Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Poor analysis

This book is intended to portray the US infantry divisions fighting in north west Europe 1944-5. Had the author written only about the US divisions, the book might have been better. However, he makes several comparisons with the German units and also occasionally with British units. These sections display poor analysis, exhibit sweeping but unsubstantiated statements and faulty use of sources. Had he refrained from this and dealt only with the US divisions, the book might have deserved a higher rating, but these errors display poor scholarship.