Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Good while it lasted

I was very impressed with my smoker for the first 6 months that I had it. Minimal fuss and easy cleanup. While the smoking wasn't as good as an outdoor smoker, it seemed to do the trick.However, after 6 months I put some water in it after it had cooled down , and found I had about a dozen cracks in the bottom of the pan causing the water to leak out. I followed the directions to the letter, yet this stainless steel pan which the manufaturer claims will "last for years" was done after 6 months. $60 flushed down the drain. I wouldn't recomend this to anybody. Unfortunately I gave one as a gift also. Waiting to hear how long that one lasted.