Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: Mostly a fine book, with two shortcomings

I concur with most of the positive things that have been said about this book, BUT ... it is limited as a learning toolUnfortunately, the images printed in the book are not included in the CDROM. The author's excuse is that they are copyright images and therefore can't be included. My view is that he chose the wrong photos, since it is now impossible to follow along with his book in photoshop.My second beef is that his descriptions are sometimes unnecessarily complex and lack clear direction. Again, I am looking at this book package as a source of learning.The big shortcoming is the lack of alignment of the CDROM with the book. I felt badly let down. If you forget about the CDROM, you will be much happier and probably give him 5 stars.