If you've also used the Sven, how does the blade of this one compare? Trying to decide between the two...
1322758
I haven't used the Sven in about 20 years, but my memory is that the Sven feels more solid, as it's all metal, but by design it takes more effort to set up and take down. Plus there's the (theoretically) easily lost wing nut. I prefer the design of the Coghlans due to the ease of set-up and take-down, but there is quite a bit of force applied to a set screw which is mounted in the plastic handle- what remains to be determined is if the plastic fatigues over time, and as I just bought the Coughlin and haven't done any camping, so have yet to use it. Time will tell. However, there are a number of reviews on Amazon from folks who have owned the Coughlan for quite awhile, and few complaints about premature failure. Conclusion: the Coughlan seems better by design, the Sven by virtue of being all metal seems to be (possibly) more durable.
1322759
I'm impressed with the coghlans folding saw.. I,used it to clear a camp of brush pickers and small trees' cutting it all very well..I,ve cut dry dead logs up to 6 inches with ease..the blade is holding a sharp edge after about 10 backpacking trips averaging about 1 hour of use per trip to cut up a an ample supply of wood for the night..good saw ...good value..
1322760
I have not used the Sven. But the blade on this saw makes short work of any wood I have tried to cut.
1314648
For durability, yes this is the one. I suspect the other, cheaper ones are lighter, but this one is real mil-spec and is not phased by rocks or roots. I think I would have a hard time breaking this if I tried. After all the regular abuse I have put it through this season, the finish is completly worn off the bottom third of the blade, but there are no gauges in the surface or chips in the edge. It does rust were the metal is bare, so keep it dry and oiled.BTW, I highly recomend a hori hori garden knife for metal detecting. Most of the ones with wood handles are of decent quality(the sheaths are not, however). They are great for digging small holes less than a foot down. For durability, yes this is the one. I suspect the other, cheaper ones are lighter, but this one is real mil-spec and is not phased by rocks or roots. I think I would have a hard time breaking this if I tried. After all the regular abuse I have put it through this season, the finish is completly worn off the bottom third of the blade, but there are no gauges in the surface or chips in the edge. It does rust were the metal is bare, so keep it dry and oiled.BTW, I highly recomend a hori hori garden knife for metal detecting. Most of the ones with wood handles are of decent quality(the sheaths... » Read More For durability, yes this is the one. I suspect the other, cheaper ones are lighter, but this one is real mil-spec and is not phased by rocks or roots. I think I would have a hard time breaking this if I tried. After all the regular abuse I have put it through this season, the finish is completly worn off the bottom third of the blade, but there are no gauges in the surface or chips in the edge. It does rust were the metal is bare, so keep it dry and oiled.BTW, I highly recomend a hori hori garden knife for metal detecting. Most of the ones with wood handles are of decent quality(the sheaths are not, however). They are great for digging small holes less than a foot down. « Show Less
1706892
Although I have both, I prefer the 102 is it is smaller, its blade is thinner and narrower which in my mind makes it a more useful and versatile knife. The 119 is a cool knife also but it is very large and stout. I do love the brown handle versus the black, it is worth the extra cost in my view.
1098285
IIRC, out of the box the blade was good and sharp.If you sharpen your own, you'll *love* the way this thing takes an edge. My Zetsurin is just about the sharpest thing I own. After a bit of work ;)
1283333
I bought the 632 as well figure it will last longer and is better overall. Look around I got the smooth blade free no charge. Good luck.
2130683
I researched it some before buying my first instance of the Eros knife. I was not able to get what I considered and authoritative answer but check this "http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/763981-How-does-Acuto-steel-compare". I am personally very pleased with the blade. It holds its edge very well. I have both the Ripple and the Eros. At first I was put off by how pointy the blade of the Eros is, but now see it as a plus. I have carried the Eros daily for two or three years. I lost one, and bought another to replace it. I have bought others for gifts. Took the clip off, to slim it down even more. I researched it some before buying my first instance of the Eros knife. I was not able to get what I considered and authoritative answer but check this "http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/763981-How-does-Acuto-steel-compare". I am personally very pleased with the blade. It holds its edge very well. I have both the Ripple and the Eros. At first I was put off by how pointy the blade of the Eros is, but now see it as a plus. I have carried the Eros daily for two or three years. I lost one, and bought another to replace it. I have bought others for gifts. Took... » Read More I researched it some before buying my first instance of the Eros knife. I was not able to get what I considered and authoritative answer but check this "http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/763981-How-does-Acuto-steel-compare". I am personally very pleased with the blade. It holds its edge very well. I have both the Ripple and the Eros. At first I was put off by how pointy the blade of the Eros is, but now see it as a plus. I have carried the Eros daily for two or three years. I lost one, and bought another to replace it. I have bought others for gifts. Took the clip off, to slim it down even more. « Show Less
1958553
As best I can see the pic you posted, it looks like the one I bought for my slicer and it is a wonderful blade. I almost never use the serrated blade. The smooth one slices cold cuts thinner than paper!!
