Instruct: Classify the given Amazon review into its appropriate rating category
Query: Nice contents, dirty exterior.

I absolutely loved the book. We used it as a guest book at a Winnie the Pooh themed baby shower. However, the jacket was filthy with grey/black smudges all over it. I'm glad we were able to just take it off, but still, for $23 "new" it should have at least been in "new" condition.