Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Too sentimental, essentially meaningless

This book, about a family torn apart by a baby's death in the Depression is frankly, depressing. The entire book takes place on a rooftop with flashbacks making up most of the content. There is no particular reason to be on the roof it justs "feels like the right place to be" or something of the like. And in an attempt to be very profound the author attributes the cause of their rooftop venture as the family's way of "getting near to baby." Yes, that is the whole point of the novel. The exciting climax where the family actually talks on the roof is heartpounding and turbulent. If you can't detect my sarcasm by now, you are not educated enough to read this book. Well honestly this book is to touchy-feely, if that were ever thought possible and has no conflict or plot whatsoever. The moral learned from reading this is not to ever read a book by someone who lists their hobby as "making stone walls."