2133744
I like the SCHF9 because its a longr blade and a grippier handle with a blade just as thick as the bk2 for a lower price.
1635139
I've used this one for years. the only difference between the two is just the width of the blade. I have always just switched between the two.
1672074
I tried a set of the Freud blades and was happy with them. I have run a bit of wood through these blades and they seem to cut just as well. I guess I'll find out how well they last in the long run. I think most of these blades are probably made by the same company and everyone puts their name on them. Laying the Freud, Ridgid and these out together I can't see any difference in them. I guess in a couple of months I'll find out if they hold up as well.
1860588
I like the knife my friend has the same brand but not as good a model his works very well but gets. Hotter with prolonged use I have used mine for 4 hours straight without stopping his he needs to let rest every so often . I also like the blades that came with mine it easy to do small fish with the blades that are 1/2 the thickness but they can be bought separate . I have bought and and still have a Berkley knife and a tatertwister knife they was a a waist of money in my opinion . I hope this helps you make your mind .
127042
I personally would go with the Mora. It is a utility knife hands down. If you break it, the factory will replace it. I have about 5 of these for different uses. these blades are awesome. Gerber, I have always had a problem with them getting rusty
492813
Honestly it is a well made blade. Feels strong and stable, I've used on 2 inch thick branches, sliced right through them no issue at all period. There's a lot of Gerber haters out there. It comes with an awesome side sheath for belt it works for left or right hand. Overall I would recommend it highly. I have been clearing out back of house lots of trees big branches 2 to 4 inch thick branches. I went in and sliced straight through with no problems at all. I haven't seen a dent nor chip in the blade. So yes it does come with sheath for sides using left or right but not for your back like a sword type of thing. The blade is very reliable. Honestly it is a well made blade. Feels strong and stable, I've used on 2 inch thick branches, sliced right through them no issue at all period. There's a lot of Gerber haters out there. It comes with an awesome side sheath for belt it works for left or right hand. Overall I would recommend it highly. I have been clearing out back of house lots of trees big branches 2 to 4 inch thick branches. I went in and sliced straight through with no problems at all. I haven't seen a dent nor chip in the blade. So yes it does come with sheath for sides using left or right but not for your back like a... » Read More Honestly it is a well made blade. Feels strong and stable, I've used on 2 inch thick branches, sliced right through them no issue at all period. There's a lot of Gerber haters out there. It comes with an awesome side sheath for belt it works for left or right hand. Overall I would recommend it highly. I have been clearing out back of house lots of trees big branches 2 to 4 inch thick branches. I went in and sliced straight through with no problems at all. I haven't seen a dent nor chip in the blade. So yes it does come with sheath for sides using left or right but not for your back like a sword type of thing. The blade is very reliable. « Show Less
1865878
I personally prefer the stainless blade. It doesn't take much to mess up the black covering and the knife looks ratty. But with the stainless it always looks good!
649974
I would say any are good choices. For more fine detail work I would probably go with the rodan. The bushlore blade I a great all around bush knife. The edge is very keen and needs to be maintained. For working wood I think the scandi grind is king. But that's me. The scandi does not hold up well to abuse but comes back quickly and easily. Hope that helps. Any day in the woods is better than any day at work
127041
The Mora is the superior product in my book. Maybe 1984 Gerbers would be better, but these Morakniv Bowie style is light weight and extremely sharp. I touched the tip by mistake and it instantly made a scalpel sharp little cut. Go to Mora's web site and review the metals they use. Staying in Sweden, we will see that the metal provider is like hundreds of years, same address type business. So, where are Gerbers made and from what metals? Also, get the 8 inch blade. It is a very nice knife.
889297
They have several versions of this wonderful blade, mine was the shorter 6 5/8" x 3/16" the other is 7 1/4" x 1/4", the very 1st run was D2 steel(not many made the market)- I do like the 1095CV and the thinner steel is a lot lighter, I have the "Pot Belly" it's heavy - wonderful shape, high quality blade, the sheath needs a thin strip of deer skin or rubber to keep it from rattling