Will the Colts ever win the superbowl with Peyton Manning as a quarterback?
202540
Probably not.\n\nThe Colts time is running out- last year had to be their best shot.  They will have another good year this year though because James should be able to be replaced relatively well in the draft and they didn't lose too much else.\n\nManning just does not handle pressure well.  Want to blame Vanderjagt last year?  First look at Manning.  Vandy should have had to kick a much shorter FG, but Manning fell apart when they crossed half-field.  Even the announcers were questioning his decisions on the last few plays.  If they were to get home field advantage though and were able to somehow avoid the Steelers or another blitz-heavy team, they might find themselves in luck.\n\nAfter all, who thought the Steelers would win last year?  Never know.
350370
Make that 2.\n\nI LOVE YOU ADDAI! :-D\n\nGo Colts! Go Manning!
581657
Its pure and simple the good ole 16 manning is great he has more responsibility on a field than any player ever. He is a field general he makes so many calls. However he has struggeled when it counts most. I am a huge Manning fan but until he can win in the post season and win the big one nobody comes close. And Brady had better not ever see light in this argument cuz i could've lead those patriot teams they were so stocked.\n\nYou can't go based on stats alone. Marino had such a lengthy career of course he has all those records only one of which still stands btw. That record will someday fall maybe at the hands of peyton maybe not. Fact is Marino couldn't scramble if he had to move outside the pocket his accuracy plummeted, I'd take a healthy elway over marino any day, at least he knows what if feels like to win the big one.
38044
Do you know why Peyton Manning wins?  Because he's a student of the game.  He has great mental abilities.  Tom Brady wins because he has heart and can come through in the clutch.  If you put those two together and surround them with a pretty good offense and a defense that doesn't allow too many points.  You're gonna have a great team.  You can talk about stats all you want, but all you need is the win.
372427
THE LUCK IS WITH THE COLTS RIGHT NOW
661515
The manning bros are so goofy i wish they would keep the camera out of their face.  Even if peyton won no one would care because finding a colt fan is like finding a buffalo nickel.  There are huge superstar brothers who played against each other in the nfc champ a few years ago in t he barber brothers.
250788
Stats don't really matter. Favre threw for the 3rd most yards last year but the Packers were 4-12. Manning threw 49 tds and...um...o ya nothing done in the post season. Those are just a few examples that prove my point.\n\nSo you have to weight Championships alot for the Best QB of all time.  If Marino won just one Superbowl, he would be.  If he had won two or more, hands down Marino is the best Qb. But it never happened so he forever will be know as the best QB not to win a Superbowl.\nIt is funny to see how different QBs are looked at and see that if the won/lost the Superbowl how they would be looked at now.  One big one is Jim Kelly.  If he and the Bills had won those 4 SBs(Superbowls) he would be easy HOF and maybe considered One of the best QBs of all-time.  At least one would have helped him.  If the Bills would have at least won the last 2 of the 4, Troy Aikman would be a nobody.  Yes, he was "good" but many people could have been in that situation.  I'm not saying I could do it, maybe, no I couldn't.  But da Bears of 85 I sure could have won with. And yes if McMahon played in the Dolphin game they still would have lost.\nOk enough babblying from me.  \n\nSo the Best QBs has to come down to,\nBig Ben-1 (My name is Ben, so I liked him.  I never thought he'd win a superbowl so soon though)\nTom Brady-3 (unfortunatly)\nJohn Elway-2 (I hate him)\nBrett Farve-1(I hate him even though he plays on the Pack)\nTroy Aikman-3 (A cheerleader could do as good as him)\nSteve Young-1 (for some reason I thought he won more)\nJoe Montana-4 (Ok, thats why)\nJim Pluckett-2 (Didn't matter what city he played in he still won)\nTerry Bradshaw-4 (and still balding)\nRoger Staubach-2 (Aikman 3, Staubach 2, Good debate for best Cowboy QB.)\nBob Greise-2 (17-0, thats all that I can say)\nJohnny Unitas-1 (47 games in row with a TD pass, crazy)\nBart Starr-2 (9-1 in the postseason and 4 championships before the Superbowl came.)\nNo Namath, I guarrantee that he isn't the best and that I can't spell.\n\nIt's your pick but my top five are:\n5. John Elway\n4. Terry Bradshaw\n3. Tom Brady\n2.  Joe Montana\nAnd the Best QB ever is...\n1. Bart Starr\n\nJust imagine if he played today. What would he do?\n\nI hope I helped you out.
388297
I'm an Eagles fan, but really we need to come to reality. These are the Indianpolis Colts. There's a enormous difference between Jeff Garica and Peyton Manning, a definite Hall of Famer. It's gonna be a bad loss for us.
382151
to justin, brady has 3, count em, 3 interceptions tonite! and no td's. wow this really proves everyone's point that brady is better than manning. you guys rlly need to check the box score. and also realize the fact that manning holds a freakin NFL record.\n\nso what if brady has 3 rings. the pats were an all around team then. i'd still rather have peyton who's in his prime.
183469
Ya know, the colts are by far my favorite team. I think they made a huge mistake by getting rid of Edgrin James. There running game is going to be nowhere near as strong without him. They are going to have to air out, which peyton manning can really do. I just fear its going to be there only weapon. I think they will make the playoffs, but lose in the 2nd round. BUT.....Hopefully they will win the superbowl. go colts!!
439781
I agree. Peyton has done nothing special all year except set some records for QB/WR combos. L.T is the one who just set a record for most touchdowns in a 5 game span with 15 touchdowns. L.T. is clearly the MVP of this season.
517070
The Patriots will beat the Colts easy. The Pats have a WAY better defense and an awesome quarterback. All the colts have is manning. Without manning the colts are nothing. The pats will win 34-27
110524
Yes. The dolphim did well last year with a mediocre quarterback. With Daunte on the team they have a shoot at a play off birth this year. If the dolphins can put some talent around Culpepper I can easily see him getting them to the superbowl.
512647
I saw it coming when I saw the pointspread. A 9-0 team against a 5-4 team and the 5-4 team is favored? The fix was in. The Colts average 28 points a game and score 7 each half. I only watched the first half and it was ludicrous. The Colts drive into Cowboy territory and then turn it over. Manning hasn't been intercepted all year on 3rd down, has thrown 14 TDs on 3rd down, gets to the Dallas ONE and gets picked off.\nThis one was TOO obvious.
493175
peyton manning is a better qb and is probley not trying since they already made it to the playoffs so i would start brees
508916
the only ones that can hurt my COLTS this year are the COLTS themselves. I love 'em with every fiber of my being, but is this deja vu' or what? we've gotta BELIEVE this is their year!!!! I think the game against the Eagles should prove interesting if nothing else. GO COLTS!!!!
515669
Peyton Manning is the Poster Boy of the NFL so if his Colts are doing good that is all you will hear about. Also don't count out Jacksonville. Espically don't count out Miami should Indy get to that point. Yeah they are doing bad BUT that '72 Dolphins team is the PRIDE of the Franchise. Do you think that the Dolphins in '85 didn't take great pleasure in being the Bears only loss. On top of wanting to beat the undefeated team but that is the soul of the Franchise. They will do everything in their power to win if it protects the '72 Dolphins record.