Instruct: Classify Amazon reviews into positive or negative sentiment
Query: better than nothing but not a stellar design

My two piece splatter shield came with the KA mixer I purchased about 20 years ago. The mixer still runs beautifully but the splatter shield is problematic. One of the tabs broke off completely so I use one hand to hold it together while with the other hand I try to contain the flour spraying out from between the lip of the bowl and the loose splatter shield. What I would like it a snug fitting shield with a silicone gasket to prevent the spray out. The spray out problem is not caused by the broken tab, but by the loose fitting design. I'm trying to decide whether to purchase another shield...might go with the one piece because there is less chance of breakage but on the down side - more room for flour to fly out because of the open area in the design.