Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Overrated

Always on the prowl for the best mascara (my biggest concerns being the brush and whether or not it will leave those faint grey smudges under my eyes from flaking), I read that Allure recommended this one 3 years in a row as the Best Mascara. I will admit that I love the brush and the way it goes on. But, from day one, it flakes and I get smudges under my eyes. I was told by a Mac representative that that means the mascara is old and needs to be replaced. That was true for my last mascara (Mac), but either I purchased old Dior mascara, or Dior is just overrated (and probably pays Allure for that #1 spot). So, I guess I'm out $24, and will go back to the Mac counter and buy there. When you find something good, stick with it! Also, I wasn't expecting the mascara to smell so perfumy! Ugh. I hate perfumes.