Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Good Premise, diasappointing execution

I would have every reason to like this book, as it correlates closely to my own life: I work at Stanford, I study Scots Gaelic and all things Celtic, and I have traveled many times to the Highland locales in the book..... So, imagine my disappointment when all the characters are painfully stock, all the dialogue is trite (yes, even the Gaelic bits), and the potential of the great fantasy line of the story is swamped in every romance cliche imaginable.This could have been truly riveting, given the subject matter, but the execution was far below the mark. Hopefully, in the rest of the trilogy, Hanna will develop the potential of her characters and storyline in a more skillful manner.