Has anyone compared a white one and a granite one side-by-side? The white costs so much less I'm wondering if it is made of less-durable material.
1425883
nope, never had them side by side. But plastic is plastic and will be here long after we get tired of them. White will be probably be easier to clean. Granite is only gray plastic but is two tone while the white one is probably the same color throughout
1425884
I didn't even see the white one when I was looking at them--says there is no "overmold"--I'd have gotten the cheaper one if I'd have seen it!!
1425885
sorry, I haven't compared the two. The granite one is pretty durable material, though, if that helps...
1425886
I'm pretty sure they're the same in quality--just different colors. As the previous replies said, the granite was the only color available when I made the purchase. I'm satisfied with that purchase--but I probably would've gotten the white one, had I knew it was it was cheaper.
1425887
I never compared them. Only saw the granite color. Very satisfied with the granite silverware tray.
535064
We under-mounted ours...I thought it could be done both ways, because when the granite people templated our counters they asked if I wanted it dropped in or under-mounted. Also, you wouldn't have to put white caulking around it if you dropped it in, they make a very nice CLEAR caulk that you'd never even notice. I have it around other sinks in my home.
1571296
The granite is probably sealed from the factory. It will not hurt it even if it is not sealed. You can still use it.
1818676
there are engravings of the model on the bottom. i cannot say it is not a smooth bottom however i personally do not put it on my countertop which is granite as i am afraid it might scratch the surface.
78010
Grinding rice helps eliminate powdering, a common condition with stone. Hopefully this granite is strong enough that it will not continue to powder. If it does then I would suspect the granite is of poor, weak quality. Could you kindly update us if the powdering eventually stopped after conditioning? I'm interested in buying this myself. Thanks! :-)
1014943
we have granite with quartz. But it was recommended to us to seal the counters beforehand. It's much easier to clean the counters now. We will put more sealer on I think every 2-3 years.
2142124
The granite is sort of a greyish beige. It's like a blend between the two colors. Very neutral and nice.
634777
If I were you, I would definitely call the Powell company to be sure. I love the top myself, but your idea of switching it out for a granite counter top would make this island even more beautiful! Postyour decision, I may consider doing this in the future as well.
634773
Wish I could answer your question but I really don't know right now. I am planning on either building a new top or replacing it with granite. I am favoring making the butcher block top which I have already done for my daughter and I love it. But right now I can't help you as I have not removed the top yet.
830112
It is sturdy and heavy but I wouldn't trust the weight of a granite top on it. If you do order do not order if Brookstone is the seller! Had a horrible experience with them and had to have amazon interject.
896260
Don't understand the bad reviews??? What do folks think they're getting for this reasonable price. From what I've read it never says its granite....marble but certainly not solid marble. It's durable though, saves space and I am able to get six of my grandkids seated there with no problem. The covering is a microfiber of sorts.... Not the best quality but has held up well.. Anything from greasy handprints to peanut butter and jelly wipes clean and dries quickly.
545161
I'm not sure I fully understand your question but I did use the color granite on my deck and was a very good choice. It was a rich gray color and looks very good.
1424806
I have it on a beautiful piece of granite. I took the bowl with me when I picked it out. It's gorgeous.
1941448
The top side of the marble slab is polished and is 100% smooth. The other side is rough a rough finish but has "feet" to keep it off of any counter-top surface. What I like about it,is that is hefty in weight but not so heavy that you can not move it from one place to another. Also, because it is marble, it it always cold so that it makes for an excellent surface for rolling out dough.
1349968
I do still love this sink, its beautiful. BUT I will say that I do have some chips/scratches on both front corners. They're small and hard to see but they're there which is frustrating. Could've been the way the sink was installed or how the countertop was laid over it. We have quartz counters so they're quite heavy. It also seems to stain pretty easily - if I have a pot or pan in the sink for a day or two I find I'm scrubbing extra hard to remove any ring it left. In hindsight - as much as I love the sink and this type of sinks - I'd probably not go with an apron front sink, and stick with an undermount stainless steel or granite sink! Good luck. I am sure you'll be happy with either choice!
598060
This picture does make the white look different. I ordered the white sink in the larger size and it does not have what appears to be a double rim shown in this picture. For the record, I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this giant sink. Literally both my kids fit it in.. I love that a giant pan can fit right in it and I believe i have had it installed for at least a year and haven't noticed any dings or blemishes.
1770303
Well counter tops are generally highly polished and do bead water after being polished. Outside granite might have a coarse finish? If they are polished I would think they would be slippery when wet.