Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: WaterProof?????

Looked great when I bought it, had high hopes. Moved from MA to NY in pretty good rain, opened up the bag and everything was soaked from the bottom up. Not sure if it was because the felt bottom was in contact with the roof of the car, but AMAZON said this was recommended with the roof rack I purchased. Terribly dissapointed, I hate writing bad reviews, but I bought this because it was supposed to be WATERPROOF. Wish I could return it.