Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Written for Older Singers

For a girl of 15, Charlotte Church does a reasonably good job on these show songs on Enchantment. However, these songs were written for mature adult singers; thus Charlotte's very young sounding voice is conspicuously weak on most of the tunes. She seems to be O.K. on "Carrickfergus", a Celtic ballad, but then on "The Water is Wide", another Celtic ballad, she again sounds very weak and clearly inferior to the version done live on the Lilith Fair CD by Sarah McLachlan, Jewel, and the Indigo Girls.Charlotte is not ready to sing the songs on Enchantment yet and needs to focus on those songs her voice is NOW ready to accomodate. I do not recommend this album.