance.\n\n(As for personal favorites, I like Chris!!!)
308807
this is the 0843th time i'm gna answer this question.. well.. i think its gna b chris.. he has d voice, personality n everythin else.. tho i dont he got d looks.. katherine wud prolly be voted out.. in d end.. eliott is next.. for obv reasons
298986
Even though I'm rooting for Danielle, I think Joanie will win by a process of elimination. First, the judges fill that Danielle's southern drawl will hinder her from being a cover girl since that requires being a spokesmodel. Second, Jade is not approachable at all so no one would want to work with her and she would make an awful spokesmodel.\n\nBut, we'll see tonight, won't we?
304788
My opinion on Katherine is we'll see her in Playboy/Hustler if she doesn't win Idol. She just wants to be seen. She should've been the one to go instead of Chris. She's fake & so full of herself.
152018
Go BJ & Tyler, they said they would Yield the Frat Boys because the Frat Boys have been name-calling, that's childish. Mo Jo will be next eliminated, she can't handle the heat much longer. It will be a run for the finish with Ray & Yolanda, the Frat Boys and BJ & Tyler.\nGo Hippies !!
106468
I agree with you 110%! Kelly should've been in the bottom three and even voted off last night in Idol. Her performance of the Stevie Wonder song was absolutely horrid... I think it even made my ears bleed! (yikes). I have no idea why she's still there, I guess its because Simon likes her so much and America thinks she's cute. But like you said, you can't win American Idol on your looks, its supposed to be out singing! Hopefully she'll get voted off soon. And Kevin too.
272941
I was shocked that the 2 favorites, Kat and Chris were both in the bottom two, let alone that Chris got voted off.  I thought that they were the 2 that best deserved to be in the finals: Chris because he was the best from the beginning and Kat because she had made the most progress, is at least close to Chris in talent now and she has the Idol look and personality.  Chris is more of a rocker and the fans tend to shy away from them a bit.  Chris did have the disadvantage of being one of 3 guys and Kat is the only gal.  Girl fans are so divided between all the guys that it was just a matter of numbers as to the fact a guy would go this week.  I thought it was a poor choice of themes at this stage of the game to have an Elvis theme.  This was Taylor's forte and was very unfair to Kat especially, but also to Chris.  Elliot really stepped up though and he has also improved quite a bit since the beginning of the competition.  Taylor is the novelty factor and I'm shocked he is still there.  I am still hoping for Kat to win, I like her style, her abilities and her personality.
324983
I think that Katherine McPhee should have gotten voted off instead of Chris. Even she was surprised that she didn't go home. Taylor, Elliot, & Chris are far better singers than her. I think its going to be Taylor all the way!!!
255578
I was so glad that Jade did not win. She should have been gone a long time ago. She was very pretty, but her attitude made her extremely ugly. Furhonda was ugly too.
521084
Amanda got voted off, the second twin. It was between her and Caridee....ooohhh and Caridee got the beginnings of hypothermia!!! is that evil that I think that's kind of funny? I don't like her. For someone who says Melrose is so fake and two-faced, she sure gossips and talks crap about her a lot behind her back! jerk.\n\nOh - the challenge was flamenco dancing and then also floating with a partner on your back in freezing cold water in a pool looking like a mermaid nymph or something. Amanda and Caridee were paired, obviously leaving Melrose and Eugena...
256193
that was Clay? OH OK! I was confused who that was, but happy for the kid to sing that song with Clay. I loved the show. I liked it when Dionne Warwich appeared. I like to see the people voted off perform. I like Elliot and of course I like Chris, but it was nice to see the ones from several weeks ago.
645353
Kaysar, definatley..\nJanell.. Howie...\n\nI think maybe Alison, Jase and maybe like James or someone to even it out..\nI want DRAMA.. so it would be good for Ivette and Diane to come- but I CANNOT STAND THEM!! ! >:(\n\nAnyway- u can only vote for one a day- right??
246256
hopefully elliot! he's amazingly good and i love him. but if taylor wins, i won't be upset. anyone but kat, ugh.
254007
Youre an imature twat responder before me.  Taylor is the best and he will win. Hands down. Katherine has to go tonight.
477403
I think that Jaeda was the right person to go. She kept complaining about her hair!! It will grow back!!!\n\nI hope that Melrose loses the whole thing. \nCaridee is the best person there,\nShe will win!!!!
163882
if my favorite,Chris gets voted off my next favorite would defintaly Kellie. Is awsome too!!!!!
266837
omg i so think that is unfair.  Kathrine so should have gone out. she is soo robotic (if you know what i mean)  Chris is the best evr to be on American idol!