 contract with South Korean MMA promotion Battlefield Fighting Championship and is expected to make his promotional debut against Raja Shippen on July 27, 2019.

Championships and awards
Ultimate Fighting Championship
Fight of the Night (One time)
Submission of the Night (One time)

Personal life
Caraway previously dated former UFC fighter Miesha Tate. They had been together since attending Central Washington University. In 2014, Tate was credited with saving the life of Bryan's mother, Chris Caraway, when the latter suffered an asthma attack while scuba diving, stopped breathing and became completely unresponsive.

Caraway is featured in the award-winning mixed martial arts documentary Fight Life. Released in 2013, the film is directed by indie filmmaker James Z. Feng and produced by RiLL Films.

Mixed martial arts record

|Loss
|align=center|21–9
|Pedro Munhoz
|TKO (body kick and punches)
|The Ultimate Fighter: Heavy Hitters Finale 
|
|align=center|1
|align=center|2:39
|Las Vegas, Nevada, United States 
|
|- 
|Loss
|align=center| 21–8
|Cody Stamann
|Decision (split)
|UFC 222 
|
|align=center|3
|align=center|5:00
|Las Vegas, Nevada, United States
|
|-
|Win
|align=center| 21–7
|Aljamain Sterling
|Decision (split)
|UFC Fight Night: Almeida vs. Garbrandt
|
|align=center|3
|align=center|5:00
|Las Vegas, Nevada, United States
|
|-
| Win
| align=center| 20–7
| Eddie Wineland
| Decision (unanimous)
| UFC on Fox: Dillashaw vs. Barão 2
| 
| align=center|3
| align=center|5:00
| Chicago, Illinois, United States
|
|-
| Loss
| align=center| 19–7
| Raphael Assunção
| Decision (unanimous)
| UFC Fight Night: MacDonald vs. Saffiedine
| 
| align=center| 3
| align=center| 5:00
| Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
| 
|-
| Win
| align=center| 19–6
| Érik Pérez
| Submission (rear-naked choke)
| UFC Fight Night: Henderson vs. Khabilov
| 
| align=center| 2
| align=center| 1:52
| Albuquerque, New Mexico, United States
| 
|-
| Win
| align=center| 18–6
| Johnny Bedford
| Submission (guillotine choke)
| UFC 159
| 
| align=cent