Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Brilliant final movement in the Bruch but...

The sheer brilliance of Pine's playing in the final movement of the Bruch Fantasy is worth paying for. But on the whole the Scottish Fantasy falls short of perfection, with her playing too light in many sections and lacking the Romantic essence which is part of Max Bruch. The orchestra fails too in its support of her own search for a deep and fufilling interpretation. I prefer the playing of Salvatore Accardo with the London Symphony under Colin Davis. There is a richness and a depth about this rendition which surpasses even the technical aptitude of Pine. Having said that, the combination of the Bruch with the other pieces makes this CD an acquisition well worth having in your classical collection.