Instruct: Classify the given Amazon review into its appropriate rating category
Query: No discernible improvement, didn't seem to do any harm

It's okay. I didn't notice any dramatic difference between this and Curel Itch Relief lotion. I put one on one leg and one on the other -- neither was better than the other. This was for eczema/dermatitis, and basically what helped me most was getting a humidifier, along with using just about any moisturizing lotion. Although one of the lotions/creams I tried seemed to make things worse, I don't think it was this one.