Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: an early Tolkien clone, from 1964

THE GOOD:* Good Welsh atmosphere.* Wholesome story for kids: good, clean, old-fashioned fun.THE BAD:* Hard to take the first book seriously because the main characters spend most of it looking for a pig.* Too many names and characters and nary a glossary in sight, save one for pronunciation.* Cliched situations.* Thinly-disguised liftings from Tolkien abound.