Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Good, but not flawless

The cd was shipped to me with a scratch, which takes out about 10 seconds of the climax of the first movement of the second concerto. But, that's not why I gave it a four. It was a good recording, good playing and fair taste in playing, or style. All was going well until the third movement of the second started. I've heard several recordings of it, and this has to be the one that left the worst taste in my mouth. Nothing is technically wrong, but I think he plays parts of it too fast, with too much pedal, and a myriad of other slight annoyances. The first movement of the third's cadenza is slightly irritating because of the rather slow speed it is played with. These things are very minor, and unless you happen to be a rachmaninoff nut, consider the rating a 5. But, if you are a rachmaninoff nut, consider the host of other recordings, but don't dismiss this one.